Cheryl A Moyer1, Brienne McNally2, Raymond A Aborigo3, John E O Williams3, Patience Afulani4. 1. University of Michigan Medical School, 1111 East Catherine Street, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. Electronic address: camoyer@umich.edu. 2. University of California San Francisco, 550 16(th) St, 3(rd) Floor, 3573, San Francisco, CA 94158, USA. 3. Navrongo Health Research Centre, Ghana Health Service, PO Box 114, Navrongo, UER, Ghana. 4. University of California San Francisco, 550 16(th) St, 3(rd) Floor, 3573, San Francisco, CA 94158, USA. Electronic address: patience.afulani@ucsf.edu.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: This study explored providers' perspectives and behavior regarding respectful maternity care, including knowledge, attitudes, and practices. DESIGN: Mixed-methods cross-sectional study combining quantitative survey data, qualitative interviews, and observations of labor and delivery across four health facilities SETTING: Government health facilities in rural northern Ghana PARTICIPANTS: 43 front-line maternity care providers completed a survey of practice patterns before a quality of care training. We then used purposive and convenience sampling to recruit a sub-sample for in-depth interviews (N=17), and convenience sampling and self-selection to observe approximately half (N=8) providing clinical care. MEASUREMENTS AND FINDINGS: We calculated descriptive statistics from quantitative data and used the framework approach for qualitative analysis. Observational data were examined using the CHANGE Project's Assessment Tools for Caring Providers. We utilized split frame methodology to make comparisons across data sources. Quantitative survey results (N=43) indicate most providers report explaining procedures to women (89.5%), involving women and families in care decisions (84.1%), and covering or screening women for privacy (81.5%). At the same time, 38.9% reported they have shouted at, scolded, insulted, threatened, or talked rudely to a woman, and 26.4% said they have treated a woman differently because of her personal attributes. Qualitative interview data (N=17) suggested that providers can articulate a vision of respectful care, aspire to offer respectful care, and recognize they do not always meet those aspirations. Among those (N=8) volunteering to be observed, introductions and explanations for procedures were rare, privacy screening was infrequent, and participants were observed slapping, scolding, and restraining women in labor, often associated with patient non-compliance to provider instructions. KEY CONCLUSIONS: Even among providers knowledgeable about respectful maternity care and who agreed to be observed providing delivery care, disrespect and abuse were present. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Further research and programmatic efforts are needed to address the gap between knowledge and behavior.
OBJECTIVE: This study explored providers' perspectives and behavior regarding respectful maternity care, including knowledge, attitudes, and practices. DESIGN: Mixed-methods cross-sectional study combining quantitative survey data, qualitative interviews, and observations of labor and delivery across four health facilities SETTING: Government health facilities in rural northern Ghana PARTICIPANTS: 43 front-line maternity care providers completed a survey of practice patterns before a quality of care training. We then used purposive and convenience sampling to recruit a sub-sample for in-depth interviews (N=17), and convenience sampling and self-selection to observe approximately half (N=8) providing clinical care. MEASUREMENTS AND FINDINGS: We calculated descriptive statistics from quantitative data and used the framework approach for qualitative analysis. Observational data were examined using the CHANGE Project's Assessment Tools for Caring Providers. We utilized split frame methodology to make comparisons across data sources. Quantitative survey results (N=43) indicate most providers report explaining procedures to women (89.5%), involving women and families in care decisions (84.1%), and covering or screening women for privacy (81.5%). At the same time, 38.9% reported they have shouted at, scolded, insulted, threatened, or talked rudely to a woman, and 26.4% said they have treated a woman differently because of her personal attributes. Qualitative interview data (N=17) suggested that providers can articulate a vision of respectful care, aspire to offer respectful care, and recognize they do not always meet those aspirations. Among those (N=8) volunteering to be observed, introductions and explanations for procedures were rare, privacy screening was infrequent, and participants were observed slapping, scolding, and restraining women in labor, often associated with patient non-compliance to provider instructions. KEY CONCLUSIONS: Even among providers knowledgeable about respectful maternity care and who agreed to be observed providing delivery care, disrespect and abuse were present. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Further research and programmatic efforts are needed to address the gap between knowledge and behavior.