| Literature DB >> 33324935 |
Michael Bartl1, Rebekka Kewitsch1, Mark Hallett2, Martin Tegenthoff3, Walter Paulus1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Diagnosis of functional movement disorders and specifically functional tremor (FT) (representing 50% of them) remains demanding. Additionally, due to heterogeneity of the disorders, structured concepts and guidelines for diagnosis and therapy are difficult to establish. Ascertaining the state of knowledge to derive instructions for operating procedures is the aim of this review. MAIN TEXT: Based on a standardized systematic literature research using the term "psychogenic tremor" in the MEDLINE database dating back ten years, 76 studies were evaluated. Conventional features of FT are variability of frequency and amplitude. Further, response to distraction by motor and cognitive tasks is a key diagnostic feature in differentiation between organic and functional origin. A variety of electrophysiological tests have been evaluated including surface electromyography and accelerometry to establish laboratory-supported criteria for diagnosing tremor. Also, finger tapping tests have been used to identify FT, showing positive potential as supplementary evidence.Imaging studies in general are mostly underpowered and imaging cannot be used on an individual basis. Therapeutic studies in FT often have a diagnostic component. Cognitive behavioral therapy should be the preferred psychological treatment independent of additional psychiatric symptoms. Other psychotherapeutic methods show lack of evidence concerning FT. Relaxation techniques and physiotherapy are an important additional feature, especially in children and adolescents. In regard to drug therapy, randomized and blinded trials are not available. A significant decrease in rating scales could be detected after active, not sham repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation with a long-lasting effect. Also root magnetic stimulation seems to be effective. The clinical feature of tremor entrainment in FT can be used in combination with biofeedback as so-called tremor retrainment, using self-modulation of frequency and severity, to bring the movements under volitional control.Entities:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33324935 PMCID: PMC7713151 DOI: 10.1186/s42466-020-00073-1
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Neurol Res Pract ISSN: 2524-3489
Fig. 1flow of information, systematic review
Study selection criteria
| Study category | Quality criteria |
|---|---|
| Low rated (LR) | Case reports, reviews and clinical studies without standardized diagnostic criteria, evaluations scales and protocols |
| Moderate rated (MR) | Clinical trials with low patient numbers, lack of control groups, Reviews with incomplete study entry on validated basis |
| High rated (HR) | Controlled trials, reviews with standardized procedures, validated protocols and sufficient methodology |
Listing of diagnostic methods in functional tremor
| diagnostic methods | definition | associated studies |
|---|---|---|
| The EMG based tests: tapping performance, tapping response at different frequencies, testing of the ballistic movement response, tonic coactivation, coherence testing, loading tests have been shown as an effective tool to differentiate different tremor forms in a neurophysiological test battery | [ | |
| EMG can help to differentiate between different tremor forms, by using surface EMG and time-frequency analysis. Variation in tremor frequency and between different muscles can be recorded. In functional tremor fewer limbs and limb segments are involved than in essential or Parkinson tremor. Further, the variability of the frequency is higher. The term “frequency dissociation” describes frequency differences higher than 0.1 Hz between two extremities. This can usually not be detected in functional tremor but in organic forms. | [ | |
| During self-initiated movements a reduction in the SEP amplitude can be found at the onset of the movement. This is called sensory attenuation (SA) and is reduced in functional movement disorders | ([ | |
| Recording EMG of muscle pairs and performing coherence and synchronicity analysis shows different patterns in postural upper limb tremor occurring in different tremor associated movement disorders | [ | |
| Method that can detect coherence variations and phase differences between EMG signals. This can help to differentiate between organic and functional tremor forms and is more precise than conventional coherence analysis. | [ | |
| In a study comparing organic and functional dystonia the motor cortical inhibition (short interval intracortical inhibition, SICI) measured by TMS showed abnormal values in both organic and non-organic groups. Further, paired associative stimulation (PAS) was abnormally high in the organic patient group and normal in the functional disorder group. They also found enhanced facilitation of the motor evoked potentials (MEP) in organic dystonia patients, but not in the functional controls. This could be validated in TMS recordings using cortical inhibition (SICI, long interval intracortical inhibition, LICI and cortical silent period, cSP). A reduced cortical inhibition is discussed as a precipitating factor for both organic and non-organic dystonia. | [ | |
| By using back averaging, in simultaneous recordings of the EMG and EEG it can be analysed if the EMG activity is preceded by EEG activity. This so-called movement related cortical potentials (MRCP) precede the onset of voluntary movement that are self-initiated. Two components of the Bereitschaftspotential (BP) and the reafferent potential recorded after the EMG activity can be differentiated. The involuntary movements in patients with FMD have a BP with appearance similar to that of normal voluntary movements. | [ | |
| Distinct patterns of cerebral perfusion at rest and during motor tasks could distinguish between functional and essential tremor from ET. A study showed a deactivation of the default mode network | [ | |
| Possibly, abnormal sensory integration is a part of the pathogenesis of functional tremor. PET showed a hypermetabolism of the posterior parietal lobes bilaterally in patients | [ | |
| Multiple recordings of muscle activity coupled with frequency analysis can be used to differentiate between different tremor forms in experimental study designs. They characterize the typical features like spontaneous variability of the tremor frequency and frequency entrainment induced by contralateral rhythmic tasks | [ |
Clinical features of organic tremor evaluated and described in studies
| A typical feature of PMD is its paroxysmal nature and a | |
| The symptoms are (almost) maximal | |
| The tremor can have | |
| Frequency analysis can help to differentiate between organic and functional tremors. Based on a classification of frequency into low (< 4 Hz), medium (4–7 Hz) and high (> 7 Hz) tremors with frequency > 11 is usually organic, but there is no rule with lower frequencies. Essential tremor is often 6 or 7 Hz, many tremor frequencies were suggested between | |
| The amplitude, frequency as well as direction show a higher variability in functional tremor than in organic forms, usually the frequency of organic tremor does not show a variation higher than 0.5 to 1.0 Hz, in functional tremor a | |
| Tremor shows different reactions to | |
| In an | |
| Often functional tremor can be precipitated by | |
| Impaired walking and standing without a tendency to fall is often detected in functional tremor, meaning swaying gait and apparent |
Therapeutic methods evaluated to treat functional tremor
| therapeutic approach | type of application | associated studies |
|---|---|---|
| Repeated low-frequency (0.25 Hz) magnetic simulation over the motor cortex or the spinal roots on the symptomatic side showed symptom improvement in functional tremor patients | ([ | |
| Tremor entrainment in form of tactile and auditory external cueing combined with real-time visual feedback as a short-term treatment can be effective in functional tremor therapy | [ | |
| drugs (e.g. propanolol, primidone, gabapentin, clonazepam, botulinum toxin, trihexyphenidyl) known from organic tremor treatment can be used with more or less success in FT therapy | ([ | |
| PDP can lead to an improvement in patients suffering from functional tremor. The prediction of responding rates is very challenging and prospective studies are generally lacking. | ([ | |
| CBT is an approach to instruct patients in identifying cognitive as well as physiologic responses experienced with stress. It aims to interrupt automatisms learned in association with the functional movement disorder. Even if the amount of data are small, single blind studies proved it as an effective therapeutic option | ([ |