| Literature DB >> 33305018 |
Dania Talaat Dahmash1, Zakia B Shariff1, Daniel J Kirby1, David Terry1, Chi Huynh1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To identify studies that highlighted medication administration problems experienced by parents and children, which also looked at health literacy aspect using a validated tool to assess for literacy. STUDYEntities:
Keywords: health services research; pharmacology; qualitative research
Year: 2020 PMID: 33305018 PMCID: PMC7692990 DOI: 10.1136/bmjpo-2020-000841
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Paediatr Open ISSN: 2399-9772
Figure 1Flow diagram for the study selection based on Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews andMeta-Analyses flow diagram.
Figure 2List of the review results.
Characteristics of the observational included studies in the review (listed by health literacy test)
| Study information | Participants characteristics | Findings | |||||
| First author (year) | Setting | Methods | Aim | Age of the recruited sample | Sample size | Health literacy test used | Outcomes and gaps |
| Morrison | Outpatient clinic and emergency department | Interviews and applied assessment | To examine the association between parent health literacy and pain medication knowledge and applied skills in parents of children with sickle cell disease. | Parents of children 1–12 years old. | 100 | Newest vital sign (NVS) | Parents with low health literacy made more under dose frequency errors on the pain treatment skills. |
| Torres | Paediatric outpatient clinics | Cross-sectional analysis | Sought to examine the interrelationships between parents’ preferences and perceptions regarding unites of measurement, parents millilitre dosing experiences, and parent health literacy. | Parents or legal guardian of children≤8 years old. | 493 | NVS | Parents preferred the millilitre dosing to be easy; few 11.5% prefers teaspoon units. Parents will low health literacy levels had a higher odd of having a teaspoon preference and greater odds of perceiving difficulty with the millilitre only dosing. |
| Williams | Outpatient clinics | Cross-sectional analysis | To assess parent decision‐making regarding dosing tools, a known contributor to medication dosing errors, by evaluating parent dosing tool use, beliefs, and access, and the role of health literacy, with a focus on dosing cups, which are associated with an increased risk of multifold overdose. | Parents or legal guardians of children aged ≤8 years old. | 473 | NVS | Health literacy is one of the factors that could be associated with the dosing tool choice. Parents with limited health literacy reported that dosing cups were the tool used most of the time. |
| Yin | Paediatric clinic | Observational | To assess parents’ liquid medication administration errors by dosing instrument type and to examine the degree to which parents’ health literacy influences dosing accuracy. | Parents of children with no specific age limitation. | 302 (287 mothers, 8 fathers, 7 legal guardians) | NVS | Health literacy was significantly related to doing errors with the cups as well as the dosing spoon, while non-significant trend was seen for the dropper and the oral syringes with the bottle adaptor. |
| Samuels-Kalow | Tertiary | Prospective observational | To examine language-based disparities in discharge communication and parental understanding of discharge instructions. | Parents of children 2 to 24 months. | 145 | Short Test of Functional Health Literacy | Parents had acetaminophen dosing errors. |
| Yin | Paediatric emergency department | Interviews and observations | To examine the degree to which recommended provider-counselling strategies, including advanced communication techniques and dosing instruments provision, are associated with reductions in parents liquid medication dosing errors. | Parents of children aged <8 years old. | 287 | S-TOFHLA | Majority of the patents made underdoing errors as well as few made overdosing errors. |
| Yin | Emergency department | Interviews and observations | To examine the association between unit used and parent medication errors and whether non-standard instruments mediate the relationship. | Parents of children aged <9 years old. | 400 | S-TOFHLA | Parents made different kind of error in measurement. One in six parents used kitchen spoon rather than a standard instrument. |
| Yin | Paediatric emergency department. | Interviews | To assess whether low caregiver health literacy was related to risk factors for liquid medication dosing errors, including reported use of non-standardised dosing tools and lack of knowledge about weight-based dosing. | Parents and caregivers of children aged between 30 days to 8 years old. | 292 | Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults | Low health literacy, particularly reading comprehension, was associated with reported use of non-standardised dosing instruments and lack of knowledge regarding weight-based dosing. In addition, this has been found previously to be associated with decreased dosing accuracy. |
Characteristics of the randomised controlled experiment included in the review (listed alphabetically according to first author)
| Study information | Participants characteristics | Findings | |||||
| First author (year) | Setting | Methods | Aim | Age of the recruited sample | Sample Size | Health literacy test used | Outcomes and gaps |
| Wallace | Outpatient clinic | Randomised | To address the gap by addressing whether instructions wording that implicit versus explicit dosage intervals was associated with participant’s ability to describe and correctly measure a dose of a commonly prescribed liquid paediatric prescription medication. | Women of childbearing age. | 193 | Estimated using three established items: How often do you have problems learning about your medical condition because of difficulty understanding written information? How often do you have someone help you read hospital martials? How confident are you filling out medical forms by yourself? | One third of the participants (32.1%) were able to describe and measure the dose accurately. |
| Yin | Paediatric clinic | Randomised controlled experiment | Hypothesised that unit concordance would be associated with fewer errors and that parents would measure most accurately with syringes we also sought to examine differences in impact by parents health literacy and language because low health literacy and limited English proficiency (LEP) are factors known to place children at risk for errors. | Parents of children aged ≤8 years old. | 2099 parents | Newest vital sign | Nearly all parents (99.3%) measured ≥1 dose that was not the exact amount. Overdoing (68.0%) was the majority of the errors. |
| Harris | Outpatient | Randomised controlled experiment | To examine the association between health literacy and limited English proficiency and liquid medication dosing errors in Hispanic parents | Hispanic parents of children<8 years old. | 1126 parents | NVS | 70% of the recruited parents had LEP, 82.7% had limited literacy. Of parents who had LEP 88.8% had limited and 11.2% adequate health literacy. |
| Yin | Outpatient paediatric clinic | Randomised controlled trail | To sought whether a pictographic dosing diagram included as part of written instructions can decrease parent errors in dosing infant acetaminophen as well as whether pictogram benefit varies by parent health literacy level. | Parents or caregiver of a child with no specific age limitation. | 299 parents were assessed | NVS | Both groups were associated with poor dosing with the tendency for the parents who have received text plus pictogram significantly less likely to make dosing error (0.6%) compared with parents who received text only instructions (5.6%). |
| Yin | Paediatric outpatient clinic | Randomised controlled experiment | To examine the degree to which errors could be reduced with pictographic diagrams, millilitre-only units, and provision of tools more closely matched to prescribed volumes | Parents of children aged ≤8 years old. | 2099 for all arms | NVS | Majority of the parents (99.3%) made dosing errors. More errors with the 2 and 7.5 mL dosing amount when compared with the 10 mL (2 mL vs 10 mL aOR=3.7; 7.5 mL vs 10 mL aOR=1.4). |
| Yin | Paediatric emergency department | Randomised controlled trial | To evaluate the efficacy of a pictogram-based health literacy intervention to decrease liquid medication administration errors by caregivers of young children. | Parents and caregivers of children aged 30 days to 8 years. | 245 | Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults | Caregiver’s dose accuracy was higher among the intervention group prescribed daily and as needed medications regardless of the cut-off point was 20% or 40%. |