Waqas Ali Haider1, Muhammad Tahir1, Liang He1, H A Mirza2, Ruiqi Zhu1, Yulai Han3, Liqiang Mai1,4. 1. State Key Laboratory of Advanced Technology for Materials Synthesis and Processing, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430070, China. 2. Department of Chemistry, York University, Toronto, M3J 1P3 Ontario, Canada. 3. School of New Materials and New Energies, Shenzhen Technology University, Shenzhen 518118, China. 4. Foshan Xianhu Laboratory of the Advanced Energy Science and Technology Guangdong Laboratory, Xianhu Hydrogen Valley, Foshan 528200, China.
Abstract
The development of portable, wearable, and miniaturized integrated electronics has significantly promoted the immense desire for planar micro-supercapacitors (MSCs) among the extremely competitive energy storage devices. However, their energy density is still insufficient owing to the low electrochemical performance of conventional electrode materials. Compared with their bulk counterparts, the large specific surface area and fast ion transport with efficient intercalation of two-dimensional (2D) transition metal compounds have spurred the research platforms for their exploitation in the creation of high-performance MSCs. This Outlook presents a systematic summary of cutting-edge research on atomically thin, layered structures of transition metal dichalcogenides, MXenes, and transition metal oxides/hydroxides. Special emphasis is given to the rapid and durable storage of ions, benefiting from the low ion diffusion barriers of host interlayer spaces. Moreover, various strategies have been described to circumvent the structural damage due to the volume change and simultaneously evincing remarkable electronic properties.
The development of portable, wearable, and miniaturized integrated electronics has significantly promoted the immense desire for planar micro-supercapacitors (MSCs) among the extremely competitive energy storage devices. However, their energy density is still insufficient owing to the low electrochemical performance of conventional electrode materials. Compared with their bulk counterparts, the large specific surface area and fast ion transport with efficient intercalation of two-dimensional (2D) transition metal compounds have spurred the research platforms for their exploitation in the creation of high-performance MSCs. This Outlook presents a systematic summary of cutting-edge research on atomically thin, layered structures of transition metal dichalcogenides, MXenes, and transition metal oxides/hydroxides. Special emphasis is given to the rapid and durable storage of ions, benefiting from the low ion diffusion barriers of host interlayer spaces. Moreover, various strategies have been described to circumvent the structural damage due to the volume change and simultaneously evincing remarkable electronic properties.
The sustained progression
of portable technologies has driven the
desire for the development of micro-power-sources which are potentially
able to be integrated into miniaturized systems for medical, telecommunication,
and other microelectronic devices.[1,2] Although thin-film
Li-ion microbatteries (MBs) are dominant due to their high energy
density (∼1 mW h cm–2), their short lifetime
(500–10 000 cycles) and low power density (<5 mW
cm–2) inhibit their applications in systems where
battery replacement is infeasible, and huge energy spikes are required.[3−5] Micro-supercapacitors (MSCs) are safe alternative energy-storage
solutions which manifest a longer lifetime (>100 000 cycles)
and provide high power density (>10 mW cm–2)
with
rapid charge/discharge capabilities.[6−8] MSCs with the conventional
electric double layer (EDL) mechanism exhibit low energy density (<0.1
mW h cm–2) owing to their intrinsic electrostatic
charge storage that requires large surface area and pore sizes.[9,10] Although the capacitance can be increased by employing an active
electrode material with large volume, that consequently increases
the size of the cell to an undesired extent.[11] Contrary to EDL, the pseudocapacitive mechanism of charge storage
exhibits elevated energy density and specific capacitance via a rapid
repeatable redox reaction among the active electrode material and
electrolyte.[12,13] Typically, EDL and pseudocapacitance
occur together in MSCs; however, one of them becomes dominant based
on the interaction of electrode material with electrolyte ions.[14] The redox reaction involves the exchange of
charges across the double layer rather than creating a cloud of immovable
charges around the electrode material.[15] The charge storage of pseudocapacitive materials has a linear reliance
on the range of applied potential and tendency of oxidation and reduction,
though the redox reaction can continuously change the oxidation states
of electrode cations, which eventually degrades the cycling performance
of the pseudocapacitor.The aforementioned challenges cause
a driving force toward the
exploration of electroactive materials to achieve efficient charge
transfer between electrode and electrolyte. Materials based on transition
metal compounds have been enthusiastically investigated for charge
storage because of their variable oxidation states, which enable transition
metal cations to actively participate in the Faradaic charge transfer
process.[16,17] However, their potential applications are
still restricted since they experience an inadequate rate capability
and cycling performance due to their slow charge transfer kinetics
and low electrical conductivity. Nevertheless, the compounds of transition
metals with layered structures are fascinating because of their great
potential for the fast ion diffusion that allows maximum insertion
and extraction of electrolyte ions into the interlayer spaces of the
electrode material.[18] The ultrathin layered
crystals will endow the electrode material with several advantages
such as a large surface area available for electrolyte interaction.
The edges of layered sheets provide higher electrochemical activity
than the planar surface to store more metal ions due to the intercalation,
and these crystal structures are less fragile, providing high mechanical
strength for flexible wearable devices.[19] Transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) exhibit a two-dimensional
(2D) layered structure with strong covalent intralayer and weak interlayer
van der Waals interactions which make them good hosts for the inclusion
of electrolyte ions.[20,21] These ions are repeatedly inserted
into the van der Waals gaps for the storage and delivery of charges
through the adjacent layers. The incorporation of carbon and/or nitrogen
atoms into the early transition metals forms another group of inorganic
compounds (MXenes), which present layered formation with high electrical
conductivity, hydrophilicity, and excellent mechanical strength.[22] These characteristics are associated with the
covalent, ionic, and metallic bonds between the atoms in MXenes.[23] The covalent nature of interaction produces
a low postintercalation volume expansion that brings excellent stability
to the structures. Furthermore, excellent ionic properties and high
electrical conductivity of the transition metal atoms are desirable
for charge storage and delivery.[24] Besides
these compounds, another class of electrode materials includes the
transition metal oxides/hydroxides (TMOs/TMHs), which are considered
superior due to their exceptional theoretical capacities (e.g., RuO2, ∼1400–2200 F g–1; MnO2, 1370 F g–1), rapid reversible electron
transfer, and their abundance in nature.[25,26] Oxides/hydroxides of transition metals can reveal surface redox
reaction or intercalation dominated pseudocapacitance depending on
their structure and charge storage behavior.[27] The morphology of TMOs and TMHs can be tailored through facile synthesis
procedures which often require a relatively low temperature.[28] The morphology and size are important parameters
to determine the diffusion kinetics and cyclability of the electrode
materials. Bulk transition metal compounds suffer from intrinsic low
electrical conductivity; however, their 2D structures provide a high
surface area to demonstrate fast ion diffusion and high electrical
conductivity. Besides, there are opportunities for further research
aimed at the amalgamation of diverse capacitive materials to obtain
hybrid systems, which produce an enhanced electrochemical performance
owing to the synergistic effect established between active materials.
The performance of MSCs depends not only on the attributes of active
materials but also on the configuration and arrangement of microelectrodes.[29]Hence, there is a constellation of materials
and composites with
EDL or pseudocapacitance that are being developed to realize the high-performance
MSCs. This Outlook highlights the latest advances of highly electroactive
2D TMDs, MXenes, and TMOs/TMHs in the assembly of MSCs with a planar
configuration (Figure ). The critical issues of structural aggregation and inherently low
electrical conductivity associated with the conventional transition
metal compounds hinder their wide-ranging applications. Herein, we
presented impactful strategies to overcome these obstacles by structural
engineering for tuning the crystal structure, porosity, and electrical
conductivity of the metallic phase. Additionally, various coupling
principles are elucidated to rationally integrate the composite hybrids
and asymmetric configurations of electrodes to construct the MSCs
with high electrochemical performance.
Figure 1
Schematic illustration
of 2D electrode materials based on transition
metals for the micro-supercapacitor.
Schematic illustration
of 2D electrode materials based on transition
metals for the micro-supercapacitor.
Transition Metal Dichalcogenides (TMDs)
TMDs represent
a family of 2D layered inorganic materials with
a generalized chemical notation MX2, where M denotes a
transition metal atom (Mo, W, V, etc.), and X is a chalcogen atom
(S, Se, or Te). The transition metal atoms are covalently intercalated
between two chalcogen layers, so their crystal constitutes a layered
structure with weak interlayer van der Waals forces.[30] Recently, owing to their attractive physicochemical properties
such as high surface area, electrochemical activity, mechanical permanency,
excellent processability, and low cost, these materials have triggered
wide research for utilization in the fields of energy storage, hydrogen
evolution electrocatalysis, solar systems, sensors, biotechnology,
and nanoelectronics.[31,32] Their heterostructures could
convert the indirect band gap to a direct band gap, which is critical
for electrocatalytic conversion, electrochemical energy storage, and
applications in other electronics. Regarding energy storage, the reduced
dimension of the atomically thin MX2 layer offers the electrolyte
a maximized contact with the active electrode for Faradaic and non-Faradaic
interactions, and the interlayer spaces act as excellent hosts for
swift ion diffusion ensuring the higher utilization of material for
developing high-performance electrodes.[33] Considering MoS2 as a prominent candidate of TMD species,
Cao et al. demonstrated an MSC based on 2D MoS2 film, where
microelectrodes were prepared by the spray painting of a hydrothermally
prepared substance, followed by laser cutting.[34] The structured nanosheets expedite the approach of aqueous
electrolyte ions to the electrode, and the cell exhibited an areal
specific capacitance of 8 mF cm–2 but showed insufficient
cycling performance due to self-restacking of nanosheets. Later, another
perspective was given to reveal that exfoliated few-layered MoS2 exhibits higher electrochemical activity than the bulk material,
and in that particular study, MoS2 flakes showed a capacitance
of 2.4 mF cm–2, superior to the bulk counterpart
(∼0.5 mF cm–2).[35] The exfoliated structures still showed the problem of aggregation
and restacking, reducing the performance, so their crystal structures
are further modified. The later sections describe the significant
developments in the utilization of 2D TMDs.
2D Metallic
TMDs
The phase engineering
of chemically exfoliated sheets of metallic TMDs shows enhanced electrochemical
behavior by allowing high intercalation of electrolyte ions. Research
reveals that the metallic 1T (octahedral) phase of TMDs exhibits a
higher electrochemical performance due to the enhanced electrical
conductivity relative to the semiconducting 2H (trigonal prismatic)
phase.[36] In this regard, earlier research
employed chemical exfoliation to achieve highly concentrated metallic
1T phase MoS2 films.[37] The nanosheets
showed the capability of efficient intercalation of H, Li, K, and
Na cations so that the thin-film electrode delivered a specific capacitance
ranging from 400 to 700 F cm–3 in various electrolytes.
The high performance was attributed to the intrinsic hydrophilic property,
electrical conductivity, and ability of exfoliated nanosheets to efficiently
intercalate the electrolyte ions. It is anticipated that achieving
the 1T metallic phase of various other TMDs through exfoliation would
also show a progressive electrochemical response. On this subject,
another research effort which was published later demonstrated the
electrochemical activity and stability of highly conductive metallic
1T-WS2 nanoribbons.[38] The prepared
electrodes exhibited a capacitance of 2.81 mF cm–2, several factors higher than that of the semiconducting 2H-WS2 electrode. The improved electrical conductivity and extended
spaces for intercalation between the consecutive layers revealed the
potential of 2D metallic TMDs for power applications. Wu et al. proposed
one-step acid-assisted exfoliation for the synthesis and surface modification
of a large monolayer of TaS2 (Figure a).[39] Acid treatment
of LiTaS2 yielded the metallic sub-nanopore TaS2 (MSP-TaS2) with simultaneously exploiting the etching
property of the hydrogen ion (H+) for porosity engineering
to obtain a pore size of ∼0.95 nm, which was optimized with
the size of electrolyte ions to provide fast ion transport kinetics.
The interdigital MSC based on MSP-TaS2 microelectrodes
delivered a specific capacitance of 508 F cm–3 and
an energy density of 58.5 W h L–1. The quasirectangular
cyclic voltammetry (CV) curves showed the dominant EDL capacitive
behavior in the voltage range 0–0.9 V, which corroborates the
effective electrolyte ion permeation through the MSP-TaS2 film (Figure b).
Furthermore, the MSC showed improved cyclability, and 92% of the original
capacitance was retained after 4000 cycles (Figure c). In another report, metallic 2D 1T-VSe2 exfoliated nanosheets were prepared by employing a facile
ambient pressure chemical vapor deposition (AP-CVD) technique.[40] A flexible in-plane supercapacitor was fabricated
with high mechanical strength, demonstrating a stable performance
even after 10 000 bending cycles. The prepared device presented
dominant EDL behavior with a capacitance of 4.17 mF cm–2 in PVA/KNO3 gel electrolyte. 1T-MoS2 has also
been extensively employed in energy storage due to its plentiful active
sites and virtuous conductivity, though it is thermodynamically unstable
owing to the slanted crystal structure. Recently, the Mai research
group monitored a mixed 2H-1T phase of MoS2, which possesses
optimal performance and high stability.[41] Initially, 2H-MoS2 was lithiated to obtain a 1T-MoS2 nanosheet micro-/nanodevice, followed by the electrochemical
treatment for transition to the stable 2H-1T mixed phase of MoS2 (Figure d).
The 2H-1T mixed phase retained a lower adsorption energy at the boundary,
allowing the protons to easily combine at the boundary instead of
adsorbing on the surface of S atoms in 2H and 1T phases (Figure e). The electronegativities
of Mo and S atoms are higher at the boundary in the 2H-1T phase as
compared to the 2H and 1T phases. Although the I–V measurements
showed the higher electrical conductivity of the 1T phase because
of it being pure metallic in nature, practically, the 2H-1T mixed
phase had the smallest specific value of Rct (Figure f). The
smallest impedance of the 2H-1T phase revealed by EIS showed the best
charge transfer rate in the mixed phase. Since various exfoliated
metallic nanosheets exhibit a hydrophobic nature, they are still prone
to aggregation, which is further annihilated by the growth and integration
of other nanostructures.
Figure 2
(a) Schematic illustration
of acid-assisted etching and exfoliation
to obtain TaS2 monolayers for the fabrication of MSC.[39] (b) CV curves at different scan rates and (c)
cycling stability of the MSP-TaS2-based MSC at a current
density of 2 A g–1; the inset is the GCD curves
at the 1st and 4000th cycle. Schematic diagram of (d) the phase transition
from state I to state III and (e) simulation of proton adsorption
in the 2H, 1T, and mixed 2H-1T phases of MoS2.[41] (f) Specific conductivity of three states and
their corresponding Rct values. (g) Scheme
to visualize the one-body array of core/shell nanowires (left), and
corresponding ADF-STEM image of WO3/WS2 core/shell
nanowire (right).[47] (h) Optical image under
mechanical bending (left), and corresponding SEM image (right) of
densely aligned core/shell nanowires; the inset shows their faceted
surface. (i) Cycling performance at a scan rate of 100 mV s–1. Reprinted with permission from refs (39, 41, and 47). Copyright
2018 American Chemical Society, 2020 Royal Society of Chemistry, 2016
American Chemical Society.
(a) Schematic illustration
of acid-assisted etching and exfoliation
to obtain TaS2 monolayers for the fabrication of MSC.[39] (b) CV curves at different scan rates and (c)
cycling stability of the MSP-TaS2-based MSC at a current
density of 2 A g–1; the inset is the GCD curves
at the 1st and 4000th cycle. Schematic diagram of (d) the phase transition
from state I to state III and (e) simulation of proton adsorption
in the 2H, 1T, and mixed 2H-1T phases of MoS2.[41] (f) Specific conductivity of three states and
their corresponding Rct values. (g) Scheme
to visualize the one-body array of core/shell nanowires (left), and
corresponding ADF-STEM image of WO3/WS2 core/shell
nanowire (right).[47] (h) Optical image under
mechanical bending (left), and corresponding SEM image (right) of
densely aligned core/shell nanowires; the inset shows their faceted
surface. (i) Cycling performance at a scan rate of 100 mV s–1. Reprinted with permission from refs (39, 41, and 47). Copyright
2018 American Chemical Society, 2020 Royal Society of Chemistry, 2016
American Chemical Society.
Hybrid Composites of 2D TMDs
Usually,
the pure TMDs have 3 phase structures: 1T phase with fine conductivity,
2H with poor conductivity, and 3R phase with almost insulation.[42] The electrochemical performance of pristine
TMDs is considerably low owing to the intrinsic low conductivity and
the property of restacking.[43] The hybridization
of TMDs with other conductive materials influences the physicochemical
properties to realize better exploitation of charge storage and to
show improved cycling stability through mechanical reinforcement and
better rate capability of the conductive hybrid.[44,45] Wang et al. composited VSe2 with carbon nanotubes (VSe2/CNT) through a one-step CVD method to fabricate a solid-state
flexible in-plane supercapacitor.[46] The
authors reported that VSe2 nanosheets effectively exposed
the surface for charge storage, and the CNT had a high conductivity
and mechanical strength. Only 7% of capacitance was reduced after
10 000 charge–discharge cycles, and 91% of the original
capacitance was retained after bending the device up to an angle of
40°. A distinct study by Jung and co-workers reported a flexible
core/shell supercapacitor based on a 1D single-crystalline tungsten
trioxide (WO3) core seamlessly integrated with a 2D WS2 layered shell.[47] The interface
was self-assembled without any binder to form a one-body architecture
(Figure g). The electrode
design and material presented multifold advantages such as densely
aligned nanowires providing a large surface area for ion adsorption/intercalation,
sub-nanometer gaps of the WS2 layer facilitating electrolyte
ion insertion, and the conductive core having efficiently drawn out
the charges (Figure h). This hybrid formation confirmed the excellent synergistic behavior
of WO3/WS2 core/shell nanowires through performing
the electrochemical performance measurements using a three-electrode
setup. The quasisymmetrical CV loops corroborated the dominant EDL
capacitance over the Faradaic behavior in the voltage range from −0.3
to 0.5 V. The slight deviation of CV curves from the ideal rectangular
shape indicated some degree of redox reaction taking place by the
intercalation of electrolyte ions, and the increasing skewness from
the symmetrical curve at scan rates beyond 200 mV s–1 is ascribed to the enhanced accumulation of electrolyte ions on
the electrode surface. The initial capacitance of the nanowire-based
supercapacitor was calculated to be 47.5 mF cm–2 at 5 mV s–1; however, the capacitance increased
to 74.25 mF cm–2 at the same scan rate after 2500
cycles. During the cycling, it was observed that the capacitance continued
to increase up to 2500 cycles because the WS2 shell became
electrochemically more active as the exposure of layers to electrolyte
increased with cycles. The device showed an exceptional cycling performance
with no decline in capacitance even after 30 000 charge–discharge
cycles (Figure i).
After 30 000 cycles, material characterizations revealed the
exceptional structural and chemical stability of WO3/WS2 nanowires. The practicability of the reported supercapacitor
was determined by the maximum energy density of 0.06 W h cm–3.Another strategy removed the barriers in the progress of
TMDs by preparing a composite of a MoS2 nanosheet-wrapped
CoS2 nanotube array via a facile hydrothermal reaction
route.[48] This collaboration endowed high
capacitance where the conductive channels of CoS2 nanotubes
offered large expandable spaces for volume change to prevent the aggregation,
and the MoS2 nanosheets provided more active sites for
effective electrolyte accessibility. It is evident that the hybridization
with a conductive basis reveals the approach for rational design and
synthesis of diverse TMD electrodes. Li et al. demonstrated the development
of an interpenetrated nanowire network in which Ag nanowires provided
a highly conductive basis for collection and transport of charge carriers,
and 2D metallic 1T phase MoS2 nanosheets were employed
as an ultrathin hydrophilic capacitive covering (Figure a).[49] It was elucidated that the electrolyte protons inserted into the
interlayer spacing of clad MoS2 to combine with electrons
and produced a redox mechanism (Figure b). Based on the transparent films of clad AgNWs-MoS2, a highly flexible MSC was fabricated (Figure c), which delivered an auspicious electrochemical
performance and high rate capability with a specific capacitance of
27.6 mF cm–2 at 0.2 V s–1, reduced
to 16.9 mF cm–2 at a high scan rate of 3 V s–1. The MSC exhibited a specific energy density of 2.45
μW h cm–2 and a corresponding power density
of 1.47 mW cm–2. Furthermore, the MSC performed
well during stability measurements by losing only 3.6% of the initial
capacitance after 10 000 cycles (Figure d). The mechanical strength and bendability
of the device were tested by bending it to an angle of 180° 100
times, and the device showed a slight degradation of 1.4% in capacitance
as compared with the normal state.
Figure 3
Schematic representation of (a) AgNWs-MoS2 illustrating
the electron transport, (b) ion diffusion in the microelectrodes during
charging, and (c) laser-patterning of a flexible, transparent MSC.[49] (d) Cycling stability up to 20 000 cycles
at 0.5 V s–1 and rate capability at different scan
rates. (e) Schematic illustration of transferring active materials
into the microchannel for the asymmetric hybrid configuration of VS2@EG/AC-MSC.[53] (f) Working mechanism
of MSC during charging and discharging. (g) Contribution ratio of
capacitive and diffusion-controlled behavior at different scan rates.
(h) Specific areal capacitance as a function of current density. Reprinted
with permission from refs (49) and (53). Copyright 2019 Elsevier, 2019 Wiley-VCH.
Schematic representation of (a) AgNWs-MoS2 illustrating
the electron transport, (b) ion diffusion in the microelectrodes during
charging, and (c) laser-patterning of a flexible, transparent MSC.[49] (d) Cycling stability up to 20 000 cycles
at 0.5 V s–1 and rate capability at different scan
rates. (e) Schematic illustration of transferring active materials
into the microchannel for the asymmetric hybrid configuration of VS2@EG/AC-MSC.[53] (f) Working mechanism
of MSC during charging and discharging. (g) Contribution ratio of
capacitive and diffusion-controlled behavior at different scan rates.
(h) Specific areal capacitance as a function of current density. Reprinted
with permission from refs (49) and (53). Copyright 2019 Elsevier, 2019 Wiley-VCH.
Asymmetric Hybrid 2D TMD-MSCs
To
enhance the energy capabilities of MSCs, the asymmetric assembly is
an effective strategy to extend the working voltage range through
the combination of dissimilar microelectrodes.[50,51] For example, Moosavifard et al. obtained interdigital micropatterns
of laser scribed graphene (LSG) onto the flexible PET substrate followed
by the selective electrodeposition of CoNi2S4 to construct a flexible MSC.[52] Here,
LSC/CoNi2S4 and LCG worked as the positive and
negative interdigital microelectrodes, respectively, with GO as the
separator and PVA/KOH gel electrolyte to formulate a hybrid all-solid-state
flexible MSC. The device exhibited EDL and pseudocapacitive mechanisms
simultaneously in a potential range of up to 1.7 V, which is the characteristic
of a hybrid system. The stack capacitance was evaluated in correspondence
to the deposition cycles, and a maximum capacitance of 122.4 F cm–3 was obtained with 15 deposition cycles. The MSC showed
an outstanding cycling performance, retaining 93.9% of the original
capacitance after 10 000 charge–discharge cycles at
15 A cm–3, and the CoNi2S4 nanosheets remained stable even after the cycling. Here, graphene
was considered as a “superhighway” for fast electron
transport, and CoNi2S4 nanosheets provided a
large surface area for the redox activity to enhance the overall performance.
The MSC showed excellent flexibility up to a bending angle of 180°
and delivered an energy density of 49 W h L–1. Another
work by Feng’s group described the construction of a new type
of hybrid asymmetric MSC by formulating hierarchical VS2 nanosheets grown on the electrochemically exfoliated graphene (EG).[53] VS2@EG served as the negative electrode;
activated carbon (AC) was employed to fabricate the positive electrode,
and the nonaqueous NaClO4 dispersion was used as the electrolyte
(Figure e). The hierarchical
nanostructures of VS2@EG exposed the surface for rapid
insertion/extraction of ions, and the AC enabled high adsorption/desorption
resulting in a high rate capability and reversibility during charge–discharge
(Figure f). The balanced
mass distribution of electrode materials was attained to demonstrate
a high-efficiency hybrid MSC, which worked within the large voltage
range 0.01–3.5 V. The hybrid MSC delivered a specific capacitance
of 110.7 mF cm–2 at 0.2 mA cm–2 and maximum energy and power densities of 188.3 μW h cm–2 and 5.9 mW cm–2, respectively.
Moreover, the device showed no noticeable capacitance degradation
after charging and discharging 5000 times; rather, there was an increase
in capacitance that could be attributed to wettability and good penetration
of the electrolyte after several cycles. The synergistic effect was
due to the dissimilar capacitive mechanisms of the VS2@EG
anode and AC cathode. The ratio of the pseudocapacitive contribution
by VS2@EG kept increasing at higher scan rates owing to
the exposed active surface sites for the rapid Na+ insertion/extraction,
and the MSC presented a high rate capability due to the hierarchical
porous structure (Figure g,h). Other than typical graphene, various carbon-free TM
chalcogenides (e.g., CuSe) revealed a better affinity with Au current
collectors to provide a conductive scaffold. For instance, transition
metal oxyhydroxides (MOOH: FeOOH and MnOOH) were alternatively deposited
onto vertically oriented CuSe nanosheets with interspaces of 2–3
μm for better utilization of MOOH.[54] The asymmetric MSC exhibited a specific capacitance of 20.47 mF
cm–2, excellent cycle performance (95% remained
after 32 000 cycles), a high energy density of 16 mW h cm–3, and a power density of 1299.4 mW cm–3. Forgoing research spurred the rationality of asymmetric assembly
design, which facilitated MSCs to operate steadily in an extended
voltage window for the enhancement of energy density.
Transition Metal Carbides and/or Nitrides (MXenes)
MXenes are 2D inorganic materials based on transition metal carbides
and/or nitrides and are emerging as high-performance materials for
applications in Li/Na-ion energy-storage systems, supercapacitors,
and water purification. The common notation of MXenes is MXT in which M represents the transition metals (Ti, Cr, Mo, V,
Nb, Zr, etc.) and X carbon or nitrogen; n is an integer
from 1 to 3, and T stands for the surface
termination group like hydroxyl, oxygen, or fluorine. The surface
termination groups reduce the hydrophilicity and significantly influence
their electrical properties.[55,56] MXenes are obtained
by selective etching of the “A” layer from the MAX phase
and added “ene” to the end for revealing its 2D nature.
Since their discovery, MXenes have received tremendous attention in
the field of energy storage due to their exceptional structures. For
example, they have efficient electron transport owing to their highly
conductive inner transition metal carbide layer and large active sites
for fast surface redox reactions comparable with transition metaloxides. Out of more than 20 reported MXenes, titanium carbide (Ti3C2) is widely explored for applications in MSCs
because of its high electrical conductivity (6.76 × 103 S cm–1), large specific capacitance (1500 F cm–3), and excellent rate performance (10 V s–1) in acidic electrolyte.[57−59] In addition to the high specific
capacitance, MXenes possess a high mechanical stability due to their
layered nature and are hence favorable for MSCs specifically.[60] Different electrolyte cations, for instance,
Li+, K+, Na+, NH4+, Al3+, etc., can intercalate in the MXene layers
during the electrochemical process, which makes them promising candidates
for supercapacitors and multivalent ionic electrolyte batteries.[61] Contrary to charge storage onto/into the electrode
surface by adsorption of electrolyte ions, MXenes store charge through
fast reversible redox reactions, offering high volumetric capacitance
at a high charge/discharge rate with excellent electrical conductivity.
Most of the MXene-based MSCs reported so far have displayed limited
areal energy density (<10 mW h cm–2) due to their
small operating voltage range in aqueous electrolytes (0.6–1.0
V). Herein, we describe the latest substantial developments in the
MXene-based MSCs.
Pristine MXene-Based MSCs
Ionogel
is a specific quasi-solid-state electrolyte in which ionic liquids
(ILs) are assimilated into the suitable polymer matrix during polycondensation,
and their exceptional thermal stability empowers a wide operation
temperature of MSCs, high working voltage window, and excellent cycling
stability.[62−64] Zheng et al. reported the construction of a novel
type of ionogel-based on-chip MSC by IL preintercalated MXene layers
that operated in a high voltage and achieved a high volumetric energy
density and extraordinary flexibility with segmental incorporation
of bipolar cells.[65] By using interdigital
mask-assisted deposition of MXene onto the graphene support, the obtained
microelectrodes realized a high electrical conductivity of 2200 S
cm–1 and high stability for fast electron transfer
without any polymer binder and conducting additives or the metal current
collectors. Due to the IL preintercalation, the MXene-based film established
a network of ion transportation with an extended interlayer spacing
(1.45 nm), larger than those of undried (1.27 nm) and dried (1.09
nm) MXenes (Figure a,b). Furthermore, the MSC assembled with EMIMBF4 electrolyte
displayed a remarkable areal capacitance of 140 F cm–3, a specific energy density of 13.9 μW h cm–2 (43.7 mW h cm–3), and exceptional flexibility
with long-term cycling stability retaining ample capacitance by no
loss up to 10 000 cycles. The enlarged pseudocapacitance of
the electrochemically active MXene as shown by the CV curves in Figure c was attributed
to the expanded interlamellar spaces created by intercalated IL, which
provided a large ion-approachable surface area and low ionic resistance,
enabling interlayer nanochannels to accommodate more insertion/extraction
of EMIM+ cations. The arrangement of the highly conductive
pseudocapacitive charge storage mechanism of MXenes with enhanced
mechanical flexibility and squashed film design results in a favorable
electrochemical performance. The Nicolosi research group developed
an elegant and quick stamping technique to fabricate MSCs based on
2D Ti3C2T nanosheets
by slightly pressing the 3D printed stamps on paper substrates after
coating with viscous MXene ink (Figure d).[66] The MXene ink constituted
hexagonal structured Ti3C2T nanosheets with an average lateral size of 1.2 ± 0.2
μm and thickness of ∼1.5 nm. Taking advantage of the
metallic conductivity of MXene nanosheets and homogeneous film morphology,
the current-collector-free electrodes were designed with fast electron
transport and high rate response (Figure e). Due to the favorable surface chemistry
of the stamped MXene on paper, there was an enhanced accessibility
of electrolyte ions deep inside the multilayered Ti3C2T nanoflakes (Figure f,g). By applying the gel electrolyte
and connecting Ag wire collectors, the constructed interdigital MSC
revealed an areal capacitance of 61 mF cm–2 at 25
μA cm–2 and a retained capacitance of 50 mF
cm–2 at 800 μA cm–2.
Figure 4
Schematic diagram
of the (a) production of IL preintercalated and
dried MXene electrode films and (b) preintercalated MXene MSC with
ionogel electrolyte, and parallel ion transfer between the films.[65] (c) CV curves (from 10 to 100 mV s–1) of MSC. (d) Representation of Ti3C2T nanosheet ink-based MSCs using the stamping
approach.[66] (e) Digital photo of stamped
MSCs with different designs. (f) SEM image of multilayered Ti3C2T. (g) TEM image
of dried Ti3C2T flakes; the inset is the selected area electron diffraction (SAED)
pattern. (h) Schematic for tuning MXene flake size by sonication.[67] (i) I–V characteristics of spray-coated MXene films of different flake sizes;
the inset shows the schematic of the four-point probe conductivity
measurement. (j) SEM image of a cross-section showing spray-coated
Ti3C2T thin films.
(k) Nyquist plot and schematic illustration of typical ion diffusion
paths of MXene films with different flake sizes. Reprinted with permission
from refs (65, 66, and 67). Copyright
2019 Royal Society of Chemistry, 2018 and 2019 Wiley-VCH.
Schematic diagram
of the (a) production of IL preintercalated and
dried MXene electrode films and (b) preintercalated MXene MSC with
ionogel electrolyte, and parallel ion transfer between the films.[65] (c) CV curves (from 10 to 100 mV s–1) of MSC. (d) Representation of Ti3C2T nanosheet ink-based MSCs using the stamping
approach.[66] (e) Digital photo of stamped
MSCs with different designs. (f) SEM image of multilayered Ti3C2T. (g) TEM image
of dried Ti3C2T flakes; the inset is the selected area electron diffraction (SAED)
pattern. (h) Schematic for tuning MXene flake size by sonication.[67] (i) I–V characteristics of spray-coated MXene films of different flake sizes;
the inset shows the schematic of the four-point probe conductivity
measurement. (j) SEM image of a cross-section showing spray-coated
Ti3C2T thin films.
(k) Nyquist plot and schematic illustration of typical ion diffusion
paths of MXene films with different flake sizes. Reprinted with permission
from refs (65, 66, and 67). Copyright
2019 Royal Society of Chemistry, 2018 and 2019 Wiley-VCH.The shortcoming of MXene-based MSCs fabricated by filtration
or
the stamping method is the control of interspaces between the electrode
fingers to achieve a high-frequency response with low relaxation time
constant (τ0). Solution-processed pseudocapacitive
materials usually display limited electrical conductivity resulting
in a low charge transfer rate and, hence, are not suitable for AC-line
filtering applications. The significant characteristics in the construction
of AC-line filtering capacitors include a high surface area with optimal
pore size to lower the electrolyte resistance, high ion/electron conducting
layered materials with minimal interspace resistance, and strong ohmic
contact between electrode materials and current collectors to lower
the impedance. Jiang and coresearchers designed a solution-processable
2D Ti3C2T nanosheet-based
interdigital MSC by optimizing the flake size and device architecture
resulting in a high-frequency response device comparable with an electrolytic
capacitor.[67] The suspension of Ti3C2T was ultrasonicated for
45 min by a tip sonicator (Figure h) to obtain smaller flake sizes (0.3 μm). For
the construction of the MSC, standard photolithography and a lift-off
process were employed, followed by the spray coating of the MXene.
The Ti3C2T dispersion
was spray coated onto the hydrophilic gold current collectors to obtain
a uniform distribution and robust adhesion of MXene flakes with the
metal surface. The interdigital MXene MSC was obtained after applying
PVA/H3PO4 gel electrolyte. The relationship
of flake size and electrical conductivity of the MXene was observed
by a four-probe method, and it was found that Ti3C2T film with a smaller flake size
(0.3 μm) displayed less electrical conductivity (900 S cm–1) compared with the larger flake size (1.7 μm)
with an electrical conductivity of 4500 S cm–1 (Figure i). Owing to the
strong adhesion of Ti3C2T sheets with metal collectors, the active material did not
peel off even after bath sonication during the lift-off procedure
(Figure j). The feasibility
of the wafer-scale MXene-based MSC was tested, which displayed a specific
capacitance of 30 F cm–3, a high rate performance
up to 300 V s–1, and a relaxation time constant
of 0.45 ms which was shorter than conventional capacitors. Consequently,
the device showed the filtering capability of 120 Hz ripples generated
by an AC power line at 60 Hz. Interestingly, even though the electrical
conductivity of Ti3C2T-0.3 μm is low, it showed lower equivalent series resistance
(ESR) (0.2 Ω cm2) than that of the Ti3C2T-1.7 μm (0.5 Ω
cm2), which indicated that ion access and dynamics are
equally essential for high rate charge/discharge (Figure k).
Composite
Hybrids and Asymmetric MSCs
An obstacle in large-scale applications
of MXene-based electrodes
is the restacking of nanosheets, which limits the intercalation of
electrolyte ions resulting in the low areal specific capacitance of
the constructed device. To prevent this issue, 1D carbonaceous materials
(e.g., carbon nanotubes and carbon fibers) have been extensively used
as interlayer spacers to prevent the restacking of MXene nanosheets
for the ultimately enhanced performance of the composite electrode.[68−72] Nevertheless, the high production cost considerably limits their
commercial applications on a large scale. Jiao et al. fabricated a
high-performance stretchable, bendable, and twistable MSC based on
fully delaminated few-layered 2D Ti3C2T nanoflakes composited with 1D bacterial
cellulose fibers (BC) through a solution-based paper making process
followed by high-power laser cutting (Figure a).[73] Within the
plane of this composite structure, the firmly stuffed MXene sheets
offered profoundly productive electron transport pathways, whereas
the BC fibers incredibly improved the mechanical stability of the
composite by acting as an adhesive between the Ti3C2T sheets, as displayed within
the magnified cross-sectional image (Figure b,c). The fabricated MSC exhibited an areal
capacitance of 111.5 mF cm–2 without any apparent
loss in capacitance during a tensile strain of 100% by bending and
twisting. The MSC unit prepared by the composite showed a 132% enhancement
in the areal energy performance compared to pure MXene (Figure d).
Figure 5
(a) Schematic diagram
of the MXene/BC solution, and MSCs in stretched
and relaxed states.[73] Representative SEM
images of (b) etched multilayered MXene sheets and (c) MXene/BC composite
showing BC fibers inserted between the MXene layers. (d) Areal energy
densities of MSCs based on pure MXene and MXene/BC composites prepared
with different mass ratios. (e) Schematic of the protocols for preparing
MXene-rGO composite aerogel.[76] (f) TEM
image of two MXene nanoflakes; inset is the corresponding SAED pattern.
(g) Capacitance retention of the fabricated MSC when cycled at 2 mA
cm–2; inset is the GCD curve of the last 11 cycles.
(h) Demonstration of MSCs operating a photodetector. (i) Schematic
illustration of the charge storage mechanism of an asymmetric MSC;
inset shows the CV curves of MXene and AC electrodes at a scan rate
of 10 mV s–1.[77] (j) Cross-sectional
SEM image indicating the thickness of the Ti3C2T-based negative electrode. (k) Nyquist
plots and the fitted equivalent circuit and (l) GCD curves of MXene-based
symmetric and MXene/AC asymmetric MSCs. (m) Schematic demonstration
of ion transport in interdigital and sandwich configurations of asymmetric
MSCs based on 2D Ti3C2T/rGO flakes.[78] (n) Electrical conductivities
of Ti3C2T and rGO
films. (o) Stability of different AMSCs and a symmetric MSC bent at
30° during cycling at 0.2 mA cm–2. Reprinted
with permission from refs (73 and 76−)(78). Copyright 2019
Wiley-VCH, 2019 American Chemical Society, 2020 Elsevier, 2018 Wiley-VCH.
(a) Schematic diagram
of the MXene/BC solution, and MSCs in stretched
and relaxed states.[73] Representative SEM
images of (b) etched multilayered MXene sheets and (c) MXene/BC composite
showing BC fibers inserted between the MXene layers. (d) Areal energy
densities of MSCs based on pure MXene and MXene/BC composites prepared
with different mass ratios. (e) Schematic of the protocols for preparing
MXene-rGO composite aerogel.[76] (f) TEM
image of two MXene nanoflakes; inset is the corresponding SAED pattern.
(g) Capacitance retention of the fabricated MSC when cycled at 2 mA
cm–2; inset is the GCD curve of the last 11 cycles.
(h) Demonstration of MSCs operating a photodetector. (i) Schematic
illustration of the charge storage mechanism of an asymmetric MSC;
inset shows the CV curves of MXene and AC electrodes at a scan rate
of 10 mV s–1.[77] (j) Cross-sectional
SEM image indicating the thickness of the Ti3C2T-based negative electrode. (k) Nyquist
plots and the fitted equivalent circuit and (l) GCD curves of MXene-based
symmetric and MXene/AC asymmetric MSCs. (m) Schematic demonstration
of ion transport in interdigital and sandwich configurations of asymmetric
MSCs based on 2D Ti3C2T/rGO flakes.[78] (n) Electrical conductivities
of Ti3C2T and rGO
films. (o) Stability of different AMSCs and a symmetric MSC bent at
30° during cycling at 0.2 mA cm–2. Reprinted
with permission from refs (73 and 76−)(78). Copyright 2019
Wiley-VCH, 2019 American Chemical Society, 2020 Elsevier, 2018 Wiley-VCH.Another effective approach to prevent the agglomeration
of MXene
nanosheets is to employ graphene between MXene layers as a perfect
spacer, thus improving the electrochemical properties of MXene.[74] However, due to the small size of MXene, the
contact resistance between the slices eventually causes an increase
in the internal resistance of the device.[75] A study by Yue and co-workers reported a simple method to construct
a self-healing MSC by using MXene-rGO composite aerogel by a freeze-drying
method followed by laser cutting (Figure e).[76] The MXene
nanoflakes had a 2D lamellar structure with a lateral size of a few
hundred nanometers (Figure f). When the blend arrangement of GO and MXene was solidified
by freezing, the nanosheets were constrained to slowly adjust along
the ice crystal boundary and ultimately cross-linked by the π–π
interaction to create a permeable network. The composite aerogel not
only shared the high surface area of graphene and excellent conductivity
of MXene but also prevented the self-restacking of the 2D lamellar
structure and the oxidation of MXene. By using carboxylated polyurethane
(PU) self-healable electrolyte, a flexible MSC was developed. The
MXene-rGO aerogel-based MSC displayed a high areal specific capacitance
of 34.6 mF cm–2 at 1 mV s–1, with
an excellent cycling performance and Coulombic efficiency after 15 000
cycles (Figure g).
The practical application of the real product was shown by driving
a photodetector of perovskite nanowires with a fully charged device
(Figure h).MSCs based on MXene present a high capacitive performance, rate
capability, cyclability, and capability of AC filtering. However,
due to its inception, the MXene-based electrodes still operate in
a low positive potential, limiting the energy density for extensive
practical applications. They suffer from excessive polarization at
a voltage beyond the open circuit potential, which causes an increase
in resistance and loss of adequacy.[61] Considering
the foregoing issues, Xie et al. designed and fabricated a high-voltage
asymmetric MSC by pairing Ti3C2T MXene as negative and activated carbon (AC) as positive
electrodes via a cutting–spraying method.[77] The microelectrodes shared a broad working voltage of 1.6
V using the neutral PVA/Na2SO4 gel electrolyte
without partaking in any unacceptably excessive polarization (Figure i). The enhanced
working potential intrinsically resulted in a boosted energy and power
performance. Furthermore, the microelectrodes had an excellent transmission
of electrolyte ions into the laminated morphology of MXene nanosheets
with a thickness of 2.6 μm (Figure j). The electrochemical performances of symmetric
and asymmetric MSCs were compared, which showed the superiority of
the asymmetric MSC (Figure k,l). Likewise, another research group applied the sequential
spray coating of hydrophilic Ti3C2T MXene and rGO to develop a binder and current collector-free
asymmetric MSC.[78] The MXene with high metallic
conductivity facilitated the transfer of electrons, and the paired
2D layered materials enabled the fast ion diffusion (Figure m). The electrical conductivity
of the Ti3C2T film
was determined with a four-point probe system and found to be 6400
± 120 S cm–1 depending on the flake size and
flake-to-flake contact resistance (Figure n). It was noted that the thin film of MXene
(<100 nm) was semitransparent and, however, prone to undergo oxidation
in air. That is why the thickness of the MXene layer needed to be
optimized, or it would have required an inert atmosphere and nonaqueous
electrolyte to provide stability. The asymmetric MSC showed a high
electrochemical performance and the device exhibited a 97% capacitance
retention after withstanding 10 000 charge–discharge
cycles at various bending states up to 90° (Figure o).
Transition
Metal Oxides/Hydroxides (TMOs/TMHs)
Among other pseudocapacitive
2D phases, layered TMOs/TMHs are becoming
increasingly popular in micro-supercapacitors due to their high theoretical
capacity, ample redox activity, chemically stable structure, and compatibility
with electrolyte.[79] Typical bulk TMOs and
TMHs possess an impeded rate capability due to their inherently low
conductivity, slow charge diffusion, severe volume expansion, and
aggregation,[80] while the 2D layered structures
enhance the electrochemical performance and cyclability by shortening
the ion flow path and offering a large surface area for electrochemical
reaction.[81] Moreover, their planar 2D geometry
is compatible with the planar devices, and the interlayer spaces provide
a certain degree of expansion to prevent their disintegration.[82,83] In this section, we describe various strategies that have been adopted
to overcome the aforementioned challenges associated with the nature
of typical TMOs/TMHs and realize the favorable features of layered
structures in the applications for micro-supercapacitors.
Pristine 2D TMOs/TMHs Electrodes
Wu et al. demonstrated
the design of a flexible MSC with 2D ultrathinNi(OH)2 nanoplates as the active electrode material.[84] The fabricated MSC displayed high capacitive
properties with high bendability and cyclability by losing only 0.2%
capacitance after 10 000 cycles. 2D TMH-based electrodes with
a unique interconnected porous network, augmented nanopore array,
and large surface area are vital for the construction of planar MSCs.
Following this notion, Kurra employed a top-down photolithography
protocol and bottom-up chemical bath deposition to obtain the MSC
based on vertically oriented Ni(OH)2 mesoporous nanoflakes
with a thickness of 500 nm (Figure a).[85] Electrolyte ions rapidly
diffused into the vertical nanoflakes and microelectrodes as the planar
configuration showed no involvement of any separator (Figure b,c). The CV curves displayed
two strong oxidation and reduction peaks, so it is evident that the
Ni(OH)2 lost the electron during the oxidation of Ni2+ to Ni3+, and the process was rapidly reversible
during the reduction (Figure d). The MSC showed redox activity even at higher scan rates
due to the fast redox reaction, which corresponds to higher values
of pseudocapacitance. The specific areal capacitance of the MSC determined
from the discharge curve was 16 mF cm–2 with high
energy and power performance. The planar MSCs exhibited fascinating
virtues of thinness, fast charge/discharge competency, and long cyclability,
making them prominent among microscale power supplies for integrated
electronics. An outstanding MSC performance was achieved by full utilization
of pseudocapacitive MnO2 with the assistance of nanoporous
gold (NPG) to be current collectors and support for active TMO.[86] The fabricated MSC gave rise to more than 1
order of magnitude higher energy density compared to carbon-/graphene-based
MSCs through the rapid reversible redox reaction of thin-film MnO2 with proton incorporation and surface adsorption of Li+ cations from LiCl aqueous solution. Regardless of some effective
presentations, pristine TMOs/TMHs electrodes display integrally low
electrical conductivities, untimely ensuing low power density and
rate performance.
Figure 6
(a) Uniform vertically grown Ni(OH)2 nanoflakes
on substrate;
inset shows the interconnected Ni(OH)2 nanosheets.[85] Schematic illustration of (b) the in-plane configuration
of microelectrodes and (c) the nucleation process of Ni(OH)2 over the Ni surface; below is shown the photograph of MSC fabricated
on the PEN substrate. (d) CV curve of Ni(OH)2-MSC in 1
M KOH electrolyte. SEM images of (e) the vertically oriented framework
of interpenetrating CuSe NSs (inset shows the magnified image) and
(f) Ni(OH)2 nanosheets deposited onto the CuSe framework.[89] (g) Schematic illustrating the ion transport
mechanism of the CuSe@Ni(OH)2 NS-based hybrid in-plane
MSC. (h) Cycling performance of the MSC under different bending states.
Reprinted with permission from refs (85) and (89). Copyright 2015 Wiley-VCH, 2018 American Chemical Society.
(a) Uniform vertically grown Ni(OH)2 nanoflakes
on substrate;
inset shows the interconnected Ni(OH)2 nanosheets.[85] Schematic illustration of (b) the in-plane configuration
of microelectrodes and (c) the nucleation process of Ni(OH)2 over the Ni surface; below is shown the photograph of MSC fabricated
on the PEN substrate. (d) CV curve of Ni(OH)2-MSC in 1
M KOH electrolyte. SEM images of (e) the vertically oriented framework
of interpenetrating CuSe NSs (inset shows the magnified image) and
(f) Ni(OH)2 nanosheets deposited onto the CuSe framework.[89] (g) Schematic illustrating the ion transport
mechanism of the CuSe@Ni(OH)2 NS-based hybrid in-plane
MSC. (h) Cycling performance of the MSC under different bending states.
Reprinted with permission from refs (85) and (89). Copyright 2015 Wiley-VCH, 2018 American Chemical Society.
Composites of 2D TMOs/TMHs
As stated
above, the low conductivity and capacity decay of TMOs/TMHs due to
the restacking of nanosheets after the long-term cycling process diminish
their electrochemical properties.[87] Recently,
defect engineering of 2D MnO2 nanosheets by atomic-level
substitutional doping of transition metal cation (Fe3+,
Co2+, and Ni2+) has been proven to introduce
new electronic states near the Fermi level, thus improving the natural
electrical conductivity and the concentration of redox-active sites.[88] The influence of substitutional doping, in particular,
the Fe doping, was observed in a symmetric MSC, which showed the superior
electrochemical performance by delivering high energy and power densities.
Gong et al. investigated electrochemically grown capacitive Ni(OH)2 nanosheets on a conductive framework of predeposited CuSe
nanosheets (Figure e).[89] It was elucidated that these particular
Ni(OH)2 NSs had a small lateral size (50 nm) and thickness
(<10 nm), which enabled the high rate of ion intercalation compared
to bulk structures (Figure f). This unique geometry overcame the poor conductivity and
restacking of Ni(OH)2 nanosheets; at the same time, the
vertically aligned hybrid nanosheets provided enhanced pathways for
ion transport into the electrodes (Figure g). The ESR of the MSC based on CuSe@Ni(OH)2 was estimated to be 92.2 Ω, which was lower than pure
Ni(OH)2-MSC (155.5 Ω). The MSC exhibited a specific
capacitance of 38.9 F cm–3, an energy density of
5.4 mW h cm–3, and a maximum power density of 833.2
mW cm–3. A negligible drop in performance was observed
without any loss in capacitance even after 10 000 cycles under
varying bending states up to a 180° fold (Figure h). It was observed during the cyclic analysis
that the device displayed an increase in the capacitance up to the
initial 4000 cycles followed by a gradual decrease. The initial increase
in capacitance was attributed to the activation of redox-active species
by exposure to the electrolyte with charge–discharge.One of the challenges in MSCs is micronizing of active material on
a small chip. The commonly used techniques such as electrochemical
(EC) or electrophoretic (EP) deposition lead to material instability.
Synthesizing 2D layered materials with patterning techniques is the
ultimate solution. Birnessite manganese dioxide (δ-MnO2) is an emerging electrode material for thin-film supercapacitors,
possessing atomically thin layered structures, high theoretical capacity,
environmental friendliness, and low cost. Recently, Wang et al. prepared
highly concentrated ink of 2D δ-MnO2 nanosheets with
a lateral size and thickness of 89 and 1 nm, respectively.[90] δ-MnO2 micropatterns were engineered
on oxygen plasma-treated glass/polyimide substrate through inkjet
printing without the undesired “coffee-ring” effect.
By employing a PVA/LiCl gel electrolyte, a solid-state symmetric MSC
was constructed displaying excellent capacitive, energy storage, and
delivery performances with a capacitance loss of 12% after 3600 charge–discharge
cycles. Mn3O4 is another attractive anode material
with the potential of high alkali-metal (Li/Na/K)-ion storage providing
high capacity. Designing hierarchical structures is an effective approach
to boost their charge storage capacity and cycling permanence by accommodating
the volumetric changes in the spaces within substructures. Tang et
al. utilized a selective dissolution strategy to produce hierarchical
Mn3O4/graphene microflowers composed of ultrathin
nanosheets with an excellent electrochemical performance and enhanced
cycling stability.[91] The SEM image revealed
the formulation of nanosheet-assembled Mn3O4-G microflowers with a size of 1–2 μm (Figure a). The overlapping of the
CV curve of the second and third cycles indicated the high reversibility
of the Mn3O4 electrodes (Figure b). Improved cycling stability was achieved
by controlling the nanosheets’ interspace and designing hierarchical
structures (Figure c).
Figure 7
(a) FESEM image
of ultrathin nanosheet-assembled hierarchical Mn3O4-G microflowers.[91] (b) CV curves
of Mn3O4 at 0.1 mV s–1. (c)
Cycling performance of Mn3O4-G at 0.5
A g–1; the inset shows the schematic diagram of
selective dissolution to fabricate Mn3O4-G microflowers.
Schematic shows the (d) synthesis of mesoporous MnO2 nanosheets
and (e) configuration of asymmetric MSC.[94] (f) CV curves of m-MnO2 and VN NSs measured by the three-electrode
setup. Reprinted with permission from refs (91) and (94). Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society, 2019 Elsevier.
(a) FESEM image
of ultrathin nanosheet-assembled hierarchical Mn3O4-G microflowers.[91] (b) CV curves
of Mn3O4 at 0.1 mV s–1. (c)
Cycling performance of Mn3O4-G at 0.5
A g–1; the inset shows the schematic diagram of
selective dissolution to fabricate Mn3O4-G microflowers.
Schematic shows the (d) synthesis of mesoporous MnO2 nanosheets
and (e) configuration of asymmetric MSC.[94] (f) CV curves of m-MnO2 and VN NSs measured by the three-electrode
setup. Reprinted with permission from refs (91) and (94). Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society, 2019 Elsevier.
2D TMOs/TMHs-Based Asymmetric
MSCs
Asymmetric MSCs based on TMOs/TMHs draw further research
interests
because of their high energy capacity originating from the larger
work function drop between dissimilar electrodes.[92,93] Qin et al. successfully synthesized a highly porous interconnected
network of 2D mesoporous MnO2 (m-MnO2) through
the self-assembly strategy.[94] Ultrathin
nanosheets were obtained with a thickness of 10 nm, mesopores of diameter
ranging from 5 to 15 nm, and a surface area of 128 m2 g–1 (Figure d). The mesoporous network provided structural integrity during
the cycling process, as these mesopores created enough void spaces
to hold the increase in volume of nanosheets during charging and discharging.
Mask-assisted layer-by-layer deposition was employed to obtain an
asymmetric MSC device based on the positive electrode of as-prepared
m-MnO2 and negative electrode of vanadium nitrate (VN)
nanosheets (Figure e). The prepared mesoporous nanosheets and AMSC were tested in various
other configurations, but the device tested with SiO2–LiTFSI
gel electrolyte (VN/MnO2-AMSC-GE) yielded the best electrochemical
performance. The microelectrodes with an optimized mass ratio of active
materials kept a charge balance and operated in the wide potential
range 0–2 V; besides, the pseudocapacitive behavior originated
from the swift ion diffusion in the m-MnO2 and VN nanosheets
(Figure f). VN/MnO2-AMSC-GE presented a specific capacitance of 16.1 mF cm–2, a maximum energy density of 21.6 mW h cm–3, and a power density of 1539 mW cm–3. Furthermore,
the AMSC retained 90% of the original capacitance after 5000 cycles,
and 98% capacitance was retained after bending the device at an angle
of 180°. Intercalating sodium ions Na+ into layered
TMOs could effectively increase the voltage window of the fabricated
electrodes.[95] However, the growth of nanosheets
on a common substrate is quite challenging. Recently, Zhang et al.
successfully coupled hierarchical Na-MnO@NCF/CNTF as the cathode and VN nanosheet arrays as the anode to
assemble AMSCs which could operate in a broad voltage window of 2.4
V.[96] By applying Na2SO4/carboxymethyl (CMC) gel electrolyte, the constructed AMSC delivered
a notable specific capacitance of 109.5 mF cm–2 with
an energy density of 87.62 μW h cm–2. Besides,
the AMSC exhibited greater mechanical stability with negligible decay
after 3000 bending cycles. Combining the supercapacitive anode with
a battery-like cathode into a single device produces a hybrid system
with high performance. This was illustrated by constructing an all-solid-state
flexible asymmetric MSC based on a vanadium nitrate (VN) nanosheet
anode and redox-active Co(OH)2 nanoflake cathode by employing
the vacuum filtration technique.[97] In the
first step, metal-free current collectors of chemically exfoliated
graphene (EG) were fabricated on a nylon substrate through vacuum
filtration followed by continuous deposition of 2D porous VN nanosheets
as an anode and Co(OH)2 as a cathode with 10% and 15% of
EG as the conducting additive on either electrodes, respectively.
By applying a thin film of PVA/KOH gel electrolyte, a specific capacitance
of 21 mF cm–2, an energy density of 12.4 mW h cm–3, and a capacitance preservation of 84% over 10 000
cycles were achieved by the AMSC with high flexibility and facile
integration strategy.
Conclusion and Outlook
The unique properties of electrochemically active 2D layered transition
metal compounds endow a wide window of opportunities in achieving
outstanding electrode materials for applications in micro-energy-storage
systems. In particular, the exploration of MSCs is the platform of
evolving thrust in research where these 2D inorganic materials show
great potential toward coupling a highly energy-dense powering system
to the planar, wearable, and flexible electronics. This Outlook focuses
on recent experimental progress of 2D structural TMDs, MXenes, and
TMOs/TMHs regarding their exceptional ultrathin geometry, large surface
area, ample redox-active sites, tunable physicochemical properties,
and outstanding flexibility. Along with the surface charge storage
properties for high-level power, their variable oxidation states confer
dominant energy density through the Faradaic charge storage mechanism
of transition metal cations. The aforementioned properties are prerequisite
for obtaining electrode materials with enhanced energy capacity, high
rate capability, and reliable cycling performance for MSCs. Nevertheless,
some vital technical constraints remain to be resolved to achieve
full exploitation of transition-metal-based 2D compounds as the active
electrode materials for widespread practical applications.The
lamellar, porous structures form the basis of enhancing the
active sites and specific surface area to achieve the efficient adsorption,
intercalation, and ion transport for the enhancement of the electrochemical
reaction. One-step exfoliation of bulk crystals has been proven to
be an effective strategy to induce interlayer lattice expansion of
exfoliated monolayer sheets to overcome the issue associated with
the poor conductivity of TMOs/TMHs and TMDs; at the same time, the
pore engineering through etching the basal plane produces uniform
porous structures. Besides, the nanosheets prepared via soft chemical
exfoliation have a degree of bendability that is desirable for a thin,
mechanically robust, and flexible MSC. The alteration of the crystalline
structure through the geometric shift of atoms yields an intriguing
metallic 2D 1T phase which is hydrophilic and 107 times more conductive
than the semiconducting 2H phase, while the nonterminated metallic
MXene sheets intrinsically exhibit a high ionic/electronic mobility
which renders them promising for the electrode material. Despite expanding
the interlayer spacing, the bottleneck of 2D layered materials still
lies in their tendency of inevitable aggregation due to interaction
between charged nanosheets and electrolyte cations.The interlayer
spaces can be modulated by the incorporation of
additional species, which stabilize the crystal structure of the host
material, prevent the restacking of layers during the insertion/extraction
of electrolyte ions, and enhance the electrochemical utilization of
the entire layered structure. The hybridization of transition metal
compounds through conductive additives produces high capacitance due
to the increased electrical conductivity. Hierarchical integration
of heterostructures would alleviate instability issues during the
volume expansion and presents multifold advantages required for high
electrochemical performance. The heterostructures with vertically
aligned 2D nanosheets of smaller lateral size realize short diffusion
pathways for electrolyte ions. Moreover, the direct contacts between
nanosheets and conductive collectors fasten the electron transport
through the interface in a coaxial direction. Therefore, the strongly
coupled hybrid materials witness to overcome the various shortcomings
associated with TMDs, MXenes, and TMOs/TMHs and produce synergistic
effects more expedient than the individual counterparts. Nevertheless,
the overall performance relies not only on the active materials but
also on the construction of MSCs. Taking this into account, the asymmetric
configuration is an effective strategy to utilize the extended working
potential of two dissimilar microelectrodes for the enhancement of
their energy density. Given the aforementioned challenges and achievements,
it is anticipated that the surface chemistries and precise engineering
of transition-metal-based 2D layered materials can pave the path for
numerous opportunities to improve the intrinsic properties of electrode
materials desired for the future endeavors in MSCs as the energy storage
units for on-chip integrated systems.