| Literature DB >> 33274149 |
Avinash Chakrawarty1, Piyush Ranjan2, Arnav Thrinath2, Eishvauk Aggarwal2, Joshua A Isaac2, Parul Berry2, Upendra Baitha2, Ashish D Upadhyay3, Souradeep Chowdhury2, Arvind Kumar2.
Abstract
Objectives COVID-19 has infected millions of people across the globe, leading to hundreds of thousands of deaths. Currently, there are no vaccines available for COVID-19, and the most effective way to curb its spread is to follow preventive practices. The present study aimed to assess the extent of adoption of preventive practices among the general population in India. Methods A web-based cross-sectional survey was carried out recruiting 964 participants from all over India through purposive sampling. A pre-validated questionnaire consisting of 37 questions was used to collect data. Items 1A to 18A covered various preventive practices and items 1B to 19B covered reasons for not following those preventive practices. Descriptive statistics, chi-square tests, t-tests and one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) were conducted. Results Most participants reported taking precautions such as wearing masks (91.80%), covering both nose and mouth (79.14%) and avoiding hand shaking (83.40%). However, practices like following social distancing in public places (51.76%) and workplace (51.04%), frequent hand washing/sanitising (63.59%) and washing hands for at least 20 seconds (45.44%) were less commonly observed. Participants failed to follow social distancing because of overcrowding and lack of space. They also found it cumbersome to wash hands multiple times. Female participants and people residing in metropolitan and small cities were fairly doing well in following preventive practices. Conclusion The study helped in identifying the glitches in following various preventive practices against COVID-19 during unlock phase and reasons for the failure to perform these practices.Entities:
Keywords: covid 19; cross-sectional survey; general population; india; preventive practices
Year: 2020 PMID: 33274149 PMCID: PMC7707894 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.11274
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Socio-demographic profile (n = 964)
| Demographic characteristics | Respondents [Frequency (%)] |
| Age (years) (Mean 40 ± 14.8 SD) | |
| 18-30 | 307 (31.85) |
| 31-50 | 424 (43.98) |
| 51 and above | 233 (24.17) |
| Gender | |
| Male | 555 (57.57) |
| Female | 409 (42.43) |
| Marital status | |
| Single | 293 (30.39) |
| Married | 666 (69.09) |
| Others (divorced, etc.) | 5 (0.52) |
| Socioeconomic status | |
| Upper | 310 (32.16) |
| Middle | 339 (35.17) |
| Lower | 315 (32.68) |
| Place of residence | |
| Metropolitan cities | 516 (53.53) |
| Small cities | 313 (32.47) |
| Small towns and villages | 135 (14.00) |
Frequency of responses to various items in section A of the questionnaire (n = 964)
Except items 1, 10, 17, 18, other items are rated as (1) = Rarely (less than 10% times), (2) = Occasionally (approx. 25% times), (3) = Commonly (approx. 50% times), (4) = Mostly (approx. 75% times), (5) = Always (more than 90% times).
For item 1: (1) = Always (more than 90% times), (2) = Mostly (approx. 75% times), (3) = Commonly (approx. 50% times), (4) = Occasionally (approx. 25% times), (5) = Rarely (less than 10% times).
For item 10: (1) = More than three times, (2) = Thrice, (3) = Twice, (4) = Once, (5) = Never.
| S No. | Item | Frequency of responses (%) | ||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||
| Hand hygiene | ||||||
| How often do you shake hands while greeting people now-a-days? | 51 (5.29) | 24 (2.49) | 26 (2.70) | 59 (6.12) | 804 (83.40) | |
| How often do you wash/sanitize your hands with soap and water/alcohol based sanitizer? | 5 (0.52) | 17 (1.76) | 60 (6.22) | 269 (27.90) | 613 (63.59) | |
| How often do you ensure that you wash/sanitize your hands for at least 20 seconds? | 25 (2.59) | 41 (4.25) | 138 (14.32) | 322 (33.40) | 438 (45.44) | |
| How often do you ensure that you clean your hands before touching your eyes/nose/mouth? | 35 (3.63) | 65 (6.74) | 159 (16.49) | 359 (37.24) | 346 (35.89) | |
| How often do you ensure that you cover your face with a handkerchief/bent elbow while coughing/sneezing? | 17 (1.76) | 17 (1.76) | 66 (6.85) | 208 (21.58) | 656 (68.04) | |
| Social distancing | ||||||
| How often do you maintain a minimum distance of 1 metre at your workplace? | 17 (1.76) | 24 (2.49) | 115 (11.93) | 316 (32.78) | 492 (51.04) | |
| How often do you maintain a minimum distance of 1 metre while eating food with your colleagues at your workplace? | 41 (4.25) | 47 (4.88) | 106 (11.00) | 263 (27.28) | 507 (52.59) | |
| How often do you avoid going out of the house unnecessarily? | 51 (5.29) | 32 (3.32) | 63 (6.54) | 261 (27.07) | 557 (57.78) | |
| How often do you maintain a minimum distance of 1 metre in public spaces (Ex: grocery shopping, social gatherings, etc.)? | 11 (1.14) | 23 (2.39) | 117 (12.14) | 314 (32.57) | 499 (51.76) | |
| How often have you attended social gatherings in the past two months? (Like meeting friends, going to religious places, visiting malls, theatres, etc.)? | 62 (6.43) | 55 (5.71) | 103 (10.68) | 166 (17.22) | 578 (59.96) | |
| Masks | ||||||
| How often do you wear mask while going out of home? | 1 (0.10) | 4 (0.41) | 12 (1.24) | 62 (6.43) | 885 (91.80) | |
| While wearing a mask, how often do you ensure that both your nose and mouth are covered? | 2 (0.21) | 4 (0.41) | 42 (4.36) | 153 (15.87) | 763 (79.14) | |
| How often do you keep your mask properly in a separate bag/dustbin after using it? | 46 (4.77) | 46 (4.77) | 83 (8.61) | 174 (18.05) | 615 (63.80) | |
| Gadgets/Fomites | ||||||
| How often do you clean/sanitise your personal items (e.g., purse/mobile phone, etc.) with sanitizer when you come home? | 118 (12.24) | 93 (9.65) | 151 (15.66) | 252 (26.14) | 350 (36.31) | |
| How often do you take precautions when buying things to avoid virus contamination? | 13 (1.35) | 30 (3.11) | 102 (10.58) | 277 (28.73) | 542 (56.22) | |
| Law | ||||||
| How often do you obey government restrictions regarding COVID pandemic? | 4 (0.41) | 7 (0.73) | 44 (4.56) | 217 (22.51) | 692 (71.78) | |
| In case you develop symptoms of disease, will you contact hospital/helpline/authority regarding it? | 1 (0.10) | 9 (0.93) | 54 (5.60) | 173 (17.95) | 727 (75.41) | |
| If you come in contact with COVID positive/suspect person, would you stop going to work and confine yourself to a home away from friends and family members? | 4 (0.41) | 7 (0.73) | 32 (3.32) | 143 (14.83) | 778 (80.70) | |
Percentage of participants giving ideal response for various items
| Frequency of responses to items | No. of items | Questions |
| >80% participants giving ideal response | 3 | 1,11,18 |
| 60-80% participants giving ideal responses | 6 | 2,5,12,13,16,17 |
| 40-60% participants giving ideal responses | 7 | 3,6,7,8,9,10,15 |
| <40% participants giving ideal responses | 2 | 4,14 |
Assessment of reasons for deficiency in following preventive practices
| S No. | Question | Responses | Frequency of responses |
| Hand Hygiene | |||
| What is/are the reason(s) due to which you can’t avoid shaking hands in the current scenario (COVID-19 pandemic)? | Not applicable, Don't know that COVID spreads through hand shakes, Avoiding hand shaking will not prevent COVID infection, Difficult to change habit, Looks rude not do so when opposite person extends hand for handshake, Other reasons | 751, 29, 20, 75, 113, - | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not washing/sanitizing hands at frequent intervals? | Not applicable, Don't know that washing hands prevents spread of COVID, Frequent hand-washing will not prevent COVID infection, It leads to wastage of water and resources, Difficult to change habit, Non-availability/shortage of water/sanitizer, Lack of time, Cumbersome to sanitize hands too many times, Other reasons | 668, 15, 12, 19, 92, 52, 74, 109, 10 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not washing hands for at least 20 seconds? | Not applicable, Don’t know that hands have to be washed for at least 20 seconds, Time duration is not important while washing hands, Unable to check the time while washing hands, Cumbersome when washing hands multiple times, Other reasons | 567, 44, 53, 261, 101, 3 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not coughing/sneezing into the handkerchief/bent elbow? | Not applicable, Don’t know that coughing into elbow stops spread of infection to others, It is not important in preventing spread of disease, Sometimes I forget, Difficult to change habit, Other reasons | 728, 22, 13, 190, 85, - | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for touching eyes/nose/mouth without cleaning hands? | Not applicable, Don’t know that touching eyes/nose/mouth with unclean hands can cause spread of COVID, Not important in preventing COVID, Don’t remember, Difficult to change habit, Other reasons | 575, 22, 16, 230, 170, 6 | |
| Social Distancing | |||
| What is/are the reason(s) for not maintaining social distance in the workplace? | Not applicable, Don’t know that at least 1-2-meter distance should be maintained, Social distancing is not important in prevention of COVID, Lack of space, Difficulty in talking, Overcrowding, Other reasons | 665, 16, 8, 163, 74, 108, 14 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not maintaining at least one-meter distance while having food with colleagues? | Not applicable, Don’t know that at least 1-2-meter distance should be maintained, Social distancing is not important in prevention of COVID, Lack of space, Difficulty in talking, Overcrowding, Other reasons | 718, 20, 5, 145, 60, 65, 8 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for going out of house? | Not applicable, Work, Grocery shopping, Walking/exercising, Socializing, Visiting religious places, Entertainment (Club, visiting friends, etc.), Other reasons | 226, 385, 476, 201, 45, 27, 23, - | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not maintaining social distancing in public spaces? | Not applicable, Don’t know that at least 1-2-meter distance should be maintained, Social distancing is not important in prevention of COVID, Lack of space, Difficulty in talking, Overcrowding, Other reasons | 605, 19, 3, 225, 47, 85, 1 | |
| Masks | |||
| What is/are the possible reason(s) for not wearing masks while going out of home? | Not applicable, I didn’t know wearing mask prevents spread of COVID, I believe masks are useless, Lack of availability, Not comfortable, Difficult to breath, Doesn’t look good, Other reasons | 839, 9, 7, 10, 56, 89, 3, 3 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not covering both nose and mouth while wearing masks? | Not applicable, Don’t know that both nose and mouth have to be covered, Don’t find it useful, Have difficulty breathing while wearing it, Don’t feel comfortable wearing it, It slides down due to loose fit, Other reasons | 780, 7, - 95, 74, 62, 2 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not keeping mask properly in separate bags/bins after using it? | Not applicable, Don’t know it should be kept properly in a separate bag/bin, Don’t know how to dispose of the mask, Don’t feel it is important to keep it properly, Too tired after work, Don’t find a suitable place to dispose the mask, Other reasons | 707, 53, 71, 24, 50, 85, - | |
| Gadgets/Fomites | |||
| What is/are the reason(s) for not cleaning personal items (e.g., purse/mobile phone, etc.) when you reach home? | Not applicable, Don't know that I should clean it after work, Believe it is not useful, Non-availability of sanitizers, Not needed as there is no contact with COVID positive patients, Too tired to do so, Using sanitizer on personal items like mobile will damage it, Other reasons | 574, 50, 35, 37, 100, 91, 121, - | |
| What precaution(s) do you take while purchasing groceries from local stores/vendors? | Not applicable, Opting for home delivery, Shopping at a time when it is less busy, Wearing a face mask, Carrying hand sanitizer or wipes with you, Using mobile pay/debit cards/credit cards for making payments, Buying 1-2 weeks-worth of groceries at a time, Others reasons | 204, 285, 367, 549, 388, 289, 407, - | |
| Technology and Law | |||
| Have you installed the AarogyaSetu app in your phone? | Yes, No, Initially installed then deleted | 554, 317, 93 | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not using the AarogyaSetu app? | Not applicable, Don’t know about it, Don’t find it useful, Don’t have space in phone for it, Don’t have a smartphone, It drains battery, Other reasons | 583, 96, 158, 53, 47, 33, - | |
| What is/are the reason(s) for not obeying government restrictions? | Not applicable, Don’t know about government restrictions, They are not effective, Other reasons | 896, 31, 37, - | |
| Preparedness | |||
| What is/are the reason(s) for not being aware of any helpline/authority/hospital to contact in case you develop symptoms of disease? | Not applicable, Don’t know that there is any helpline/authority, Prefer to treat oneself at home if develop symptoms, Other reasons | 788, 39, 137, - | |
Classification of responses obtained from participants to what do they think is the cause of the rising number of COVID cases among general population and their solutions
| Causes for rising number of COVID cases as per participants responses | ||
| S No. | Cause | Frequency of responses |
| 1 | Irresponsible behaviour of people. They have a careless attitude. | 787 |
| 2 | People are not sincerely following the rules of the government. | 793 |
| 3 | People are either not wearing masks or they are wearing it inappropriately. | 689 |
| 4 | People are not maintaining social distance. | 605 |
| 5 | People are not following hand hygiene properly. | 430 |
| 6 | People do not believe that the coronavirus does exist and are having faith on fake messages. | 3 |
| 7 | People want to rush back to work. | 108 |
| Solutions to control the rising number of cases | ||
| S No. | Solutions | Frequency of responses |
| 1 | Wearing masks properly | 602 |
| 2 | Maintaining social distance | 584 |
| 3 | Avoiding maximum gatherings at religious places, crowded places, malls, theatres, etc. | 346 |
| 4 | Adopting personal hygiene, frequent hand washing | 423 |
| 5 | The government should have proper quarantine facilities. | 183 |
| 6 | Strict action must be taken against offenders. | 554 |
| 7 | Vaccinations are required. | 276 |
Association between various characteristics and preventive practices
One-way ANOVA applied; *Kruskal-Wallis test applied; # t-test applied
| Groups | Responses | Association |
| Age (years) | ||
| 18-30 (1) | 77.35 ± 9.25 | F (2,961) = 7.19, p-value = 0.008 p (1vs2) = 0.001 p (1vs3) = 0.027 |
| 31-50 (2) | 79.71 ± 7.80 | |
| 50 and above (3) | 79.30 ± 8.79 | |
| Gender# | ||
| Male | 77.67 ± 0.39 | t = -5.1062, p-value < 0.05 |
| Female | 80.49 ± 0.36 | |
| Marital status* | ||
| Single (1) | 77.43 ± 9.25 | χ2 (2) = 12.024, p = 0.0024 p (1vs2) = 0.011 |
| Married (2) | 79.49 ± 8.20 | |
| Others (3) | 79.40 ± 10.16 | |
| Socio-economic Status | ||
| Upper | 78.83 ± 8.47 | F (2,961) = 0.44, p-value = 0.64 |
| Middle | 79.18 ± 8.04 | |
| Lower | 78.55 ± 9.25 | |
| Place of Residence | ||
| Metropolitan cities (1) | 79.32 ± 7.93 | F (2,961) = 5.89, p-value = 0.003 p (1vs3) = 0.005 |
| Small cities (2) | 79.12 ± 8.87 | |
| Small towns and villages (3) | 76.53 ± 9.93 | |