Ping Yu1, Xin Tan1, Haiyang Yu2. 1. Doctoral candidate, State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases, National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases, and Department of Prosthodontics, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu, PR China. 2. Professor, State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases, National Clinical Research Center for Oral Diseases, and Department of Prosthodontics, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu, PR China. Electronic address: YHYmechanics@163.com.
Abstract
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Sealing products have been produced to reduce microleakage at the implant abutment interface. However, little is known about their effectiveness and any alterations in mechanical behavior of implant systems with their application. PURPOSE: The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the effect of a silicone sealing gel on implant abutment interface microleakage, abutment screw torque loss, and thread wear of implant systems in a simulated oral environment. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Five specimens each of 3 implants systems (Nobel, Straumann, and WEGO) that included sealed and unsealed groups were analyzed (N=30). Before assembling the components, toluidine blue solution was injected to the implant intaglio cavity to evaluate implant abutment interface microleakage. After tightening to the recommended torque, 20 to 200 N of 30-degree off-axis dynamic force was applied at 2 Hz for 48 hours. The toluidine blue solution was extracted to test optical density values at 1, 3, 9, 24, 33, and 48 hours. Detorque values were measured before and after cycling loading, and torque loss rates were calculated. The abutment screw morphologies were observed by using scanning electron microscopy. The coefficient of friction tendency of applying sealing gel was explored with a ball-on-flat configuration. One-way ANOVA and Student t test were used for statistical analysis (α=.05). RESULTS: The optical density value increased with the loading time, especially for Straumann group. The sealing gel decreased the implant abutment interface microleakage of Straumann assemblies after cyclic loading of 9 hours (P=.044), whereas no statistical difference was found for Nobel (P=.140) or WEGO groups (P=.402) at 6 time points. Torque loss occurred during tightening and further increased after dynamic cyclic load in each group. Among the 3 implant systems, Straumann implants reported the best antiloosening property (P<.001). The application of sealing gel reduced the initial (P=.048) and final (P=.032) torque loss rate in all the 3 systems. Scanning electron microscopy observations revealed the bottom thread tended to have more abrasion than the first thread. After applying sealing gel, less thread abrasion was found in Nobel and WEGO assemblies, whereas the protective effect was not evident for the Straumann group. The coefficient of friction of sealed group (0.17 ±0.026) was significantly (P=.012) lower than that of unsealed group (0.24 ±0.044). CONCLUSIONS: The silicone sealing gel improved the immediate fastening and long-term antiloosening performances of 3 implant systems, decreased the implant abutment interface microleakage of Straumann system, and reduced abutment screw thread abrasion of the Nobel and WEGO systems.
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Sealing products have been produced to reduce microleakage at the implant abutment interface. However, little is known about their effectiveness and any alterations in mechanical behavior of implant systems with their application. PURPOSE: The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the effect of a silicone sealing gel on implant abutment interface microleakage, abutment screw torque loss, and thread wear of implant systems in a simulated oral environment. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Five specimens each of 3 implants systems (Nobel, Straumann, and WEGO) that included sealed and unsealed groups were analyzed (N=30). Before assembling the components, toluidine blue solution was injected to the implant intaglio cavity to evaluate implant abutment interface microleakage. After tightening to the recommended torque, 20 to 200 N of 30-degree off-axis dynamic force was applied at 2 Hz for 48 hours. The toluidine blue solution was extracted to test optical density values at 1, 3, 9, 24, 33, and 48 hours. Detorque values were measured before and after cycling loading, and torque loss rates were calculated. The abutment screw morphologies were observed by using scanning electron microscopy. The coefficient of friction tendency of applying sealing gel was explored with a ball-on-flat configuration. One-way ANOVA and Student t test were used for statistical analysis (α=.05). RESULTS: The optical density value increased with the loading time, especially for Straumann group. The sealing gel decreased the implant abutment interface microleakage of Straumann assemblies after cyclic loading of 9 hours (P=.044), whereas no statistical difference was found for Nobel (P=.140) or WEGO groups (P=.402) at 6 time points. Torque loss occurred during tightening and further increased after dynamic cyclic load in each group. Among the 3 implant systems, Straumann implants reported the best antiloosening property (P<.001). The application of sealing gel reduced the initial (P=.048) and final (P=.032) torque loss rate in all the 3 systems. Scanning electron microscopy observations revealed the bottom thread tended to have more abrasion than the first thread. After applying sealing gel, less thread abrasion was found in Nobel and WEGO assemblies, whereas the protective effect was not evident for the Straumann group. The coefficient of friction of sealed group (0.17 ±0.026) was significantly (P=.012) lower than that of unsealed group (0.24 ±0.044). CONCLUSIONS: The silicone sealing gel improved the immediate fastening and long-term antiloosening performances of 3 implant systems, decreased the implant abutment interface microleakage of Straumann system, and reduced abutment screw thread abrasion of the Nobel and WEGO systems.
Authors: Igor Smojver; Roko Bjelica; Amir Ćatić; Ana Budimir; Marko Vuletić; Dragana Gabrić Journal: Materials (Basel) Date: 2022-02-21 Impact factor: 3.623
Authors: Igor Smojver; Roko Bjelica; Marko Vuletić; Dražena Gerbl; Ana Budimir; Dragana Gabrić Journal: Int J Mol Sci Date: 2022-07-21 Impact factor: 6.208