| Literature DB >> 33195970 |
Paula Kage1, Julia Zarnowski1, Jan-Christoph Simon1, Regina Treudler1.
Abstract
Atopic dermatitis (AD) is a chronic inflammatory disease. During the last years, researchers have focused on a variety of associated comorbidities, especially psychosocial disease. This article aims at giving an overview over recent data. A systematic literature research was performed in PubMed including data from the time period January 1, 2018 until March 1, 2020. Patients with AD frequently suffer from cocomitant depression, anxiety, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. There is less evidence about the relation between AD and schizophrenia, eating disorder, and obsessive compulsive disorder. There is still great need for research in the connection between AD and psychosocial disease, particularly about the pathogenesis and the influence of new therapies. © Dustri-Verlag Dr. K. Feistle.Entities:
Keywords: anorexia; anxiety; atopic dermatitis; atopic eczema; attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; depression; obsessive compulsive disorder ; schizophrenia
Year: 2020 PMID: 33195970 PMCID: PMC7659463 DOI: 10.5414/ALX02174E
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Allergol Select ISSN: 2512-8957
Figure 1.Flowchart of the selection process of included studies.
List of abbreviations.
| WHO-5 | 5-item World Health Organization Well-Being Index |
| AD | Atopic dermatitis |
| AESEC | Atopic eczema score of emotional consequences |
| BASC-2 | Behavior assessment system for children 2nd edition |
| BAI | Beck anxiety inventory |
| BDI | Beck Depression Inventory-short form |
| CES-D | Centre of epidemiologic studies-depression scale |
| CPRS-R | Conners’ parent rating scale |
| DASS-42 | Depression, stress and anxiety scale |
| DMS-IV | Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders-IV |
| EASI | Eczema area and severity index |
| EQ5D-5L | Five-dimension five-level version of the EQ-5D |
| FPI-R | Freiburg personality inventory |
| FBB-ADHS | External assessment sheet attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (Fremdbeurteilungsbogen Aufmerksamkeitsdefizit-/Hyperaktivitätsstörungen) |
| GAD-7 | Generalized anxiety disorder |
| GT | Gießen Test |
| HAM-A | Hamilton anxiety rating scale |
| HAMD | Hamilton depression rating scale |
| ICD | International statistical classification of diseases and related health problems |
| ISI | Insomnia severity index |
| K-6 | Kessler-6 index |
| LSNS | Lubben social network scale |
| MADRS | Montgomery Åsberg depression rating scale |
| MPT | Munich personality test |
| NEO-FFI | Neo-five factor inventory |
| PHQ-2 | Patient health questionnaire-2 |
| POEM | Patient oriented eczema measure |
| QoLPAD | Quality of life in parents of children with atopic dermatitis |
| QOLI | Quality of life inventory |
| QPE | Questionnaire for psychotic experiences |
| SCORAD | SCORing atopic dermatitis |
| SCARED | Screen for child anxiety related emotional disorders |
| SCS | Self-consciousness-scale |
| SF-8 | Short form health survey 8 |
| SF-12 | Short form health survey 12 |
| SMFQ | Shortened mood and feelings |
| STAI | State-trait anxiety inventory |
| SDQ | Strengths and difficulties questionnaire |
| TEG-II | Tokyo University Egogram II |
| TSST-C | Trier social stress test for children |
| VADRS | Vanderbilt ADHD diagnostic rating scale |
Studies on depression and anxiety.
| Author | Study design | Parameter | Number of patients, age in years (y) | Country | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | CS | Natural language processing, IGA | 1,231 with AD ≥ 18 y | USA, K, F, D, I, E, UK | Depressive feelings, anxiety and hopelessness are more common in moderate/severe AD than in mild AD. |
| [ | Pro, CC | Serum serotonin levels, | 31 with AD 14 controls Mean: 41 y | Po | All pat. with SCORAD > 50 had depression. |
| [ | Pro, CC | Total IgE, cortisol and testosterone levels, HAMD, SCORAD | 56 with AD 49 controls | Israel | All pat. with AD had an elevated score for depression. |
| [ | Pro, CC | Medical history, questionnaires, depression, DASS-42 | 75 with AD 75 controls 18 – 41 y | Turkey | No difference between the scores for depression and anxiety in pat. with AD and controls (p > 0.05). |
| [ | CS | CES-D, GAD-7, LSNS, SF-8 | 9,481; thereof 372 with AD ≥ 18 y | D | Pat. with AD showed higher scores for depressive symptoms (9.3 vs. 6.3%; p < 0.001) and anxiety (8.4 vs. 5.6%, p < 0.001). |
| [ | CS | ICD-9, ICD-10 | 2.2 million thereof 62.849 with AD > 6 y | E | The frequency of diagnosis of anxiety and agitation was higher in pat. with severe AD than in the normal population |
| [ | CS | Medical history, EASI, SCORAD, IGA, DLQI, PGA, NRS | 612 with AD | D | Pat. with AD described depression more often than the normal population (10 vs. 7.7%). |
| [ | CS | ICD-9, medical history, frequency of depression screenings | 9,345 with AD | USA | During medical consultations (with dermatologists and other specialists), 1.2% of AD pat. were subjected to a screening test for depression. |
| [ | CS | IGA, EASI, SCORAD, POEM, HADS, DLQI, medication | 18 – 65 y | K, F, D, I, E, UK | Pat. with severe AD had an increased prevalence of psychological comorbidities compared to those with mild to moderate AD (p < 0.001). |
| [ | CS | ICD-10 | 526,808 with AD 2,569,030 controls ≥ 18 y | UK | AD was associated with an increased incidence of newly onset depression (HR, 1.14) and anxiety (HR 1.17). A strong effect of AD on depression with increasing severity of AD was observed: HR compared to healthy subjects: mild, 1.10; moderate, 1.19; and heavy, 1.26. This dependence on severity was weaker in relation to anxiety disorders: HR compared to healthy subjects: mild, 1.14; moderate, 1.21; and severe, 1.15. |
| [ | CS | ICD-10 | 656 with AD 52.1 ± 17.9 y | UK | The prevalence of depression was 10.8%. |
| [ | CS | Questionnaires, 5-item World Health Organization Well-Being Index (WHO-5) | 34,313 thereof 4,175 with AD | S | Adults with mild AD had an increased risk of major depression (RR 1.78) and anxiety (RR 1.97). |
| [ | Pro, double blind, cohort | AD diagnosed by physician, prescriptions | 844 with AD 25 ± 16.5 y | UK | The prevalence of having repeatedly prescribed antidepressants was twice as high in AD pat. with high need for topical steroids compared with AD pat. with low need (12 vs. 6%). |
| [ | CS | ICD-10 | 42,641 with AD 139,486 with other dermatosis | Ko | The incidence of depression did not differ between pat. with/without AD. |
| [ | CS | ICD-9, HQ-2, K-6 | 19,840 | USA | Pat. with AD |
| [ | Randomized, placebo-controlled, phase 3 | EASI, HADS | 1,379 with AD | USA | Dupilumab improved symptoms of depression and anxiety as measured by HADS compared to placebo (p < 0.001). |
| [ | CS | POEM, DLQI, HADS, AESEC | 1,189 with AD | F, E, I, UK, D, NL, DK, S, Czech Republic | 10% of the pat. with AD showed depressive symptoms. |
| [ | CS | POEM, PO-SCORAD, DLQI, HADS, SF-12, SF-6D | 2,893 thereof 602 with AD | USA | PO-SCORAD and POEM showed a moderate to strong correlation with DLQI and HADS. |
| [ | CS | SF-36, HADS, DLQI | 1,860 with AD | F, D, I, E, UK | Depression had a higher prevalence in pats. with AD compared to controls (25.8% in pat. with controlled AD and even higher with 36.2% in pat. with uncontrolled AD compared to 12.9%). |
| [ | CS | Questionnaire | 917,948 thereof 21,111 with AD | Ko | Pat. with AD had a 2.31-fold higher risk of being diagnosed with depression compared to the normal population. |
| [ | CS | PO-SCORAD, POEM, DLQI, HADS, SF-12 | 3,495 thereof 602 with AD | USA | HADS showed a strong correlation with SF-12 and moderate to weak correlation with PO-SCORAD, POEM, and DLQI. |
| [ | CS | BDI, HAM-A | 24 children with AD and their mothers | Tunisia | The mothers in the AD group showed higher HAM-A scores but no increased depression scores in the BDI compared to the controls. |
| [ | CS | POEM, DLQI, HADS | 1,185 thereof 93 with AD | USA | 24.73% of the pat. with AD showed the clinical signs of anxiety compared to 9.20% of the controls (p < 0.001). |
| [ | CC | ICD-8 to 10 | 8,602 children with AD | DK | No significant association between mental illnesses (depression, alcohol addiction, and drug addiction) in the parents and the development of AD in their children. |
| [ | CS | POEM, SA-EASI, medical history | 287 with AD | USA | 26.2% of pat. with AD had anxiety in the past, 34.0% had depression. |
| [ | Open pilot study cognitive behavioral treatment | SCORAD, BAI, MADRS | 9 with AD | S | Significant reduction in anxiety measured with BAI but no significant difference in depressive symptoms measured with MADRS. |
| [ | CS | Medical history, PO-SCORAD, POEM, HADS | 8,217; thereof 602 with AD | USA | In AD, increased risk of anxiety and depression compared to controls (OR 2.34, 95% CI 1.91 – 2.87). |
| [ | CS | PO-SCORAD, HADS, DLQI | 1,519 with AD | USA | In moderate/severe AD, significantly higher prevalence of anxiety and depression vs. mild AD (50.2 vs. 27.3%, p < 0.001). |
| [ | CS | Medical history, questionnaires | 13,275 children; thereof 12.29% with AD | USA | In pat. with AD, higher risk for depression (OR 2.287), anxiety (OR 2.001), and stress (OR 2.013) compared to controls. |
| [ | CS | ICD-9 | 46,647 with atopic diseases | TW | Pat. with AD alone or AD and allergic rhinitis showed a lower risk of mental illness (OR 0.256; p = 0.031) (OR 0.554; p = 0.018). |
| [ | CS | Medical history, SCORAD, SMFQ | 14,197; thereof 3,152 with AD | S | Children who had ever suffered from AD were shown to have an increased risk of depression or anxiety (OR 1.23; p < 0.01). |
| [ | CS | Medical history, SF-36 | 638 with AD | Japan | The self-reported prevalence of depression (10.25%) and anxiety (3.31%) was higher in AD pat. compared to controls (p < 0.001). |
| [ | Pro, interventional educational program for AD | SCORAD, anxiety measurement by Spielberger | 20 mothers of children with AD | South Korea | The scores for anxiety decreased significantly after the training. |
| [ | Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, phase 3 | IGA, SCORAD, EASI, DLQI, POEM, HADS | 325 with AD | Europe | Dupilumab in combination with topical steroids significantly improved AD, quality of life, and symptoms of anxiety and depression compared to topical steroids alone (p < 0.001). |
| [ | CS | ICD-9 | 6,186 with AD | E | 26.1% of the pat. took anxiolytics, 22.7% antidepressants. The severe form of AD was associated with depression. |
| [ | CS | Questionnaire, EQ-5D | 37,578; thereof 677 with AD | Ko | Pat. with AD demonstrated severe psychological stress (p < 0.001), a higher prevalence of depressive mood (p = 0.001), use of psychological counseling centers (p = 0.001), depression (p = 0.002), and suicidal ideation (p < 0.001) significantly more often. |
| [ | Blinded, interventional Itch induction | SCORAD, HADS, SCS | 23 with AD | D | No difference between pat. with AD and the controls with regard to depression and self-confidence in public. |
| [ | CS | Medical history, DSM-5, hospitalization rate, suicide rate, prescriptions | 9,656 thereof | DK | Significant association between AD and depression (OR 1.92), and diagnosed anxiety (OR 1.74). |
| [ | CS | ICD-8, prescriptions | 201,090 men thereof 691 with AD | S | Increased risk of antidepressant prescription in AD (OR 1.43; p < 0.001). |
CS = cross sectional study; CC = case control study; pro = prospective; pat. = patient; y = years; D = Germany; DK = Denmark; S = Sweden; F = France; I = Italy; K = Canada; Ko = Korea; Po = Poland; E = Spain; TW = Taiwan; UK = United Kingdom; OR = odds ratio; RR = relative risk; HR = hazard ratio
Studies on ADHD.
| Author | Study design | Parameter | Number of patients, age in years (y) | Country | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | CS | Conner rating Scale for ADHS | 95 with AD 4 – 18 y | Iran | Prevalence of hyperactivity 20%; attention deficit 29.47%. Attention deficit was associated with AD in the cheek area (p = 0.01) and sleep problems (p = 0.01). |
| [ | Cohort | ICD-9 | 20,170 siblings of pat. with ADHS 80,680 controls 15.7 ± 5.3 y | TW | Siblings were at an increased risk of developing AD (RR 1.10), asthma, allergic rhinoconjunctivitis, and other atopic diseases. |
| [ | Pro, CC | Cortisol levels in saliva, SCORAD, POEM, FBB-ADHS, TSST-C, ICD-10 | 42 with AD 34 with ADHS 31 with AD and ADHS 47 controls 6 – 12 y | D | Children with AD showed increased AHDS-like behavior such as inattention, impulsiveness. |
| [ | CC | SCORAD, VADRS | 17 with AD 18 controls 6 – 17 y | USA | The VADRS screening test was not significantly more positive for ADHD (p = 0.47) or other behavioral disorders (p = 0.23) in children with AD compared to controls. |
| [ | Pro, non-interventional | ICD-10, SCORAD, POEM, medical history | 154 children 42 with AD 34 with ADHS, 31 with AD and ADHS 47 controls 6 – 12 y | D | Compared to the control group, significantly increased risk for behavioral problems and lower quality of life in patients with AD alone, ADHD alone, or both AD and ADHD. |
| [ | CS | Medical history, DSM-4 | 2,772 thereof 411 with AD 3 – 6 y | TW | Increased risk for ADHS (OR 4.5) in pats. with AD compared to controls.. |
CS = cross-sectional study; CC = case control study; pro = prospective; pat. = patient; y = years; D = Germany; TW = Taiwan; OR = odds ratio; RR = relative risk.
Studies on schizophrenia.
| Author | Study design | Parameter | Number of patients Age in years (y) | Country | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | CS | Medical history, QPE | 6,479 thereof 1,181 with AD | Netherlands | Increased risk of psychotic events (OR 1.20; p = 0.009) and hallucinations (OR 1.24; p = 0.002) in AD compared to the general population. |
| [ | CS | ICD-9 | 835 with AD 2,434,703 controls | USA | Adults with AD: increased risk of hospitalization due to mental illness (OR 1.78), children not (OR 0.68). |
CS = cross sectional; pat. = patient; y = years; OR = odds ratio.