| Literature DB >> 33162468 |
Tomokazu Aoki1, Yoshitaka Narita2, Kazuhiko Mishima3, Masao Matsutani4.
Abstract
Palliative care and advance care planning (ACP) from the first diagnosis of glioblastoma are important. This questionnaire survey was conducted to understand the current status of palliative care for brain tumors in Japan. Representative characteristics of Japan in comparison with Western countries (P <0.01) are described below: (1) Gender ratio of male in physicians who treat brain tumors in Europe and the United States/Canada are about 70%, but 94% in Japan. (2) The specialty is predominantly neurosurgeon (93%) in Japan. The ratio of neurologists is predominantly 40% in Europe. In the United States/Canada, neurologist (27%) and neurosurgeon (29%) are main parts. (3) Years of medical experience over 15 in physicians is 73% in Japan. Proportions of those with over 15 years are 45% in Europe and 30% in the United States/Canada. (4) In practicing setting, the rate of academic medical centers is about 80% in Europe and the United States/Canada, and ~60% in Japan. Representative differences compared with past domestic data (2007) (p<0.01): (1) In glioblastoma, the rate of explaining about median survival time increases from 39% (2007) to 80% (2018). Explanation about medical conditions to the patient himself with his family increases from 20% (2007) to 39% (2018). (2) Place of death: The rate at hospital is decreasing from 96% (2007) to 79% (2018) and at home is increasing from 3% (2007) to 10% (2018) (3) The rate of ventilator in adult has decreased from 74% (2007) to 54% (2018), but nasal tube feeding has remained unchanged from 62% (2007) to 60% (2018). These results will be shared with physicians to make better care systems for patients with brain tumors.Entities:
Keywords: advance care planning; glioblastoma; glioma; malignant brain tumor; palliative care; terminal care
Year: 2020 PMID: 33162468 PMCID: PMC7803700 DOI: 10.2176/nmc.oa.2020-0243
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) ISSN: 0470-8105 Impact factor: 1.742
Comparison of international patters of palliative care in neuro-oncology
| Questionnaire | Variable | Response | Japan (n = 154) (%) | Europe (n = 75) (%) | United States/Canada (n=164) (%) | P value J/E : Japan/Europe J/USA: Japan/United States/Canada |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sex | Male | 141 (94) | 53 (71) | 117 (71) | J/E 0.000118 |
| 2 | Specialty | Neurology | 6 (4) | 30 (40) | 44 (27) | J/E 0.0001 |
| 3 | Formal training in neuro-oncology | No formal special training | 5 (3) | 5 (7) | 16 (10) | J/E 0.0982 |
| 4 | Training for palliative care | No formal special training | 18 (12) | 31 (41) | 62 (38) | J/E 0.144 |
| 5 | Patients with brain tumors seen per week | <1 | 17 (11) | 0 (0) | 7 (4) | J/E |
| 6 | Practicing independently | <1 years | 2 (1) | 9 (12) | 68 (41) | J/E |
| 7 | Practicing setting | Academic | 91 (59) | 63 (84) | 131 (80) | J/E 0.000169 |
| 8 | I prefer patients to palliative care/symptom management at the moment of: | Diagnosis | 15 (10) | 7 (9) | 5 (3) | J/E |
| 9 | What percentage of all of your patients are referred to hospice for end-of-life care? | 0% | 15 (10) | 6 (8) | 5 (3) | J/E |
| 10 | I feel comfortable dealing with end-of-life issues on my own without the need for a formal palliative care support service | Strongly agree | 2 (1) | 12 (17) | 30 (19) | J/E |
| 11 | Our unit assesses symptom burden and quality of life on a routine basis | Strongly disagree | 54 (35) | 14 (19) | 47 (30) | J/E |
| 12 | Our unit routinely utilizes palliative medicine professionals at the time of first diagnosis for our high-grade primary brain tumor patients (WHO grade III and IV) | Strongly agree | 9 (6) | 7 (10) | 9 (6) | J/E |
| 13 | My patients have easy referral access to outpatient palliative care services | Strongly agree | 40 (26) | 12 (17) | 43 (28) | J/E |
| 14 | My patients have easy referral access to in-patient palliative care services | Strongly agree | 36 (23) | 18 (25) | 56 (36) | J/E |
| 15 | My patients have easy access to hospice services | Strongly agree | 23 (15) | 11 (15) | 60 (39) | J/E |
| 16 | Patient’ expectations for ongoing therapies hinder my ability to offer palliative medicine referral | Strongly agree | 12 (8) | 1 (1) | 6 (4) | J/E |
| 17 | As a brain tumor specialist, I would prefer a service called supportive care rather than palliative care | Strongly agree | 12 (8) | 20 (28) | 29 (19) | J/E |
Comparison of awareness of palliative care in neuro-oncology in Japan between 2018 and 2007.
| Questionnaire | 2018 (n = 154) | 2007 (n = 132) | P value | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | How many people do you confirm patient’s death by yourself in a year? | 0 | 11 (7) | ||
| 19 | How to explain about to adult patients with gliomas | 1, Regardless of age, if consciousness is clear, tell pathology/grade | 52 (34) | 48 (36) | 0.000001 |
| 20 | How to explain to the patient himself and his/her family |
The explanation to the patient himself and the family is the same Do not give a very strict explanation to the patient himself, tell the family in detail Do not announce the disease name to the patient himself, tell the family in detail Others | 60 (39) | 26 (20) | 0.000774 |
| 21 | When glioblastoma, how to explain about the prognosis? Multiple answers allowed |
Median survival time Progression-free survival 5-year survival rate Late complication (cognitive function) No explanation about details Others | 123 (80) | 51 (39) | 0.0000163 |
| 22 | Treatment when depressed: Multiple answers allowed |
Treat by yourself with psychiatrist No treat | 65 (42) | 63 (48) | 0.725 |
| 23 | When glioblastoma, do you announce? |
Cancer notification without exception Cancer notification in consideration of age and symptom Others | 37 (24) | 11 (8) | 0.0000001 |
| 24 | To whom do you explain? |
Patient only Patient with family Family only | 6 (4) | 4 (3) | 0.000132 |
| 25 | Until when chemotherapy? |
As far as possible Until patients cannot go home Patient cannot judge Family wish Others | 58 (32) | 46 (35) | 0.0281 |
| 26 | Treatment for restless patients |
Treat on your own consult with psychiatrist No treat | 66 (43) | 67 (51) | 0.227 |
| 27 | Hospice for malignant brain tumor |
Any patients Mild symptoms None | 66 (43) | 26 (20) | 0.0000001 |
| 28 | If a patient cannot be discharged to home? |
Our hospital Hospital with neurosurgeon Hospital without neurosurgeon Nursing home Home care | 36 (23) | 58 (44) | 0.0042 |
| 29 | Utilization of Nursing home at the end of stage |
Active use I want to use No use | 36 (23) | 16 (12) | 0.00132 |
| 30 | The timing of explaining about DNR |
In good condition No chance of recovery Not explain | 15 (10) | 8 (6) | 0.848 |
| 31 | Use of ventilator at end of stage in adult patients with gliomas |
All cases More than half Sometimes No cases | 0 (0) | 0 (0) | 0.000351 |
| 32 | Use of ventilator at the end of stage for child patients with gliomas |
All cases More than half Sometimes No cases | 5 (3) | 3 (2) | 0.127 |
| 33 | When patients with gliomas at the end of stage cannot eat. |
Nasal tube feeding Gastrostomy Central venous port peripheral drip infusion | 92 (60) | 82 (62) | 0.336 |
| 34 | Palliative care at home |
Strong recommendation Possible recommendation No recommendation | 38 (25) | 30 (23) | 0.204 |
| 35 | Place of death |
Our hospital A hospital with neurosurgeon A hospital without neurosurgeon Nursing home Home | 50 (32) | 61 (46) | 0.0000106 |
| 36 | Opioids for brain tumor |
Analgesia Analgesia Respiratory comfort Others No usage | 59 (38) |
Fig. 1Representative questionnaires: Part 1. Data of Japan from this study. Data of Europe and the United States/Canada from Ref. 14. (A) Sex of physicians in Neuro-oncology (Q1). (B) Speciality of physician in Japan, Europe, and the United States/Canada (Q2). (C) Practicing independently (years of medical practice) (Q6). (D) Practice setting (Q7).
Fig. 2Representative questionnaires: Part 2. Data of Japan from this study. Data of Europe and the United States/Canada from Ref. 14. (A) How to explain about prognosis? (Q21). (B) To whom do you explain? (Q24). (C) A ventilator at the end of stage of adult malignant brain tumors (Q31). (D) When oral intake becomes difficult at the end of stage (Q33).
Fig. 3Representative questionnaires: Part 3. Data of Japan from this study. Data of overseas from Ref. 10. (A) Place of death. (Comparison with the past in Japan) (Q35). (B) Place of death (International comparison).