| Literature DB >> 33134959 |
Arian MadaniNeishaboori1, Donya Moshrefiaraghi1, Kosar Mohamed Ali2, Amirmohammad Toloui1, Mahmoud Yousefifard1, Mostafa Hosseini3.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Several studies have confirmed neurological involvements, such as acute cerebrovascular disease and impaired consciousness in COVID-19. In the present study, our aim is to investigate the current evidence regarding central nervous system (CNS) complications in patients with confirmed COVID-19.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; Central Nervous System Diseases; Prevalence; Stroke
Year: 2020 PMID: 33134959 PMCID: PMC7587989
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Arch Acad Emerg Med ISSN: 2645-4904
Medline search query
| Search terms |
|---|
|
“Betacoronavirus”[mh] OR “Coronavirus”[mh] OR “Coronavirus Infections”[mh] OR "COVID-19 vaccine"[Supplementary Concept] OR "COVID-19 diagnostic testing"[Supplementary Concept] OR 2019 novel coronavirus disease[tiab] OR COVID19[tiab] OR COVID-19[tiab] OR SARS-CoV-2[tiab] OR COVID-19 pandemic[tiab] OR SARS-CoV-2 infection[tiab] OR COVID-19 virus disease[tiab] OR 2019 novel coronavirus infection[tiab] OR 2019-nCoV infection[tiab] OR coronavirus disease 2019[tiab] OR coronavirus disease-19[tiab] OR 2019-nCoV disease[tiab] OR COVID-19 virus infection[tiab] OR Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2[tiab] “Stroke”[mh] OR “Cerebrovascular Disorders”[mh] OR “Brain Ischemia”[mh] OR “Encephalitis”[mh] OR “Infectious Encephalitis”[mh] OR “Encephalitis, Viral”[mh] OR “Encephalitis Viruses”[mh] OR “Meningitis”[mh] OR “Meningitis, Viral”[mh] OR “Central Nervous System Infections”[mh] OR “Central Nervous System Viral Diseases”[mh] OR “Nervous System Diseases”[mh] OR “Central Nervous System Diseases”[mh] OR “Neurologic Manifestations”[mh] OR “Brain”[mh] OR “Brain Infarction”[mh] OR Stroke[tiab] OR Strokes[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Accident[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Accidents[tiab] OR CVA (Cerebrovascular Accident)[tiab] OR CVAs (Cerebrovascular Accident)[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Apoplexy[tiab] OR Apoplexy, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Vascular Accident, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Vascular Accident[tiab] OR Brain Vascular Accidents[tiab] OR Vascular Accidents, Brain[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Stroke[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Strokes[tiab] OR Stroke, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Strokes, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Apoplexy[tiab] OR Cerebral Stroke[tiab] OR Cerebral Strokes[tiab] OR Stroke, Cerebral[tiab] OR Strokes, Cerebral[tiab] OR Stroke, Acute[tiab] OR Acute Stroke[tiab] OR Acute Strokes[tiab] OR Strokes, Acute[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Accident, Acute[tiab] OR Acute Cerebrovascular Accident[tiab] OR Acute Cerebrovascular Accidents[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Accidents, Acute[tiab] OR Brain Infarction[tiab] OR Brain Infarctions[tiab] OR Infarction, Brain[tiab] OR Infarctions, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Infarct[tiab] OR Brain Infarcts[tiab] OR Infarct, Brain[tiab] OR Infarcts, Brain[tiab] OR Anterior Circulation Brain Infarction[tiab] OR Infarction, Brain, Anterior Circulation[tiab] OR Infarction, Anterior Circulation, Brain[tiab] OR Anterior Circulation Infarction, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Infarction, Anterior Circulation[tiab] OR Venous Infarction, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Venous Infarction[tiab] OR Brain Venous Infarctions[tiab] OR Infarction, Brain Venous[tiab] OR Infarctions, Brain Venous[tiab] OR Venous Infarctions, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Infarction, Venous[tiab] OR Brain Infarctions, Venous[tiab] OR Infarction, Venous Brain[tiab] OR Infarctions, Venous Brain[tiab] OR Venous Brain Infarction[tiab] OR Venous Brain Infarctions[tiab] OR Anterior Cerebral Circulation Infarction[tiab] OR Infarction, Anterior Cerebral Circulation[tiab] OR Brain Infarction, Posterior Circulation[tiab] OR Posterior Circulation Infarction, Brain[tiab] OR Posterior Circulation Brain Infarction[tiab] OR Infarction, Brain, Posterior Circulation[tiab] OR Infarction, Posterior Circulation, Brain[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Disorders[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Disorder[tiab] OR Vascular Diseases, Intracranial[tiab] OR Intracranial Vascular Disease[tiab] OR Intracranial Vascular Diseases[tiab] OR Vascular Disease, Intracranial[tiab] OR Intracranial Vascular Disorders[tiab] OR Intracranial Vascular Disorder[tiab] OR Vascular Disorder, Intracranial[tiab] OR Vascular Disorders, Intracranial[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Diseases[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Disease[tiab] OR Disease, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Diseases, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Brain Vascular Disorders[tiab] OR Brain Vascular Disorder[tiab] OR Vascular Disorder, Brain[tiab] OR Vascular Disorders, Brain[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Occlusion[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Occlusions[tiab] OR Occlusion, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Occlusions, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Insufficiency[tiab] OR Cerebrovascular Insufficiencies[tiab] OR Insufficiencies, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Insufficiency, Cerebrovascular[tiab] OR Brain Ischemia[tiab] OR Brain Ischemias[tiab] OR Ischemia, Brain[tiab] OR Ischemic Encephalopathy[tiab] OR Encephalopathy, Ischemic[tiab] OR Ischemic Encephalopathies[tiab] OR Cerebral Ischemia[tiab] OR Cerebral Ischemias[tiab] OR Ischemias, Cerebral[tiab] OR Ischemia, Cerebral[tiab] OR Encephalitis[tiab] OR Brain Inflammation[tiab] OR Inflammation, Brain[tiab] OR Brain Inflammations[tiab] OR Rasmussen Syndrome[tiab] OR Rasmussen Encephalitis[tiab] OR Rasmussen's Syndrome[tiab] OR Encephalitis, Rasmussen[tiab] OR Infectious Encephalitis[tiab] OR Encephalitis, Infectious[tiab] OR Encephalitis Infection[tiab] OR Encephalitis Infections[tiab] OR Infection, Encephalitis[tiab] OR Infections, Encephalitis[tiab] OR Encephalitis, Viral[tiab] OR Encephalomyelitis, Infectious, Viral[tiab] OR Infectious Encephalomyelitis, Viral[tiab] OR Encephalomyelitis, Viral Infectious[tiab] OR Viral Infectious Encephalomyelitis[tiab] OR Viral Encephalitis[tiab] OR Encephalitis Viruses[tiab] OR Viruses, Encephalitis[tiab] OR Encephalitis Virus[tiab] OR Virus, Encephalitis[tiab] OR Meningitis[tiab] OR Meningitides[tiab] OR Pachymeningitis[tiab] OR Pachymeningitides[tiab] OR Meningitis, Viral[tiab] OR Meningitides, Viral[tiab] OR Viral Meningitides[tiab] OR Viral Meningitis[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Infections[tiab] OR Infections, Central Nervous System[tiab] OR CNS Infections[tiab] OR CNS Infection[tiab] OR Infection, CNS[tiab] OR Infections, CNS[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Infection[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Viral Diseases[tiab] OR Viral Diseases, Central Nervous System[tiab] OR Viral Infections, Central Nervous System[tiab] OR Infections, CNS, Viral[tiab] OR Infections, Viral CNS[tiab] OR CNS Infection, Viral[tiab] OR CNS Infections, Viral[tiab] OR Infection, Viral CNS[tiab] OR Viral CNS Infection[tiab] OR Viral CNS Infections[tiab] OR CNS Viral Diseases[tiab] OR CNS Viral Disease[tiab] OR Disease, CNS Viral[tiab] OR Diseases, CNS Viral[tiab] OR Viral Disease, CNS[tiab] OR Viral Diseases, CNS[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Viral Infections[tiab] OR Nervous System Diseases[tiab] OR Disease, Nervous System[tiab] OR Diseases, Nervous System[tiab] OR Nervous System Disease[tiab] OR Neurologic Disorders[tiab] OR Disorder, Neurologic[tiab] OR Disorders, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurologic Disorder[tiab] OR Neurological Disorders[tiab] OR Disorder, Neurological[tiab] OR Disorders, Neurological[tiab] OR Neurological Disorder[tiab] OR Nervous System Disorders[tiab] OR Disorder, Nervous System[tiab] OR Disorders, Nervous System[tiab] OR Nervous System Disorder[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Diseases[tiab] OR Central Nervous System Disorders[tiab] OR CNS Diseases[tiab] OR CNS Disease[tiab] OR Neurologic Manifestations[tiab] OR Manifestation, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurological Manifestations[tiab] OR Neurologic Manifestation[tiab] OR Neurologic Signs and Symptoms[tiab] OR Manifestations, Neurologic[tiab] OR Manifestations, Neurological[tiab] OR Manifestation, Neurological[tiab] OR Neurological Manifestation[tiab] OR Neurologic Deficits[tiab] OR Deficit, Neurologic[tiab] OR Deficits, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurologic Deficit[tiab] OR Neurologic Symptoms[tiab] OR Neurologic Symptom[tiab] OR Symptom, Neurologic[tiab] OR Symptoms, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurologic Findings[tiab] OR Finding, Neurologic[tiab] OR Findings, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurologic Finding[tiab] OR Neurologic Signs[tiab] OR Neurologic Sign[tiab] OR Sign, Neurologic[tiab] OR Signs, Neurologic[tiab] OR Focal Neurologic Deficits[tiab] OR Deficit, Focal Neurologic[tiab] OR Deficits, Focal Neurologic[tiab] OR Focal Neurologic Deficit[tiab] OR Neurologic Deficit, Focal[tiab] OR Neurologic Deficits, Focal[tiab] OR Neurologic Dysfunction[tiab] OR Dysfunction, Neurologic[tiab] OR Dysfunctions, Neurologic[tiab] OR Neurologic Dysfunctions[tiab] OR Encephalopathy[tiab] OR Clinical characteristics[tiab] OR Brain[tiab] #1 AND #2 |
Figure 1Flow diagram of the present meta-analysis
Summary of included studies
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chen; 2020; China | Retrospective | 274 | 62 | 171 | Clinical symptom and laboratory findings | Hypoxic encephalopathy | 24 |
| Helmes; 2020; France | Prospective | 58 | 63 | NR | MRI | Cerebral ischemic stroke | 3 |
| MRI | Brain leptomeningeal enhancement | 8 | |||||
| Clinical symptom | Encephalopathy | 13 | |||||
| Clinical symptom | Dysexecutive syndrome | 15 | |||||
| MRI | Brain perfusion abnormalities | 11 | |||||
| Klok; 2020; Netherlands | Prospective | 184 | 64 | 139 | CT | Acute Cerebrovascular disease | 3 |
| Li; 2020; China | Retrospective | 221 | 53.3 | 131 | CT | Acute Cerebrovascular disease | 13 |
| Lodigiani; 2020; Italy | Retrospective | 388 | 66 | 264 | Report of treating physician | Acute Cerebrovascular disease | 9 |
| Lu; 2020; China | Retrospective | 304 | 44 | 182 | Clinical symptom | Encephalopathy | 8 |
| NR | Acute cerebrovascular disease | 3 | |||||
| Mao; 2020; China | Retrospective | 214 | 52.7 | 87 | CT | Acute cerebrovascular disease | 6 |
| NR | Ataxia | 1 |
CT: Computed tomography scan; MRI: Magnetic resonance imaging; NR: Not reported
Figure 2Funnel plot for assessment of publication bias in central nervous system (CNS) complications following SARS-CoV2 infection. Other complications: Brain leptomeningeal enhancement, dysexecutive syndrome, brain perfusion abnormalities, ataxia
Risk of bias assessment of included studies based on NHLBI tools
|
|
NA: Not applicable;
Criteria 1. Was the research question or objective in this paper clearly stated?
Criteria 2. Was the study population clearly specified and defined?
Criteria 3. Was the participation rate of eligible persons at least 50%?
Criteria 4. Were all the subjects selected or recruited from the same or similar populations (including the same time period)? Were inclusion and exclusion criteria for being in the study prespecified and applied uniformly to all participants?
Criteria 5. Was a sample size justification, power description, or variance and effect estimates provided?
Criteria 6. For the analyses in this paper, were the exposure(s) of interest measured prior to the outcome(s) being measured?
Criteria 7. Was the timeframe sufficient so that one could reasonably expect to see an association between exposure and outcome if it existed?
Criteria 8. For exposures that can vary in amount or level, did the study examine different levels of the exposure as related to the outcome (e.g., categories of exposure, or exposure measured as continuous variable)?
Criteria 9. Were the exposure measures (independent variables) clearly defined, valid, reliable, and implemented consistently across all study participants?
Criteria 10. Was the exposure(s) assessed more than once over time?
Criteria 11. Were the outcome measures (dependent variables) clearly defined, valid, reliable, and implemented consistently across all study participants?
Criteria 12. Were the outcome assessors blinded to the exposure status of participants?
Criteria 13. Was loss to follow-up after baseline 20% or less?
Criteria 14. Were key potential confounding variables measured and adjusted statistically for their impact on the relationship between exposure(s) and outcome(s)?
Figure 3Forest plot for prevalence of central nervous system (CNS) complication following SARS-CoV-2 infection. The overall prevalence of CNS complication was 6.27%. Other complications: Brain leptomeningeal enhancement; Dysexecutive syndrome; Brain perfusion abnormalities; Ataxia