PURPOSE: In this phase II response-adaptive trial, we investigated the rational application of immune checkpoint blockade in renal cell carcinoma (RCC; ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03203473). METHODS: We enrolled patients with metastatic RCC with no prior checkpoint inhibitor exposure. All patients received nivolumab alone with subsequent arm allocation based on response. Patients with a confirmed partial response (PR) or complete response (CR) within 6 months discontinued nivolumab and were observed (arm A). Patients with stable disease or progressive disease (PD) after no more than 6 months of nivolumab received two doses of ipilimumab (arm B). The primary endpoints were the proportion of patients with PR/CR at 1 year after nivolumab discontinuation (arm A) and proportion of nivolumab nonresponders who converted to PR/CR after ipilimumab (arm B). RESULTS: Overall, 83 patients initiated treatment, of whom 96% had clear-cell histology, 51% were treatment naïve, and 67% had intermediate/poor-risk disease. Median follow-up was 19.5 months. Within 6 months, induction nivolumab resulted in a confirmed PR in 12% of patients (n = 10). Fourteen patients were not allocated to a study arm (seven because of toxicity, seven because of PD). Twelve patients (14%) were allocated to arm A and discontinued nivolumab, of whom five (42%; 90% CI, 18% to 68%) remained off nivolumab at ≥ 1 year. Of 57 patients (69%) allocated to arm B, two patients converted to a confirmed PR (4%; 90% CI, 1% to 11%), and no CRs were observed. CONCLUSION: In this study, nivolumab followed by two doses of ipilimumab resulted in no CRs and a low PR/CR conversion. The number of patients evaluated for nivolumab discontinuation was too small to assess the value of this approach. Currently, our data do not support a response-adaptive strategy for checkpoint blockade in advanced RCC.
PURPOSE: In this phase II response-adaptive trial, we investigated the rational application of immune checkpoint blockade in renal cell carcinoma (RCC; ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03203473). METHODS: We enrolled patients with metastatic RCC with no prior checkpoint inhibitor exposure. All patients received nivolumab alone with subsequent arm allocation based on response. Patients with a confirmed partial response (PR) or complete response (CR) within 6 months discontinued nivolumab and were observed (arm A). Patients with stable disease or progressive disease (PD) after no more than 6 months of nivolumab received two doses of ipilimumab (arm B). The primary endpoints were the proportion of patients with PR/CR at 1 year after nivolumab discontinuation (arm A) and proportion of nivolumab nonresponders who converted to PR/CR after ipilimumab (arm B). RESULTS: Overall, 83 patients initiated treatment, of whom 96% had clear-cell histology, 51% were treatment naïve, and 67% had intermediate/poor-risk disease. Median follow-up was 19.5 months. Within 6 months, induction nivolumab resulted in a confirmed PR in 12% of patients (n = 10). Fourteen patients were not allocated to a study arm (seven because of toxicity, seven because of PD). Twelve patients (14%) were allocated to arm A and discontinued nivolumab, of whom five (42%; 90% CI, 18% to 68%) remained off nivolumab at ≥ 1 year. Of 57 patients (69%) allocated to arm B, two patients converted to a confirmed PR (4%; 90% CI, 1% to 11%), and no CRs were observed. CONCLUSION: In this study, nivolumab followed by two doses of ipilimumab resulted in no CRs and a low PR/CR conversion. The number of patients evaluated for nivolumab discontinuation was too small to assess the value of this approach. Currently, our data do not support a response-adaptive strategy for checkpoint blockade in advanced RCC.
Authors: Michael A Postow; Jason Chesney; Anna C Pavlick; Caroline Robert; Kenneth Grossmann; David McDermott; Gerald P Linette; Nicolas Meyer; Jeffrey K Giguere; Sanjiv S Agarwala; Montaser Shaheen; Marc S Ernstoff; David Minor; April K Salama; Matthew Taylor; Patrick A Ott; Linda M Rollin; Christine Horak; Paul Gagnier; Jedd D Wolchok; F Stephen Hodi Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-04-20 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Robert J Motzer; Nizar M Tannir; David F McDermott; Osvaldo Arén Frontera; Bohuslav Melichar; Toni K Choueiri; Elizabeth R Plimack; Philippe Barthélémy; Camillo Porta; Saby George; Thomas Powles; Frede Donskov; Victoria Neiman; Christian K Kollmannsberger; Pamela Salman; Howard Gurney; Robert Hawkins; Alain Ravaud; Marc-Oliver Grimm; Sergio Bracarda; Carlos H Barrios; Yoshihiko Tomita; Daniel Castellano; Brian I Rini; Allen C Chen; Sabeen Mekan; M Brent McHenry; Megan Wind-Rotolo; Justin Doan; Padmanee Sharma; Hans J Hammers; Bernard Escudier Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2018-03-21 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: E A Eisenhauer; P Therasse; J Bogaerts; L H Schwartz; D Sargent; R Ford; J Dancey; S Arbuck; S Gwyther; M Mooney; L Rubinstein; L Shankar; L Dodd; R Kaplan; D Lacombe; J Verweij Journal: Eur J Cancer Date: 2009-01 Impact factor: 9.162
Authors: Robert J Motzer; Bernard Escudier; David F McDermott; Saby George; Hans J Hammers; Sandhya Srinivas; Scott S Tykodi; Jeffrey A Sosman; Giuseppe Procopio; Elizabeth R Plimack; Daniel Castellano; Toni K Choueiri; Howard Gurney; Frede Donskov; Petri Bono; John Wagstaff; Thomas C Gauler; Takeshi Ueda; Yoshihiko Tomita; Fabio A Schutz; Christian Kollmannsberger; James Larkin; Alain Ravaud; Jason S Simon; Li-An Xu; Ian M Waxman; Padmanee Sharma Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-09-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Daniel Y C Heng; Wanling Xie; Meredith M Regan; Mark A Warren; Ali Reza Golshayan; Chakshu Sahi; Bernhard J Eigl; J Dean Ruether; Tina Cheng; Scott North; Peter Venner; Jennifer J Knox; Kim N Chi; Christian Kollmannsberger; David F McDermott; William K Oh; Michael B Atkins; Ronald M Bukowski; Brian I Rini; Toni K Choueiri Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2009-10-13 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Hans J Hammers; Elizabeth R Plimack; Jeffrey R Infante; Brian I Rini; David F McDermott; Lionel D Lewis; Martin H Voss; Padmanee Sharma; Sumanta K Pal; Albiruni R Abdul Razak; Christian Kollmannsberger; Daniel Y C Heng; Jennifer Spratlin; M Brent McHenry; Asim Amin Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2017-07-05 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Robert J Motzer; Konstantin Penkov; John Haanen; Brian Rini; Laurence Albiges; Matthew T Campbell; Balaji Venugopal; Christian Kollmannsberger; Sylvie Negrier; Motohide Uemura; Jae L Lee; Aleksandr Vasiliev; Wilson H Miller; Howard Gurney; Manuela Schmidinger; James Larkin; Michael B Atkins; Jens Bedke; Boris Alekseev; Jing Wang; Mariangela Mariani; Paul B Robbins; Aleksander Chudnovsky; Camilla Fowst; Subramanian Hariharan; Bo Huang; Alessandra di Pietro; Toni K Choueiri Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2019-02-16 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Jacob J Adashek; Joshua J Breunig; Edwin Posadas; Neil A Bhowmick; Leigh Ellis; Stephen J Freedland; Hyung Kim; Robert Figlin; Jun Gong Journal: Drugs Date: 2022-02-17 Impact factor: 9.546
Authors: Michael B Atkins; Opeyemi A Jegede; Naomi B Haas; David F McDermott; Mehmet A Bilen; Mark Stein; Jeffrey A Sosman; Robert Alter; Elizabeth R Plimack; Moshe Ornstein; Michael Hurwitz; David J Peace; Sabina Signoretti; Thomas Denize; Alessia Cimadamore; Catherine J Wu; David Braun; David Einstein; Paul J Catalano; Hans Hammers Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2022-04-20 Impact factor: 50.717
Authors: Andrea B Apolo; Rosa Nadal; Daniel M Girardi; Scot A Niglio; Lisa Ley; Lisa M Cordes; Seth M Steinberg; Olena Sierra Ortiz; Jacqueline Cadena; Carlos Diaz; Marissa Mallek; Nicole N Davarpanah; Rene Costello; Jane B Trepel; Min-Jung Lee; Maria J Merino; Mohammad Hadi Bagheri; Paul Monk; William D Figg; James L Gulley; Piyush K Agarwal; Vladimir Valera; Heather J Chalfin; Jennifer Jones; Howard Streicher; John J Wright; Yangmin M Ning; Howard L Parnes; William L Dahut; Donald P Bottaro; Primo N Lara; Biren Saraiya; Sumanta K Pal; Mark N Stein; Amir Mortazavi Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2020-09-11 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Pedro Barata; Whitley Hatton; Arpita Desai; Vadim Koshkin; Ellen Jaeger; Charlotte Manogue; Patrick Cotogno; Malcolm Light; Brian Lewis; Jodi Layton; Oliver Sartor; Arnab Basu; Deepak Kilari; Hamid Emamekhoo; Mehmet A Bilen Journal: Front Oncol Date: 2020-10-22 Impact factor: 6.244
Authors: Rafael Antonio Medina López; Ines Rivero Belenchon; Javier Mazuecos-Quirós; Carmen Belén Congregado-Ruíz; Felipe Couñago Journal: World J Clin Oncol Date: 2022-01-24