A multivariate analysis of risk factors associated with death by Covid-19 in the USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany.

Aim: Our aim was to investigate the risk factors associated with death from COVID-19 in four countries: The USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany. Subject and methods: We used data from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation with projection information from January-August 2020. A multivariate analysis of logistic regression was performed. The following factors were analyzed (per day): number of beds needed for the hospital services, number of intensive care units (ICU) beds required, number of ventilation devices, number of both hospital and ICU admissions due to COVID-19. Nagelkerke's R2 coefficient of determination was used to evaluate the model's predictive ability. The quality of the model's fit was assessed by the Hosmer-Lemeshow and the chi-square tests.
Results: Among the evaluated countries, Italy presented greater need for ICU beds/day (≤ 98; OR = 2315.122; CI 95% [334.767-16,503.502]; p < 0.001) and daily ventilation devices (≤ 118; OR = 1784.168; CI 95% [250.217-12,721.995]; p < 0.001). It is expected that both Italy and Spain have a higher ICU admission rate due to COVID-19 (n = 14/day). Spain will need more beds/day (≤ 357; OR = 146.838; CI 95% [113.242-190.402]; p  < 0.001) and probably will have a higher number of daily hospital admissions (n = 48/day). All the above-mentioned factors have an important impact on patients' mortality due to COVID-19 in all four countries. Conclusions: Further investments in hospitals' infrastructure, as well as the development of innovative devices for patient's ventilation, are paramount to fight the pandemic in the USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany. © Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2020.

Introduction

The present study was carried out on April 19, 2020, then all the data used in this study refer to the period from the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic to the month of April of this year. The World Health Organization recorded more than 4 million confirmed cases and 224 thousand deaths by the new Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in more than 208 countries. The largest number of confirmed cases was reported by the United States of America (USA) (n = 1,060,572), Spain (n = 212,917), Italy (n = 203,597), France (n = 128,442), and Germany (n = 161,187) (Arabi et al. 2020; WHO 2020a). The exponential increase in the number of infected individuals, especially critically ill patients, is challenging public health systems worldwide. The infections caused by the SARS-COV-2 virus can be asymptomatic or cause mild symptoms in the respiratory tract (e.g., dry cough, fever). However, severe cases of the disease are characterized by difficulty breathing and chest pain, usually requiring treatment in intensive care units (ICU) (Chen et al. 2020; Huang et al. 2020; RKI 2020; Rodriguez-Morales et al. 2020a; Rodriguez-Morales et al. 2020b). Severe cases often occur in patients over 50 years old, in whom mortality rates are higher (Cascella et al. 2020; Chen et al. 2020; Huang et al. 2020; Lai et al. 2020). Unfortunately, mortality rates are not always accurately assessed, as not all asymptomatic patients or those with mild symptoms are completely recorded by the healthcare systems. The calculation is usually based on incomplete follow-up data (i.e., underestimation due to delayed deaths). Therefore, data comparisons between countries may be difficult due to differences in the populations originally affected by the virus. For instance, the elderly were primarily the most infected group in Italy, which was not the scenario in Germany (Saglietto et al. 2020; Weiss and Murdoch 2020).

Currently, COVID-19 mortality rates have ranged from 0.3% to 5.8%, being significantly higher compared to the seasonal influenza (0.1%) (Anderson et al. 2020; Li et al. 2017; WHO 2020a; WHO 2020b; WHO 2020c). The reduction of these rates depends, among other things, on the capacity and quality of services of the healthcare system of each country (Müller et al. 2020). In many countries, the amount of mechanical ventilation and ICU beds available for the treatment of critically ill patients is far from ideal. So far, no specific antiviral treatment or vaccine for COVID-19 exist (Chen et al. 2020; Huang et al. 2020). The most favorable coping strategy to deal with this infection has been prevention, aiming at reducing community transmission of the virus. In the past days, aggressive measures of social distance (isolation) in China led to a progressive reduction in the number of cases (Cascella et al. 2020).

Our aim was to investigate the predictors of COVID-19 mortality in some of the most affected countries (i.e., USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany) including clinical and quality-of-service indicators such as number of beds and ventilation devices available, number of hospitalizations, and number of patients attending ICU.

Methods

Study design and data collection

An epidemiological study was conducted using the Coronavirus Projections Database from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) of the University of Washington (USA) (IHME 2020).

Data were projected from January 3 to August 4, 2020. Only information from the USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany was evaluated. Data from other European countries have been excluded. The number of required beds/day, number of required ICU beds/day, number of ventilation devices, number of new hospital admissions/day, and number of new ICU patients/day were considered as independent variables for patients affected by COVID-19. The dependent variable was death by COVID-19, which was dichotomized into death or life.

Statistical analyses

Quantitative data with normal distribution were presented as a mean and 95% confidence interval (CI). The categorical (qualitative) variables were presented as frequency. The evaluation of risk factors associated with mortality due to COVID-19 was conducted using the multivariate model of logistic regression. The quantification of the effect size of the mortality risk factors was performed using the odds ratio (OR) with a 95% CI. The model was built using hierarchical criteria based on theoretical reasons. Nagelkerke’s R2 coefficient of determination was used to evaluate the model’s predictive ability. The quality of the model’s fit was assessed by the Hosmer–Lemeshow and chi-square tests. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS Software version 20 (Chicago, USA). A level of significance of p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

In the USA, the estimated number of beds in hospitals was 174 beds/day (CI 95%, 1.04–3.85), while in Italy, Spain, and Germany the numbers were 347 beds/day (CI 95%, 3.07–4.22), 357 beds/day (CI 95%, 2.96–4.93), and 96 beds/day (CI 95%, 6.9–1.85) respectively. Regarding the number of beds required in ICU for treating COVID-19, the values were 48 beds/day in the USA, while Italy and Spain presented similar rates (98 and 97 beds/day respectively), and Germany had the lowest values (26 beds/day). Italy and Spain also showed the highest numbers of ventilation equipments (88 and 87 devices/beds/day respectively), followed by USA (43 devices/beds/day) and Germany (24 devices/beds/day). These same patterns were observed for hospital admissions due to COVID-19 (Italy: 47 beds/day, Spain: 48 beds/day, USA: 24 beds/day, Germany: 13 beds/day) and ICU admissions (Italy: 14 beds/day, Spain: 14 beds/day, USA: 7 beds/day, Germany: 4 beds/day) (Table 1). During the studied period, the cumulative forecast of deaths from COVID-19 in the USA was 620 (CI 95%, 4.08–12.53), while in Italy it was 1428 deaths (CI 95%, 13.17–16.60), in Spain 1359 (CI 95%, 11.80–17.82) and in Germany 352 deaths (CI 95%, 2.69–6.44).

Table 1

Forecast of average number of beds, ventilation devices and hospital admissions per day for treating COVID-19 in the USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany (03/01/2020–04/08/2020)

Variable	USA			Italy			Spain			Germany
	Mean	−95% CI	+95% CI	Mean	−95% CI	+95% CI	Mean	−95% CI	+95% CI	Mean	−95% CI	+95% CI
Number of beds/day	174	104	385	347	307	422	357	296	493	96	69	185
Number of ICU beds/day	48	29	104	98	88	118	97	82	133	26	19	51
Number of ventilation devices/bed/day	43	26	92	88	79	106	87	73	119	24	17	45
Number of hospital admissions/day	24	13	53	47	40	60	48	38	69	13	9	26
Number of ICU admissions/day	7	4	14	14	12	17	14	11	19	4	3	7
Cumulative deaths (COVID-19)	620	408	1253	1428	1317	1660	1359	1180	1782	352	269	644

CI = confidence interval

All the above-mentioned factors (number of daily hospital beds, ICU beds, ventilation devices, hospital, and ICU admission) were associated with the risk of death by COVID-19 in the four countries (chi-square test of model adjustment, p < 0.05). The prediction of the regression models was greater than 97% (R2 Negelkerk > 0.85) and the observed data were statistically like the predicted data (Hosmer–Lemeshow, p > 0.05) (Table 2).

Table 2

Chi-square test for coefficient significance analysis, Nalgelkerk R2 and Hosmer–Lemeshow tests for adjustment analysis of the multivariate logistic regression model of all studied variables

Model	Chi-square test “p value”	Hosmer–Lemeshow test “p value”	Nagelkerk R2
USA	0.000	0.080	0.88
Italy	0.000	0.784	0.87
Spain	0.000	0.435	0.88
Germany	0.000	0.052	0.86

The risk factors associated with COVID-19 mortality in the USA were: having a number of hospital beds equal or less than 174 per day [OR = 286.344 (CI 95% 208.962–392.381); p < 0.001] having a number of ICU beds for COVID-19 lower than 48 per day [OR = 284.585 (CI 95% 206.916–391.408); p < 0.001]; having less than 43 available ventillation devices per day [OR = 349.251 (CI 95% 243.715–500,488); p < 0.001]; number of hospital admissions equal or superior to 24 patients per day [OR = 120.738 (CI 95% 95.670–152.375); p < 0.001] and number of patients attending ICU due to COVID-19 higher than 7 per day [OR = 146.838 (CI 95% 113.242–190.402); p < 0.001] (Table 3). In Italy, the risk factors associated with COVID-19 mortality were: having a number of hospital beds equal or less than 347 (p < 0.001); having a number of ICU beds for COVID-19 lower than 98 (p < 0.001); having less than 118 available ventilation devices per day (p < 0.001); number of hospital admissions equal or superior to 47 patients per day (p < 0.001); and number of patients attending ICU higher than 14 per day (p < 0.001) (Table 3).

Table 3

Multivariate analysis of COVID-19 mortality risk factors in the USA and Italy

Italy					USA					Spain					Germany
Covariate	OR	−95% CI	+95% CI	P	Covariate	OR	−95% CI	+95% CI	P	Covariate	OR	−95% CI	+95% CI	P	Covariate	OR	−95% CI	+95% CI	P
Number of beds/day				0.000	Number of beds/day				0.000	Number of beds/day				0.000	Number of beds/day				0.000
[> 347 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[> 174 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[> 357 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[> 96 beds]	1.0	......	......	......
[< 347 beds]	2370.465	332.536	16,897.722		[< 174 beds]	286.344	208.962	392.381		[< 357 beds]	146.838	113.242	190.402		[< 96 beds]	219.438	123.516	389.855
Number of ICU beds/day				0.000	Number of ICU beds/day				0.000	Number of ICU beds/day				0.000	Number of ICU beds/day				0.000
[> 98 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[>48 beds]					[> 98 beds]					[> 26 beds]	1.0	......	......	......
[<98 beds]	2315.122	324.767	16,503.502		[<48 beds]	284.585	206.916	391.408		[< 98 beds]	195.673	62.340	614.183		[< 26 beds]	254.884	140.447	462.563
Number of ventillation devices/bed/day					Number of ventillation devices/bed/day				0.000	Number of ventillation devices/bed/day				0.000	Number of ventillation devices/bed/day				0.000
[> 118 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[>43 beds]					[> 87 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[> 24 beds]	1.0	......	......	......
[< 118 beds]	1784.168	250.217	12,721.995		[<43 beds]	349.251	243.715	500.488		[< 87 beds]	676.618	215.921	2120.278		[< 24 beds]	207.223	118.831	361.364
Number of hospital admissions/day				0.000	Number of hospital admissions/day				0.000	Number of hospital admissions/day				0.000	Number of hospital admissions/day				0.000
[< 47 patients]	1	......	......	......	[< 24 patients]					[< 48 patients]	1.0	......	......	......	[< 13 patients]	1.0	......	......	......
[>47 patients]	385.296	171.358	866.332		[> 24 patients]	120.738	95.670	152.375		[> 48 patients]	284.449	133.435	606.370		[> 13 patients]	65.990	44.949	96.879
Number of ICU admissions/day				0.000	Number of ICU admissions/day					Number of ICU admissions/day				0.000	Number of ICU admissions/day				0.000
[< 14 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[< 7 beds]					[< 14 beds]	1.0	......	......	......	[< 4 beds]	1.0	......	......	......
[> 14 beds]	386.819	172.037	869.750		[> 7 beds]	146.838	113.242	190.402	0.000	[> 14 beds]	277.808	130.314	592.239		[> 4 beds]	77.,519	51.802	116.003

OR = odds ratio; CI = confidence interval

In Spain, the risk factors associated with mortality from COVID-19 were: the number of hospital beds less than 357 available per day [OR = 146.838 (CI 95% 113.242–190.402); p < 0.001]; number of ICU beds less than 98 per day [OR = 195.673 (CI 95% 62.340–614.183); p < 0.001]; number of ventilation devices less than 87 per day [OR = 676.618 (CI 95% 215.921–2120.278); p < 0.001]; number of hospital admissions equal or greater than 48 patients/day [OR = 284.449 (CI 95% 133.435–606.370); p < 0.001]; and number of ICU admission superior to 14 patients daily [OR = 277.808 (CI 95% 130.314–592.239); p < 0.001] (Table 3). The risk factors associated with COVID-19 mortality in Germany were: number of hospital beds less than 96 per day (p < 0.001); number of ICU beds less than 26 per day (p < 0.001); number of ventilation devices less than 24 per day (p < 0.001); number of hospital admissions greater 13 daily (p < 0.001) and number ICU admissions superior to 4 patients per day (p < 0.001) (Table 3).

Discussion

Our study demonstrated with a 7-month projection (January 2020 until August 2020) the low number of both beds in ICU and ventilation devices available per day being associated with an increase of 100-fold (OR > 100) in mortality from COVID-19 in all four evaluated countries (USA, Spain, Italy, and Germany) if no further measures were taken. These four countries were chosen because they had the highest numbers of predicted cases and the highest mortality from COVID-19 in the database used. In China (Wuhan), where the pandemic started, 49% of all 2087 inpatients seriously affected by COVID-19 died, reaching a mortality rate around 62%. In the USA, these rates are already around 52% (Washington, DC) (Phua et al. 2020). Given that the mortality of severely ill patients with SARS-CoV-2 pneumonia is high, and that the survival time of these patients ranges from 1 to 2 weeks in hospital beds, the lack of infrastructure for treating patients with COVID-19 will impact on the disease’s course. Additionally, hospitals must provide areas and beds with minimum safety parameters to admit routine patients that are not infected with the virus, but still need care, avoiding extending morbimortality to other diseases (Remuzzi and Remuzzi 2020).

The reduced number of hospital beds predisposes the healthcare system to saturation (Di Lorenzo and Di Trolio 2020). The need for measures such as increasing the number of ICU beds had already been foreseen in some studies carried out for European countries, such as the study of Verelst et al. (2020). In Italy, one of the countries most affected by the pandemic worldwide, it is estimated that the number of ICU beds needed to provide a minimum set of care for COVID-19 patients will reach several thousand. According to the study by Verelst et al. (2020) which was carried out with data available until the beginning of March 2020 in Italy, maximum occupancy of all available beds in the country was predicted (n = 5200) by the end of the same month, pointing out the need for allocation of resources to increase the number of beds in order to contribute to coping with the pandemic (Verelst et al. 2020). In the study of Remuzzi and Remuzzi (2020), a projection of the number of patients in ICU beds was calculated from February 2020, reaching up to 7500 ICU beds in a week in Italy if the infection rate continued to increase (Remuzzi and Remuzzi 2020).

A study published by Rhodes et al. (2012) evidenced a very considerable heterogeneity in the number of ICU beds among European countries, with Germany, for instance, having 6.9 times the number of beds per capita compared to other nations (Rhodes et al. 2012). These differences may be explained, among others, by socioeconomic variances among regions and by features of the healthcare systems (Rhodes et al. 2012). This heterogeneity among the countries was also evident regarding the need for structure during a COVID-19 pandemic. While Italy and Spain identified the number of ICU beds of 98 per day as a risk factor associated with COVID-19 mortality, Germany showing the number of 26 per day. In an intermediate position to European countries, the USA showed the number of 48 ICU beds per day as a risk factor. The same ranking was observed when comparing the other risk factors, as the total number of hospital beds and the number of available ventillation devices per day. The worst results were pointed out for Italy and Spain, followed by the USA, while Germany presented the best scenario.

Patients infected with COVID-19 that require hospitalization are usually classified according to the clinical manifestations and disease severity into: (1) mild disease with pneumonia or absence (81% of cases), (2) severe disease with dyspnea, altered respiratory rate, blood oxygen saturation ≤ 93%, change in the PaO2/FiO2 or P/F ratio and the percentage of oxygen supplied with possible pulmonary infiltrate (14% of cases), and (3) critical illness with respiratory failure, septic shock, or multiple organ dysfunction (MOD) or failure (MOF) (5% of cases) (Cascella et al. 2020). In a retrospective cohort study of 201 patients with confirmed COVID-19 pneumonia admitted to Wuhan Jinyintan Hospital in China between December 25, 2019, and January 26, 2020, 82.1% of patients (n = 165) required oxygen support in the hospital (Wu et al. 2020; Wu and McGoogan 2020). In mainland China, it was estimated that 3.2% of all patients infected with COVID-19 received intubation and invasive ventilation (Meng et al. 2020). Despite the small percentage of patients requiring invasive ventilation, the large number of infected patients simultaneously may mean limited access to this type of treatment resource (Whittle et al. 2020). There is an estimate that in the USA there are about 60,000 to 160,000, depending on the functionality of the equipment (Ranney et al. 2020). However, according to the present study, less than 43 ventilator devices available per day was a risk factor for death, that is, the number of ventilators in the country is critical in view of the growing increase in COVID-19 cases. The scenario is even more critical when we look at the figures for Italy and Spain (118 per day and 87 per day respectively), which are countries that already lack these fans (Rosenbaum 2020).

Although the pandemic requires a significant increase in the number of beds in hospitals, the circumstances can also reduce the available resources. The SARS outbreak in Toronto led to the closure during 10 days of 38% of the ICU beds at a tertiary care university, mainly due to the lack of professionals, who have been affected by the disease or were in quarantine. In this context, in addition to increasing the capacity of beds and availability of ventilators, hospitals must have strategies to increase the safety of the employees (Arabi et al. 2020).

Our results confirm the statement of the World Health Organization that COVID-19 is an emergency public health problem of worldwide interest, both for developed countries (such as the USA, Spain, Italy, and Germany) and for developing countries. This disease saturates local health systems, regardless of the country. In this context, it is important to reinforce further preventive public measures, such as quarantine, for the control of the disease. Quarantined people contribute to the reduction of new viral infections, consequently reducing overcrowding of hospitals. Additionally, further investments in hospitals’ infrastructure are needed, as well the development of innovative devices for patient’s ventilation.

The present study is based on prediction data, which may represent a limitation. The predictions on the number of new cases and mortality may not reflect the complete reality in all countries, but rather give an overall idea of what may happen until August. Besides that, it was not possible to assess the association of different variables related to healthcare access (e.g., healthcare settings, categories of care) on COVID-19 outcomes, as these data were not available on the consulted database. Further studies considering this information are needed to better understand the impact of different healthcare services on disease evolution.

Conclusions

The number of ICU beds, ventilation devices, hospital admissions, and ICU admissions per day due to COVID-19 are important predictors of mortality in the USA, Italy, Spain, and Germany. In these countries, there is an urgent need to expand hospitals’ infrastructure and services and increase the production of devices used to treat patients with this disease. Political leaders and healthcare officials should ensure that minimum resources are safely provided, including staff, hospital beds, and ICU.