Matthew Nayor1, Ravi V Shah1, Patricia E Miller2, Jasmine B Blodgett1, Melissa Tanguay1, Alexander R Pico3, Venkatesh L Murthy4, Rajeev Malhotra1,5, Nicholas E Houstis1, Amy Deik6, Kerry A Pierce6, Kevin Bullock6, Lucas Dailey6, Raghava S Velagaleti7, Stephanie A Moore7, Jennifer E Ho1,5, Aaron L Baggish1, Clary B Clish6, Martin G Larson2,8, Ramachandran S Vasan8,9, Gregory D Lewis1,5,10. 1. Cardiology Division and the Simches Cardiovascular Research Center, Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School (M.N., R.V.S., J.B.B., M.T., R.M., N.E.H., J.E.H., A.L.B., G.D.L.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. 2. Department of Biostatistics, Boston University School of Public Health, MA (P.E.M., M.G.L.). 3. Institute of Data Science and Biotechnology, Gladstone Institutes, San Francisco, CA (A.R.P.). 4. Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Department of Medicine, and Frankel Cardiovascular Center, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor (V.L.M.). 5. Cardiovascular Research Center (R.M., J.E.H., G.D.L.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston. 6. Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA (A.D., K.A.P., K.B., L.D., C.B.C.). 7. Cardiology Section, Department of Medicine, Boston VA Healthcare System, West Roxbury, MA (R.S. Velagaleti, S.A.M.). 8. Boston University and National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Framingham Heart Study, MA (M.G.L., R.S. Vasan). 9. Sections of Preventive Medicine and Epidemiology and Cardiology, Department of Medicine, Boston University School of Medicine, MA (R.S. Vasan). 10. Pulmonary Critical Care Unit (G.D.L.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Whereas regular exercise is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality, mechanisms of exercise-mediated health benefits remain less clear. We used metabolite profiling before and after acute exercise to delineate the metabolic architecture of exercise response patterns in humans. METHODS: Cardiopulmonary exercise testing and metabolite profiling was performed on Framingham Heart Study participants (age 53±8 years, 63% women) with blood drawn at rest (n=471) and at peak exercise (n=411). RESULTS: We observed changes in circulating levels for 502 of 588 measured metabolites from rest to peak exercise (exercise duration 11.9±2.1 minutes) at a 5% false discovery rate. Changes included reductions in metabolites implicated in insulin resistance (glutamate, -29%; P=1.5×10-55; dimethylguanidino valeric acid [DMGV], -18%; P=5.8×10-18) and increases in metabolites associated with lipolysis (1-methylnicotinamide, +33%; P=6.1×10-67), nitric oxide bioavailability (arginine/ornithine + citrulline, +29%; P=2.8×10-169), and adipose browning (12,13-dihydroxy-9Z-octadecenoic acid +26%; P=7.4×10-38), among other pathways relevant to cardiometabolic risk. We assayed 177 metabolites in a separate Framingham Heart Study replication sample (n=783, age 54±8 years, 51% women) and observed concordant changes in 164 metabolites (92.6%) at 5% false discovery rate. Exercise-induced metabolite changes were variably related to the amount of exercise performed (peak workload), sex, and body mass index. There was attenuation of favorable excursions in some metabolites in individuals with higher body mass index and greater excursions in select cardioprotective metabolites in women despite less exercise performed. Distinct preexercise metabolite levels were associated with different physiologic dimensions of fitness (eg, ventilatory efficiency, exercise blood pressure, peak Vo2). We identified 4 metabolite signatures of exercise response patterns that were then analyzed in a separate cohort (Framingham Offspring Study; n=2045, age 55±10 years, 51% women), 2 of which were associated with overall mortality over median follow-up of 23.1 years (P≤0.003 for both). CONCLUSIONS: In a large sample of community-dwelling individuals, acute exercise elicits widespread changes in the circulating metabolome. Metabolic changes identify pathways central to cardiometabolic health, cardiovascular disease, and long-term outcome. These findings provide a detailed map of the metabolic response to acute exercise in humans and identify potential mechanisms responsible for the beneficial cardiometabolic effects of exercise for future study.
BACKGROUND: Whereas regular exercise is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality, mechanisms of exercise-mediated health benefits remain less clear. We used metabolite profiling before and after acute exercise to delineate the metabolic architecture of exercise response patterns in humans. METHODS: Cardiopulmonary exercise testing and metabolite profiling was performed on Framingham Heart Study participants (age 53±8 years, 63% women) with blood drawn at rest (n=471) and at peak exercise (n=411). RESULTS: We observed changes in circulating levels for 502 of 588 measured metabolites from rest to peak exercise (exercise duration 11.9±2.1 minutes) at a 5% false discovery rate. Changes included reductions in metabolites implicated in insulin resistance (glutamate, -29%; P=1.5×10-55; dimethylguanidino valeric acid [DMGV], -18%; P=5.8×10-18) and increases in metabolites associated with lipolysis (1-methylnicotinamide, +33%; P=6.1×10-67), nitric oxide bioavailability (arginine/ornithine + citrulline, +29%; P=2.8×10-169), and adipose browning (12,13-dihydroxy-9Z-octadecenoic acid +26%; P=7.4×10-38), among other pathways relevant to cardiometabolic risk. We assayed 177 metabolites in a separate Framingham Heart Study replication sample (n=783, age 54±8 years, 51% women) and observed concordant changes in 164 metabolites (92.6%) at 5% false discovery rate. Exercise-induced metabolite changes were variably related to the amount of exercise performed (peak workload), sex, and body mass index. There was attenuation of favorable excursions in some metabolites in individuals with higher body mass index and greater excursions in select cardioprotective metabolites in women despite less exercise performed. Distinct preexercise metabolite levels were associated with different physiologic dimensions of fitness (eg, ventilatory efficiency, exercise blood pressure, peak Vo2). We identified 4 metabolite signatures of exercise response patterns that were then analyzed in a separate cohort (Framingham Offspring Study; n=2045, age 55±10 years, 51% women), 2 of which were associated with overall mortality over median follow-up of 23.1 years (P≤0.003 for both). CONCLUSIONS: In a large sample of community-dwelling individuals, acute exercise elicits widespread changes in the circulating metabolome. Metabolic changes identify pathways central to cardiometabolic health, cardiovascular disease, and long-term outcome. These findings provide a detailed map of the metabolic response to acute exercise in humans and identify potential mechanisms responsible for the beneficial cardiometabolic effects of exercise for future study.
Entities:
Keywords:
exercise; metabolomics; prevention & control
Authors: Katherine J E Sattler; Sehriban Elbasan; Petra Keul; Miriam Elter-Schulz; Constantin Bode; Markus H Gräler; Martina Bröcker-Preuss; Thomas Budde; Raimund Erbel; Gerd Heusch; Bodo Levkau Journal: Basic Res Cardiol Date: 2010-07-21 Impact factor: 17.165
Authors: Douglas H Deutschman; Jeffrey S Carstens; Robert L Klepper; Wyatt S Smith; M Trevor Page; Thomas R Young; Lisa A Gleason; Nobuko Nakajima; Roger A Sabbadini Journal: Am Heart J Date: 2003-07 Impact factor: 4.749
Authors: Gregory D Lewis; Debby Ngo; Anna R Hemnes; Laurie Farrell; Carly Domos; Paul P Pappagianopoulos; Bishnu P Dhakal; Amanda Souza; Xu Shi; Meredith E Pugh; Arkadi Beloiartsev; Sumita Sinha; Clary B Clish; Robert E Gerszten Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2016-01-19 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Paul Petrus; Simon Lecoutre; Lucile Dollet; Clotilde Wiel; André Sulen; Hui Gao; Beatriz Tavira; Jurga Laurencikiene; Olav Rooyackers; Antonio Checa; Iyadh Douagi; Craig E Wheelock; Peter Arner; Mark McCarthy; Martin O Bergo; Laurienne Edgar; Robin P Choudhury; Myriam Aouadi; Anna Krook; Mikael Rydén Journal: Cell Metab Date: 2019-12-19 Impact factor: 27.287
Authors: Juergen Graessler; Dominik Schwudke; Peter E H Schwarz; Ronny Herzog; Andrej Shevchenko; Stefan R Bornstein Journal: PLoS One Date: 2009-07-15 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Daniel E Lieberman; Timothy M Kistner; Daniel Richard; I-Min Lee; Aaron L Baggish Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2021-12-14 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Matthew Nayor; Ariel Chernofsky; Nicole L Spartano; Melissa Tanguay; Jasmine B Blodgett; Venkatesh L Murthy; Rajeev Malhotra; Nicholas E Houstis; Raghava S Velagaleti; Joanne M Murabito; Martin G Larson; Ramachandran S Vasan; Ravi V Shah; Gregory D Lewis Journal: Eur Heart J Date: 2021-11-21 Impact factor: 35.855
Authors: Matthew Nayor; Ravi V Shah; Melissa Tanguay; Jasmine B Blodgett; Ariel Chernofsky; Patricia E Miller; Vanessa Xanthakis; Rajeev Malhotra; Nicholas E Houstis; Raghava S Velagaleti; Martin G Larson; Ramachandran S Vasan; Gregory D Lewis Journal: Am J Cardiol Date: 2021-08-12 Impact factor: 3.133
Authors: Ravi V Shah; Gregory D Lewis; Matthew Nayor; Ariel Chernofsky; Patricia E Miller; Nicole L Spartano; Venkatesh L Murthy; Rajeev Malhotra; Nicholas E Houstis; Joanne M Murabito; Clary B Clish; Martin G Larson; Ramachandran S Vasan Journal: Circ Genom Precis Med Date: 2022-05-10
Authors: Jason V Tso; Chang Liu; Casey G Turner; Karan Uppal; Ganesh Prabakaran; Kiran Ejaz; Aaron L Baggish; Dean P Jones; Arshed A Quyyumi; Jonathan H Kim Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2022-05-26
Authors: Venkatesh L Murthy; Matthew Nayor; Mercedes Carnethon; Jared P Reis; Donald Lloyd-Jones; Norrina B Allen; Robert Kitchen; Paolo Piaggi; Lyn M Steffen; Ramachandran S Vasan; Jane E Freedman; Clary B Clish; Ravi V Shah Journal: Diabetologia Date: 2022-01-18 Impact factor: 10.122