Xiaoxi Yuan1,2, Zhigang Jiang1, Qiliang Wang1, Nan Gao1, Hongdong Li1, Yibo Ma3. 1. State Key Laboratory of Superhard Materials, Jilin University, Changchun 130012, P. R. China. 2. Institute for Interdisciplinary Quantum Information Technology, Jilin Engineering Normal University, Changchun 130052, P. R. China. 3. College of Sciences, Beihua University, Jilin 132013, P. R. China.
Abstract
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) with high toxicity, low lethal dose, and bioaccumulation have been inhibited for application in wide fields, and a highly efficient trace detection is thus greatly desirable. In this study, we produce dense Au-nanoparticles by twice sputtering and twice annealing (T-Au-NPs) on boron-doped diamond (BDD). The successful formation of T-Au-NPs/BDD nanocomposites was confirmed by scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis. Based on T-Au-NPs/BDD, an electronic biosensor with aptamers is fabricated to detect trace polychlorinated biphenyl-77 (PCB-77) by electrochemical impedance. A good linear relationship in the range of femtomolar to micromolar and significantly low detection limit of sub-femtomolar level (0.32 fM) are realized based on the biosensor. The emphasis of this research lies in the key role of the diamond substrate in the biosensor. It is demonstrated that the biosensor has excellent sensitivity, specificity, stability, and recyclability, which are favorable for detecting the trace PCB-77 molecule. It is attributed to the important effect presented by the BDD substrate and the synergistic influence of T-Au-NPs combined with aptamers.
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) with high toxicity, low lethal dose, and bioaccumulation have been inhibited for application in wide fields, and a highly efficient trace detection is thus greatly desirable. In this study, we produce dense Au-nanoparticles by twice sputtering and twice annealing (T-Au-NPs) on boron-doped diamond (BDD). The successful formation of T-Au-NPs/BDD nanocomposites was confirmed by scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis. Based on T-Au-NPs/BDD, an electronic biosensor with aptamers is fabricated to detect trace polychlorinated biphenyl-77 (PCB-77) by electrochemical impedance. A good linear relationship in the range of femtomolar to micromolar and significantly low detection limit of sub-femtomolar level (0.32 fM) are realized based on the biosensor. The emphasis of this research lies in the key role of the diamond substrate in the biosensor. It is demonstrated that the biosensor has excellent sensitivity, specificity, stability, and recyclability, which are favorable for detecting the trace PCB-77 molecule. It is attributed to the important effect presented by the BDD substrate and the synergistic influence of T-Au-NPs combined with aptamers.
Persistent
organic pollutants would generally lead to genotoxicity
and tumor promotion, which seriously threaten the health of the ecosystem
and humans.[1] Among them, the polychlorinated
biphenyls (PCBs) have high toxicity, low lethal dose, and bioaccumulation,
and they have been inhibited comprehensively.[2] Unfortunately, there are PCBs residues in food, water, and air,[3] and they are highly accumulative and gradually
enriched through the food chain. The Food and Drug Administration
recommends that the amount of PCBs should not exceed 3 μM in
food.[4] They are hydrophobic with low water
solubility, while they have high solubility in most organic oils and
fats. With the enrichment of the food chain, the PCB content in the
organism could be 107–108 times that
of the surrounding environment. Therefore, the release of most pollutants
is an accumulative process, and the lower detection limit is helpful
to detect the trace pollutant for early prevention and/or intervention.
Therefore, it is urgent to achieve the highly sensitive and selective
detection of PCBs. Thus far, several typical techniques, such as gas
chromatography–mass spectrometry,[5] liquid chromatography,[6] and immunoassay-liquid
chromatography,[7] have been developed for
the quantitative detection of PCBs with detection limits of several
picomolars. However, the complex pretreatment programs and expensive
and time-consuming systems make such methods unsuitable for on-site
detection limiting.[8]The electrochemical
method offers a relatively simple, low-cost,
and sensitive implementation process to realize a low detection limit
in a wide dynamic range.[9] The PCBs are
generally monitored by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS)
analysis owing to chemical inertness and insulating properties of
PCBs for electrochemical activity.[10] EIS
is a very sensitive technique to make response information about the
interface,[11] while the detection limit
of carbon nanotube/pyrenecyclodextrin at the μM level[12] could not satisfy the demand of environmental
science. Introducing aptamers into the electrode surface is an effective
strategy to enhance the specificity and sensitivity.[13] Aptamers are single-strand DNA or RNA with high target
affinities, unique conformations, and detailed three-dimensional structures,[14] providing a good alternative approach to sensitively
and selectively identify target molecules by changing their structures
to enhance the detection limit.[15−17] It was reported that the aptamers
added in carbon nanotubes could importantly increase the detection
limit to nM.[18] Also, Au-based biosensors
with aptamers could realize the detection limit to pM[13] since Au electrodes had the advantages of high electrical
conductivity, chemical stability, and easy attachment to aptamers.[19,20] Au-nanoparticles (Au-NPs) with large specific surface area would
provide more adsorption sites for aptamers by forming Au–S
bonds.[21−24] Carbon nanomaterials are key components of transducers in biosensors
due to their intrinsic chemical and mechanical properties.[25] Boron-doped diamond (BDD) is an excellent carbon
material for electrochemical examinations[26] because of its chemical inertness, wide potential window, low background
current, and good electrochemical stability.[27−29]Recently,
many groups investigated the Au-NPs on BDD electrodes
by different ways (electrodeposition,[30] microemulsion technique,[31] sputtering-annealing
treatment). In the microemulsion technique and electrochemical deposition
methods, the agglomeration of Au-NPs often occurs, which will affect
the stability of diamond electrode performance. In addition, the application
of these schemes is not convenient because of expensive raw materials,
environmental unfriendliness, and difficult size control. However,
the technology of sputtering and annealing is simple; the density
and size of nanoparticles are easy to control, and the obtained particles
do not have agglomeration, which has the advantages of simple, fast,
and low cost.Based on above consideration, in this paper, we
fabricate a BDD
electrode coated with Au-NPs by twice sputtering and twice annealing
(T-Au-NPs). The distance between T-Au-NPs reaches the nanometer level
uniformly. Aptamers are demonstrated on the T-Au-NPs/BDD to test the
trace polychlorinated biphenyl-77 (PCB-77) molecule. A detection limit
of as low as 0.32 fM is realized by EIS. It is demonstrated that the
linear detection range of the aptasensor could work on an extensive
examination scale from the femtomolar to micromolar by diluting PCB-77
concentrations several orders of magnitude for the secondary measurements.
The sensitivity, specificity, stability, and recyclability of aptasensors
show a positively significant improvement.
Results
and Discussion
Characterization of the
Au-NPs/BDD Electrode
As seen from the SEM images, Figure a shows the polycrystalline
BDD film without depositing
a Au film, and the diamond film has a flat surface and a prominent
crystal shape with an annealing time of 1 min. Figure b–d shows the Au-NPs/BDD films after
sputtering a gold film of different thickness and same annealing.
The sputtering times of the gold film were (b) 10, (c) 20, and (d)
30 s. The annealing time of the samples in Figure was 1 min (800 °C). As sputtering time
increases, the content of gold atoms increases gradually. Using software
NanoMeasurer1.2, the size of nanoparticles can be obtained and calculated.
The average sizes of Au-NPs in Figure b–d are about 15.7, 22.6, and 28.3 nm. After
sputtering and annealing, the mean densities are 4.8 × 1010, 7.6 × 1010, and 3.52 × 1010 Au-NPs/cm2, respectively. It can be seen from Figure that the size and
density of Au-NPs are related to the sputtering time. A longer sputtering
time increases the average particle size of Au-NPs. When the temperature
decreases, the gold particles solidify and form Au-NPs with a certain
size distribution on the surface of BDD. This process makes the thick
gold film sputtered more likely to form larger particles and lower
density of particles. The rate of the Au-NP area is 0.30:1.00:0.73
with sputtering times of 10, 20, and 30 s, respectively. Thus, a longer
sputtering time with a thicker gold film does not increase the surface
area of the Au-NPs. The surface area of Au-NPs formed by an appropriate
sputtering time (20 s) is the largest.
Figure 1
SEM images of (a) polycrystalline
BDD and (b–d) Au-NPs/BDD.
The gold deposit on polycrystalline BDD substrate with sputtering
times of the Au film of (b) 10, (c) 20, and (d) 30 s and annealing
treatment at 800 °C for 1 min. Panels (e), (f), and (g) are bar
graphs of Au-NP size distribution of panels (b), (c), and (d), respectively.
SEM images of (a) polycrystalline
BDD and (b–d) Au-NPs/BDD.
The gold deposit on polycrystalline BDD substrate with sputtering
times of the Au film of (b) 10, (c) 20, and (d) 30 s and annealing
treatment at 800 °C for 1 min. Panels (e), (f), and (g) are bar
graphs of Au-NP size distribution of panels (b), (c), and (d), respectively.
Characterization of Aptamers/Au-NPs/BDD
(AA/BDD)
Electrodes
Nyquist plots of BDD, Au-NPs/BDD, and AA/BDD with
a sputtering time of 20 s are presented in Figure a. The charge transfer resistance of the
BDD electrode is 387 Ω. After Au-NP deposition, the charge transfer
resistance of the Au-NPs/BDD electrode drops to 189 Ω, which
would facilitate electron transfer denoting the improving conductivity.
After modification of aptamers on the Au-NPs/BDD electrode, the impedance
increases to 1715 Ω, which is attributed to the electrostatic
repulsion between the negatively charged aptamers and the Fe(CN)63–/4– redox probe, making it difficult
for Fe(CN)63–/4– to reach the
surface of AA/BDD.[32] These results agree
well with cyclic voltammetry (CV) spectra (Figure S1). For the AA/BDD electrodes with sputtering times of 10,
20, and 30 s immersed in solution with 1.0 × 10–11 M PCB-77, the impedance enhanced compared to those without PCB-77
(Figure b). The rate
of the electrode impedance change with sputtering times of 10, 20,
and 30 s before and after incubation with a concentration of PCB-77
is 0.43:1:0.74, which is incongruous with that of Au-NP area. The
electrodes might improve the sensitivity of electrochemical detection
of target molecules by enhancing the detection area.[33] It suggests that the AA/BDD electrode with a sputtering
time of 20 s has the highest sensitivity of detecting PCB-77 for the
largest relative impedance shift because the sensor obtained with
a sputtering time of 20 s has more surface area of Au-NPs to modify
more aptamers.
Figure 2
(a) Impedance spectra (Nyquist plots) of BDD, Au-NPs/BDD,
and AA/BDD
electrodes based on a sputtering time of 20 s tested in solution containing
5 mmol L–1 Fe(CN)63–/4– and 0.1 mol L–1 KCl. (b) Bar graph of impedance
change of the electrodes based on different sputtering times before
and after incubation with a concentration of 10–11 mol L–1 PCB-77.
(a) Impedance spectra (Nyquist plots) of BDD, Au-NPs/BDD,
and AA/BDD
electrodes based on a sputtering time of 20 s tested in solution containing
5 mmol L–1 Fe(CN)63–/4– and 0.1 mol L–1 KCl. (b) Bar graph of impedance
change of the electrodes based on different sputtering times before
and after incubation with a concentration of 10–11 mol L–1 PCB-77.
Characterization of T-Au-NPs/BDD
In order
to further increase the surface area of Au-NPs, we propose
an approach to get Au-NPs/BDD by a twice sputtering and twice annealing
process. The BDD film was coated with a thin Au layer by sputtering
the Au target for 10 s, and following a heat treatment at 800 °C
in air for 30 s, the Au-NPs appeared on BDD film. Sputtering on the
former Au-NPs/BDD and an annealing process under the same conditions
were performed to produce a second Au nanolayer. Evidently, the T-Au-NPs
have a higher Au-NP density of ∼2.5 × 1011/cm2 on BDD (Figure a). According to the elemental mapping using an energy-dispersive
spectrometer (EDS), the BDD surface is uniformly covered by T-Au-NPs
(Figure b). However,
the average size of the T-Au-NPs decreased to ∼12.8 nm (Figure c). More uniformly
distributed nanoparticles are obtained by this method, and the agglomeration
of Au-NPs hardly occurs.[34] Compared to
the Au-NPs/BDD by single sputtering and annealing with the same total
sputtering time (20 s) and total annealing time (1 min), the area
of T-Au-NPs increased slightly by 5.5%, which had more sites for the
absorption of aptamers. From the XRD results of T-Au-NPs/BDD in Figure d, the BDD film consists
of micrometer grains with the typical (111), (110), and (311) surfaces,
and Au-NPs are mainly (311) grains. The BDD film characterized by
Raman spectroscopy (Figure e) shows a typical Fano effect related asymmetrical and downshift
feature of a diamond peak at 1330 cm–1.[35] The XPS survey scan of the T-Au-NPs/BDD (Figure f) shows that the
T-Au-NPs are elementary substances offering sites for aptamers. The
O1s peak comes from the oxygen termination of the annealed BDD surface
in air.
Figure 3
SEM image of T-Au-NPs/BDD after two-step treatment of sputtering
and annealing with total sputtering time (20 s) and total annealing
time (1 min). The inset image is obtained at high magnification. (b)
EDS mapping of the Au element. (c) Bar graph of particle size distribution
in panel (a). (d) XRD and (e) Raman spectrum of T-Au-NPs/BDD. (f)
XPS survey scan of the T-Au-NPs/BDD.
SEM image of T-Au-NPs/BDD after two-step treatment of sputtering
and annealing with total sputtering time (20 s) and total annealing
time (1 min). The inset image is obtained at high magnification. (b)
EDS mapping of the Au element. (c) Bar graph of particle size distribution
in panel (a). (d) XRD and (e) Raman spectrum of T-Au-NPs/BDD. (f)
XPS survey scan of the T-Au-NPs/BDD.
Importance of BDD
For the AA/BDD
electrodes based on sputtering times of 10, 20, and 30 s (Figure b) and Aptamers/T-Au-NPs/BDD
(ATA/BDD) electrode, a relative impedance shift in solution with 1.0
× 10–11 M PCB-77 could effectively enhance
by 22, 52, 36, and 88% compared to those without PCB-77, respectively.
The ATA/BDD biosensor has excellent sensitivity. Meanwhile, the excellent
sensitivity on ATA/BDD could not be caused entirely by a slightly
increased area of T-Au-NPs providing more sites for aptamers. The
high sensitivity of the ATA/BDD sensor might be due to the key factor
(BDD substrate). We hypothesize that a conformational change in the
aptamer upon specific binding of PCB-77 may alter the channel of Fe(CN)63–/4– reaching the surface of BDD.
Before capturing PCB-77, Fe(CN)63–/4– could reach the surface of ATA/BDD freely with stretching aptamers.
After capturing PCB-77, the aptamers present a compact tetrahedral
structure to block Fe(CN)63–/4– from contacting the Au surface. When the distance of the T-Au-NPs
is close to the size of the compact tetrahedral aptamer, the channel
of Fe(CN)63–/4– reaching the surface
of BDD is closed. The BDD substrate has good stability and high resistance
to fouling, which can reduce the adsorption of nonspecific substances
in the detection process. Thus, the ATA/BDD sensor shows excellent
sensitivity because the impedance increases sharply because the channel
to the Au-NPs and the channel to the BDD could be blocked. By comparison,
the AA/BDD sensor is not sensitive enough because only the channel
to the Au-NPs could be blocked and the partial channel to the BDD
could not be blocked when the distance between the Au-NPs is much
larger than the compact aptamer structure (Figure S2).
Strong Affinity between
Aptamers and PCB-77
The strong affinity between aptamers
and PCB-77 is important to
realize high sensitivity and improve the detection limit, which is
confirmed by UV spectral measurement. As shown in Figure a, PCB-77 causes a significant
increasing effect of the adsorption band for the PCB-77 aptamer centered
at 262 nm with increasing PCB-77 concentration in aptamer solution. Figure b reveals the linear
relationship based on the equation (lg[A/Aterminate – A] = n lg[PCB-77] + lg Ka), where A and Aterminate are the intensities of the spectra after adding x mol L–1 PCB-77 and excess PCB-77 into
2 μmol L–1 aptamer solution, n is the comprehensive coordination number, [PCB-77] is the concentration
of PCB-77, and Ka is the corresponding
association constant. The fitted n and Ka are 1.145 and 3.47 × 106 M–1, respectively. Such a large value of Ka reflects a high affinity of PCB-77 on aptamers.
Figure 4
(a) UV spectra of different
proportions of aptamer with PCB-77.
The concentration of aptamer solution is 2 μmol L–1. (b) Linear fitting to calculate the corresponding association constant
(Ka) reflecting the affinity of PCB-77
on aptamers.
(a) UV spectra of different
proportions of aptamer with PCB-77.
The concentration of aptamer solution is 2 μmol L–1. (b) Linear fitting to calculate the corresponding association constant
(Ka) reflecting the affinity of PCB-77
on aptamers.
ATA/BDD
for the Sub-Femtomolar Detection Limit
of PCB-77
The impedance spectra of PCB-77 with different
concentrations are shown in Figure a, and the inset presents the corresponding equivalent
circuit. Evidently, the impedance increases with the increase of concentration
of PCB-77. All impedance spectra are fitted with detailed fitting
data (Table S1). The peak current in CV
curves tested in Fe(CN)63–/4– solution
nonlinearly decreases with the increase of PCB-77 concentration ranging
from 1.0 × 10–15 to 1.0 × 10–11 M (Figure S3), corresponding to the EIS
spectra in Figure a. As plotted in Figure b, the relative impedance linearly increases with PCB-77 concentration
in the region of 1.0 × 10–15 to 1.0 ×
10–11 M. Determined by equation ΔRct = R0 + A lg C, where C is the PCB-77 concentration,
the fitting data include 242.17 Ω for R0, 14.35 for A, and a correlation coefficient
(R2) of 0.993. The detection limit of
the AA/BDD electrode reaches a sub-fetomolar magnitude of 0.32 fM,
which is calculated based on the response of three times the standard
deviation of blank samples on the aptasensor.[36] Further, the achieved detection limit is 3 orders superior to most
of the previous reports as shown in Table .[5,13,18,37−39] Noted elsewhere,[40] a single Au nanoneedle (400 nm in diameter)
modulated by β-cyclodextrin was proposed as the electrode to
realize a detection limit of 0.21 fM, while its linear detection was
in a narrow range of 2–16 fM. Comparatively, the ATA/BDD sensor
offers a rigid and recyclable diamond-based electrode with a wide
linearity range and low background noise signals, implying that the
electrode in this work is more favorable for practical applications.
Figure 5
(a) Impedance
spectra (Nyquist plots) of the ATA/BDD sensor incubated
with varying concentrations of PCB-77. The inset of panel (a) is the
equivalent circuit of text. (b) The calibration plot of the relative
impedance shift as a function of PCB-77 concentration.
Table 1
Relevant Published Various Methods
of PCB Detection
(a) Impedance
spectra (Nyquist plots) of the ATA/BDD sensor incubated
with varying concentrations of PCB-77. The inset of panel (a) is the
equivalent circuit of text. (b) The calibration plot of the relative
impedance shift as a function of PCB-77 concentration.In this work, the ATA/BDD aptasensor presents high-performance
electrochemical properties, which is attributed to the following factors.
(i) The BDD substrate has a wide potential window, good stability,
and high resistance to fouling, which can reduce the adsorption of
nonspecific substances in the detection process.[41] The sensor is sensitive enough because not only the channel
to the Au-NPs could be blocked but also the channel to the BDD could
be blocked. The BDD is the optimal material as a substrate for detecting
PCB-77 with limitation as low as 10–16 M. (ii) T-Au-NPs
can promote electron transfer and increase the superficial area to
have more sites for the absorption of aptamers. Appropriate density
of T-Au-NPs is helpful for compact tetrahedral aptamers to block the
channel to BDD. (iii) The high affinity and specificity of aptamers
for PCB-77 further realize high sensitivity and improve the detection
limit.[42] The superior stability and sensitivity
of the ATA/BDD electrode are due to the synergistic action of the
above factors.
Specificity and Stability
of the ATA/BDD Aptasensor
The high-performance specificity
is the most unique characteristic
of the ATA/BDD aptasensor, which is examined in the 50-fold solutions
containing PCB-28, PCB-52, PCB-81, PCB-126, lindane, coronene, pyrene,
and hexachlorobenzene, in which 1.0 × 10–13 M PCB-77 is added (Figure S4). The selected
additional persistent organic pollutants have similar structures or
functional groups to PCB-77. The impedance for pure PCB-77 is set
as 100%, and the relative impedance fluctuation of each mixture ranges
between −2.9 and 5.8%. Moreover, the relative impedance shift
of a series of PCBs is also examined, such as PCB-28, PCB-52, PCB-81,
and PCB-126 probes. Evidently, in contrast to the result of PCB-77,
all these PCB samples have nonspecificity to the aptasensors at the
varying concentrations (Figure S5), implying
the excellent specificity of the ATA/BDD sensor. The aptasensor is
also tested for 10 days under the same test conditions, as shown in Figure S6. For 10–13 M PCB-77,
the daily change in the relative response is in the region of −2.4–4.5%
compared to the first day with 100%, which reveals the stability of
the ATA/BDD aptasensor within 10 days.
Linear
Detection Range (LDR)
For
expanding the LDR beyond the region of 10–15 to
10–11 M, the following strategy is adopted. When
the concentration of PCB-77 is higher than 10–11 M (e.g., 10–10–10–6 M),
the impedance signals of the tested PCB-77 solutions approach the
calibrated data of 10–11 M (Figure S7a). These samples with the higher PCB-77 concentrations
are then diluted by one or several orders of magnitude for the secondary
measurements, showing a linear relationship of relative impedance
shift and PCB-77 concentrations (Figure S7b). The real concentrations of the undiluted samples are then calculated
from the secondarily measured PCB-77 concentration by multiplying
the dilution factor when the PCB-77 concentrations are in the region
of 10–15–10–11 M. The PCB-77
with a higher concentration thus can be accurately detected. It is
demonstrated that the LDR of ATA/BDD aptasensors could work on an
extensive examination scale from the femtomolar to micromolar region.
Detecting PCB-77 Trace in Real Samples by
the ATA/BDD Aptasensor
It is of great significance to investigate
the performance of the aptasensor in practical applications. The aptasensor
is applied to water samples collected from a natural water source
with and without addition of PCB-77. Trace amounts of PCB-77 are added
to the water, and the recoveries of the sensor are in the range of
96–106% with relative standard deviations less than 5.3% (Table ). These results further
confirm the high sensitivity, accuracy, and wide range of the aptasenor,
which has great potential in trace detection of PCBs with low concentration.
Table 2
Recoveries of PCB-77 with Varying
Concentrations Added in Lake Water Samples
lake water
added PCB-77
(M)
detected
(M)
recovery
(%)
RSD (%)
1
0
undetectable
2
1 × 10–15
0.98 × 10–15
98%
3.4
3
1 × 10–13
0.96 × 10–13
96%
3.8
4
1 × 10–11
1.05 × 10–11
105%
4.7
5
1 × 10–9
1.01 × 10–9
101%
4.2
6
1 × 10–7
1.06 × 10–7
106%
5.3
Recyclability of the Aptasensors
The recyclability of the sensing electrode is another important
advantage
of aptasensors.[43] The electrochemical desorption
method is adopted to break the gold–thiol bond and remove all
aptamers from the T-Au-NPs/BDD surface after each detection. The EIS
and CV tests of T-Au-NPs/BDD and regenerated T-Au-NPs/BDD after desorption
(Figure ) prove that
all components are detached from the surface of T-Au-NPs/BDD. Compared
with T-Au-NPs/BDD, the regenerated T-Au-NPs/BDD has the same impedance
spectrum and peak current. For PCB-77 detection, the recyclable aptasensor
by modifying aptamers still retains 95% of its original response,
confirming the recyclability of the sensor without significant loss
of response.
Figure 6
(a) CV and (b) EIS of T-Au-NPs/BDD and the regenerated
T-Au-NPs/BDD
in 5 mmol L–1 Fe(CN)63–/4– solution containing 0.1 mol L–1 KCl (scan rate:
50 mV s–1).
(a) CV and (b) EIS of T-Au-NPs/BDD and the regenerated
T-Au-NPs/BDD
in 5 mmol L–1 Fe(CN)63–/4– solution containing 0.1 mol L–1 KCl (scan rate:
50 mV s–1).
Conclusions
In this study, we design and
fabricate an aptasensor based on BDD
films coated with dense T-Au-NPs and aptamers by forming Au–S
bonds for detecting organic pollutants. The sensor exhibits good linearity
from the femtomolar to micromolar and a low detection limit of sub-fetomolar
magnitude (0.32 fM) for the PCB-77 molecule, which is superior to
other sensors, suggesting the successful realizing of trace detection
of PCB-77. Moreover, the high selectivity, specificity, stability,
and recyclability of the aptasensor are found. The high performance
is attributed to the synergistic effect of BDD films, T-Au-NPs, and
aptamers as follows: the BDD substrate exhibits low background signals;
the dense T-Au-NPs evidently increase the absorption sites for aptamers
and the channel to the BDD could be blocked when the distance between
the T-Au-NPs is close to the compact aptamer structure; the high affinity
of PCB-77 on aptamers could realize high sensitivity and improve the
detection limit. This work is helpful to construct a diamond-based
sensor to detect various trace substances with low concentrations
in wide fields.
Methods
Preparation
of Au-NPs/BDD and T-Au-NPs/BDD
Electrodes
The polycrystalline BDD films were fabricated
on a p-type Si substrate by microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition
(CVD) at 2.45 GHz.[44] The surface of the
Si substrate was cleaned and seeded with nanodiamond powders for the
following CVD diamond film growth.[35] During
the CVD deposition process, the doping of boron was carried out under
hydrogen flow (2.5 sccm) with trimethylborate, and the flow rate of
the reaction gases was H2:CH4 = 150:2 (sccm).
After deposition for 12 h, the thickness of BDD films was 15 μm.
In the formation process of the Au-NPs/BDD structure, the BDD film
was coated with a thin Au layer by sputtering the Au target for 10,
20, 30, and 40 s. Following a heat treatment at 800 °C in air
for 1 min, an annealing process of the Au film occurred, and the Au-NPs
appeared on the BDD film. The BDD film was coated with a thin Au layer
by sputtering the Au target for 10 s, and following a heat treatment
at 800 °C in air for 30 s, the Au-NPs appeared on the BDD film.
Sputtering on the former Au-NPs/BDD and an annealing process under
the same conditions were performed to produce a second Au nanolayer.
Evidently, the T-Au-NPs have a higher Au-NP density on BDD.
Preparation of ATA/BDD
The 38-mer
single-strand DNA aptamers for PCB-77 were synthesized by Sangon Biotech,
China. The structure of the thiol-terminated aptamer probes (obtained
by SELEX)[42] was5′-SH-(CH2)6-AAGCGCGCGAGACTACGTTTGTAGGGATACCGATGTCG-3′.
Aptamers were grafted on the T-Au-NPs/BDD by forming Au–S bonds
and subsequently incubated at 37 °C for 5 h. The obtained ATA/BDD
was washed and cleaned with Tris-HCl buffer and ultrapure water to
remove the unhybridized aptamers. The PCB-77 aptasensor showed the
specific adsorption of PCB-77 for detection. The design and manufacturing
processes of the PCB-77 aptasensor is schematically illustrated in Scheme . The preparation
of the AA/BDD scheme is presented in Figure S2. The sensors were then stored in a refrigerator at 4 °C.
Scheme 1
Schematic Illustration of the Fabrication Procedure for PCB-77 Aptasensors
Electrochemical Measurements
and Detection
of PCB-77
PCB-77 was from the Laboratory of the Government
Chemist Labor Gesellschaft mit beschränkter Haftung. PCB-77
probes with varying concentrations were dissolved in a binding buffer
(100 mM Tris-HCl at pH = 8.0 with 200 mM NaCl, 25 mM KCl, 10 mM MgCl2). The DNA aptamer was dissolved in ultrapure water without
any enzymes. The electrochemical experiments were carried out in an
electrochemical cell containing 5 mM Fe(CN)63–/Fe(CN)64– and 0.1 M KCl as the electrolyte.
The amplitude of the sinusoidal interference voltage was 5 mV. In
the detection of PCB-77, the aptasensor was immersed in binding buffer
with different standard concentrations of PCB-77 for 15 min and then
washed with binding buffer to remove unbound PCB-77. The EIS tests
were performed in the electrolyte solution in a frequency region of
10–1–105 Hz. The relative impedance
shift ΔRct is defined as ΔRct = (Rct – Rct0)/Rct0, where Rct0 is the initial impedance without PCB-77
and Rct is the impedance of the ATA/BDD
aptasensor after treatment with certain concentrations of PCB-77.
Determination of PCB-77 in Real Samples
The PCB-77 solution was diluted with anhydrous methanol into a
stock solution (10 μM). The ATA/BDD aptasensors were applied
to examine trace amounts of PCB-77 in water, which was a natural water
source. The examined samples were filtered through a membrane followed
by the addition of Tris-HCl buffer solution. Then, the obtained liquid
sample was spiked with certain amounts of PCB-77 standard solution,
and the natural sample without added PCB-77 was used as the control
group. Trace PCB-77 was detected by the ATA/BDD aptasensor.
Characterization and Electrochemical Measurements
The
morphologies, structures, and vibrational characters of the
electrodes were characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM,
JSM-6480LV), X-ray diffraction (XRD, Rigaku D/MAX-RA), and Raman spectroscopy
(Renishaw in Via Raman microscope equipped with 514 nm laser excitation),
respectively. The affinity between aptamers and PCB-77 was confirmed
by ultraviolet spectroscopy measurement (UV, UV–vis 1700).
All electrochemical measurements were performed with an electrochemical
workstation (CHI 760E). The aptasensor was based on the BDD electrode,
platinum foil, and saturated calomel electrode as the working electrode,
counter electrode, and reference electrode, respectively.
Authors: Laura A Hutton; James G Iacobini; Eleni Bitziou; Robert B Channon; Mark E Newton; Julie V Macpherson Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2013-07-15 Impact factor: 6.986