Literature DB >> 32793779

Dataset supporting the use of nematodes as bioindicators of polluted sediments.

Janina Schenk1, Sebastian Höss1,2, Marvin Brinke3, Nils Kleinbölting4, Henrike Brüchner-Hüttemann1, Walter Traunspurger1.   

Abstract

We provide the dataset supporting the research article "Nematodes as bioindicators of polluted sediments using metabarcoding and microscopic taxonomy" [1]. Nematodes are frequently used as bioindicators and the NemaSPEAR[%] is an validated index that is originally based on morphological data. The index was compared to molecular sequence data for the 28S rDNA, 18S rDNA and COI gene for 7 locations. This dataset includes chemical analyses of the sediments for 33 different substances. The sequence data for OTU-based analyses for the 28S rDNA, 18S rDNA and COI gene is given, together with the read distribution during bioinformatics processing. We furthermore include alternative ASV data, based on a cluster-independent approach. The morphological data is presented, including the biomass for each species, as well as an overview about whether the species is represented in the NCBI database. Furthermore, rarefaction analysis is given for the morphological data, and furthermore NMDS plots for the species and genus level based on morphological and molecular data. The correlation between the mean PEC-Q and the NemaSPEAR[%] values is given in order to compare the efficiency of the index, based on morphological and molecular data.
© 2020 The Authors.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Bioindicator; Nemaspear[%]; Nematodes; Polluted sediments

Year:  2020        PMID: 32793779      PMCID: PMC7412863          DOI: 10.1016/j.dib.2020.106087

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Data Brief        ISSN: 2352-3409


Specifications table

Value of the data

This dataset supports a pilot study evaluating suitability of molecular-based data for bioindication purposes with nematodes. This dataset provides benefit for molecular-based studies with biomonitoring aims, especially in the field of meiofauna, which is often difficult to identify morphologically. This data can be used to further verify this approach, e.g. with the use of bulk samples instead of isolated nematode communities. This dataset will give further insight into nematode-based bioindication using the NemaSPEAR[%] index.

Data description

This dataset contains the chemical analyses for the seven locations for 33 substances traceable in the sediment samples (Table 1). The number of analysed nematodes for each sample and replicate is given, together with the information if samples were combined due to low specimen numbers (Table 2). For the molecular approach, using Operational Taxonomic Units (OTU) clustering, the list of the final OTU inventory is given for three genetic markers (Tables 4, 5, 6), together with the read distribution during the bioinformatic pipeline using mothur (Table 7). Amplicon Sequence Variants (ASVs) for an alternative cluster-independent approach are given for the three genetic markers in Table 3. For the COI gene, OTUs and ASVs phylogenetic tress show the relationship between the sequence variants, as the majority of OTUs and ASVs in the analyses was classified as “unknown” (Fig. 4 and 5). The morphological approach includes a list of all species found by microscopic analysis, including the biomass, based on measured specimens from this study, for each species (separated for female and male) and the information whether a reference sequence can be found at National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) (Table 8). A rarefaction analysis based the morphological data provides insights into the (extrapolated) number of species in order to compensate that different numbers of individuals were analysed for the locations, due to samples with rare individual numbers (Fig. 1). For each of the Nematode Species at Risk (NemaSPEAR) a NCBI inspection was performed to validate if reference sequences are available for the genus and the species level (Table 9). For molecular-based and morphology-based data, NMDS plots were calculated comparing the nematodes communities for each replicate at the species and genus level (Fig. 2). The NemaSPEAR[%] values for morphological and molecular data were plotted against mean probable-effect-concentration quotients (mean PEC-Q), in order to give insights about the coherences between the indices and the toxic potential of the sediment (Fig. 3).
Table 1

Chemical analysis of sediment samples. Given is the measured value for each of the 33 substances for each of the seven locations investigated; PEC = consensus-based probable effect concentrations as defined by De Deckere et al. [2] as “Consensus 2; dw = dry weight; values with

SubstanceUnitPECRM1LU1CUM1HI1VE1ÖR1FB1
Asmg/kg dw50146425341<0.5<2.5
Pbmg/kg dw11848333124107<2.5<2.51.6
Cdmg/kg dw7.80.5453.14.9<0.05<0.05<0.1
Crmg/kg dw6877117412497242.8
Cumg/kg dw60485719710113<0.5
Nimg/kg dw32523085360131.5
Hgmg/kg dw1.20.462.753.431.67<0.025<0.0250.05
Znmg/kg dw8001693507772950<5<56
Naphthalenemg/kg dw6.60.26.60.0880.22<0.005<0.005<0.005
Acenaphthylenemg/kg dw5.20.0350.550.0130.031<0.005<0.005<0.005
Acenaphthenemg/kg dw3.30.02520.020.047<0.005<0.005<0.005
Fluorenemg/kg dw0.260.0532.60.0250.066<0.005<0.005<0.005
Phenanthrenemg/kg dw0.890.414.40.180.40.0120.010.015
Anthracenemg/kg dw0.170.131.70.0480.12<0.005<0.005<0.005
Fluoranthenemg/kg dw1.20.813.90.310.750.0260.0180.022
Pyrenemg/kg dw0.940.614.50.260.610.0150.010.012
Benzo(a)anthracenemg/kg dw0.60.30.710.140.320.01<0.0050.011
Chrysenemg/kg dw0.830.270.440.180.35<0.005<0.0050.01
Benz(b)fluoranthenemg/kg dw0.660.230.470.180.32<0.005<0.005<0.005
Benzo(k)fluoranthenemg/kg dw0.320.0830.170.0760.13<0.005<0.0050.005
Benzo(a)pyrenemg/kg dw0.60.210.250.110.26<0.005<0.0050.011
Dibenz(a,h)anthracenemg/kg dw0.120.0220.0440.020.044<0.005<0.005<0.005
Indeno(1,2,3-cd)pyrenemg/kg dw0.480.130.070.10.2<0.005<0.005<0.005
Benzo(ghi)perylenemg/kg dw0.450.170.230.130.25<0.005<0.005<0.005
PCB 28µg/kg dw20.13261.22.9<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 52µg/kg dw4.60.24711.42.7<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 101µg/kg dw6.70.41883.14.4<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 118µg/kg dw6.90.241101.82.7<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 138µg/kg dw7.50.511009.711<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 153µg/kg dw9.70.58781013<0.025<0.025<0.005
PCB 180µg/kg dw5.50.17287.911<0.025<0.025<0.005
p,p'-DDDµg/kg dw3.20.92101144<0.025<0.025<0.005
p,p'-DDEµg/kg dw6.80.91875.113<0.025<0.025<0.005

Abbreviation for locations: Rischmühle (RM), Luppe (LU), Cumlosen (CUM), Hitzacker (HI), Veerse (VE), Örtze (ÖR) and Furlbach (FB).

Table 2

Overview about the number of nematodes for each replicate for the seven locations and the morphological and molecular approach. A black box indicates that these replicates were combined into a new replicate due to low individual number. For the location VE more than five replicates were available for morphological analysis, no further samples were available for molecular analysis, though.

ReplicateFBVEÖRRMCUMHILU
Morph.
I872695989910299
II1009810198100102100
III98910110411010092
IV10071102999699100
V100101009998101100
VI99
VII100
VIII73
IX33
SUM485516499498503504491
Mol.
I5008020020020020050
II2620020020020050
III1510020020020050
IV910020020040
V20060
SUM5001305007008001000250
Table 4

List of OTUs determined for the 28S rDNA gene fragment, using the primer pairs 1274/706 for the seven locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM, VE and FB). Clustering was performed at 99%.

OTU 1274/706CUMHILUÖRRMVEFB
Acrobeloides sexlineatus5.392.470.000.160.060.000.00
Anaplectus granulosus0.370.620.000.000.010.0010.22
Aphanolaimus aquaticus0.000.000.000.000.000.000.04
Aphelenchus spec0.140.170.000.000.010.000.00
Aporcelaimellus obtusicaudatus32.2342.800.070.822.290.000.00
Basiria sp. SAN-20050.040.000.000.000.000.000.00
Boleodorus sp. 2 TJP-20120.030.000.000.000.000.000.00
Bursilla sp. PS11790.151.050.000.010.050.000.00
Cephaloboides cf. armata SB3630.000.000.000.000.310.000.00
Cephalobus cubaensis1.410.800.000.030.010.000.00
Chromadorita leuckarti0.000.200.450.1630.980.086.92
Coslenchus costatus12.631.030.000.540.090.000.00
Diplogastrellus sp. NK-20100.000.875.500.003.680.000.00
Dorylaimus stagnalis0.000.060.000.160.500.000.00
Epitobrilus medius0.020.020.000.010.000.000.00
Ethmolaimus pratensis0.220.200.001.170.000.277.11
Eucephalobus cf oxyuroides37.5326.200.001.130.990.000.00
Eucephalobus striatus0.451.660.020.010.040.000.00
Eudorylaimus sp. 2 KH-20180.260.000.000.000.000.000.00
Eumonhystera filiformis0.000.160.800.000.260.250.00
Ironus longicaudatus0.000.000.000.000.000.000.12
Ironus tenuicaudatus0.000.000.000.060.000.000.00
Meloidogyne arenaria0.030.000.000.000.000.000.00
Mesocriconema curvatum0.020.830.440.000.060.000.00
Mesodorylaimus bastiani0.130.620.000.000.000.000.00
Monhystera paludicola0.000.000.000.080.360.050.04
Monhystera spec0.000.000.000.040.000.000.00
Mononchoides sp. 1 VS-20140.050.000.000.000.000.000.00
Mononchus aquaticus1.330.580.000.000.020.000.00
Mononchus truncatus0.020.100.000.050.550.480.00
Neotobrilus longus0.630.020.000.520.011.7129.59
Panagrolaimus detritophagus0.000.050.000.000.000.000.00
Panagrolaimus sp. PS11590.000.020.000.000.000.000.00
Panagrolaimus0.030.000.000.000.000.000.00
Paractinolaimus sp.0.070.010.000.010.000.000.00
Paratylenchus microdorus0.000.030.000.000.000.000.00
Pellioditis sp. VS-20140.000.040.000.000.000.000.00
Plectus aquatilis0.020.000.000.000.000.002.75
Plectus exinocaudatus0.090.050.220.000.050.080.16
Plectus opisthocirculus0.000.050.000.000.000.000.08
Plectus velox0.010.100.000.000.010.000.00
Pratylenchoides ritteri0.020.070.000.000.000.000.00
Pratylenchoides sp. 1 MP-20131.6015.800.000.040.400.000.00
Pratylenchus convallariae0.060.000.000.000.000.000.00
Prionchulus punctatus0.010.040.000.000.000.000.00
Prismatolaimus dolichurus0.340.270.000.010.010.000.08
Prismatolaimus intermedius0.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
Prodesmodora circulata0.000.000.000.000.001.110.00
Protolitonotus magnus0.000.000.000.010.000.000.00
Rhabditidoides sp. NK-20100.000.000.000.000.020.000.00
Rhabditis sp. DF50590.040.020.010.000.000.000.00
Rhabditoines regina0.000.000.000.000.000.000.08
Rotylenchus robustus0.810.090.000.020.000.000.00
Semitobrilus pellucidus0.190.032.2889.370.9888.460.00
Theristus agilis0.000.050.004.771.076.8638.35
Tobrilus cf. helveticus KR-20130.040.000.000.000.000.000.00
Tobrilus gracilis1.591.8990.210.7256.580.510.00
Tobrilus sp. BI-LSU-3180.000.000.000.000.000.040.00
Trichodorus arasbaranensis0.170.000.000.000.000.110.00
Tripyla glomerans0.000.140.000.040.570.000.00
Tripyla setifera0.000.070.000.030.000.004.48
unknown_10.030.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_100.070.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_110.020.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_120.030.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_130.140.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_20.000.040.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_30.020.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_40.080.100.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_50.070.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_60.050.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_70.000.040.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_80.020.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_90.050.000.000.000.000.000.00
Zeldia punctata1.190.520.000.030.020.000.00
Table 5

List of OTUs determined for the 18S rDNA gene fragment, using the primer pairs 3NDf/C_1132f for the six locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM and VE). Clustering was performed at 99%.

OTU_3NDf/C_1132fCUMHILUÖRRMVE
Cephalobus sp./Acrobeloides nanus46.6424.140.005.191.850.00
Amplimerlinius macrurus0.500.460.000.000.000.00
Anaplectus sp. PDL-20050.050.230.000.000.000.00
Aphelenchoides bicaudatus0.000.000.000.000.150.00
Aphelenchoides sp. Asp67530.000.070.000.000.000.00
Aphelenchoides sp. BE10.000.000.000.000.000.00
Aphelenchus sp. JH-20040.720.480.000.000.000.00
Aporcelaimellus sp. AMS-20130.290.000.000.000.000.00
Basiria duplexa10.720.490.000.410.060.00
Boleodorus thylactus0.070.000.000.000.000.00
Cephaloboides cf. armata SB3630.000.000.000.0011.430.00
Cephalobus persegnis0.002.720.000.000.080.00
Chromadorina bioculata0.000.000.000.000.710.00
Coslenchus turkeyensis0.050.310.000.000.000.00
Daptonema hirsutum0.000.000.000.001.130.00
Daptonema sp. 12550.000.120.000.007.850.00
Diphterophora communis7.090.000.000.420.000.00
Diplogaster rivalis0.145.3526.110.0113.910.00
Ditylenchus sp. 10 JH-20141.202.220.000.100.070.00
Ditylenchus sp. 6 JH-20140.000.140.000.000.000.00
Ditylenchus sp. 8 JH-20140.000.110.000.000.000.00
Ethmolaimus pratensis0.000.000.000.130.000.00
Eumonhystera sp. 1 JH-20140.000.000.008.530.007.60
Filenchus vulgaris0.500.000.000.000.000.00
Geocenamus quadrifer0.006.700.000.000.270.00
Hemileius microclava0.000.000.000.000.030.00
Heterocephalobus elongatus1.030.860.080.020.000.00
Ironus sp.0.000.000.000.000.020.00
Merlinius brevidens0.971.150.000.000.030.00
Merlinius joctus0.000.440.000.000.000.00
Mesorhabditis sp. FL-Type-101.074.240.000.000.880.00
Monhystera cf. paludicola JH-20140.000.000.000.500.160.00
Monhystera sp. 1 JH-20140.000.000.000.001.840.00
Mononchus aquaticus_100c0.000.000.0112.550.0117.73
Neotobrilus longus0.000.000.002.200.002.33
Neotobrilus longus2.271.008.883.061.483.70
Oscheius tipulae0.634.430.000.001.270.00
Panagrolaimus cf. rigidus AF400.000.910.000.000.000.00
Panagrolaimus sp. AS010.000.500.000.000.000.00
Paratylenchus dianthus0.000.150.000.000.000.00
Phasmarhabditis sp. SA20.630.000.000.000.000.00
Phasmarhabditis sp. SA41.120.620.000.000.250.00
Plectus opisthocirculus0.000.070.000.000.000.00
Plectus sp. 3 JS-20160.000.060.000.000.030.00
Prismatolaimus cf. dolichurus JH-20040.410.000.000.020.000.00
Prismatolaimus dolichurus0.140.730.000.000.010.00
Pristionchus lheritieri0.980.000.000.130.000.00
Punctodora ratzeburgensis0.000.000.000.005.280.00
Rhabditis sp. DF505912.4023.221.621.052.360.00
Rhabditis sp. RA58.1414.500.000.002.130.00
Rhynchoscolex simplex0.000.000.000.310.000.00
Semitobrilus pellucidus0.000.000.000.000.001.67
Semitobrilus pellucidus /Tobrilidae sp. 1 JH-20140.140.000.0063.540.0062.82
Tobrilus cf. zakopanensis 1 JH-20140.000.000.160.000.030.00
Tobrilus gracilis/Tobrilus sp. 1 JH-20140.342.3862.801.4945.390.00
Trichodorus similis1.090.000.000.000.000.00
Tridentulus sp. PDL-20050.000.010.340.000.004.15
Tripyla glomerans0.000.490.000.060.800.00
Tripyla sp. JH-20040.000.170.000.000.000.00
unknown_130.000.000.000.000.510.00
unknown_160.000.170.000.000.000.00
unknown_170.000.090.000.000.000.00
unknown_190.310.010.000.000.000.00
unknown_210.000.000.000.270.000.00
unknown_220.120.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_40.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_60.000.270.000.000.000.00
unknown_90.210.000.000.000.000.00
Table 6

List of OTUs determined for the COI gene, using the primer pairs mlCOIint/dgHCO for the six locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM, and VE). Clustering was performed at 97%.

COI_OTUCUMHILUÖRRMVE
Acanthocyclops vernalis0.000.000.000.010.010.00
Amphichaeta raptisae0.020.000.000.490.000.00
Arthropoda environmental sample0.000.000.000.060.000.00
Asellus aquaticus0.062.290.000.000.000.00
Blastomussa loyae0.000.000.000.000.006.77
Bos taurus0.6411.200.120.080.180.59
Candona candida0.000.000.000.000.010.00
Chironomus melanescens0.000.000.000.200.000.00
Chironomus pallidivittatus0.000.000.110.010.010.00
Chydoridae sp. SHDT1508040.000.000.000.010.000.00
Coccinella trifasciata perplexa0.005.800.000.000.560.00
Corynoneura kadalinka0.000.000.000.000.350.00
Cricotopus sylvestris0.050.000.000.020.010.00
Endochironomus albipennis0.000.000.000.000.010.00
Eucyclops cf. serrulatus ZISP 11SNM-5470.000.000.000.000.030.00
Eucyclops cf. serrulatus ZISP 11SNM-5490.000.000.000.070.020.00
Fejervarya granosa0.001.300.000.000.200.00
Homo sapiens0.150.000.000.000.000.00
Limnodrilus claparedianus0.000.000.000.810.580.00
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri complex lineage IX0.000.000.000.180.000.00
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri complex lineage X0.000.000.000.000.200.00
Naididae sp. JCOCH052–100.000.000.000.870.000.00
Nais communis0.000.000.000.020.000.00
Nais sp. N12 RV-20170.000.010.000.000.040.00
Ophidonais serpentina0.000.000.000.000.040.00
Parasitidae sp. BOLD:AAF92330.000.000.000.030.000.00
Penicillium sclerotiorum0.013.330.000.020.020.00
Polypedilum albinodus0.000.000.000.010.000.00
Polypedilum pullum0.221.440.850.061.2420.46
Potamothrix heuscheri0.000.000.000.010.010.00
Potamothrix moldaviensis0.000.000.000.130.000.00
Prodiamesa olivacea0.010.000.000.150.000.00
Propappus volki0.000.000.000.000.050.00
Pseudo-nitzschia subfraudulenta0.000.000.000.000.000.40
Tanytarsus pallidicornis0.000.000.000.040.000.00
Tubifex tubifex0.000.003.391.630.370.00
Tubificinae sp. 1 RV-20160.000.000.000.140.000.00
Tubificinae sp. T2_3360.000.000.000.010.000.00
uncultured fungus0.150.000.000.010.000.00
unknown_100.000.000.0028.460.000.00
unknown_1020.004.910.000.000.090.00
unknown_1040.000.001.060.000.000.00
unknown_1050.000.000.000.020.010.00
unknown_1070.620.000.000.020.000.00
unknown_1090.000.000.000.320.000.00
unknown_110.000.000.000.001.370.00
unknown_1100.000.000.000.000.290.12
unknown_1120.000.000.001.180.000.00
unknown_1130.000.000.000.000.140.00
unknown_1140.000.000.030.000.000.00
unknown_1150.110.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_1160.580.590.000.000.100.00
unknown_1170.000.000.000.000.011.73
unknown_1180.000.190.000.000.000.00
unknown_121.180.000.000.050.000.00
unknown_1200.000.000.000.000.020.00
unknown_1210.000.000.000.0010.680.00
unknown_1220.010.000.000.020.000.03
unknown_1230.000.004.550.000.000.00
unknown_1240.050.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_1250.000.030.000.000.000.00
unknown_1270.010.000.000.030.000.00
unknown_1280.000.000.000.020.000.00
unknown_1290.010.000.010.000.000.00
unknown_132.760.000.000.060.000.00
unknown_1310.000.000.000.000.191.11
unknown_1320.000.010.080.000.350.00
unknown_1330.000.000.240.000.110.00
unknown_13414.740.000.910.740.000.00
unknown_150.020.000.0052.830.0867.54
unknown_160.000.000.000.000.030.03
unknown_170.000.000.000.010.000.00
unknown_180.000.620.000.000.020.00
unknown_20.000.000.000.000.170.00
unknown_210.000.070.000.000.000.00
unknown_220.000.000.000.000.200.00
unknown_230.000.000.000.040.010.09
unknown_240.130.010.000.000.010.00
unknown_250.000.000.000.020.030.00
unknown_260.000.000.030.000.000.00
unknown_272.430.000.000.040.000.00
unknown_2836.220.310.000.310.040.00
unknown_310.110.000.000.220.000.00
unknown_301.250.960.000.060.010.00
unknown_310.000.000.000.150.000.00
unknown_320.130.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_340.000.110.000.000.020.00
unknown_350.000.000.000.000.011.08
unknown_360.000.000.020.000.000.00
unknown_371.040.000.000.080.000.00
unknown_380.000.390.000.000.010.00
unknown_390.000.000.100.000.000.00
unknown_410.110.000.000.240.000.00
unknown_410.000.390.000.000.010.00
unknown_430.001.100.000.000.020.00
unknown_440.430.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_450.301.640.000.000.000.00
unknown_460.000.000.020.000.000.00
unknown_470.280.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_480.150.0020.890.000.000.00
unknown_490.000.000.000.240.000.00
unknown_500.023.974.670.005.680.00
unknown_510.000.000.000.080.000.00
unknown_520.000.000.000.000.020.00
unknown_530.000.430.000.000.020.00
unknown_550.000.0016.830.000.010.03
unknown_560.000.000.000.000.010.00
unknown_570.000.050.000.000.000.00
unknown_592.635.540.000.110.720.00
unknown_63.853.250.000.130.000.00
unknown_600.000.000.000.000.480.00
unknown_610.001.180.000.000.030.00
unknown_620.0011.550.000.000.260.00
unknown_630.000.000.100.000.000.00
unknown_640.005.570.000.000.090.00
unknown_660.000.930.000.000.030.00
unknown_680.320.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_700.001.290.000.000.020.00
unknown_710.820.010.000.000.000.00
unknown_720.000.0116.300.000.010.00
unknown_754.020.000.000.130.000.00
unknown_760.000.110.000.000.000.00
unknown_770.070.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_790.240.000.000.010.000.00
unknown_80.000.000.000.000.010.00
unknown_810.000.000.000.020.000.00
unknown_830.000.000.000.070.000.00
unknown_840.000.000.008.280.000.00
unknown_850.020.370.000.000.000.00
unknown_860.120.0021.310.7525.030.00
unknown_870.000.000.000.000.000.00
unknown_890.120.000.000.0021.520.00
unknown_90.000.028.290.000.640.00
unknown_900.000.000.000.000.740.00
unknown_910.000.170.000.001.210.00
unknown_920.000.000.000.000.130.00
unknown_940.000.000.070.000.000.00
unknown_950.080.060.000.000.000.00
unknown_960.560.000.000.010.000.00
unknown_970.000.060.000.000.100.00
unknown_980.0325.790.010.0125.000.00
unknown_993.162.960.000.120.290.00
Table 7

Distribution of reads within the bioinformatic pipeline using mothur. Given is the number of reads at each current step of the analysis for each sample sequenced for the three genetic markers (1274/706 = 28S rDNA, mlCOIint/dgHCOCOI, 3NDf/C_1132f = 18S rDNA).

1274/706totalCum1-NCum4-NCum8-NCum9-NHi1-NHi2-NHi3-NHi4-NHi5-N
Reads939,93233,29740,54241,78339,66720,26020,46832,32243,42440,865
After Merging664,45623,15727,57429,27925,75511,77413,93223,26730,75527,636
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers664,45623,15727,57429,27925,75511,77413,93223,26730,75527,636
After filtering of not fitting reads598,18421,41426,35327,43517,70211,07610,80017,78224,45225,978
After uchime505,35315,84920,22620,71213,7098860676812,01519,51721,399
After removal of rares461,69013,59518,17718,24911,5968073549110,22317,47419,660
1274/706LU1-NLU2-NOE1-NOE10-NOE2-NRM10-NRM2-NRM3-NRM4-NVE1-N
Reads83,96560,94567,11760,60083,51167,83653,47039,09240,64970,119
After Merging60,26243,29446,39544,28963,03947,96537,98328,17228,20351,725
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers60,26243,29446,39544,28963,03947,96537,98328,17228,20351,725
After filtering of not fitting reads59,01542,88145,94143,80362,74544,75828,14113,68323,06751,158
After uchime52,30937,93842,38137,41857,89239,01625,006945717,14147,740
After removal of rares48,05335,76640,19533,87554,53736,02523,152787015,09544,584
mlCOIintF/dgHCOtotalCum1-NCum4-NCum8-NCum9-NHi1-NHi2-NHi3-NHi4-NHi5-N
Reads219,69347326793417419,136267513,08711,21042703889
After Merging156,48127212879137413,759785548719920331397
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers156,48127212879137413,759785548719920331397
After filtering of not fitting reads156,48127212879137413,759785548719920331397
After uchime155,93027142879136913,749785542719220331397
After removal of rares155,47326912829135013,706735522717820121369
mlCOIintF/dgHCOLU1-NLU2-NOE1-NOE10-NOE2-NRM10-NRM2-NRM3-NRM4-NVE1-N
Reads41,914613316,7559593825211,62930,348815611,0885859
After Merging38,149402413,83071005804917225,265489979933257
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers38,149402413,83071005804917225,265489979933257
After filtering of not fitting reads38,149402413,83071005804917225,265489979933257
After uchime37,690401013,82770945804915825,262489979763257
After removal of rares37,657400713,80170745766913125,233488179583235
3NDf/C_1132ftotalCum1_NCum4_NCum8_NCum9_NHi1_NHi2_NHi3_NHi4_NHi5_N
Reads526,51922,60725,26824,39433,17922,06722,67323,61223,51924,289
After Merging112,014566642856265435658796479726361423330
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers112,014566642856265435658796479726361423330
After filtering of not fitting reads110,098558742146196422457996372718760663269
After uchime105,997531239995818396956535957673758893058
After removal of rares56,835290619133233195531773185396032361403
3NDf/C_1132fLU1_NLU2_NOE10_NOE1_NOE2_NRM10_NRM2_NRM3_NRM4_NVE1_N
Reads39,34529,81631,39925,15036,83031,74529,05125,81631,38324,376
After Merging9663876468093420690282432453340886664021
After filtering of long or short reads/homopolymers9663876468093420690282432453340886664021
After filtering of not fitting reads9525868066693351673181422383326685543883
After uchime9397857564633285659579842216308481823824
After removal of rares529754192903156432264446888125048981976
Table 3

Results of the cluster-independent bioinformatic approach. Amplicon Sequence Variants (ASVs) are given for the three genetic markers (COI = mlCOIint/dgHCO, 28S rDNA = 1274/706, and 18S rDNA= 3NDf/C_1132f). Numbers are given for all samples and replicates combined, as this is only an alternate approach, which was not regarded further.

ASV (mlCOIint/dgHCO)overallASV (1274/706)overallASV (3NDf/C_1132f)overall
unknown_419,900Nematoda environmental sample67,051Diplogaster rivalis2717
unknown_513,129Aporcelaimellus obtusicaudatus25,065Homalozoon vermiculare553
unknown_611,719Tobrilus gracilis;Tobrilus sp. BI-LSU-31223,119Oscheius tipulae399
unknown_710,593Eucephalobus oxyuroides19,260Mesorhabditis belari290
unknown_98837Tobrilus gracilis15,565invertebrate environmental sample274
unknown_126880Tobrilus pellucidus11,906Semitobrilus pellucidus75
unknown_25113unknown_1770656c24
unknown_183899Merlinius sp. MerlSp15177unknown_924
unknown_193809unknown_24139Punctodora ratzeburgensis21
unknown_223355Rhabditis sp. DF50592857unknown_1121
unknown_212992Rhynchoscolex simplex2798Bacillidium sp.19
unknown_232929unknown_32733unknown_1219
unknown_202851Acrobeloides tricornis2548unknown_316
unknown_242802unknown_41931Microsporidium sp. BPAR716
unknown_252693Mononchus truncatus1052Aphelenchoides bicaudatus14
Polypedilum pullum2657unknown_5969unknown_1413
unknown_262636uncultured Paractinolaimus sp.895Daptonema sp. 125512
unknown_112325Amplimerlinius paraglobigerus813uncultured fungus11
unknown_272022unknown_6735Mesorhabditis sp. WB-200910
unknown_281787Ethmolaimus pratensis648Tobrilus cf. zakopanensis 1 JH-20149
unknown_291729unknown_7615unknown_199
unknown_321654Mononchus aquaticus610Frontonia leucas7
Coccinella trifasciata perplexa1648Cephalobus cubaensis596Oscheius sp. AW-20116
unknown_331585Mesodorylaimus bastiani578unknown_136
unknown_351447Zeldia punctata512unknown_266
unknown_371315Eumonhystera filiformis418Chromadorina bioculata6
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri1145unknown_8412unknown_275
unknown_381131unknown_9405unknown_293
unknown_391017unknown_10398Rhabditis sp. DF50593
unknown_401004Eucephalobus striatus337Basiria duplexa3
unknown_42941Monhystera paludicola;Monhystera stagnalis267uncultured eukaryote2
Tubifex tubifex927unknown_11262Acrobeloides_nanus-7–3NDf2
Limnodrilus claparedianus867Homalozoon vermiculare259Ironus sp. 199_89c2
unknown_45821Tripyla glomerans249Aporcelaimellus sp. SSU_32
unknown_46801unknown_12224
unknown_47769Anaplectus granulosus220
unknown_48687Pratylenchus convallariae204
unknown_49681unknown_13197
unknown_50666unknown_14184
unknown_51619Monhystera paludicola/Monhystera sp.178
Nais communis594Prodesmodora circulata166
unknown_53585unknown_15166
Phasmarhabditis papillosa582uncultured Tobrilus164
unknown_54496Oscheius tipulae163
unknown_55486Mesorhabditis sp. 'Bursilla' PS1179155
unknown_56483unknown_16148
unknown_43482unknown_17142
unknown_57464unknown_18121
Fejervarya granosa418unknown_19118
unknown_60410unknown_20117
unknown_61379unknown_21117
unknown_62376unknown_22116
unknown_63360unknown_23109
unknown_65325unknown_24107
unknown_66312unknown_25104
unknown_67300unknown_26104
unknown_70265Aphelenchus sp. OH-2016102
unknown_69261unknown_27100
Bos taurus247unknown_28100
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri complex lineage VIII227unknown_2989
Meloidogyne naasi223unknown_3082
unknown_72223Cephaloboides cf. armata SB36381
unknown_73220Dorylaimus stagnalis80
unknown_76209unknown_3179
unknown_71204unknown_3279
Blastomussa loyae203unknown_3375
Naididae sp. JCOCH052–10201unknown_3475
unknown_78188unknown_3571
unknown_79186unknown_3671
unknown_80186Boleodorus sp. 2 TJP-201264
unknown_81185unknown_3760
unknown_86156unknown_3854
unknown_88152Rhabditis brassicae53
Gammarus pulex145unknown_3952
unknown_89140unknown_4051
unknown_90139unknown_4150
unknown_92128unknown_4250
unknown_93128unknown_4349
unknown_84127unknown_4449
unknown_94127unknown_4546
unknown_95123unknown_4643
unknown_97115unknown_4743
unknown_98106unknown_4842
unknown_99106unknown_4939
unknown_100105Plectus exinocaudatus38
Amphichaeta raptisae104unknown_5038
Rhabditida sp. 3028ed103unknown_5137
unknown_101102Trichodorus similis36
unknown_103101unknown_5236
unknown_104101unknown_5334
Tubificinae sp. 1 RV-2016100unknown_5434
unknown_105100unknown_5533
Enochrus ater88unknown_5628
unknown_10688Coslenchus costatus27
unknown_10787Plectus velox26
unknown_10986unknown_5725
Rhabditida sp. 3003ed84Chiloplectus andrassyi22
unknown_11184Plectus opisthocirculus21
unknown_11284unknown_5820
unknown_11381unknown_5919
unknown_11481Trichodorus arasbaranensis18
unknown_11580unknown_6018
unknown_11680unknown_6118
unknown_11779unknown_6218
unknown_11976unknown_6317
unknown_12074unknown_6417
unknown_12273unknown_6517
unknown_12466Trischistoma sp. 2 ZQZ-2010a16
unknown_12665unknown_6616
unknown_12765unknown_6716
unknown_12865unknown_6816
Corynoneura carriana64unknown_6916
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri complex lineage X64Plectus aquatilis/Plectus acuminatus15
unknown_12964unknown_7015
unknown_13061unknown_7115
unknown_11859unknown_7215
unknown_13258unknown_7315
unknown_13358Pellioditis sp. VS-201414
unknown_13556unknown_7414
unknown_13755unknown_7514
unknown_13853unknown_7614
unknown_13652unknown_7714
unknown_1551unknown_7813
unknown_14048unknown_7913
unknown_14148Acrobeloides sp. ES-201712
unknown_14248Meloidogyne graminicola12
Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri complex lineage IX47unknown_8012
unknown_14347unknown_8112
unknown_14446unknown_8212
unknown_13945unknown_8312
unknown_14545unknown_8412
Chironomus melanescens42unknown_8511
unknown_12539unknown_8611
unknown_14939unknown_8711
unknown_15038unknown_8811
unknown_15138unknown_8911
unknown_15238Prismatolaimus dolichurus10
unknown_14837unknown_9010
Cricotopus sylvestris36unknown_9110
unknown_1736unknown_9210
unknown_15335unknown_9310
unknown_15434unknown_9410
unknown_15534unknown_9510
unknown_15634unknown_9610
unknown_15833unknown_9710
unknown_15932unknown_9810
unknown_16031unknown_9910
unknown_3631unknown_1009
unknown_16130unknown_1019
unknown_16229unknown_1029
unknown_16329unknown_1039
unknown_16429unknown_1049
unknown_16528unknown_1058
unknown_16628unknown_1068
unknown_16728unknown_1078
unknown_16828unknown_1088
Prodiamesa olivacea27unknown_1098
unknown_16927Frontonia sp. 4 WS-20147
unknown_17127unknown_1107
Propappus volki25unknown_1117
unknown_17225unknown_1127
unknown_3425unknown_1137
unknown_17324unknown_1147
unknown_17524unknown_1156
unknown_17624unknown_1166
unknown_17824unknown_1176
unknown_18023unknown_1186
unknown_5823unknown_1196
unknown_18422unknown_1206
unknown_3122unknown_1216
unknown_18921unknown_1226
unknown_17020unknown_1236
unknown_19020unknown_1246
unknown_19120unknown_1256
unknown_19220unknown_1266
unknown_19320unknown_1276
unknown_19420unknown_1286
unknown_19520Arabidopsis thaliana5
unknown_19719uncultured Asellus sp.5
Potamothrix moldaviensis18unknown_1295
unknown_19818unknown_1305
unknown_19918unknown_1315
unknown_20018unknown_1325
unknown_20118unknown_1335
Tanytarsus pallidicornis17unknown_1345
unknown_20217unknown_1355
unknown_20317unknown_1364
unknown_20417unknown_1374
unknown_20517unknown_1384
uncultured fungus16unknown_1394
unknown_20616unknown_1404
unknown_20716unknown_1414
unknown_20916unknown_1424
unknown_21016Daubaylia potomaca3
Arthropoda environmental sample15Tobrilus medius3
Ophidonais serpentina15unknown_1433
unknown_21215unknown_1443
unknown_21315unknown_1453
unknown_21415unknown_1463
unknown_21515unknown_1473
Asellus aquaticus14unknown_1483
Penicillium sclerotiorum14Bos indicus x Bos taurus2
unknown_21614Mesocriconema xenoplax2
unknown_21714unknown_1492
unknown_21814unknown_1502
unknown_21914unknown_1512
unknown_22013unknown_1522
unknown_22313unknown_1532
unknown_22413unknown_1542
unknown_22513unknown_1552
unknown_22613unknown_1562
Homo sapiens12unknown_1572
unknown_22712unknown_1582
unknown_22912unknown_1592
unknown_23012unknown_1602
Nais sp. N12 RV-201711unknown_1612
unknown_23111unknown_1622
unknown_23211unknown_1632
unknown_23411
unknown_23511
unknown_23811
unknown_18210
unknown_23910
unknown_24010
Parasitidae sp. BOLD:AAF92339
unknown_1579
unknown_2219
unknown_2419
unknown_2429
unknown_2449
unknown_2459
unknown_2479
unknown_449
Eucyclops cf. serrulatus ZISP 11SNM-5498
unknown_2498
unknown_2508
Chironomus pallidivittatus7
Micospina auribohnorum7
unknown_1817
unknown_2087
unknown_2517
unknown_2527
unknown_2547
unknown_2557
unknown_2587
Acanthocyclops vernalis6
Anomala ruficapilla6
Paragordius tricuspidatus6
unknown_2606
unknown_2616
unknown_2626
unknown_2636
unknown_2646
unknown_2666
Potamothrix heuscheri5
unknown_1965
unknown_2715
unknown_2725
unknown_2735
unknown_2745
unknown_2755
unknown_2765
unknown_2775
unknown_2785
unknown_2795
unknown_2805
unknown_35
Eucyclops cf. serrulatus ZISP 11SNM-5474
unknown_2814
unknown_2824
unknown_2844
unknown_2854
unknown_2864
unknown_2874
unknown_2914
unknown_2924
unknown_2934
unknown_2944
unknown_2954
unknown_684
Chydoridae sp. SHDT1508043
Habrotrocha constricta3
unknown_2963
unknown_2973
unknown_2983
unknown_2993
unknown_3003
unknown_3013
unknown_3023
unknown_3033
unknown_3043
unknown_3053
unknown_3063
unknown_3073
unknown_3083
unknown_3093
unknown_3103
unknown_3113
unknown_3123
unknown_3143
unknown_12
unknown_3152
unknown_3162
unknown_3182
unknown_3192
unknown_3202
unknown_3212
unknown_3222
Fig. 4

Maximum likelihood tree based on the OTU inventory for the COI gene. The numbers at the branches represent the support values for the nodes.

Fig. 5

Maximum likelihood tree based on the ASV inventory for the COI gene. The numbers at the branches represent the support values for the nodes.

Table 8

Inspection of NCBI reference database for the Nematode SPEcies At Risk (NemaSPEAR[%]) as defined by Höss et al. [3] at the species and at the genus level. An” x” indicates whether the species or genera is found at NCBI for the 18S rDNA or 28 rDNA gene, while an “n” indicates that no reference sequence was found. The number of deposited sequences is given, the numbers in parentheses indicate reference sequences that were generated in our lab but are not yet published.

NemaSPEAR18Sn28SnNemaSPEAR genus18Sn28Sn
Achromadora ruricolax1nAchromadorax17n
Achromadora terricolax1nAglenchusx30x6
Aglenchus agricolax25x2Alaimusx18x3
Alaimus meylinnAmphidelusx1n
Alaimus parvusx2nAphanolaimusx3x5
Alaimus primitivusnnAphelenchusx>50x>50
Amphidelus cf elegansnnAporcelaimellusx>50x38
Aphanolaimus aquaticusx3x3Bastianiax4n
Aporcelaimellus obtusicaudatusx24x17Cephalenchusx>50x>50
Coslenchus costatusx6x3Coslenchusx30x20
Cuticularia oxycercannCrassolabiumnx3
Cylindrolaimus communisx1nCriconeman51x15
Epidorylaimus agilisnnCylindrolaimusx6x12
Epitobrilus mediusx1x17Diplogasteritusx6x12
Epitobrilus steinerinnEpidorylaimusx9x3
Ethmolaimus pratensisx3x7(+7)Ethmolaimusx3x7
Eucephalobus oxyuroidesx12x5Eudorylaimusx>50x18
Eudorylaimus acuticaudannFictorx13x25
Eudorylaimus carterix5x4Hemicycliophorax30x>50
Eumonhystera andrassynnHirschmanniellax28x32
Eumonhystera barbatannHofmaenneriann
Eumonhystera longicaudatulax1nIronusx15x7
Eumonhystera simplexx1nMonhystrellax2n
Eumonhystera vulgarisx1nParamphidelusx4n
Helicotylenchus pseudorobustusx61x38Paraphanolaimusx4n
Hemicycliophora typicax4x2Paraplectonemax1x2
Hirschmaniella gracilisnnPlectusx>50x>50
Hofmaenneria brachystomannPratylenchusx>50x>50
Ironus ignavusnnPrismatolaimusx>50x8
Ironus longicaudatusx2x2Prodesmodorax7x3
Ironus tenuicaudatusnx3Prodorylaimusx6x4
Mesodoryaimus conurusnnPunctodorax5n
Mesodoryaimus subtiliformisnnRhabditisx>50x>50
Monhystera lemaninnRhabdolaimusx>50n
Monhystrella paramacrurannSemitobrilusx4x1
Mononchus truncatusx5x3Theristusx33 (+>50)x3 (+>50)
Neotobrilus longusx3x16Thorniax1n
Panagrolaimus cf thienemanninnTrischistomax19x8
Paramphidelus dolichurusnn
Paraphanolaimus anisitsinn
Paraplectonema pedunculatumx1n
Plectus aquatilisx7x5
Plectus cirratusx1x2
Plectus opisthocirculusx1x1
Plectus rhizophilusx2x
Prismatolaimus dolichurusx3x7
Prismatolaimus intermediusx3n
Prismatolaimus tenuicaudatusnn
Prodesmodora circulatax4x3
Punctodora dudichinn
Punctodora ratzeburgensisx5n
Rhabditis gracilicaudann
Rhabdolaimus terrestrisx1n
Semitobrilus pellucidusx2x16
Theristus agilisx3(x)(>150)
Theristus vesentiniaenn
Thornia propinquann
Trischistoma monhysterann
Fig. 1

Rarefaction analyses based on morphological data for the 7 locations (CUM, HI, ÖR, VE, FB and RM). Given is the species diversity that was observed, as well as extrapolated estimates for up to 1000 individuals inspected (dashed lines).

Table 9

Species inventory for the seven locations (VE, ÖR, RM, HI, LU, CUM, FB). Given are the species identified by morphological inspection, together with the biomass for a male (m biomass) and female (fm biomass) based on measured specimen in the dataset. It is indicated if a NCBI sequence for the 28S rDNA or 18S rDNA gene is found, an “n” showing that this species is missing.

SpeciesNCBIfm biomassm biomassVEÖRRMHILUCUMFB
Achromadora cf. terricola18S0.930.000.600.000.000.000.591.24
Achromadora longicaudan0.050.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Achromadora ruricola18S0.190.144.270.000.000.001.020.000.00
Achromadora sp.18S0.130.000.000.000.990.200.000.00
Achromadora micoletzkyn0.170.0811.060.000.604.960.4114.310.00
Aglenchus sp.18S,28S0.110.100.000.000.400.000.000.000.00
Alaimus parvus18S0.130.000.000.000.000.000.400.00
Alaimus primitivusn0.340.120.590.000.000.400.000.790.00
Amphidelus dudichin1.340.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Amphidelus elegansn0.450.190.000.000.000.000.400.00
Anaplectus grandepapillatus18S2.341.720.000.000.000.000.000.0018.56
Anaplectus granulosus28S0.920.690.000.000.002.380.001.000.00
Aphanolaimus aquaticus18S,28S0.820.430.000.000.800.000.000.000.00
Aphelenchoides bicaudatus18S0.070.060.190.000.000.200.000.000.00
Aphelenchoides parietinus28S0.230.200.000.000.000.990.000.790.00
Aphelenchus cf. avenae18S,28S0.210.250.000.000.000.200.000.400.21
Aporcelaimellus obtusicaudatus18S,28S9.990.970.000.003.370.002.980.00
Bastiania gracilis18S0.140.110.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Bitylenchus dubius18S0.290.140.000.000.209.910.003.180.00
Bursilla monhysteran0.630.130.000.000.200.400.001.200.00
Cephalenchus hexalineatus18S,28S0.120.100.000.000.000.200.000.000.00
Cephalobus persegnis18S,28S0.430.230.190.000.6020.220.6111.520.00
Chromadorina bioculata18S,28S0.270.220.000.002.010.200.610.000.00
Chromadorita leuckarti18S,28S1.480.802.140.400.000.202.030.0010.10
Chromadorina viridis28S0.790.540.000.001.810.000.000.000.00
Chrysonema holsaticumn1.900.550.000.000.000.000.000.200.00
Clarkus papillatus18S,28S1.461.950.000.000.000.400.000.000.00
Coslenchus costatus18S,28S0.110.070.000.000.002.180.611.590.00
Crassolabium ettersbergensisn0.300.000.000.000.000.000.590.00
Crocodoylaimus flavomaculatusn1.271.230.000.000.000.000.000.400.00
Cryptonchus tristis18S1.571.710.380.000.000.000.000.000.00
Cylindrolaimus melancholicusn1.360.990.000.000.000.000.000.000.82
Daptonema dubiumn5.062.200.000.0021.903.370.000.000.00
Diplogaster rivalis18S,28S1.920.650.000.000.000.401.020.000.00
Ditylenchus sp.18S,28S0.920.460.000.000.000.990.000.000.00
Dorylaimidae sp.18S,28S3.412.500.000.000.200.000.200.000.00
Dorylaimoides limnophilus18S,28S1.220.000.000.200.200.000.000.00
Dorylaimus stagnalis18S,28S47.6442.070.000.000.000.400.610.400.00
Epidorylaimus agilisn2.350.380.000.200.000.000.000.21
Epitobrilus stefanskii18S3.272.510.190.400.200.001.630.000.00
Ethmolaimus pratensis18S,28S0.680.440.199.020.000.000.000.001.03
Eucephalobus oxyuroides18S,28S0.260.140.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
Eudorylaimus acuticaudan3.942.690.000.000.000.990.000.790.00
Eudorylaimus carteri18S,28S4.653.270.000.000.000.000.000.000.21
Eudorylaimus centrocercus28S3.711.720.000.000.000.000.000.400.00
Eumonhystera barbatan0.120.190.000.200.000.000.000.21
Eumonhystera disparn0.431.160.200.200.401.220.000.82
Eumonhystera filiformis18S,28S0.270.225.436.016.226.7426.880.400.00
Eumonhystera longicaudatula18S0.221.9417.433.410.990.000.001.86
Eumonhystera pseudobulbosan0.041.750.801.410.592.030.400.21
Eumonhystera simplex18S0.032.710.001.001.190.003.380.00
Eumonhystera vulgaris18S0.196.4119.240.000.591.420.002.27
Eumonhystera sp.18S0.1418.620.000.000.000.000.000.00
Euteratocephalus palustris18S0.240.000.000.000.200.000.200.00
Eutobrilus grandepapillatusn10.805.890.000.000.000.200.000.000.00
Fictor fictorn1.580.590.190.000.000.200.000.000.00
Filenchus sp.18S,28S0.090.000.000.000.000.000.000.21
Filenchus vulgaris18S,28S0.100.095.430.004.628.330.6116.690.00
Helicotylenchus pseudorobustus18S,28S0.350.380.000.000.200.001.000.00
Hemicycliophora typica18S,28S0.524.270.000.000.400.410.200.00
Heterocephalobus elongatus18S0.410.320.000.000.000.590.000.200.00
Hirschmaniella gracilisn1.361.020.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Hofmaenneria niddensisn0.580.410.000.000.000.000.000.001.65
Ironus longicaudatus18S,28S1.000.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Laimaphelenchus penardi18S0.160.130.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Malenchus bryophilus18S,28S0.060.030.000.000.000.400.410.200.00
Mermithidae0.190.000.400.000.000.000.41
Mesodorylaimus bastiani18S,28S1.451.040.190.000.000.000.001.790.00
Mesodorylaimus paetzoldin2.810.000.000.000.000.200.000.00
Mesodorylaimus sp.18S,28S1.940.000.200.000.000.200.000.00
Monhystera paludicola18S,28S0.860.565.042.001.810.002.440.000.41
Monhystera stagnalis18S,28S1.240.680.000.000.800.000.200.000.21
Monhystera sp.18S,28S0.430.000.003.010.000.000.000.00
Monhystrella macruran0.160.080.000.000.200.000.000.000.00
Monhystrella paramacruran0.040.060.000.005.820.200.200.790.00
Mononchus aquaticus18S,28S4.214.330.190.400.000.200.200.000.00
Mononchus truncatus18S,28S4.943.210.000.000.200.400.000.000.00
Mylonchulus brachyuris18S1.381.060.190.000.001.190.000.000.00
Mylonchulus sigmaturus18S1.861.070.000.000.001.780.000.200.00
Neotobrilus diversipapillatusn5.331.540.000.000.000.200.000.000.00
Panagrolaimus rigidus18S,28S1.070.540.590.000.002.570.411.590.00
Paractinolaimus macrolaimus18S,28S10.827.870.000.000.000.000.410.000.00
Paraplectonema pedunculatum18S0.680.000.000.000.200.000.000.00
Pellioditis pellioidesn7.973.110.380.000.000.000.000.000.00
Plectus aquatilis18S,28S1.300.190.000.000.000.200.200.00
Plectus opisthocirculus18S,28S0.130.590.200.800.992.240.000.00
Plectus parvus18S,28S0.170.590.200.000.000.201.000.00
Plectus rhizophilus18S0.760.000.000.000.000.810.000.00
Plectus tenuis18S0.640.000.000.000.000.610.000.00
Pratylenchus sp.18S,28S0.090.000.000.000.400.000.000.00
Prismatolaimus dolichurus18S,28S0.470.330.000.000.000.200.000.400.00
Prismatolaimus intermedius18S0.100.141.550.200.806.150.009.340.21
Prismatolaimus sp.18S0.370.000.000.000.590.000.000.00
Prodesmodora arctican0.070.590.000.000.000.000.000.00
Prodesmodora circulata18S,28S0.330.380.000.000.200.000.200.00
Prodorylaimus fliiariumn2.312.120.380.000.000.000.000.000.00
Prodorylaimus sp.18S,28S3.520.000.200.000.001.020.000.00
Punctodora ratzeburgensis18S0.530.340.000.0019.290.200.000.000.00
Rhabditidae18S,28S1.000.970.000.000.000.001.390.00
Rhabditidae sp.18S0.420.000.000.001.980.610.200.00
Rhabditis gracilicaudan0.510.660.190.000.000.200.000.200.00
Rhabdolaimus aquaticus18S0.080.000.000.200.000.000.000.00
Rhabdolaimus terrestris18S0.112.330.000.000.000.000.000.00
Semitobrilus pellucidus18S,28S4.865.0810.4741.890.200.000.000.009.07
Species 10.510.420.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Species 2 (Cephalobidae)0.460.370.000.000.000.000.000.590.00
Teratocephalus tenuisn0.100.050.000.000.000.200.000.200.00
Teratocephalus terrestris18S0.080.190.000.000.200.001.200.00
Theristus agilis18S1.190.680.190.000.000.200.000.0037.31
Theristus vesentiniaen0.210.150.000.000.000.000.000.793.30
Tobrilus gracilis18S,28S6.324.190.380.2019.090.0047.040.000.00
Trichodorus sparsus18S,28S0.940.601.360.000.000.000.000.000.00
Tripyla glomerans18S,28S17.7912.800.000.000.600.200.610.000.00
Tripyla setifera28S1.611.430.380.200.000.000.000.009.48
Trischistoma monohysteran1.190.740.970.000.000.200.000.400.00
Tylenchidae18S,28S0.430.330.000.000.000.000.000.590.00
Tylencholaimellus affinis18S1.801.330.190.000.000.000.000.000.00
Tylencholaimus teres18S0.480.440.190.000.000.000.002.580.00
Tylenchus davanein0.690.540.000.200.406.350.419.930.00
Tylenchus sp. 118S,28S0.690.510.190.000.000.000.000.200.00
Tylenchus sp. 20.260.380.000.000.400.000.000.00
Tylenchus sp. 30.190.000.000.000.000.001.390.00
Wilsonema otophorum18S,28S0.060.030.000.000.000.000.000.200.00
Fig. 2

-nMDS plots based on not-transformed relative abundances of species (a, b, c) and genera (d, e, f) found in sediments sampled from the seven locations based on taxonomic data for the 28S marker (a, d), the 18S marker (b, e) and the morphological analysis (c, f); Bray-Curtis similarity was applied; each location is encoded by a different color and symbol.

Fig. 3

NemaSPEAR[%] (a, c, e) and NemaSPEAR[%]genus (b, d, f) calculated based on morphological (morph; a, b) and molecular (28S-rDNA: c, d, 18S-rDNA: e, f) taxonomic nematode species and genus data of river sediment sampled at 7 sites (6 sites for 18S-rDNA) plotted against the mean PEC-Q values calculated for the respective sediments; a: r2 = 0.71; p = 0.017; b: r2 = 0.66; p = 0.027; c: r2 = 0.65; p = 0.029; d: r2 = 0.78; p = 0.008; e: r2 = 0.60; p = 0.070; f: r2 = 0.88; p = 0.006.

Chemical analysis of sediment samples. Given is the measured value for each of the 33 substances for each of the seven locations investigated; PEC = consensus-based probable effect concentrations as defined by De Deckere et al. [2] as “Consensus 2; dw = dry weight; values with Abbreviation for locations: Rischmühle (RM), Luppe (LU), Cumlosen (CUM), Hitzacker (HI), Veerse (VE), Örtze (ÖR) and Furlbach (FB). Overview about the number of nematodes for each replicate for the seven locations and the morphological and molecular approach. A black box indicates that these replicates were combined into a new replicate due to low individual number. For the location VE more than five replicates were available for morphological analysis, no further samples were available for molecular analysis, though. List of OTUs determined for the 28S rDNA gene fragment, using the primer pairs 1274/706 for the seven locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM, VE and FB). Clustering was performed at 99%. List of OTUs determined for the 18S rDNA gene fragment, using the primer pairs 3NDf/C_1132f for the six locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM and VE). Clustering was performed at 99%. List of OTUs determined for the COI gene, using the primer pairs mlCOIint/dgHCO for the six locations (CUM, HI, LU, ÖR, RM, and VE). Clustering was performed at 97%. Distribution of reads within the bioinformatic pipeline using mothur. Given is the number of reads at each current step of the analysis for each sample sequenced for the three genetic markers (1274/706 = 28S rDNA, mlCOIint/dgHCOCOI, 3NDf/C_1132f = 18S rDNA). Results of the cluster-independent bioinformatic approach. Amplicon Sequence Variants (ASVs) are given for the three genetic markers (COI = mlCOIint/dgHCO, 28S rDNA = 1274/706, and 18S rDNA= 3NDf/C_1132f). Numbers are given for all samples and replicates combined, as this is only an alternate approach, which was not regarded further. Maximum likelihood tree based on the OTU inventory for the COI gene. The numbers at the branches represent the support values for the nodes. Maximum likelihood tree based on the ASV inventory for the COI gene. The numbers at the branches represent the support values for the nodes. Inspection of NCBI reference database for the Nematode SPEcies At Risk (NemaSPEAR[%]) as defined by Höss et al. [3] at the species and at the genus level. An” x” indicates whether the species or genera is found at NCBI for the 18S rDNA or 28 rDNA gene, while an “n” indicates that no reference sequence was found. The number of deposited sequences is given, the numbers in parentheses indicate reference sequences that were generated in our lab but are not yet published. Rarefaction analyses based on morphological data for the 7 locations (CUM, HI, ÖR, VE, FB and RM). Given is the species diversity that was observed, as well as extrapolated estimates for up to 1000 individuals inspected (dashed lines). Species inventory for the seven locations (VE, ÖR, RM, HI, LU, CUM, FB). Given are the species identified by morphological inspection, together with the biomass for a male (m biomass) and female (fm biomass) based on measured specimen in the dataset. It is indicated if a NCBI sequence for the 28S rDNA or 18S rDNA gene is found, an “n” showing that this species is missing. -nMDS plots based on not-transformed relative abundances of species (a, b, c) and genera (d, e, f) found in sediments sampled from the seven locations based on taxonomic data for the 28S marker (a, d), the 18S marker (b, e) and the morphological analysis (c, f); Bray-Curtis similarity was applied; each location is encoded by a different color and symbol. NemaSPEAR[%] (a, c, e) and NemaSPEAR[%]genus (b, d, f) calculated based on morphological (morph; a, b) and molecular (28S-rDNA: c, d, 18S-rDNA: e, f) taxonomic nematode species and genus data of river sediment sampled at 7 sites (6 sites for 18S-rDNA) plotted against the mean PEC-Q values calculated for the respective sediments; a: r2 = 0.71; p = 0.017; b: r2 = 0.66; p = 0.027; c: r2 = 0.65; p = 0.029; d: r2 = 0.78; p = 0.008; e: r2 = 0.60; p = 0.070; f: r2 = 0.88; p = 0.006.

Experimental design, materials, and methods

Seven locations were sampled, with five replicates for morphological and molecular analysis each. Each replicate was comprised from five subsamples. The detailed process is described in ref [1]. Sediment samples were processed as described by Higgins and Thiel [4]. From each of the five replicates 100 nematodes were isolated for morphological analyses, if possible. For the location VE more replicates were analysed, due to low nematode densities (Table 2). For molecular analyses 200 nematodes per replicate were isolated, as this gave more DNA yield in previous studies [5]. For several replicates with low nematodes densities, two or more replicates were combined as shown in Table 2. At each of the seven locations, for analysis of chemical contamination 5–10 subsamples of sediment were collected with a stainless-steel grab sampler and then pooled in a stainless-steel tub to avoid the effects of local variability. After the removal of large debris, the sediment material was homogenized, and 1 kg was transferred to glass containers. For each pooled sample, chemical analyses were conducted for 33 substances and according to the following methods: arsenic (As; ISO 17,294–2-E29:2005–02), 7 metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Cr, Ni, Zn; ISO 17,294–2-E29:2005–02 and Hg; ISO 16,772:2005–06), 16 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs according to the US EPA; ISO 18,287), 7 polychlorinated biphenols (PCB 28, 52, 101, 118, 138, 153, 180; EN 15,308), p,p'-DDD and p,p'-DDE (both ISO 10,382); Table 1).

Morphological data

Nematodes were assigned to the lowest taxonomic level as described in ref [1]. All specimens were measured and for each species the biomass contribution was calculated following Andrassyi [6], differentiating between male, female and juvenile stages 1 and 4, as also described in ref [1]. A rarefaction curve was calculated with R, using the package “iNEXT” [7] and the functions “iNEXT” and “ggiNEXT”. It was furthermore checked, whether a NCBI sequence was available for the morphological identified species, by using the species as search term and verifying if a 28S rDNA, 18S rDNA or COI sequence was found (Table 8).

Molecular data

Molecular data was analysed with mothur [8], following the standard protocol with alterations for the BLAST identification [9]. For the 18S rDNA and 28S rDNA gene fragment a cluster threshold of 99% was chosen, while for the COI gene 97% were chosen, due to the accelerated mutation rate. The distribution of reads in the process of bioinformatics was summed up after every filtering step, including merging of paired-end reads, filtering of long/short and homopolymer reads, and filtering of reads not fitting the alignment. The final OTU inventory for the three markers is listed (Table 4, 5, 6), based on BLAST with a cut-off of 95% identity. The results of an alternative approach, using no clustering, is given in Table 3. Data was generated with DADA2 [10], using default parameters with slight adaptions (length cutoff (280,250), maxEE = c (2,2), truncQ = 2). For the 18S gene fragment no length cut-off was chosen, as the overlap was very low due to the long amplicon length (around 540 bp). The BLAST comparison was run with an identity cut-off of 97%. For the COI phylogenetic trees were built in MEGA7 [11] for the ASV and OUT inventory, using maximum likelihood with 500 bootstrap replicates and the Jukes-Cantor model.

Statistical data

NMDS plots were generated with PRIMER_v6 [12], using all replicates for the molecular and morphological data for the seven locations. The data was not transformed and Bray-Curtis similarity was applied. NMDS plot was generated with default parameters in PRIMER. Correlations between the NemaSPEAR[%] values for the morphological approach, the 28S rDNA gene fragment and the 18S rDNA gene fragment for the species and genus level against the logarithmized mean PEC-Q values were plotted using SigmaPlot11 (Fig. 3).

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships which have, or could be perceived to have, influenced the work reported in this article.
SubjectPollution
Specific subject areaAn nematode-based index (NemaSPEAR[%]), which is based on morphological data, is validated with molecular data, amplifying fragments of the 28S rDNA, 28S rDNA and COI gene.
Type of dataTable
Graph
Figure
How data were acquiredData was acquired using a Zeiss microscope and Illumina MiSeq sequencing (V3 chemistry; 2 × 300 bp; 2.5 M read pairs).
Software used for further processing: PRIMER_v6, R Studio, mothur, cutadapt, SigmaPlot 11
Data formatNGS data is deposited under PRJNA513975 and PRJNA608650.
Raw morphological data is provided here.
Analyzed
Filtered
Parameters for data collectionSediment samples were collected at seven locations across Germany, whose pollution status was analysed before.
Description of data collectionSediment samples were taken in 2017 and 2018 using a corer (2.6 cm diameter), using five subsamples per replicate.
Data source locationInstitution: Bielefeld University
City: Bielefeld
Country: Germany
Sample collection:
Furlbach: N51°53.724 E008°42.931
Veerse: N53°08.483 E009°30.060
Oertze: N53°00.944 E010°04.974
Saale-Rischmühle: N51°21.038 E012°00.213
Elbe-Hitzacker: N53°09.643 E011°02.787
Elbe-Cumlosen: N53°02.432 E011°38.592
Luppe: N51°23.116 E012°00.526
Data accessibilityWith the article and under PRJNA513975 and PRJNA608650
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bioproject/PRJNA513975
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bioproject/PRJNA608650
Related research articleJanina Schenk, Sebastian Höss, Marvin Brinke, Nils Kleinbölting, Henrike Brüchner-Hüttemann, Walter Traunspurger
Title: Nematodes as bioindicators of polluted sediments using metabarcoding and microscopic taxonomy
Journal: Environment International
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.105922
  6 in total

1.  MEGA6: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis version 6.0.

Authors:  Koichiro Tamura; Glen Stecher; Daniel Peterson; Alan Filipski; Sudhir Kumar
Journal:  Mol Biol Evol       Date:  2013-10-16       Impact factor: 16.240

2.  Introducing mothur: open-source, platform-independent, community-supported software for describing and comparing microbial communities.

Authors:  Patrick D Schloss; Sarah L Westcott; Thomas Ryabin; Justine R Hall; Martin Hartmann; Emily B Hollister; Ryan A Lesniewski; Brian B Oakley; Donovan H Parks; Courtney J Robinson; Jason W Sahl; Blaz Stres; Gerhard G Thallinger; David J Van Horn; Carolyn F Weber
Journal:  Appl Environ Microbiol       Date:  2009-10-02       Impact factor: 4.792

3.  Nematode species at risk--a metric to assess pollution in soft sediments of freshwaters.

Authors:  S Höss; E Claus; P C Von der Ohe; M Brinke; H Güde; P Heininger; W Traunspurger
Journal:  Environ Int       Date:  2011-04-12       Impact factor: 9.621

4.  Nematodes as bioindicators of polluted sediments using metabarcoding and microscopic taxonomy.

Authors:  Janina Schenk; Sebastian Höss; Marvin Brinke; Nils Kleinbölting; Henrike Brüchner-Hüttemann; Walter Traunspurger
Journal:  Environ Int       Date:  2020-07-11       Impact factor: 9.621

5.  DADA2: High-resolution sample inference from Illumina amplicon data.

Authors:  Benjamin J Callahan; Paul J McMurdie; Michael J Rosen; Andrew W Han; Amy Jo A Johnson; Susan P Holmes
Journal:  Nat Methods       Date:  2016-05-23       Impact factor: 28.547

6.  Comparison of morphological, DNA barcoding, and metabarcoding characterizations of freshwater nematode communities.

Authors:  Janina Schenk; Nils Kleinbölting; Walter Traunspurger
Journal:  Ecol Evol       Date:  2020-02-15       Impact factor: 2.912

  6 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.