| Literature DB >> 32780851 |
Jesse N Nodora1,2, Samir Gupta1,3,4, Nicole Howard5, Kelly Motadel6, Tobe Propst7, Javier Rodriguez8, James Schultz9, Sharon Velasquez10, Sheila F Castañeda11, Borsika Rabin2,12, María Elena Martínez1,2.
Abstract
The 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic has dramatically impacted numerous health and economic fronts. Because of the stay-at-home mandate and practice of physical distancing, nearly all preventive care measures have been halted, including colorectal cancer (CRC) screening. The health consequences of this temporary suspension are of great concern, particularly for underserved populations, who experience substantial CRC-related disparities. In this commentary, we describe challenges and opportunities to deliver COVID-19-adapted CRC screening to medically underserved populations receiving care in community health centers (CHC). This perspective is based on key informant interviews with CHC medical directors, teleconference discussions, and strategic planning assessments. To address the unprecedented challenges created by the COVID-19 pandemic, we identify 2 broad calls to action: invest in CHCs now and support equitable and adaptable telehealth solutions now and in the future. We also recommend 4 CRC-specific calls to action: establish COVID-19-adapted best practices to implement mailed fecal immunochemical test programs, implement grassroots advocacy to identify community gastroenterologists who commit to performing colonoscopies for CHC patients, assess cancer prevention priorities among individuals in underserved communities, and assess regional CRC screening and follow-up barriers and solutions. The COVID-19 pandemic may further exacerbate existing CRC screening disparities in underserved individuals. This will likely lead to delayed diagnosis, a shift to later-stage disease, and increased CRC deaths. To prevent this from happening, we call for timely action and a commitment to address the current extraordinary CRC screening challenges for vulnerable populations.Entities:
Year: 2021 PMID: 32780851 PMCID: PMC7454700 DOI: 10.1093/jnci/djaa117
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst ISSN: 0027-8874 Impact factor: 13.506
Impact of COVID-19 on CHC health system and patients based on interviews with chief medical officers and directors
| Levels of impact and recommendations | Examples of impact and recommendations |
|---|---|
| CHC health system impact | |
| Economic | CHCs face revenue loss because of clinic closures within the CHC systems, especially dental facilities; patient visits have decreased 50%-70%: no elective or preventive services, few pediatric visits (well-child visits postponed, immunizations for children younger than aged 2 years available), most labs deferred; most chronic disease management visits are deferred; telehealth (largely by phone) represents 80%-85% of consultations. |
| Staffing |
Staff reductions include furloughs, layoffs, and reduction in hours. Telehealth services have changed staff routines. Most CHC systems were able to quickly establish effective telehealth services, covered under emergency plan funds. Physical distancing measures impact clinical staff functions. Staff anxiety and fear related to contamination have been addressed through education (morning clinical team question-and-answer sessions) and clear procedures for use of PPE. |
| CRC screening practice (workflow) |
Lab staff is available to process FITs at most CHCs (although CHCs are not ordering FIT tests routinely). Colonoscopies currently performed only for symptomatic and emergency patients. Community gastroenterologists inquiring about restarting CHC referrals. |
| CRC screening funding | Preventive services (including CRC screening) are considered elective procedures and not performed. |
| Markers of readiness for reinitiating in-person CRC screening | Most CMOs shared their support for reinitiating in-person CRC screening, providing the following practices were in place: adequate PPE supply; sufficient COVID-19 testing capacity (viral and antibody testing); lifting of stay-at-home orders; permission to do elective procedures; sufficient staff to handle previsit screening and assessments. |
| Patient-level impact | |
| Anticipated patient hesitancy for preventive services and clinic visits |
Patients will prioritize immediate concerns over disease prevention. Patients will be hesitant to leave home. |
| Recommended additions and modifications to patient CRC screening materials and process |
Recommended modifications for CRC screening because of COVID-19 include the following: use newly created COVID-19 information where applicable and review and update existing CRC screening guidelines accounting for COVID-19 impacts. Telehealth is a huge silver lining; patients are grateful they don’t have to travel to clinic and wait around in the clinic. Telehealth funding postpandemic is a concern (but telehealth benefits during the pandemic are evidence of success). |
CHC = community health center; CMO = chief medical officer; COVID-19 = 2019 novel coronavirus disease; CRC = colorectal cancer; FIT = fecal immunochemical test; PPE = personal protective equipment.
Figure 1.Average daily visits by visit type at 1 community health center following COVID-19 pandemic stay-at-home mandate in California.
Lessons learned and COVID-19 adaptations for delivering colorectal cancer screening in community health centers
| Strategies and interventions | Lessons learned | COVID-19 adaptations |
|---|---|---|
| Mailed FIT screening |
CHCs can deliver mailed FIT without requiring a patient visit. Centralization of delivery is possible. CHCs confirmed interest in mailed FIT as key strategy for CRC screening. |
Assess and accommodate real-world experience of mailed FIT. Review current CRC screening strategies and evidence-based interventions to consider needed modifications. |
| Patient navigation for abnormal FIT follow-up |
Uniform delivery is possible by telehealth. Challenges remain regarding staff changes and turnover because of layoffs. |
Shift patient navigation to virtual delivery. Adopt the train-the-trainer model to accommodate anticipated staff turnover. |
| Colonoscopy completion for patients with abnormal FIT |
Colonoscopy capacity can remain a challenge for CHCs that are not part of an integrated system with specialty care. Access to colonoscopy and willingness to complete exam may remain particularly low and decrease further. Increasing Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement for colonoscopy and supporting enhanced telehealth-based care coordination may help optimize follow-up. |
Conduct survey of community gastroenterologists to assess capacity for CHC patients. Monitor follow-up rates and funding policies to increase access and participation. Encourage grassroots advocacy to form a list of community gastroenterologists who commit to performing colonoscopies for CHC patients. Consider strategies to prioritize patients with abnormal FIT waiting for colonoscopy who develop signs and symptoms such as iron deficiency anemia, weight loss, and frank hematochezia. |
| Telehealth capability and capacity |
CHCs report high participation in telehealth appointments with few missed appointments. Visits are largely phone-based vs video. Patients are afraid or hesitant to come to the clinic. Phone visits more likely to be successful if caller identification is known. |
Enhance telemedicine capability and capacity. Ensure caller identification capability. Conduct needs assessment of patients and providers to assess barriers for telehealth, especially video calls. Support change in policies for telehealth reimbursement. |
CHC = community health center; COVID-19 = 2019 novel coronavirus disease; CRC = colorectal cancer; FIT = fecal immunochemical test.