| Literature DB >> 32758315 |
Sameh N Saleh1,2, Christoph U Lehmann2,3, Samuel A McDonald2,4, Mujeeb A Basit1,2, Richard J Medford1,2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Social distancing policies are key in curtailing severe acute respiratory coronavirus virus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) spread, but their effectiveness is heavily contingent on public understanding and collective adherence. We studied public perception of social distancing through organic, large-scale discussion on Twitter.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32758315 PMCID: PMC7450231 DOI: 10.1017/ice.2020.406
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol ISSN: 0899-823X Impact factor: 3.254
Topic Clusters Identified by Topic Modeling[a]
| Possible Topic Label | Tweets/Topic | Mean Sentiment | Mean Subjectivity | Words Contributing to Topic Model (in Decreasing Order of Weight) | Representative Tweet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Public opinions and values | 88,993 | 0.07 | 0.43 | see, say, right, good, want, life, even, back, away, someone, many, cant, never, could, practice, give, stop, feel, way, mean | “Another month of #SocialDistancing I already dread looking at the tweets. Since I already feel Millennials are going to be conveniently blamed for this. Everytime something stupid happens, it’s always millennials faults. #ugh” |
| Media and entertainment | 71,589 | 0.21 | 0.39 | watch, video, new, game, today, fun, join, book, read, play, share, virtual, friend, zoom, week, kid, show, see, check, online | “We had a surprise 25th virtual #zoom #birthday party for my daughter @[tag] this past weekend. Her friends and family sent a 10 sec birthday video message and we created a video birthday card. SO GREAT & made this #SocialDistancing birthday fun, special & memorable [link]” |
| Quarantine measures and effects | 65,229 | 0.07 | 0.35 | lockdown, pandemic, virus, death, spread, number, test, covidー, country, corona, new, government, say, follow, state, day, india, april, police, report | “As each area reaches the peak in positive #SARSCoV2 cases, the peak deaths follow around 3 to 4 weeks later as the illness sets in and takes its’ toll on the weak. If we #stayathome we do our part to flatten the spread, reduce the illness and reduce the death. #Socialdistancing [link]” |
| Thank healthcare and reduce spread | 64,488 | 0.21 | 0.38 | thank, together, staysafe, stay_safe, safe, help, maintain, practice, everyone, health, fight, washyourhands, healthy, family, flattenthecurve, follow, pandemic, protect | “A token of appreciation and respect to all colleagues in #publichealth and Medicine especially those at the frontlines fighting #COVID2019 risking their lives for our safety on this #WorldHealthDay2020. Best way of showing gratitude is to #StayAtHome and help contain the pandemic” |
| Community support and businesses | 56,117 | 0.18 | 0.39 | help, new, way, use, tip, learn, practice, support, connect, team, community, check, online, call, business, share, contact, great, important, find | “Due to COVID-19 #socialdistancing recommendations, our office is temporarily closed. General reception phone line remains open. You can also reach our representatives through the online contact form. Please check our website regularly for further updates: [link]” |
| Activities | 53,947 | 0.15 | 0.37 | walk, today, day, run, park, exercise, morning, outside, practice, weekend, around, good, house, dog, great, workout, nice, eat, car, coffee | “Another Lush Evenings Walk with Hubby walking off our Roast Beef Dinner … Bitter cold wind but a lovely stroll in the fresh air …. 1 Exercise a day Now chilled with a Cuppa #walking #SocialDistancing #DailyExercise [link]” |
| Quarantine and isolation | 51,725 | 0.09 | 0.34 | quarantine, day, lockdown, quarantinelife, selfisolation, isolation, week, corona, covidー, new, cat, pandemic, selfquarantine, today, lol, feel, staysafe, month, mom | “Is it just me or did it feel like the month of March lasted a year? Ready to turn the calendar to a new month. #coronavirus #pandemic #ShelterInPlace #SocialDistancing I’m ready to wake up from this nightmare.” |
| Spring and good sentiments | 45,850 | 0.26 | 0.41 | day, love, beautiful, staysafe, happy, light, today, spring, enjoy, nature, dog, good, hope, photo, smile, walk, april, sunday, lockdown, good_morning | “@[tag] @[tag] Hi and Good morning share-[name], Thanks, I wish you a magic Wednesday filled with happiness, love, joy, peace, laughs and fun. Enjoy every moment with family and friends. #TakeCare #BeSafe #StayAtHome” |
| Supplies, food, and orders | 41,087 | 0.084 | 0.34 | order, mask, essential, shop, close, store, food, open, practice, delivery, local, state, use, help, wear, line, buy, grocery, park, customer | “@[tag] @[tag] @[tag] @[tag] @[tag] @[tag] @[tag] @[tag] #Stayathome limits the spread of #coronavirus #PoorPeople and low income Seniors at higher risk, stand in long store lines to buy food. #SNAP #WIC #EBT cards can’t be used to shop online. #Help correct this. [link]” |
| Music and media sharing | 35,878 | 0.21 | 0.33 | coronalockdown_coronavirus, listen, music, click_link, via, artist, check, great, enjoy, dont_forget, enjoy_friend, song, great_artist, listen_rotation, discover_great, great_unsigned, art, dance, draw, sing | “My new single is NOW FOR SALE on iTUNES!! #newmusicalert #newmusic #chillout #2020music #electronic #electronicmusic #spotify #itunes #applemusic #streaming #corona #coronavirus #socialdistancing #producer #unsignedartist [link]” |
Words contributing to the model are shown in decreasing order of weighting. The topics are labeled manually based on these words. The number of tweets primarily with that topic, mean sentiment, mean subjectivity, and sample tweet are also included.
Characteristics of Tweets and Twitter Users[a]
| Characteristic | All[ | #socialdistancing[ | #stayathome[ |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||
| Twitter for iPhone | 178,105 (31.0) | 79,739 (30.2) | 109,808 (33.1) |
| Twitter for Android | 158,071 (27.5) | 54,043 (20.5) | 104,747 (31.5) |
| Twitter Web App | 108,826 (18.9) | 51,482 (19.5) | 61,802 (18.6) |
| 38,809 (6.8) | 24,938 (9.4) | 15,147 (4.6) | |
| Hashtags | 3 (2–5) | 3 (2–5) | 3 (2–5) |
| Has link | 207,465 (36.1) | 106,428 (40.3) | 108,914 (32.8) |
| Has media | 272,005 (47.3) | 131,758 (49.8) | 151,429 (45.5) |
| Mentions user | 193,392 (33.6) | 89,623 (33.9) | 109,197 (32.9) |
| Includes place | 52,020 (9.0) | 25,333 (9.6) | 28,626 (8.6) |
| Includes geolocation | 12,639 (2.2) | 8,337 (3.2) | 4,677 (1.4) |
| Is quoted text | 51,422 (8.9) | 20,797 (7.9) | 32,630 (9.8) |
| Verified twitter account | 27,560 (5.0) | 13,463 (5.1) | 16,015 (4.8) |
| User followers | 437 (98–1,971) | 499 (113–2,356) | 392 (87–1,714) |
| User posts to date | 3,026 (584–13,086) | 3,455 (729–15,280) | 2,668 (485–11,378) |
Median (IQR) is presented for numerical variables. N (%) is presented for categorical variables.
n = 574,903; 564,886 unique.
n = 264,254 (46.0%).
n = 332,075 (57.8%).
Fig. 1.Word cloud of top 200 words.
Fig. 2.Sentiment analysis for all tweets and stratified by tweets with the hashtag #socialdistancing and #stayathome. Comparison between the two hashtags is done using χ2 testing. Bonferroni correction was used to define statistical significance at a threshold of P = .01 (0.05/n, where n = 5 since 5 comparisons were completed).
Fig. 3.Subjectivity analysis for all tweets. Complete objectivity are defined as 0 and complete subjectivity are defined as 1.
Fig. 4.Emotion analysis for all tweets and stratified by tweets with the hashtag #socialdistancing and #stayathome. Comparison between the two hashtags is done using χ2 testing. Bonferroni correction was used to define statistical significance at a threshold of P = .008 (0.05/n, where n = 6 since 6 comparisons were completed).