| Literature DB >> 32742305 |
Pallab K Maulik1,2,3, Graham Thornicroft4, Shekhar Saxena5,6.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The COVID pandemic has been devastating for not only its direct impact on lives, physical health, socio-economic status of individuals, but also for its impact on mental health. Some individuals are affected psychologically more severely and will need additional care. However, the current health system is so fragmented and focused on caring for those infected that management of mental illness has been neglected. An integrated approach is needed to strengthen the health system, service providers and research to not only manage the current mental health problems related to COVID but develop robust strategies to overcome more long-term impact of the pandemic. A series of recommendations are outlined in this paper to help policy makers, service providers and other stakeholders, and research and research funders to strengthen existing mental health systems, develop new ones, and at the same time advance research to mitigate the mental health impact of COVID19. The recommendations refer to low, middle and high resource settings as capabilities vary greatly between countries and within countries. DISCUSSION: The recommendations for policy makers are focused on strengthening leadership and governance, finance mechanisms, and developing programme and policies that especially include the most vulnerable populations. Service provision should focus on accessible and equitable evidence-based community care models commensurate with the existing mental health capacity to deliver care, train existing primary care staff to cater to increased mental health needs, implement prevention and promotion programmes tailored to local needs, and support civil societies and employers to address the increased burden of mental illness. Researchers and research funders should focus on research to develop robust information systems that can be enhanced further by linking with other data sources to run predictive models using artificial intelligence, understand neurobiological mechanisms and community-based interventions to address the pandemic driven mental health problems in an integrated manner and use innovative digital solutions.Entities:
Keywords: COVID 19; Mental health resources; Mental health services; Mental health systems; Policy making; Research
Year: 2020 PMID: 32742305 PMCID: PMC7389161 DOI: 10.1186/s13033-020-00393-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Ment Health Syst ISSN: 1752-4458
Mental health system specific recommendations relevant to policy maker by available resources during the pandemic
| Recommendations relevant to policy makers | Low resource settings with few mental health resources and infrastructure | Medium resource settings with some mental health resources and infrastructure | High resource settings with good mental health resources and infrastructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strengthen leadership and governance | * Using an intersectoral approach, develop evidence-based policies to manage basic mental health needs, and strategies for implementation of those policies, especially involving teams managing COVID infection *Inform and support politicians, and administrators to the need of mental health interventions in the light of this pandemic using existing evidence-based communication tools available on the internet *Have clear standard operating procedures (SOPs) to operationalize implementation strategies which are well integrated within the larger framework to tackle COVID infection *Develop and implement monitoring mechanisms using feasible indicators to capture prevalence of common mental disorders, number of mental health service providers and accessibility Mental health care is integrated within the overall health and humanitarian policy; decentralize the administrative machinery but ensure that certain sound principles are adhered to by all | *Mental health needs of special vulnerable population groups addressed using appropriate policies and programmes and these should focus on the poor and marginalized communities *Existing policies and programmes are tailor made to specific regional needs even within a country based on data about the burden of mental disorders in the community *Special training of policy makers are undertaken to increase knowledge about mental health in the face of this pandemic by mental health professionals | *Key aspects of the policies are geared around inclusivity and equity and specifically target vulnerable populations of different types; Teams and departments in charge of each component are outlined and accountability is addressed appropriately using suitable indicators; data collection is synchronized within the larger system that gathers data on the pandemic |
| Identify appropriate finance mechanism to support policies and programmes; develop schemes to cover longer term mental health care | *There are earmark additional funds to cover evidence-based mental health activities under health budget at national, regional and district level; especially ring-fence budget to cover the mental health impact due to COVID pandemic *Mental health expenditure is tracked and protected and mechanisms are created to do so if not in place, given increased proportion of health budget allocation for COVID *Include mental health within the care packages of social and private insurances at least to cover expenses arising out of the pandemic; identify micro financing schemes to support mental health support for individuals who may need extensive mental health care | *Budget allocated for mental health care during this crisis can be spread across different intersectoral activities including poverty alleviation programmes, employment generation activities, where addressing mental health needs is prioritised in those programmes; funds should look at both short and long term outcomes A large pool of private and public insurance schemes is in place to cover mental health care costs | *Mental health budget to address enhanced needs of mental health burden during the pandemic is increased significantly to cover current and future needs and those are tracked using robust systems *Private or public insurance systems have mental health care integrated within their policies and is adequate to cover for long term care and included in packages to cover COVID |
| Promote programmes specifically targeting vulnerable groups | *Identify specific components within other existing programmes such as those targeting homelessness, employment, migrant populations which focus on mental health needs of such populations, especially given the impact of the pandemic on these populations *Develop mental health promotion communications focused on stigma related to the pandemic and its effect on mental health If any mental health program exists, then strengthen those to specifically address needs during the crisis; specifically ensure that such programmes are accessible to those needing it Programmes are culturally relevant and tested; but programmes tested in similar settings but in some other areas may be used in order to save time and money | *Develop new mental health programmes that are not only focused on addressing the immediate mental health needs due to the COVID pandemic but has long term benefits too; implement those programmes amongst populations in need- migrants, women, elderly, children *Involve relevant stakeholders (government or non-government) in the programmes being developed and target programmes to cater to the specific needs of individuals, families, care givers, employers, different vulnerable groups *Develop targeted programmes for local settings which specifically focus on issues such as domestic violence, child abuse, elderly care, alcohol and substance use, reducing suicide risk which are showing increased prevalence during this pandemic | *Enhance any existing programmes that already focus on vulnerable populations Integrate mental health programmes within other social sector specific programmes such as those on housing, employment generation, elderly care, child care, school systems |
*Recommendations that are particularly relevant for managing mental health issues during COVID infection
Recommendations relevant to service providers and other stakeholders by available resources during the pandemic
| Recommendations relevant service providers and other stakeholders | Low resource settings with few mental health resources and infrastructure | Medium resource settings with some mental health resources and infrastructure | High resource settings with good mental health resources and infrastructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Develop or strengthen equitable, accessible and appropriate community-based mental health services and clinic-based services for those needed special care | *Enable communities to identify common mental disorders and severe mental disorders; develop routine mechanisms to collect such data during the pandemic *Make care provision inclusive especially for those most affected such as migrants, women, elderly populations, children and adolescents, who may be affected more during this pandemic *Connect community, primary, secondary and tertiary care systems using innovative care models that are accessible and equitable; secondary and tertiary level should be able to provide care to those with more severe mental health problems *Telemedicine using integrated health information systems is actively pursued to ensure remote monitoring and followup. *Robust supply chains are in place to ensure availability of all psychotropic medications listed on a countries’ Essential Drugs List; this becomes more important during the pandemic as accessibility and movement is restricted thus compromising ability to purchase medicines from private pharmacies which may be few especially in rural communities The care model centres around protection of human rights | *Upgrade the primary and secondary health system to manage mental health problems; have provisions for basic counselling at primary level; enhance community-based services to support those needing support for daily living such as groceries, laundry, etc. *Address specific needs of populations who may be particularly affected such as women facing domestic violence, children or adolescents facing abuse, individuals at high risk of suicide or self-harm, those with substance use disorders, elderly with dementia *Secondary care level has the capacity to manage complicated cases with multimorbidity which would be more common among those infected with COVID19, only the more severe cases are referred to tertiary level; electronic medical records systems are enabled for appropriate follow-up *The health information system allows patients to routinely track symptoms and link them to the medical records so that health care providers can track them easily and prioritize followup Specific programmes for those needing institutional care or elderly support are not compromised | * Integrate mental health services within care for COVID infection at each level *Health information systems are linked across different health conditions so that health providers can easily track multiple conditions and the patient can tack their health too Support is available for carers of persons with mental illnesses Care for special population such as elderly, child and adolescents are ensured Multiple medication options are available with clinicians to treat complicated cases Health system has the capacity to reach out to low or medium resource settings and enhance their capacities to provide human rights centred care |
| Train adequate primary care staff to cater to the increased mental health needs at the community level | *Awareness is provided about stigma related to mental disorders using multimedia strategies, with a specific focus on the increased risk of stigma associated with COVID infection *Train primary health workers on mhGAP and especially focus on the modules of depression, emotional stress, alcohol use disorders, suicide risk; primary care doctors should be able to identify psychotic symptoms and manage common mental disorders efficiently; fear or anxiety related to infection and death and bereavement should be managed through basic counselling skills | *Psychological therapies are more advanced than basic counselling to manage mental health issues related to COVID infection and overcoming death of loved ones Primary health workers are trained on the full mhGAP and manage most cases as per guidelines; linkages with mental health professionals should be enabled using e-health or m-health platforms Community based programmes to raise awareness about mental health and reduce stigma are implemented by health staff and other stakeholders | *Stigma campaigns are tailored to specific communities such as young or old, jobless, men or women, schools, workplace; campaigns should specifically address stigma associated with COVID infection Primary care staff supported by paramedical staff including ambulance services can identify and care for most mental disorders outlined under mhGAP; support from trained mental health professionals are sought as needed |
| Implement mental health promotion and prevention programmes | *Evidence-based and preferably culturally relevant prevention and promotion programmes to reduce stigma, raise awareness about common mental disorders and need for addressing mental health needs arising out of the COVID crisis are implemented across different settings to the extent feasible * Even if the programmes are basic in structure they should be implemented as widely as possible, and all health promotion activities are based on sound behaviour science principles; programmes are integrated as much possible within other programmes addressing COVID infections Government backed pan-regional programmes with support from local non-governmental partners are implemented | *Culturally relevant programmes addressing stigma for special populations such as health workers, child and adolescents, women are developed and implemented Non-governmental organizations partner with government agencies to implement programmes in different settings and population groups Programmes are developed for special settings like factories, prisons, schools that need different implementation pathways | *Mental health needs of special populations such as elderly, prisoners, women, LGBTQIA communities, institutionalized communities, poor and marginalized migrant workers, refugees, etc., are specifically tailored and include measures on how to address specific issues of COVID 19 related mental illness Suitable programmes are available for families and carers of persons with mental illnesses |
| Strengthen civil societies | *Civil societies identify key areas where they can contribute and pitch into support the overall government plan to manage mental health problems during the COVID pandemic *Civil societies involved in mental health service delivery or research or advocacy are identified and integrated within a government database; especially those with the ability to support multiple health conditions including mental health should would be beneficial The databases of civil societies allow the administrators to identify strengths of each organization, its reach, focus, and key resource person(s) Government plans their mental health alleviation programmes keeping civil societies in the loop and takes their opinions Government allocates ring-fenced funds to support activities undertaken by civil societies where it by itself cannot function effectively, be it research, program implementation, or advocacy | *A registry of civil societies is advanced enough to allow for an easy two-way communication between them and the government *Appropriate funds to support civil societies led programmes are present and those are planned in consultation with the government Civil societies per se can access resources and roll out programmes as per their strengths while keeping the overall focus on managing the impact of the pandemic The collaborations between civil societies and government is streamlined; the government provides oversight to local and regional programmes that are essentially implemented by civil societies | *Civil societies and government are equal partners in delivering care or conducting research during this pandemic *Civil societies working at national, regional or local levels are adequately funded to support not only their own activities but support government efforts to overcome the COVID pandemic |
| Enable employers to manage stress at workplace | *Suitable communication packages are present to engage with employers to discuss workplace stress, COVID related mental health issues, stigma *Initiate a dialogue with different employer’s associations to understand specific challenges related to COVID and how they can affect mental health *Specific interactions with employers in health care sectors, police, civil administrations who are at the forefront of managing the crisis are initiated; programmes are in place to address fear and anxiety related to being infected or death of loved ones *Labour laws are revisited or redrafted to ensure employee welfare during this pandemic | *Interaction with employer’s associations are better integrated and builds on existing models of such interactions with specific focus on managing the pandemic | *Specific programmes are developed to support needs of niche employers who are at the forefront of managing the COVID crisis, and these need to be tailored to local needs Welfare programmes for employers focused on reducing stress are in place and the staff are actively engaged in those; employers also help the programmes to grow organically through their active inputs |
*Recommendations that are particularly relevant for managing mental health issues during COVID infection
Recommendations relevant to researchers and research funders by available resources during the pandemic
| Recommendations relevant researchers and research funders | Low resource settings with few mental health resources and infrastructure | Medium resource settings with some mental health resources and infrastructure | High resource settings with good mental health resources and infrastructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Develop research to improve information systems | *Identify key mental health indicators that can be tracked over time through government applications/websites, and are built into the tracking system for COVID infection; non-governmental organizations too to include such indicators in their activities *Enable community health workers with simple questionnaires to capture stressful risk factors, and common symptoms pertaining to any mental disorders based on the mhGAP screening application or other similar tool *Develop a website for such data to be automatically uploaded and analysed | *Besides basic mental health related data, more details are gathered around access and use of mental health services and stigma perceptions in the face of the pandemic *The health websites should enable automated data analyses and report generation filtered by predefined criteria | *Health information systems are linked to detailed clinical data related to COVID infection and other risk factors *The system allows triangulation of data from different sources and linking with other data to provide a rich matrix of data to do sophisticated analyses using machine learning |
| Develop research on epidemiology, neurobiological effects, community-based and special population-based interventions, linkages with environmental and social sciences | *Conduct research to understand the epidemiology of mental health impact of the COVID pandemic across different population groups, especially those at increased risk; understand correlated factors and account for non-health related factors that are also impacting mental health Develop interventions to manage the mental health impact of the pandemic using community-based approaches based on implementation science principles Ascertain factors that determine adequate mental health service use during and after the current pandemic is over | *More resource intensive research conducted that covers larger geographical areas and provides more robust data both from an epidemiology and scalable intervention perspective, including those involving vulnerable populations *Larger randomized studies are implemented to generate robust data that will not only benefit current knowledge related to the impact of COVID infection on mental health but also inform future programmes and policies *Existing electronic databases allow intersectoral research to assess multiple dimensions related to the pandemic that affect mental health *Use social media usage analytics to assess stress and mental illness using machine learning tools Research focuses on understanding treatment outcomes to specific medications and its correlation to mental health | *Neurobiological research into the impact of COVID 19 on brain including early childhood development and brain neuroplasticity should be planned *Behavioural research explores mental health impact of the pandemic due to physical distancing, loneliness, stigma, poverty, hunger, among other issues *Machine learning and research involving artificial intelligence uses correlated datasets and modelling to forecast mental health impact of the pandemic; research has implications for future predictive models too Longer term effects of the stress on human psychology can be conducted and interventions to mitigate such can be implemented |
| Develop innovative solutions to improve mental health systems; support technology-enabled solutions to support service delivery; identify strategies to enable more efficient supply chain logistics models for medicines; use of social media to deliver interventions on mental health promotion | *Develop technology-enabled solutions to conduct research and gather data avoiding in-person contact as much as feasible, while ensuring appropriate data security and privacy *Identify culturally relevant evidence-based applications to gather data on mental health outcomes and increase access to care Conduct health systems research to investigate how supply of psychotropic medications at community level can be accomplished Use social media platforms to not only link researchers but also develop interventions based on use of social media | *Better ability to link secondary data from other sources with primary data using big data analytics | *Service use involves digital technology, interactive voice messages, video games, virtual reality *Advanced methodologies using artificial intelligence driven analytics allow development of risk profiles in real time and identify predictive models |
*Recommendations that are particularly relevant for managing mental health related problems during COVID infection