Harshita Singh Korawat1, Ashok K Basak1. 1. Department of Chemistry, Institute of Science, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi 221005, India.
Abstract
N-Sulfonylhydrazones derived from alkyl, aryl, and heteroaryl aldehydes and ketones undergo rapid conversion into the corresponding sulfinates when heated with 10 mol % K2CO3 in N,N'-dimethylethylene urea (DMEU) at elevated temperature. The reaction conditions are amenable to several functional groups and suitable for gram-scale synthesis. Under these base-catalyzed conditions, N-tosylhydrazones derived from O-allylated and O-propargylated 2-hydroxyarylaldehydes do not undergo the well-established intramolecular [3 + 2]-cycloaddition reactions and generate corresponding sulfinates in good yields. The base-catalyzed transformation proceeds via crucial rapid intermolecular protonation of the diazo intermediate 11 to generate diazonium ion 12, which upon nucleophilic displacement by the sulfonyl ion 10 provides the desired sulfinate selectively.
N-Sulfonylhydrazones derived from alkyl, aryl, and heteroaryl aldehydes and ketones undergo rapid conversion into the corresponding sulfinates when heated with 10 mol % K2CO3 in N,N'-dimethylethylene urea (DMEU) at elevated temperature. The reaction conditions are amenable to several functional groups and suitable for gram-scale synthesis. Under these base-catalyzed conditions, N-tosylhydrazones derived from O-allylated and O-propargylated 2-hydroxyarylaldehydes do not undergo the well-established intramolecular [3 + 2]-cycloaddition reactions and generate corresponding sulfinates in good yields. The base-catalyzed transformation proceeds via crucial rapid intermolecular protonation of the diazo intermediate 11 to generate diazonium ion 12, which upon nucleophilic displacement by the sulfonyl ion 10 provides the desired sulfinate selectively.
Sulfinates are a class
of sulfur-containing molecular entities
that are important in terms of their biological activities as well
as from the synthetic point of view.[1] A
few sulfinates have been reported to exhibit cytotoxic activity against
leukemia cell lines in humans.[2] Sulfinates
also act as bioluminescent sensors for the detection of thiols in
living cells.[3] Synthetically, sulfinates
have acquired considerable importance owing to their elegant dual
reactivity as electrophiles or as nucleophiles under suitable reaction
conditions.[4] Chiral sulfinates are often
utilized as convenient building blocks in the asymmetric synthesis
of sulfur-containing compounds such as sulfoxides and sulfonamides.[5] Due to these widespread applications, a great
deal of attention has been paid by the synthetic community across
the globe for the development of suitable methods for the synthesis
of sulfinates using commercially/readily available starting materials.Scheme outlines
the summary of recent important methods reported in the literature
for the synthesis of achiral sulfinates. Electrochemical[6] as well as transition-metal[7]-catalyzed oxidation of thiols in the presence of suitable
alcohols under aerobic conditions has been employed to generate corresponding
sulfinates in good yields (Scheme a). Interestingly, thiols have also been converted
into tert-butylsulfinates by treating with a TBHP/TBAI
mixture.[8] Under an oxygen atmosphere, Cu(OTf)2 catalyzes the conversion of arylsulfonylhydrazides to arylsulfinyl
radicals, which couple with suitable alcohols to generate sulfinates
(Scheme b).[9]tert-Butyl sulfoxides could
also be converted into sulfinates by treating with alcohols in the
presence of NBS-AcOH in dichloromethane (Scheme c).[10] In the presence
of a stoichiometric amount of suitable activators such as BF3·OEt2,[11a] TMSCl,[11b] and H2SO4,[11c] alcohols undergo condensation with sodium sulfinate
to generate various sulfinates in good yields (Scheme d). Recently, p-toluenesulfonylmethyl
isocyanide (TosMIC) in combination with a wide variety of alcohols
has been utilized to generate sulfinate under BiBr3-catalyzed
mild acidic conditions (Scheme e).[2] Intriguingly, TosMIC has also
been found to be a suitable reagent for the conversion of alcohols
to sulfinates under Mitsunobu conditions (Scheme f).[12]
Scheme 1
Recent
Methods for Achiral Sulfinate Synthesis
In the past decade, N-tosylhydrazones, owing to
their easy availability and stability toward bench-storage and distinctive
modes of reactivity, have emerged as an important counterpart in transition-metal-catalyzed[13] as well as transition-metal-free cross-coupling[14] reactions. In the presence of a suitable base, N-tosylhydrazones undergo decomposition via the Bamford–Stevens
reaction.[15] To this end, an extensive study
of solvent-dependent base-mediated decomposition of N-tosylhydrazones has been reported by Wei et al.[16a] When treated with a suitable base, N-tosylhydrazones
yield dialkylidenehydrazines and oximes in appropriate solvents.[16a] The sulfonyl anion, evolved during the base-promoted
decomposition of N-tosylhydrazones, couples with
the metallocarbene generated in the presence of transition metals
(Cu, Fe, and Rh) under suitable conditions to furnish synthetically
important sulfones (Scheme a).[17] On the contrary, N-tosylhydrazones give corresponding sulfinates when heated
with a stoichiometric amount of stabilized Wittig ylide in N,N′-dimethylpropylene urea (DMPU)
at elevated temperature under transition-metal-free conditions (Scheme b).[18] Adding to this development, in a very recent report, Wu
et al. have demonstrated that sulfinates could also be obtained selectively
when N-tosylhydrazones are heated with a stoichiometric
amount of diisopropylethyl amine in nitromethane at 90 °C (Scheme c).[19] Nonetheless, it is worth noting that, as per mechanism,
the conversion of N-tosylhydrazone to the corresponding
sulfinate should be catalytic with a base. However, unfortunately,
the previous methods fail to give a complete conversion with a catalytic
amount of base/promoter.[18,19] A catalytic process
would reduce the operational cost and waste generation and render
practicality to this relatively new transformation. Herein, we report
the development of a K2CO3-catalyzed rapid conversion
of N-tosylhydrazones to sulfinates in N,N′-dimethylethylene urea (DMEU) at elevated
temperature.[20]
Scheme 2
Conversion of N-Tosylhydrazone to Sulfone and Sulfinate
Results and Discussion
In our recent investigation,
we observed that the reaction of N-tosylhydrazone 1j in the presence of 2.5
equiv of K2CO3 in N,N-dimethyl formamide (DMF) at 110 °C did not undergo
the hypothesized[21] intramolecular C–C
bond-forming reaction to produce the anticipated ethyl-2,3-dihydrobenzofuran-2-carboxylate 2 but gave 66% yield of sulfinate 3j and a small
amount of sulfone 4j (Scheme ). Also, similar results were obtained when
1.0 equiv of K2CO3 was used for the transformation.
Close inspection of the reaction mixture revealed that most of the
insoluble K2CO3 remained unreacted during the
course of the reaction. This prompted us to carry out the reaction
with a catalytic amount of base. To our delight, a complete conversion
of N-tosylhydrazone was also observed using 10 mol
% K2CO3 to give sulfinate 3j and
sulfone 4j in 70 and 8% yields, respectively (entry b, Table ). Smooth decomposition
of N-tosylhydrazone 1j in N-methylpyrrolidinone (NMP) as the solvent also provided sulfinate 3j in 76% yield and a small amount of sulfone 4j (entry c, Table ). When DMPU was used as a solvent, 78% yield of sulfinate 3j and only a trace amount of sulfone 4j were
obtained (entry d, Table ). Selective formation of sulfinate in high yield (80%) was
also obtained in DMEU with 10 mol % K2CO3 at
110 °C (entry e, Table ). Other alkali metal carbonates (Li2CO3, Na2CO3, and Cs2CO3)
were also tested for the reaction in DMEU; however, inferior results
were obtained when compared to K2CO3 (entries
f–h, Table ). This suggests that the countercations of alkali metal carbonates
play an important role in the overall outcome of the reaction. The
reaction with Li2CO3, which is weakly basic,
provided slow transformation, and only about 75% conversion (60% yield)
occurred after 1 h. Na2CO3 showed comparable
reactivity with K2CO3 but gave a slightly lower
yield (70%) of sulfinate 3j. The reaction with Cs2CO3 was quick, but low yield (65%) was observed
due to partial decomposition to unidentified polar compounds. Importantly,
no reaction was observed when KHCO3 was used as the base
in DMEU at 110 °C (entry i, Table ).
Scheme 3
Initial Results
Table 1
Optimization of Reaction Conditions
for Sulfinate Synthesis
yield
(%)
entry
base (equiv)
conditionsa
3j
4j
a
K2CO3 (1.0)
DMF, 110 °C, 10 min
67
10
b
K2CO3 (0.1)
DMF, 110 °C, 10 min
70
8
c
K2CO3 (0.1)
NMP, 110 °C, 10 min
76
5
d
K2CO3 (0.1)
DMPU, 110 °C, 10 min
78
trace
e
K2CO3 (0.1)
DMEU, 110 °C, 10 min
80
trace
f
Li2CO3 (0.1)
DMEU, 110 °C, 1 hb
60
trace
g
Na2CO3 (0.1)
DMEU, 110 °C, 30 min
70
trace
h
Cs2CO3 (0.1)
DMEU, 110 °C, 10 min
65
trace
i
KHCO3 (0.1)
DMEU, 110 °C, 10 min
NR
All reactions were carried out in
0.20 mmol scale in anhydrous solvent under an inert atmosphere.
75% conversion after 1 h; DMF = N,N-dimethyl formamide; NMP = N-methylpyrrolidinone; NR = no reaction.
All reactions were carried out in
0.20 mmol scale in anhydrous solvent under an inert atmosphere.75% conversion after 1 h; DMF = N,N-dimethyl formamide; NMP = N-methylpyrrolidinone; NR = no reaction.With the encouraging results in hand, we sought to
evaluate the
scope of the base-catalyzed transformation. A variety of N-tosylhydrazones derived from known carbonyl compounds were treated
with 10 mol % K2CO3 in DMEU at 110 °C to
convert into the corresponding sulfinates, and the results are presented
in Scheme . The reaction
conditions are amenable to N-tosylhydrazones obtained
from aryl aldehydes containing electron-withdrawing (Br and NO2) as well as electron-releasing (via inductive and resonance
effect) groups (Me, tBu, OMe, and SPh). N-Tosylhydrazones derived from benzaldehyde gave sulfinate 3a in 72% yield. N-Tosylhydrazones generated from
2-methoxybenzaldehyde and 2-(phenylthio)benzaldehyde showed excellent
reactivity and furnished sulfinates 3b and 3c in 82 and 84% yields, respectively. Electron-rich 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzaldehyde-derived N-tosylhydrazone showed good reactivity and provided sulfinate 3d in 70% yield in a short reaction time (15 min). N-Tosylhydrazones derived from aromatic and aliphatic ketones
showed much lower reactivity compared to those derived from aryl aldehydes
toward the base-catalyzed sulfinate synthesis. N-Tosylhydrazone
obtained from fluorenone underwent a slow reaction to furnish sulfinate 3e in 56% yield after 1 h. Cyclopentanone-derived N-tosylhydrazone showed no reaction at 110 °C possibly
due to a higher pKa value of the N–H
proton. However, sulfinate 3f could be obtained in moderate
yield (52%) when heated at higher temperature (150 °C) for 2
h. It is noteworthy that, in the previous reports,[18,19]N-tosylhydrazones derived from aliphatic carbonyl
compounds could not be converted into corresponding sulfinates. Thus,
the current condition further expands the substrate scope of this
important transformation. A few heteroaryl aldehyde-derived N-tosylhydrazones were also subjected to the base-catalyzed
reaction conditions. N-Tosylhydrazone obtained from
furfuryl-2-carboxaldehyde produced sulfinate 3g in 72%
yield in a short reaction time. Pyridine-3-carboxaldehyde-derived N-tosylhydrazone also gave sulfinate 3h in
good yield (68%). Next, a fairly good number of N-tosylhydrazones derived from O-alkylated (alkylated
with alkyl 2-bromoacetates and benzyl chloride) 2-hydroxyarylaldehydes
bearing important functional groups were investigated. Whereas no
reaction was observed with N-tosylhydrazone derived
from salicylaldehyde[18,19] due to the presence of the acidic
phenolic hydroxyl group, N-tosylhydrazones derived
from O-alkylated 2-hydroxyarylaldehyedes incurred
excellent reactivity and provided corresponding sulfinates (3i–q) in high yields. Further, it is worth
noting that, in the presence of a stoichiometric amount of suitable
base such as LiOtBu,[22a] KOH,[22b] K2CO3,[22c] etc., N-tosylhydrazones derived from O-allylated and O-propargylated 2-hydroxybenzaldehydes
undergo the intramolecular [3 + 2]-cycloaddition reaction to generate
dihydropyrazoles and pyrazoles exclusively. In contrast, under the
present catalytic conditions, no recognizable intramolecular [3 +
2]-cycloaddition reaction occurred for these substrates and sulfinates3r and 3s were obtained in 74 and 78% yields,
respectively. Similarly, with a catalytic amount of K2CO3 in DMEU, no intramolecular [3 + 2]-cycloaddition[23] reaction took place in the case of N-tosylhydrazone derived from 2-(2-formylphenoxy)acetonitrile and
sulfinate 3t was obtained in 68% yield in a rapid conversion
(Scheme ). A point
to be noted is that sulfinate 3s incorporates an internal
alkyne and thus poised for exploration of novel intra- and intermolecular
reactions.
Scheme 4
Synthesis of Sulfinates from N-Tosylhydrazones
All reactions were carried out
in 0.20 mmol scale using 10 mol % K2CO3 in DMEU
(0.5 M) at 110 °C.
Reaction was carried out at 150 °C.
Scheme 5
Synthesis
of Sulfinate 3t
Synthesis of Sulfinates from N-Tosylhydrazones
All reactions were carried out
in 0.20 mmol scale using 10 mol % K2CO3 in DMEU
(0.5 M) at 110 °C.Reaction was carried out at 150 °C.Seeking to evaluate the effect of the aryl/heteroaryl groups attached
to the S-atom, a few N-sulfonylhydrazones were synthesized
from aryl/heteroaryl hydrazides readily obtained following the reported
experimental procedure.[18,24] Salicylaldehyde, O-alkylated with tert-butyl 2-bromoacetate,
was chosen as the aryl aldehyde for the excellent reactivity of the N-tosylhydrazone derived thereof (3k, Scheme ). Choice of the tert-butyl group provided clarity in 1H NMR spectra
in the 4.0–5.5 ppm region where the diastereotopic sulfinate
protons appear. As depicted in Scheme , the K2CO3-catalyzed reaction
was found to be effective on N-sulfonylhydrazones
derived from various aryl/heteroarylsulfonyl hydrazides. For example,
sulfinates6a and 6b having phenyl and 2,4,6-trimethylphenyl
groups on the S-atom were obtained in 80 and 76% yields, respectively.
Sulfinate 6c containing a 1-naphthyl group on the S-atom
was obtained in 68% yield. Similarly, sulfinate 6d, containing
a 4-bromophenyl group, and sulfinate 6e, having a 3-(trifluoromethyl)phenyl
group on the S-atom, were obtained in 70 and 66% yields, respectively,
under the optimized reaction conditions. Under this base-catalyzed
reaction conditions, sulfinate 6f having a 5-bromothiophenyl
group on the S-atom could also be obtained in moderate yield (60%).
To demonstrate the utility in large-scale synthesis, N-tosylhydrazone derived from 2-(phenylthio)benzaldehyde was subjected
to a gram-scale reaction. Gratifyingly, no significant loss in yield
and/or reactivity was observed in the 1.0 gram scale reaction of N-toslhydrazone 1c, showcasing the practicality
and robustness of this base-catalyzed method (Scheme ).
Scheme 6
Sulfinates from Various N-Sulfonylhydrazones
All reactions were carried out
in 0.20 mmol scale using 10 mol % K2CO3 in DMEU
at 110 °C
Scheme 7
Gram-Scale Reaction
Sulfinates from Various N-Sulfonylhydrazones
All reactions were carried out
in 0.20 mmol scale using 10 mol % K2CO3 in DMEU
at 110 °CThe conversion of N-sulfonylhydrazone
to sulfinate
proceeds intermolecularly, which was demonstrated by cross-over experiments
in previous reports.[18,19] The proposed mechanism of the
K2CO3-catalyzed conversion is depicted in Scheme . The decomposition
of N-sulfonylhydrazone 7 is triggered
by the abstraction of N–H proton by K2CO3, generating deprotonated N-sulfonylhydrazone 8 and mild base KHCO3 (inert under the reaction
conditions). Intermediate ion 8 releases the ambient
sulfonyl ion 9, leading to diazo intermediate 11. The diazo intermediate 11 gets converted into intermediate 12 via rapid intermolecular protonation, a crucial step for
the success of the catalytic conditions. Nucleophilic displacement
of the diazo group in the intermediate 12 by the sulfonyl
anion 10 that bears negative charge on the O-atom generates
sulfinate 13. At high temperature and in a polar aprotic
solvent such as DMEU, the negatively charged O-center of the ambient
sulfonyl anion 10 is the favored nucleophile over the
negatively charged S-center in 9. Deprotonated N-sulfonylhydrazone 8 enters into the decomposition
cycle to generate a sulfinate molecule along with a new entity of
the deprotonated N-sulfonylhydrazone 8. The counter cation of the anionic species 8 influences
the ionic nature and thus reactivity of the ion pair in a nonsolvating
highly polar aprotic solvent, thereby affecting the overall outcome
of the reaction. An inspection of the reaction mechanism reveals that
substitution of the diazonium ion intermediate 12 with
an external ionic nucleophile that can outcompete the sulfonyl ion 9 toward nucleophilic displacement of 12 could
be possible. We will examine this in our continued study toward the
development of novel reactions of N-sulfonylhydrazones.
Scheme 8
Mechanism of the K2CO3-Catalyzed Sulfinate
Synthesis
Conclusions
In
summary, a practical, robust, and general method for the conversion
of N-sulfonylhydrazones to the corresponding sulfinates
using a catalytic amount of K2CO3 in DMEU has
been developed. The current reaction conditions are compatible with
several functional groups. N-Tosylhydrazones derived
from O-alkylated 2-hydroxyarylaldehydes show remarkable
reactivity. These catalytic conditions permit the synthesis of sulfinates
from N-tosylhydrazones derived from O-allylated and O-propargylated 2-hydrobenzaldehydes,
which commonly undergo the intramolecular [3 + 2]-cycloaddition reaction
in the presence of a stoichiometric amount of base. Sulfinates3r–t contain important functional groups
that readily react with electrophiles and thus could be exploited
toward the development of new chemistry of sulfinates.
Experimental
Section
General Experimental Details
Unless otherwise mentioned,
all chemicals received from commercial sources were used without purification.
All commercial-grade solvents were used without any purification.
Anhydrous solvents used in the reactions were obtained following standard
procedures. Column chromatography was performed on 60–120 mesh
silica gel using gradient mixture of ethyl acetate in hexanes as eluent.
HRMS spectra were recorded on a SCIEX G2-SQ TOF (U.S.) mass spectrometer. 1H and 13C NMR spectra were recorded on a Jeol JNM-ECS
spectrometer at operating frequencies of 400/500 MHz (1H) or 100/125 MHz (13C) as indicated in the individual
spectrum using TMS as an internal standard. Thin layer chromatography
was performed on aluminum plates (silica gel 60 PF254,
0.25 mm) purchased from Merck. Melting points were recorded in open
capillary and are uncorrected. The multiplicity in 1H NMR
spectra is presented as s for singlet, d for doublet, dd for doublet
of doublet, t for triplet, apt for apparently triplet, q for quartet,
ABq for AB-type quartet, and m for multiplet.N-Sulfonylhydrazones were synthesized from known carbonyl compounds
following the previously reported procedure.[18]N-Arylsulfonylhydrazides used for the synthesis N-arylsulfonylhydrazones were obtained following the reported[18,24] procedure from commercially available sulfonyl chlorides and hydrazine
hydrate. The 2-hydroxyarylaldehydes were O-alkylated
with alkyl 2-bromoacetate, benzyl chloride, allyl bromide, propargyl
bromide, and 2-bromoacetonitrile following the reported procedure.[22,23,25] Unless otherwise mentioned, all
sulfinates were synthesized following the experimental procedure mentioned
below.
General Experimental Procedure for the Synthesis of Sulfinates
N-Tosylhydrazone 1b (60.8 mg, 0.20
mmol) and dry DMEU (0.40 mL) were charged into a 10 mL vial fitted
with a magnetic stir bar and nitrogen inlet. The mixture was then
heated in a preheated oil bath at 110 °C to obtain a clear solution.
Anhydrous K2CO3 (2.6 mg, 0.02 mmol) was then
added to the clear solution, and stirring was continued at 110 °C
for 10 min.The reaction mixture was then cooled to rt, diluted with
ethyl acetate (25 mL), washed with water (3 × 10 mL) and brine
(1 × 10 mL), dried over Na2SO4, and evaporated.
The crude product was purified by short silica gel column chromatography
using a 10 → 20% gradient mixture of ethyl acetate in hexanes
as eluent to obtain sulfinate 3b (45.2 mg, 82% yield)
as a colorless oil.
N-Tosylhydrazone 1c (1.0 g, 2.61 mmol) and
dry DMEU (5.3 mL) were charged into a 10 mL vial fitted with a magnetic
stir bar and nitrogen inlet. The mixture was then placed in a preheated
oil bath at 110 °C to obtain a clear solution. Anhydrous K2CO3 (36 mg, 0.26 mmol) was then added to the clear
solution, and stirring was continued at 110 °C for 15 min. The
reaction mixture was then cooled to rt, diluted with ethyl acetate
(50 mL), washed with water (3 × 20 mL) and brine (1 × 15
mL), dried over Na2SO4, and evaporated. The
crude product was purified by short silica gel column chromatography
using a 10 → 20% gradient mixture of ethyl acetate in hexanes
as eluent to obtain sulfinate 3c (820 mg, 82% yield)
as a light yellow oil.