The interactions of proteins and other molecules and their adsorption onto substrates is a fascinating topic that has been applied to surface technologies, biosensors, corrosion studies, biotechnologies, and other fields. The success of these applications requires a previous characterization using some analytical techniques that, ordinarily, are not electrochemical. This work proposes analyzing the variation of the double-layer capacitance obtained through impedance electrochemical spectroscopy as an alternative strategy to show evidence of the interactions between proteins and triblock copolymers. The proposal is supported through the study of the interaction and adsorption of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and a commercial triblock copolymer (P103) in phosphate buffer on a gold electrode. The double-layer capacitance and the apparent interface thickness vs polarization potential curves as well as the potential of zero charge for pure P103 (0.6 wt %, corresponding to 6 g L-1), pure BSA (3 mg mL-1), and P103-BSA solutions (0.6 wt % and 3 mg mL-1, respectively) are sensitive enough to show not only the interaction and the adsorption of the species but also the polarization potential where these interactions are taking place. A qualitative and quantitative analysis concerning the double-layer capacitance behavior is given. The significance and impact of this work is also presented.
The interactions of proteins and other molecules and their adsorption onto substrates is a fascinating topic that has been applied to surface technologies, biosensors, corrosion studies, biotechnologies, and other fields. The success of these applications requires a previous characterization using some analytical techniques that, ordinarily, are not electrochemical. This work proposes analyzing the variation of the double-layer capacitance obtained through impedance electrochemical spectroscopy as an alternative strategy to show evidence of the interactions between proteins and triblock copolymers. The proposal is supported through the study of the interaction and adsorption of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and a commercial triblock copolymer (P103) in phosphate buffer on a gold electrode. The double-layer capacitance and the apparent interface thickness vs polarization potential curves as well as the potential of zero charge for pure P103 (0.6 wt %, corresponding to 6 g L-1), pure BSA (3 mg mL-1), and P103-BSA solutions (0.6 wt % and 3 mg mL-1, respectively) are sensitive enough to show not only the interaction and the adsorption of the species but also the polarization potential where these interactions are taking place. A qualitative and quantitative analysis concerning the double-layer capacitance behavior is given. The significance and impact of this work is also presented.
The studies of interactions between proteins and metallic surfaces
have had a positive impact on several biological, sensor, and applied
biotechnological areas. For example, the study of protein adsorption
on solid electrodes and its interaction with the surrounding medium
is fundamental for the development of biosensors, medical implants,
drug delivery systems, and switchable membranes, among others.[1−8] The adsorption of proteins on metallic surfaces depends on several
physical and chemical aspects, such as protein concentration, pH,
salt concentration, and ionic strength of the medium, surface charge
of the substrate, isoelectric point, and electrostatic interaction
at the protein/metal interface. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and
ellipsometry are techniques that have been used to characterize protein
adsorption on metallic surfaces and its interactions with the medium.[2,9] However, electrochemical techniques are adequate and highly sensitive
for successfully evaluating not only the protein adsorption–desorption
process on electrodes but also its possible denaturation at the surface.
Techniques such as cyclic voltammetry (CV) and electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy (EIS), along with electrochemical quartz crystal micro-
and nanobalance and double-layer capacitance measurements, have been
applied to the study of adsorption–desorption processes of
proteins and emulsions on metallic electrodes.[9−16] According to the results, where bovine serum albumin (BSA) and human
serum albumin have been the most studied proteins, the electrochemical
techniques adequately demonstrate the adsorption–desorption
process as a function of protein concentration, substrate charge,
pH, and polarization potentials, allowing studies in the presence
and absence of charge transfer. The versatility of the electrochemical
techniques and the information acquired in the study of protein adsorption
has increased their application, and thus, they are currently preferred
over optical techniques for many researchers.[11]Beyond the knowledge of the adsorption–desorption process
of proteins, the scientific community is now interested in the interactions
between proteins and other molecules, such as polymers and copolymers
and biomolecules, such as polysaccharides. The main advances in this
topic are focused on the interactions between triblock copolymers
and proteins.[17−20] The interest in these kinds of interactions is due to the biocompatibility
of the formed molecules, the acquired capacity to form micelles at
low concentrations, and the increased facility to penetrate into cellular
membranes, allowing drug deliveries[19,20] as well as
possibilities in design for either biomaterials or biosensor surfaces.[21−24] The use of measurements such as conductivity, UV–Vis spectrophotometry,
electron paramagnetic resonance and SPR has been commonly applied
to characterize the interactions between proteins and triblock copolymers.[17−20] According to the literature, proteins and triblock copolymers interact
either by electrostatic or hydrophobic effects. These effects modify
the physical and chemical properties of both molecules. However, as
reported in the literature,[25] although
the ability of triblock copolymers to reduce protein adsorption is
known, the detailed procedure involved in this phenomenon has not
yet been clarified. Other interesting studies are those concerning
polymers blends such as miscible homopolymer–copolymer pair.[26−29] In those studies, the miscibility in polymer–polymer systems
is studied using calorimetric techniques and thermogravimetric analysis.It should be noted that electrochemical studies concerning these
interactions are scarcer and the most common imply the adsorption
of the triblock copolymers or the proteins in an isolated manner.[9−16,24,25] The aim of this work is to study the triblock copolymer–protein–electrode
interactions from the fundamental point of view of double-layer capacitance
as calculated from EIS measurements and to obtain information about
the behavior and apparent size of the interface formed by the adsorbed
species on a gold disc electrode at different temperatures. The information
obtained from this study is important in sensor and bio-surface design
based on the detection of protein liberation or a reduced protein
adsorption process in micelles. These processes can be sensed through
the double-layer capacitance variations analytically measured by the
abovementioned technique as a temperature function. Thus, the effect
of the temperature could be evaluated avoiding the use of calorimeters.The protein and copolymer studied are BSA and Pluronic P103, respectively.
The Pluronic P103 triblock copolymer is formed with sequential blocks
of poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) and poly(propylene oxide) (PPO) in the
form of PEO-PPO-PEO with the structure of PEO17PPO60PEO17.[24,25] P103 was chosen due
to its low toxicity, biodegradability, and tendency to form micelles
in the range of 0.2–1 wt %. These properties make it an excellent
vehicle for drug delivery.[20] On the other
hand, BSA was selected because it is a model globular protein, and
several sources of information concerning its adsorption on metallic
surfaces are available.[18]The study
is focused on evaluating the double-layer capacitance
as a function of the polarization potentials at 25, 30, and 40 °C
for three systems: (i) pure P103 (0.6 wt %, corresponding to 6 g L–1), (ii) pure BSA (3 mg mL–1), and
iii) mixtures of P103-BSA (0.6 wt % and 3 mg mL–1, respectively). Well-defined changes in the double-layer capacitance
values of each system are highly desirable to show evidence of modifications
at the interface associated with the interaction of each one of the
studied species. The interest of this study is focused on the polarization
potential effect in the selective adsorption of both molecules as
well as the interface thickness. However, particular emphasis is placed
in the polarization range in which BSA protein is not denaturalized,
which implies the absence of charge transfer and is a state ensured
at the open-circuit potential. Furthermore, the potential of zero
charge, obtained from the double-layer capacitance curves, is presented
and analyzed through the classical electrochemical double-layer theory.
Thus, the favorable polarization range where the adsorption and interaction
of each studied species is shown. The calculation of the apparent
interface thickness as a function of the polarization potential at
constant temperature is also shown. For all the studied systems, cyclic
voltammetry at a wide polarization potential range is presented to
complement the information. In a further work, a thermodynamic analysis
will be presented.A deep discussion about the results and their
application to sensing
proteins and triblock copolymers is presented.
Materials
and Methods
Materials and Solutions
PluronicP103 (average molecular weight, 4950 g mol–1) was
obtained from BASF, and BSA protein (average molecular weight, 66,430
g mol–1) was acquired from Sigma-Aldrich. Both reagents
were used as received. A 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS), containing
8 g L–1 NaCl, 0.2 g L–1 KCl, 2.68
g L–1 Na2HPO4·5H2O, and 0.216 g L–1 NaH2PO4 was used to maintain each studied solution at a pH of 7.2–7.4.
The above PBS solution was used to prepare three different solutions:
(i) pure P103 (0.6 wt %, corresponding to 6 g L–1), (ii) pure BSA (3 mg mL–1), and (iii) mixtures
of P103-BSA (0.6 wt % and 3 mg mL–1, respectively).
The selected BSA concentration was in the range typically studied
in other works,[18] while the P103 concentration
was selected to ensure a micellar structure.[20]A scheme of the solution preparation is shown in Figure . All solutions were
prepared with HPLC grade water.
Figure 1
Solution preparation: schematic representation.
Solution preparation: schematic representation.
Electrochemical Measurements
A typical
three-electrode cell was used. The working electrode was a gold disc
electrode (2 mm in diameter, 0.031 cm2), a platinum electrode
was used as the counter electrode, and a saturated calomel electrode
(SCE) was used as the reference electrode. Before any experiment,
the working electrode was first polished with an alumina slurry of
0.5 μm, rinsed with distilled water, and dried with compressed
air.The electrochemical response of P103 and BSA pure solutions
and P103-BSA solutions in PBS medium was acquired first by CV and
then by EIS at the concentrations cited above. The experiments were
performed at 25, 30, and 40 °C.The CV measurements were
obtained in the potential range of −1
to 1 V vs SCE at 100 mV/s in 0.1 M PBS. Two different kinds of EIS
experiments were carried out. The first experiments were performed
at the open-circuit potential (OCP). A potential perturbation amplitude
of 10 mV and a frequency range of 10 kHz to 1 mHz were applied. Seven
points per logarithmic decade were taken.The double-layer capacitance
response as a function of the polarization
potential was obtained from another set of EIS experiments performed
at 100 Hz and 10 mV of amplitude (these kinds of experiments are also
known as AC voltammetry). The same polarization range used in the
CV was used for the EIS measurements, but a sweep of 1 mV/s was employed
to ensure the quasi-steady state of the system. The double-layer capacitance
vs polarization potential curves were computed from the imaginary
part of these impedance measurements.All measurements were
carried out using an Autolab potentiostat
(PGSTAT 128N).
Results and Discussion
Voltammetry Characterization Experiments
First, the
electrochemical response was examined through the voltammetric
profiles of the gold electrode immersed in pure 0.1 M PBS, BSA, and
P103 pure solutions; subsequently, the electrochemical response of
the mixture of P103-BSA in PBS medium was analyzed. The typical voltammetric
responses of each of the studied solutions are shown in Figure .
Figure 2
Typical voltammetric
responses for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA, (c)
Au/P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C, respectively.
Typical voltammetric
responses for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA, (c)
Au/P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C, respectively.Since the interaction of P103 and BSA molecules
and their adsorption
onto gold electrodes in natural conditions imply the absence of any
faradaic process, the analysis of the voltammetric responses is centered
in the polarization potential interval where the interface behaves
as ideally polarizable. As seen in Figure a, the voltammetric response for a pure PBS
solution shows that, in a polarization potential range from −0.6
to 0.1 V vs SCE, the faradaic process is absent at the interface.In a polarization potential range from 0.1 to 0.4 V vs SCE, the
faradaic current observed in Figure a can be associated with a slight oxidation–reduction
of phosphate ions, while from 0.4 to 1 V vs SCE, the faradaic current
response is associated with the electrochemical response of the gold
electrode.[31] On the other hand, as observed
in Figure b–d,
the interface remains similar to that observed in Figure a. However, some appreciable
changes in the current magnitude are detected. Figure b reveals that BSA at 3 mg mL–1 strongly enhances the oxidation, dissolution, and reduction processes
of the gold substrate and thus modifies the polarization potential
range at which that process occurs. This behavior is more evident
at 25 and 30 °C. Conversely, when 0.6 wt % P103 is present in Figure c, the current associated
with the electrochemical process of the gold substrate decreases,
and a small cathodic peak, associated with some P103 reduction, is
observed at approximately 0.75 V vs SCE. This reduction peak can be
associated with the reduction of PEO, as has been previously evidenced.[30] Furthermore, the presence of P103 inhibits the
oxidation–reduction process of phosphate ions observed in Figure a. Nevertheless,
when BSA interacts with P103, as shown in Figure d, the polarization range where the interface
does not present any charge transfer increases, revealing that the
mixture of P103-BSA remains stable in the polarization interval from
−0.75 to 0.2 V vs SCE.
EIS and
Electrochemical Double-Layer Capacitance
Curves
Figure shows the response obtained from the first set of EIS experiments.
As observed at all temperatures, the typical Nyquist diagrams depict
the beginning of a large capacitive loop for the three systems studied.
This behavior is consistent with the OCP experimental condition corresponding
to null current flowing through the interface.
Figure 3
Nyquist diagrams obtained
at the OCP for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA,
(c) Au/ P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C,
respectively.
Nyquist diagrams obtained
at the OCP for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA,
(c) Au/ P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C,
respectively.The impedance responses show a
non-ideal double-layer capacitance
behavior associated with the electrochemical double-layer rearrangements,
which are clearly sensitive to the presence of BSA and P103 in a pure
solution and the interaction of P103-BSA molecules, as depicted by
the frequency impedance distribution observed in Figure b–d.More detailed
information concerning the interaction between the
adsorbate and substrate and its associated response to the electrochemical
double layer is acquired through the double-layer capacitance curves
calculated using the second set of EIS measurements. In these curves,
the effect of the polarization potential on the double-layer capacitance
is shown, and the polarization range where the adsorption and interaction
between the substrate and adsorbate are enhanced or inhibited is determined. Figure a–d shows
the double-layer capacitance C for pure 0.1 M PBS,
BSA at 3 mg mL–1, 0.6 wt % P103, and P103-BSA solution
at the cited concentrations in PBS medium, respectively. The effect
of a wide polarization range at the three studied temperatures is
demonstrated.
Figure 4
Double-layer capacitance curves for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA,
(c)
Au/ P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C, respectively.
Double-layer capacitance curves for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA,
(c)
Au/ P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103 0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C, respectively.An analysis of the double-layer capacitance curves
allowed the
potential of zero charge (PZC) for each one of the interfaces to be
obtained. Based on the classical capacitance double-layer theory,
the PZC is located between two maxima.[32,33] For a capacitive
process, the double-layer capacitance reaches its minimum in a polarization
potential range where faradaic reactions are negligible. This polarization
range was previously determined by CV. It should be noted that, when Figure shows at least two
local minima for each system, the one observed at positive potentials
is related to the changes of the interface due to the faradaic process
associated with either the PBS, BSA, or P103 compounds or oxidation
of the gold substrate. The above results can also be observed in Figure a–d. Thus,
the PZC for each of the interfaces studied is located at negative
polarization potentials, and the following discussion concerns this
polarization zone.The Au/PBS interface (Figure a) presents its PZC at approximately −0.55
V
vs SCE. The PZC is clearly observed by a broad minimum that slightly
varies as a function of temperature. The temperature effect is more
clearly evidenced in the interfacial double-layer capacitance values,
where the lowest values are reached at 30 °C (blue line), while
the highest values are obtained at 25 ° C (black line). In agreement
with Figure a and
according to the double-layer capacitance theory,[32,33] for polarization potentials more positive than PZC, −0.55
V vs SCE, the working electrode possesses a positive charge, and subsequently,
the phosphate ions are adsorbed onto its surface until the polarization
potential reaches 0.15 V vs SCE. At this polarization potential, a
maximum in the double-layer capacitance curve defines the end of the
capacitive response, and the beginning of faradaic effects on the
double-layer capacitance behavior begins.According to Figure b, the interface
changes its capacitive behavior in the presence
of BSA solution in PBS medium. The double-layer capacitance curves
show that the PZC strongly depends on both the temperature and polarization
potential. In this way, a very well-defined minimum at approximately
−0.6 V vs SCE. is obtained at 30 and 40 °C (blue and red
lines, respectively), while at 25 °C (black line), a wide polarization
zone achieves lower values for the double-layer capacitance, reaching
its minimum value at approximately −0.4 V vs SCE. It should
be noted that, regardless of the temperature effect, in all cases,
the electrode has a negative charge at more negative potentials than
each of the PZCs found in Figure b. The adsorption of BSA on the gold electrode will
depend on both the substrate and the BSA charge. The charge of the
BSA molecule is influenced by the pH of the medium. Since BSA possesses
an isoelectric point at a pH of 4.7,[34] it
will present a positive charge at the pH used in this work. Then,
the adsorption of BSA is favorable at more negative polarization potentials
than the observed PZC for the Au/BSA interface. Taking this into account
and according to the PZC obtained in Figure a,b at 25 °C, a competitive adsorption
of phosphate ions and the BSA protein is presented in a polarization
range from −0.4 to −0.55 V vs SCE, while at more negative
potentials, only the protein adsorption is greater. Competitive adsorption
is not present at the highest temperatures (30 and 40 °C), where
only the adsorption of the protein is favorable at more negative polarization
potentials than the PZC.On the other hand, in Figure b, at 30 and 40 °C, in
addition to the polarization
zone in which the interface gets its PZC, the capacitance curves depict
a shoulder at −0.3 V vs SCE. This behavior has also been observed
in other interfaces,[33,35] and as observed in those interfaces,
the shoulder is related to a relaxation and rearrangement of the interface,
which in turn could imply the desorption of the protein caused by
the positive charge at the electrode and the adsorption process of
the phosphate ions. These processes change the behavior of the interface
and modify the double-layer capacitance response, causing the feature
response observed in the curve.The changes in the double-layer
capacitance response as a function
of the temperature are almost negligible when a pure P103 solution
in PBS medium is studied, as shown in Figure c. As observed, the double-layer capacitance
does not show any minima but instead exhibits a polarization zone
from −0.6 to 0.1 V vs SCE, where the capacitance curves present
the typical “pit” associated with the adsorption of
neutral molecules such as triblock copolymers.[33,36,37] In this polarization range, the adsorption
of P103 is favorable. Furthermore, since the P103 is in PBS medium,
it should be highlighted that, according to Figure a, phosphate ions should also be adsorbed
in a polarization range from −0.55 to 0.15 V vs SCE. However,
according to Figure c, P103 adsorption prevails.Table summarizes
the behavior of the studied interfaces and presents the polarization
range in which adsorptions are favorable.
Table 1
Summary
of the Double-Layer and Adsorption
Properties for Au/PBS, Au/BSA, and Au/P103 Interfaces (P103 0.6 wt
%, BSA 3 mg mL–1)
interface
adsorbate,
charge
PZC
favorable
adsorption
observations
Au/PBS
phosphates, negative
–0.55 V
0.15 V > E > −0.55 V at all temperatures
adsorption of phosphates
Au/BSA (in
PBS medium)
protein, positive
25 °C
–0.4
V
–0.4 V > E > −1 V
phosphates and protein adsorption
from −0.4 to −0.55 V
30 °C
–0.6 V
–0.6 V > E > −1
V
protein adsorption
40 °C
–0.6 V
–0.6 V > E > −1 V
protein adsorption
Au/P103 (in PBS medium)
P103, neutral
0.1 V > E > −0.6
V at all temperatures
capacitive pit, adsorption
of P103 and phosphates
On the other hand, Figure d presents the modification of the double-layer
capacitance
when the gold electrode is immersed in the P103-BSA in PBS medium.
In this case, the behavior of the capacitance curves depicts a similar
behavior to that observed for a solution of PBS containing only the
protein (Figure b);
however, more pronounced changes in the double-layer capacitance values
are observed in a polarization potential range between −0.8
and 0.18 V vs SCE. Furthermore, the minimum associated with the PZC
is slightly different from that observed in Figure b, reaching a polarization potential ranging
from −0.56 to −0.5 V vs SCE, depending on the temperature.
The similarity in the capacitance curve profiles observed in Figure b,d is more evident
at the highest temperatures (blue and red lines), while at 25 °C
(black line), the shape of the capacitance curve reaches lower values
in a narrower polarization zone (−0.5 V vs SCE) compared to
the response obtained in the absence of P103. It should be noted that,
in all the temperatures tested, Figure d shows a more pronounced shoulder compared to the
one observed in Figure b. This pronounced shoulder is associated with a more prominent relaxation
and rearrangement of the interface caused by the interactions between
PBS, BSA, P103, and the electrode. According to Table and the PZC obtained in Figure d, the interface relaxation
and its rearrangements include the competitive adsorption of phosphate
ions and P103 copolymer, along with BSA desorption.The behavior
of double-layer capacitance, observed in Figure , is sensitive enough
to detect the changes in the interphase induced by the presence of
each species studied in an isolated manner and their interactions
when all of them are added to the working solution.The charge
of the electrode and the preferential adsorption of
certain adsorbates strongly depend on the polarization potential.
Envisaging the utility of this study in the fields of biomedicine
and bioengineering for the design of sensors, an analysis of the Au/P103-BSA
interface at the open-circuit potential (OCP) is quite interesting.
For the conditions presented in Figure d, the OCP is approximately 0.14 V vs SCE. At this
polarization potential, the electrode possesses a positive charge,
and the desorption of BSA occurs. At the same time, the phosphates
and neutral P103 polymer are at the polarization potential limit where
their adsorption is electrostatically favorable but are tending to
begin their desorption. If the interaction and adsorption of P103
and BSA is required, then a polarization potential more negative than
OCP, which avoids the electrochemical denaturation of the protein,
should be fixed for the electrode. For instance, at −0.6 V
vs SCE, the adsorption of P103 and BSA as well as interactions among
them is highly plausible. Additionally, according to Figure , at this polarization potential,
no electrochemical reaction is affecting the protein. Thus, it is
proven that well-defined changes in the double-layer capacitance values,
as shown in Figure d, allow sensing the adsorption/desorption process and qualitatively
reveals interactions between the protein and the triblock copolymer.
Apparent Interface Thickness
Even
though the polarization potential and temperature are parameters that
strongly modify the values of the double-layer capacitance as well
as the substrate charge, other properties influence the double-layer
structure, such as those inherent to the adsorbates, i.e., charge,
structure, and conformation. These last properties are closely related
to the interface thickness and its dielectric nature.The simplest
model of the electrochemical double-layer theory[33] establishes that the double-layer capacitance value C is inversely proportional to the interface thickness d, according to the following equation:where ε0 and
ε are the permittivities of vacuum and the medium, respectively.If the permittivity of the medium is known and the double-layer
capacitance values are measured, as in this study, the interface thickness
can be calculated. However, the permittivity value of the PBS/P103-BSA
mixed medium has not been previously reported. The permittivities
of some triblock copolymers and BSA have been studied independently,
and the main results are known.[37−40] It is well known that the dielectric constant of
P103 strongly depends on its mass fraction %, reaching an average
value of approximately 1.5 for P103 between zero and 50 wt %.[39] On the other hand, numerous values of the dielectric
constant for BSA are reported without consensus.[41] It is accepted that the dielectric constant value of BSA
depends on the frequency, hydration, temperature, and weight percentage.
Dielectric values ranging from 4 to 70 are reported.[34] In general, the frequency dielectric dispersion of BSA
is reported and related to its own protein relaxations, which are
associated to its structure and sequence.[40,41]Thus, even when the interface thickness d cannot
be calculated from eq , the permittivity value for the mixed medium, PBS/P103-BSA, is required;
the relation of ε0/C, which is known,
can be calculated from eq to obtain the apparent interface thickness parameter d*, as shown in eq :where d*
is the relation of the double-layer length and the variation of the
medium permittivity. The value of d* can bring some
qualitative and indirect insight into the structure or conformation
in which P103 and BSA interact and become adsorbed at the gold electrode.
Similar approximations have been performed previously in other studies.[42−44]Figure shows
the
variations of the apparent interface thickness d*
as a function of the polarization potential where faradaic reactions
are absent. The effect of the three studied temperatures is presented.
The apparent interface thickness is calculated by capacitance data
shown in Figure ,
the value of the permittivity of vacuum, and eq .
Figure 5
Apparent interface thickness as a function of
polarization potentials
for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA, (c) Au/P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103
0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). The apparent interface
thicknesses were calculated from eq . Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C,
respectively.
Apparent interface thickness as a function of
polarization potentials
for (a) Au/PBS, (b) Au/BSA, (c) Au/P103, and (d) Au/P103-BSA (P103
0.6 wt %, BSA 3 mg mL–1). The apparent interface
thicknesses were calculated from eq . Black, blue, and red lines for 25, 30, and 40 °C,
respectively.As observed in Figure , we can conclude that, at
all the temperatures and for the
whole polarization range, the apparent interface thickness reaches
its greatest values when the gold electrode is immersed in pure PBS
solution (Figure a)
and suggests that the double-layer structure is not compact but diffuse.The above finding is in good agreement with the well-known weak
adsorption of phosphate ions, which are related to the ion size and
solvation energies and are translated into a broad electrochemical
double-layer structure, as concluded by Anson.[45] However, the structure of the electrochemical double layer,
associated with d*, is clearly modified when BSA
and P103 are present. For instance, at approximately −0.6 V
vs SCE, when adsorption of both BSA and P103 is favorable, the interface
becomes more compact, reaching intermediate apparent thickness values
for P103 (Figure c).
The thickness decreases in a more accentuated way when BSA and P103
are interacting (Figure d), and the electrochemical double layer reaches the most compact
apparent thickness in the presence of BSA (Figure b). The apparent thickness shown in Figure d at −0.6
V vs SCE could be presumably associated with the protein–P103
interaction as a global species; however, the acquisition of a particular
conformation requires other studies.The apparent
thickness values and behavior obtained in Figure b,d are similar.
This behavior is also observed in the double-layer capacitance curves.
The apparent thickness of the interface presents an appreciable change
in its shape at a polarization of approximately −0.3 V vs SCE.
This effect confirms the relaxation of the interface, which in turn
can be associated with a change in the structure or conformation of
the adsorbate.[33,35]On the other hand, in Figure b–d, it is
evident that increasing the temperature
induces a decrease in the apparent thickness of the electrochemical
double layer. Thus, the adsorption of proteins could be similarly
seen as the adsorption of organic molecules on metal electrodes, where
it causes a decrease in the double-layer capacitance values.[12,42]If the analysis is performed around 0.14 V vs SCE, corresponding
to the OCP, it is possible to note from Figure d that the interface has lower apparent thickness
values, reaching 17, 13, and 11 pm for 25 (black line), 30 (blue line),
and 40 °C (red line), respectively. These values are appreciably
lower than those obtained at 0.14 V vs SCE for Au/PBS (Figure a), Au/PBS+BSA (Figure b), and Au/PBS+P103 (Figure c). Considering that,
at this polarization potential, the BSA protein is not being adsorbed,
the results indicate that at 0.14 V vs SCE; the presence of either
phosphate ions or P103 copolymer inside the interphase and their adsorption
on the electrode is incipient, so the apparent thickness is low. This
fact emphasizes that, at the OCP, the P103 and phosphate ions tend
to be desorbed, which is in good agreement with the discussion presented
in the previous section. Thus, d* is sensitive to
the adsorption–desorption and interaction of the studied adsorbates.If the highest interaction between the phosphate ions and both
the protein and the Pluronic is required, a more negative polarization
potential than the OCP shall be applied to the substrate, as is stated
in the previous section. According to the double-layer capacitance
curves and Table ,
a polarization potential between −0.5 and −0.6 V vs
SCE is adequate to induce the interaction of P103 and BSA and its
adsorption as a global species. As can be noted in Figure d, in a polarization potential
range from −0.5 to −0.6 V vs SCE, the interface acquires
greater apparent thickness values of approximately 33, 27, and 24
pm at 25 (black line), 30 (blue line), and 40 °C (red line),
respectively. These apparent thickness values are higher than those
obtained at the OCP, which can be related to the adsorption of BSA
and P103 polymer. Furthermore, according to the well-differentiated
curve shape and the values obtained, the double-layer capacitance
measurements and the calculation of the apparent interface thickness
through eq is considered
an adequate analytical method for sensing the protein–triblockpolymer interactions.It should be noted that, even when at
−0.5 to −0.6
V vs SCE, the adsorption of phosphate ions is not favorable, the phosphate
ion presence will influence the ionic strength, and then the interaction
between BSA and P103 will clearly modify the structure of the BSA
protein. It is well known that several structures are possible for
the adsorption of pluronics[46−50] and proteins.[5,51,52] These structures are dependent on the ionic strength of the medium,[53] which in our study is given by the phosphate
ions.Subsequently, it should be noted that the conformation
and structure
of the adsorbed global species strongly depends either on the critical
micellar concentration (cmc) or temperature (cmt) of the P103triblockpolymer as well as the structural conformation of the protein. For
the particular case of the H2O/P103triblock polymer, accurate
phase diagrams are already published,[46,47] and as a consequence,
the microstructure formed by P103 is well known. However, these structures
cannot be considered in this work because the buffer used has a different
ionic strength that modifies the P103 physical properties, mainly
its conformational structure. Furthermore, the adsorption of surfactants
on surfaces could lead to the formation of adsorbed structures as
admicelles or hemimicelles. The same consideration is valid for the
conformations of BSA.[51−53] Due to its nature as a natural polyelectrolyte, its
structure strongly depends on the ionic strength of the buffer. Consequently,
a new phase diagram using further techniques, such as rheological,
optical, or dispersion, is required to obtain the microstructure and
conformation of the global species adsorbed on the electrode.
Significance, Impact, and Possible Future
Work
The development of biosensors, biomaterials, biochips,
and modified nanoparticles for drug delivery, along with other technologically
applied fields, requires a deep understanding of the biomolecule-modified
substrate interactions and the implementation of an optimal analytical
method to detect them in an accurate way.Concerning the albumin
proteins and triblock copolymer interactions, this work successfully
demonstrates that using simple electrochemical techniques is viable.
The electrostatic effect plays an important role in the mechanism
of interaction and influences the adsorption between BSA and P103copolymer, showing that at −0.6 V vs SCE, a strong interaction
is reached. Obtaining optimal polarization ranges where the interaction
is maximum is a key topic for biomaterials and self-organized film
template development, as demonstrated in the studies presented by
Palacio et al.,[54] Liu et al.,[55] Chang et al.,[56] and
others.[57] Furthermore, by using electrochemical
methods, the use of more sophisticated techniques, such as those used
in,[54,55] namely, atomic force microscopy, small-angle
X-ray, and other physical methods, is avoided.On the other
hand, the detection of albumin proteins is important
due to its essential function in blood plasma. Colorimetry and fluorescence
spectroscopy are techniques used for their detection; however, both
have disadvantages in their estimation or selectivity.[23] Some selective albumin sensors have been designed;
however, they have shown inconveniencies related to their complex
fabrication, control, or cost. The molecularly imprinted electrochemical
sensors using macromolecular templates[23,24] or those in
which more sophisticated electrodes such as semiconductors[14] or coated-quartz crystal resonators[16,54] are used are representative examples of this type of sensor. According
to our results, a conventional gold electrode immersed in P103triblockcopolymer solution is sensitive to the interactions and adsorption/desorption
process of BSA, which is evidenced by well-defined changes in double-layer
capacitance values or the behavior of the apparent interface thickness
as a function of polarization potentials. In this way, the experimental
setup and the double-layer capacitance measurements presented in this
work are considered a possible analytical method to sense, in a simple
way, the interactions between BSA and P103. However, validation of
this method requires further research.
Conclusions
A fundamental and analytical electrochemical adsorption study of
PBS, BSA protein, and P103 triblock copolymer onto a gold electrode
was conducted via EIS measurements and double-layer capacitance curves
using a wide polarization range at three different temperatures. A
detailed analysis of these curves allowed us to detect the interactions
between PBS-BSA-P103 molecules.From the obtained double-layer
capacitance curves, it was possible
to determine the PZC for each of the interfaces studied. A discussion
concerning the polarization potential range in which the adsorption
of each species studied is favorable is presented in detail. Furthermore,
based on the simplest model of the electrochemical double-layer theory,
the apparent interface thickness was obtained.The results help
provide understanding of the electrostatic effect
during the interaction of PBS, BSA, and P103 in the interface. The
focus was on the OCP, where the lowest double-layer apparent thickness
values are obtained, showing that, at this polarization potential,
the adsorption of BSA is electrostatically impeded while the desorption
of phosphate ions and P103 copolymer begins.The interaction
of P103 and BSA and its adsorption is only favorable
at more negative polarization potentials than the OCP. The optimal
polarization potential is between −0.5 and −0.6 V vs
SCE, where BSA and P103 are adsorbed as a global species, causing
a higher apparent interface thickness of approximately 33, 27, and
24 pm at 25, 30, and 40 °C, respectively.The acquisition
of a particular conformation and structure of adsorbate
PBS-BSA and P103, as a global species, requires further studies using
other techniques, such as rheological, optical, or dispersive methods.
Authors: J G Alvarez-Ramírez; V V A Fernández; E R Macías; Y Rharbi; P Taboada; R Gámez-Corrales; J E Puig; J F A Soltero Journal: J Colloid Interface Sci Date: 2009-02-03 Impact factor: 8.128
Authors: Edgar B Figueroa-Ochoa; Eva M Villar-Alvarez; Adriana Cambón; Dharmista Mistry; José Llovo; David Attwood; Silvia Barbosa; J F Armando Soltero; Pablo Taboada Journal: Int J Pharm Date: 2016-06-08 Impact factor: 5.875