Potential Influences of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Drug Use and HIV Care Among People Living with HIV and Substance Use Disorders: Experience from a Pilot mHealth Intervention.

People living with HIV (PLWH) and substance use disorder (SUD) are particularly vulnerable to harmful health consequences of the global COVID-19 pandemic. The health and social consequences of the pandemic may exacerbate substance misuse and poor management of HIV among this population. This study compares substance use and HIV care before and during the pandemic using data collected weekly through an opioid relapse prevention and HIV management mobile-health intervention. We found that during the pandemic, PLWH and SUD have increased illicit substance use and contact with other substance-using individuals and decreased their confidence to stay sober and attend recovery meetings. The proportion of people missing their HIV medications also increased, and confidence to attend HIV follow-up appointments decreased. Optimal support for PLWH and SUD is critical during pandemics like COVID-19, as drug-related and HIV antiretroviral therapy (ART) non-adherence risks such as overdose, unsafe sexual behaviors, and transmission of infectious diseases may unfold.

Introduction

On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a global pandemic [1]. COVID-19 is an illness caused by a novel betacoronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, which typically causes common cold symptoms and may cause severe pneumonia, respiratory failure, and even death [2]. Infection was first reported in late 2019 in Wuhan, China [3] and has since then spread rapidly across the globe from person to person through respiratory droplets [2].

Millions of Americans are experiencing the detrimental effects of this health, economic, and social crisis. Among the various marginalized communities who already suffer significant social and economic disadvantages and often live with poverty, health inequities, and other burdens are people living with HIV (PLWH) [4-6]. As the COVID-19 pandemic increases stress, anxiety, fear, sadness, and loneliness, PLWH, who are already disproportionately burdened by mental illness [7], are particularly vulnerable to worsening mental health. Conditions may be especially exacerbated among PLWH who have other medical comorbidities or poorly managed HIV (e.g. a low CD4 cell count or high viral load), and are more susceptible to severe illness from COVID-19 [8]. Poor mental health and social isolation are both strong risk factors for substance use disorders (SUDs), which also disproportionately affects PLWH [9, 10]. Increased substance use, which is highly correlated with risky sexual behavior and antiretroviral therapy (ART) non-adherence, has many dangerous consequences including overdose death and transmission of HIV and other blood borne diseases [11-15]. Therefore, it is important to monitor substance use behaviors among PLWH during the COVID-19 pandemic to prevent drug-related risks.

Medical providers and public health services have taken drastic measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19, including canceling face-to-face visits and even closing clinics altogether. Mobile-health applications may provide a useful tool to collect data and retain PLWH and SUD in care during pandemics like COVID-19. Prior to the introduction of COVID-19, an existing mobile-health application, called A-CHESS, was implemented among PLWH and SUDs in Wisconsin to reduce substance use and improve HIV outcomes. The A-CHESS platform, described in detail elsewhere [16], was developed by the Center for Health Enhancement System Studies at the University of Wisconsin-Madison to support people with opioid use disorders. Key features of A-CHESS include public and private discussion forums, cognitive behavioral therapy boosters, games and relaxation activities to distract from cravings, hepatitis C virus and HIV educational information, and more [16, 17]. The goals of this ongoing pilot project are to tailor the A-CHESS application to meet the complex needs of PLWH and SUD and test the effectiveness among this population. The aims of this paper are to determine whether (1a) substance use, including alcohol, marijuana, and other illicit substances, and (1b) precursors to substance use, including confidence to stay sober, recovery support meeting attendance, and being around other people using drugs, have increased and (2a) HIV ART adherence and (2b) confidence to attend their next HIV appointment have decreased during the COVID-19 pandemic among PWLH and SUD enrolled in this pilot project.

Methods

Overview

Research coordinators identified PLWH and SUD who were at high risk for treatment failure at HIV clinics in Wisconsin through provider referrals and by reviewing clinic’s administrative databases. Enrollment began March 2019 and ended March 2020. Study participants have access to all A-CHESS support tools and are delivered brief surveys weekly to assess their general health status, mood, social support, drug use, and ART adherence for 12 months.

Setting and Timeline

Wisconsin is among the many regions heavily impacted by COVID-19, changing everyday lives as the sequence of events unfolded in early 2020. On February 5, the first case of COVID-19 was detected in Wisconsin. As the number of confirmed cases rose to seven on March 12, the governor of Wisconsin declared a State of Emergency. The next day, on March 13, he ordered all public and private K-12 schools to close by March 18. That same day, the President of the United States addressed the nation and declared the pandemic a national emergency. As confirmed cases in Wisconsin reached 72 on March 17, the governor announced a statewide ban on all gatherings with more than 10 people, and 1 week later, on March 24, a ‘Safer at Home’ order went into effect, ordering the closure of all non-essential businesses and urging citizens to stay at home to reduce the spread of COVID-19. As of May 4th, 2020, there were 8599 confirmed cases state-wide, but health officials warn that many more people are likely infected [18].

This study compares drug and alcohol use and HIV care reported on weekly surveys completed 6 weeks prior to a State of Emergency being declared in Wisconsin, from January 31 to March 12, to surveys completed 6 weeks after the ‘Safer at Home’ order went into effect, from March 24 to May 4. All weekly surveys completed during the period of rapidly spreading COVID-19 infections and changing government responses, from March 13 to March 23, were excluded because awareness and responsiveness to the pandemic varied substantially across the population.

Measures

Each week individuals were asked whether they used alcohol, marijuana, and other illicit drugs (including heroin, prescription opioids, cocaine, methamphetamine, or sedatives) in the past 7 days. They also were asked weekly whether they were around people using drugs when they were not expecting to be (yes or no), to rate their confidence to stay clean and sober on a scale from 1 (not confident at all) to 7 (very confident), and to rate their recovery support meeting attendance on a scale from 1 (no meetings) to 7 (many meetings).

Two HIV outcomes were assessed. First, individuals were asked on how many days in the past week they missed a dose of their HIV medications. Responses were dichotomized as < 2 days or ≥ 2 days, as missing 2 or more days in 1 week will likely cause viral rebound [19, 20]. Second, they were asked to rate their confidence to keep their next appointment with their HIV care provider on a scale from 1 (not confident at all) to 7 (very confident).

Statistical Methods

Mixed effects logistic regression models, using cluster-robust standard errors to account for repeated surveys by individuals, were used to determine the odds of using alcohol, marijuana, and other illicit drugs before and during the pandemic, as well as the odds of being around people using drugs when they were not expecting to be and the odds of missing their HIV medication on ≥ 2 days. Incidence rate ratios (IRRs) from mixed-effects Poisson regression, using cluster-robust standard errors, were used to compare individuals' confidence to stay clean and sober, recovery support meeting attendance, and confidence to keep their next HIV appointment. All regression models adjusted for gender, race, age, baseline employment status, whether they have ever been incarcerated, whether they have been diagnosed with a mental health disorder other than SUD, and whether they completed surveys during both study time periods or just one. A visual inspection of line graphs was used to understand trends before and during the pandemic. Chi-square and Fisher’s exact tests were conducted to compare baseline characteristics between individuals included in the pre-pandemic sample and those in the later period. To test our directional hypotheses, we used a one-tailed test and α = 0.05 to determine statistical significance. All analyses were conducted in Stata/SE 16 [21].

Results

Between January 31 and March 12, 2020, 60 individuals completed 194 weekly surveys, and between March 24 and May 4, 2020, 43 individuals completed 148 weekly surveys. The number of surveys taken by each individual ranged from 1 to 6 in each time period, and 39 individuals completed surveys during both periods. Among the 64 unique individuals included in this analysis, 75% were male, 59% were Black or African American, 9% were Hispanic or Latino, 66% had ever been incarcerated, 39% were employed at baseline, 39% had a spouse or significant other, 70% were ever diagnosed with a mental health disorder other than SUD, 8% were on medication-assisted treatment for addiction, and the mean age was 49 (Table 1). There were no statistically significant differences between those included in each study period.

Table 1

Baseline demographics of analytical sample (N = 64)

	N (%)
Male	48 (75)
Race
White	22 (34)
Black or African American	38 (59)
Mixed	1 (2)
Other	3 (5)
Hispanic or Latino	6 (9)
Ever incarcerated	42 (66)
Employed at baseline	25 (39)
Has a spouse/significant other	25 (39)
Receiving medication-assisted treatmenta	5 (8)
Diagnosed with a mental health disorder other than SUD	45 (70)
Mental health disorders
Anxiety/social anxiety	19 (30)
Bipolar/manic depression	11 (17)
Depression	33 (52)
Panic disorder	1 (2)
PTSD	5 (8)
Other	7 (11)

aOne individual was on Methadone, three were on Vivitrol, and one was on Suboxone

During the COVID-19 pandemic, there was no difference in the proportion of people using alcohol (41%) or marijuana (32%) compared to before the pandemic (Table 2). However, there was an increase in the proportion of people using other illicit substances (including heroin, prescription opioids, cocaine, methamphetamine, or sedatives), increasing from 10 to 18%. After adjusting for demographics, study participants were 2.09 times more likely to use other illicit substances (P = 0.181). During the pandemic, the proportion of people reporting being around people using drugs when they were not expecting to be doubled from 6 to 12% (P = 0.060). Likewise, during the pandemic individuals had a rate 0.886 times smaller in their confidence to stay sober (P = 0.007), and a rate 0.727 times smaller in recovery support meeting attendance (P = 0.001).

Table 2

Number (%) of surveys reporting alcohol/drug use and HIV risks before and during the COVID-19 pandemic

	Before pandemic (N = 194)	During pandemic (N = 148)	Odds ratio	Adjusteda P value
Alcohol	79 (41%)	60 (41%)	0.974	0.480
Marijuana	62 (32%)	47 (32%)	0.474	0.291
Other illicit drugsb	20 (10%)	27 (18%)	2.09	0.181
Around people using drugs	12 (6%)	18 (12%)	2.53	0.060
Mean confidence rating for staying clean and sober	5.35	4.77	0.886c	0.007
Recovery support meeting attendance rating	3.02	2.24	0.727c	0.001
Missed ART dose on 2 or more days of the week	10 (5%)	18 (12%)	2.81	0.042
Mean confidence rating to keep next appointment with HIV care provider	6.89	6.50	0.918c	0.021

Bold: statistically significant at α = 0.05 using a one-tailed test

aAdjusted for gender, race, age, baseline employment status, whether they have ever been incarcerated, and whether they have been diagnosed with a mental health disorder other than SUD

bOther illicit drugs includes heroin, prescription opioids, cocaine, methamphetamine, and sedatives

cIncidence Rate Ratio reported

During the pandemic, the proportion of participants missing their HIV medications 2 or more days per week significantly increased, from 5 to 12%, compared to before the pandemic (P = 0.042). Similarly, there was a statistically significant decrease in individual’s confidence to keep their next HIV appointment (IRR: 0.918, P = 0.021).

Pre-pandemic, there was no increasing trend visible in the proportion of people using illicit substances, around other people using drugs, or missing HIV medications on 2 or more days (Fig. 1a). Likewise, there was no pre-pandemic decreasing trend visible in the mean confidence ratings for staying sober or keeping their next HIV appointment, nor for recovery support meeting attendance (Fig. 1b).

Fig. 1

Line graphs of trends in a the proportion of people using illicit drugs, around other people using drugs, and missing HIV ART medication on 2 or more days, and b mean rating for confidence to stay sober, recovery support meeting attendance, and confidence to attend next HIV appointment 6 weeks before the pandemic (January 31 to March 12, 2020) and 6 weeks during the pandemic (March 24 to May 4, 2020)

Discussion

By examining weekly survey data collected through an ongoing mobile-health intervention study, we found that PLWH and SUD in Wisconsin have increased their use of illicit substances during the COVID-19 pandemic. Individuals have also significantly decreased their confidence to stay sober and their recovery support meeting attendance, and they are unexpectedly around people using drugs more often. The significant worsening of these risk factors provides a strong concern that illicit substance use may further increase, and the use of alcohol and marijuana may begin to increase, throughout the course of the ongoing pandemic.

This study also found a significant increase in the proportion of people missing their ART medications 2 or more days per week. Poor ART adherence is the strongest predictor of failed virologic suppression, HIV drug resistance, disease progression, and even death among PLWH [22-24]. Missing 2 days of HIV medication, or adhering to only 71% of doses weekly, is well below the minimum level of adherence necessary to maintain viral suppression, which is often cited as between 80–95% [19, 20]. Furthermore, we found a significant decrease in individual’s confidence to attend their next HIV appointment. Due to COVID-19, some providers have pushed back non-urgent medical appointments and/or provided virtual appointment options. We were unable to determine whether individual’s confidence to attend a telehealth appointment may differ. However, previous research demonstrates that missing HIV appointments also predicts viral rebound, drug resistance, and mortality [25-27]. Together, these findings signal that novel methods to retain PLWH and SUD in HIV care during pandemics like COVID-19 must be implemented in order to improve the health of this marginalized population and prevent the spread of HIV.

The lack of any trends in these outcomes before the COVID-19 pandemic provides evidence that the worsening outcomes detected in this study are likely a result of the pandemic and not any pre-existing trends. However, our study had a small sample size, with the number of surveys taken per week ranging from 22 to 35. Another limitation of this study is that we cannot assess the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on drug use behaviors and HIV care among PLWH and SUD who do not have access to A-CHESS. Considering the goals of A-CHESS are to prevent substance misuse and lapses in HIV care, it is likely that this study underestimates the effect the pandemic has on substance use and HIV care. More research is needed to understand how the pandemic has impacted drug use and HIV care among PWLH and SUD, as well as the general population, who do not have access to support tools like A-CHESS.

Further research is needed to understand mediating factors in the relationship between this social, emotional, and economical public health crisis and substance use and HIV care. We found a decrease in recovery support meeting attendance during the COVID-19 pandemic. Although social-distancing orders prevented many recovery meetings from being held in person, most programs were offering virtual meetings. We were unable to assess whether meeting attendance decreased because individuals were not offered virtual meeting options, they refused virtual options due to personal preference and recovery needs, or they lacked access to the necessary technology. Additionally, subjects reported unexpectedly being around people using drugs more often. We were unable to describe factors mediating this relationship using data. We do know, however, that self-quarantine and social-distancing measures have disrupted access to recovery meetings, employment, and other activities that take people outside their homes. Furthermore, people who use drugs are often housed with other drug-using individuals, either family/friends in their social networks or in sober living homes with others vulnerable to relapse. Therefore, contact with these individuals is likely increasing as the pandemic restricts people to their own living environments.

Optimal support for PLWH and SUD is critical during this pandemic, as drug-related and ART non-adherence risks such as overdose, unsafe sexual behaviors, and HIV transmission, may unfold. Exacerbating this crisis is that many harm reduction programs, such as syringe service programs, are operating at reduced hours or closed altogether. As face-to-face visits with medical and public health providers become less available, mobile-health interventions may provide a useful tool to remain connected, collect data, and deliver care to PLWH and SUD during pandemics like COVID-19. More research is needed to understand the long-term effects of COVID-19 on this population and to develop effective interventions that mitigate these effects and retain this population in care during pandemics.