| Literature DB >> 32678948 |
Thomas A Fox1,2, Ethan Troy-Barnes1, Amy A Kirkwood3, Wei Yee Chan1,4, James W Day1,2, Selina J Chavda1,4, Emil A Kumar1,5, Kate David6, Oliver Tomkins1, Emilie Sanchez6, Marie Scully1,7, Asim Khwaja1,4, Jonathan Lambert1,7, Mervyn Singer7,8, Claire Roddie1,4,7, Emma C Morris1,2,7,9, Kwee L Yong1,4,7, Kirsty J Thomson1,7, Kirit M Ardeshna1,7.
Abstract
Haematology patients receiving chemo- or immunotherapy are considered to be at greater risk of COVID-19-related morbidity and mortality. We aimed to identify risk factors for COVID-19 severity and assess outcomes in patients where COVID-19 complicated the treatment of their haematological disorder. A retrospective cohort study was conducted in 55 patients with haematological disorders and COVID-19, including 52 with malignancy, two with bone marrow failure and one immune-mediated thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP). COVID-19 diagnosis coincided with a new diagnosis of a haematological malignancy in four patients. Among patients, 82% were on systemic anti-cancer therapy (SACT) at the time of COVID-19 diagnosis. Of hospitalised patients, 37% (19/51) died while all four outpatients recovered. Risk factors for severe disease or mortality were similar to those in other published cohorts. Raised C-reactive protein at diagnosis predicted an aggressive clinical course. The majority of patients recovered from COVID-19, despite receiving recent SACT. This suggests that SACT, where urgent, should be administered despite intercurrent COVID-19 infection, which should be managed according to standard pathways. Delay or modification of therapy should be considered on an individual basis. Long-term follow-up studies in larger patient cohorts are required to assess the efficacy of treatment strategies employed during the pandemic.Entities:
Keywords: Covid-19; chemotherapy; risk factors
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32678948 PMCID: PMC7405103 DOI: 10.1111/bjh.17027
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Br J Haematol ISSN: 0007-1048 Impact factor: 8.615
Patient demographics, haematological diagnosis and treatment history.
|
All patients
|
Died
|
Recovered
| OR (95% CI), value |
Severe Disease
|
No severe disease
| OR (95% CI), | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age at diagnosis, median (range) | 63·0 (23–88) | 67·0 (51–88) | 60·0 (23–82) | 1·96 (1·14–3·37), | 66·0 (27–88) | 59·5 (23–82) | 1·44 (0·95–2·19), |
| Sex, % ( | |||||||
| Male | 69 (38/55) | 68 (13/19) | 69 (24/35) | 1·00 | 64 (16/25) | 73 (23/30) | 1·00 |
| Female | 31 (17/55) | 32 (6/19) | 31 (11/35) | 1·01 (0·30–3·35), | 36 (9/25) | 27 (8/30) | 1·55 (0·49–4·88), |
| Ethnicity, % ( | |||||||
| Caucasian | 70 (38/54) | 53 (10/19) | 79 (27/34) | 1·00, | 60 (15/25) | 79 (23/29) | 1·00, |
| Black | 9 (5/54) | 21 (4/19) | 3 (1/34) | 6·40 (0·65–62·84) | 16 (4/25) | 3 (1/29) | 11·20 (1·11–112·52) |
| Asian | 19 (10/54) | 26 (5/19) | 15 (5/34) | 2·40 (0·58–9·93) | 24 (6/25) | 14 (4/29) | 2·80 (0·67−11·75) |
| Other | 2 (1/54) | 0 | 3 (1/34) | – | 0 | 3 (1/29) | ‐ |
| Smoker, % ( | |||||||
| Non‐smoker | 82 (31/38) | 86 (12/14) | 78 (18/23) |
| 87 (14/16) | 77 (17/22) |
|
| Current | 3 (1/38) | 0 | 4 (1/23) | 0 | 5 (1/22) | ||
| Ex‐smoker | 16 (6/38) | 14 (2/14) | 17 (4/23) | 12 (2/16) | 18 (4/22) | ||
| BMI, median (range) | 25·7 (18–40·5) | 24·3 (18·2–31) | 26·7 (18–40·5) | 0·33 (0·09–1·25), | 25·8 (18·2–37·6) | 25·7 (18–40·5) | 0·61 (0·20–1·91), |
| Comorbidities and ceiling of care | |||||||
| COPD, % ( | |||||||
| No COPD | 98 (53/54) | 95 (18/19) | 100 (34/34) |
| 96 (24/25) | 100 (29/29) |
|
| COPD | 2 (1/54) | 5 (1/19) | 0 | 4 (1/25) | 0 | ||
| Ischaemic heart disease, % ( | |||||||
| No IHD | 94 (51/54) | 100 (19/19) | 91 (31/34) |
| 96 (24/25) | 93 (27/29) |
|
| IHD | 6 (3/54) | 0 | 9 (3/34) | 4 (1/25) | 7 (2/29) | ||
| Hypertension, | |||||||
| No hypertension | 63 (34/54) | 68 (13/19) | 60 (21/35) | 1·00 | 68 (17/25) | 60 (18/30) | 1·00 |
| Hypertension | 37 (20/54) | 32 (6/19) | 40 (14/35) | 0·69 (0·21–2·25), | 32 (8/25) | 40 (12/30) | 0·71 (0·23–2·15), |
| Diabetes, | |||||||
| No diabetes | 80 (43/54) | 84 (16/19) | 76 (26/34) | 1·00 | 80 (20/25) | 79 (23/29) | 1·00 |
| Diabetes | 20 (11/54) | 16 (3/19) | 24 (8/34) | 0·61 (0·14– 2·64), | 20 (5/25) | 21 (6/29) | 0·96 (0·25–3·62), |
| Chronic kidney disease, | |||||||
| No CKD | 87 (47/54) | 89 (17/19) | 85 (29/34) | 1·00 | 84 (21/25) | 90 (26/29) | 1·00 |
| CKD | 13 (7/54) | 11 (2/19) | 15 (5/34) | 0·68 (0·12‐ 3·91), | 16 (4/25) | 10 (3/29) | 1·65 (0·33–8·21), |
| Haematology diagnosis, % ( | |||||||
| MM/AL | 24 (13/55) | 21 (4/19) | 26 (9/35) | .. | 16 (4/25) | 30 (9/30) | .. |
| MDS | 7 (4/55) | 5 (1/19) | 9 (3/35) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 10 (3/30) | .. |
| Acute leukaemia | 20 (11/55) | 16 (3/19) | 20 (7/35) | .. | 24 (6/25) | 17 (5/30) | .. |
| CML | 2 (1/55) | 0 | 3 (1/35) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 0 | .. |
| B‐cell NHL low grade | 15 (8/55) | 16 (3/19) | 14 (5/35) | .. | 16 (4/25) | 13 (4/30) | .. |
| B‐cell NHL high grade | 16 (9/55) | 21 (4/19) | 14 (5/35) | .. | 16 (4/25) | 17 (5/30) | .. |
| BM failure syndromes | 4 (2/55) | 5 (1/19) | 3 (1/35) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 3 (1/30) | .. |
| TTP | 2 (1/55) | 0 | 3 (1/35) | .. | 0 | 3 (1/30) | .. |
| MPN | 11 (6/55) | 16 (3/19) | 9 (3/35) | .. | 16 (4/25) | 7 (2/30) | .. |
| Prior lines of therapy (Number), | |||||||
| 0 | 64 (35/55) | 58 (11/19) | 69 (24/35) | .. | 60 (15/25) | 67 (20/30) | .. |
| 1 | 13 (7/55) | 11 (2/19) | 11 (4/35) | .. | 16 (4/25) | 10 (3/30) | .. |
| 2 | 16 (9/55) | 26 (5/19) | 11 (4/35) | .. | 20 (5/25) | 13 (4/30) | .. |
| 3 | 4 (2/55) | 5 (1/19) | 3 (1/35) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 3 (1/30) | .. |
| 4 | 4 (2/55) | 0 | 6 (2/35) | .. | 0 | 7 (2/30) | .. |
| Stem cell transplant, | |||||||
| No ASCT | 83 (45/54) | 84 (16/19) | 85 (29/34) | .. | 84 (21/25) | 83 (24/29) | .. |
| AutoSCT | 13 (7/54) | 16 (3/19) | 9 (4/34) | .. | 12 (3/25) | 14 (4/29) | .. |
| AlloSCT | 4 (2/54) | 0 | 3 (1/34) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 3 (1/30) | .. |
| Immunosuppression within 14 days, | |||||||
| No immunosuppression | 53 (28/53) | 44 (8/18) | 59 (20/34) | 1·00 | 50 (12/24) | 55 (16/29) | 1·00 |
| Immunosuppression | 47 (25/53) | 56 (10/18) | 41 (14/34) | 1·79 (0·56–5·66), | 50 (12/24) | 45 (13/29) | 1·23 (0·42–3·64), |
| Days since chemo day 1, | |||||||
| ≥28 days since chemo day 1 | 18 (10/55) | 11 (2/18) | 25 (8/34) | 1·00 ( | 12 (3/25) | 23 (7/30) | 1·00 ( |
| 14‐28 days since chemo day 1 | 24 (13/55) | 26 (5/18) | 22 (7/34) | 2·86 (0·42–19·65) | 25 (6/25) | 23 (7/30) | 2·00 (0·35–11·36) |
| <14 days since chemo day 1 | 53 (29/55) | 63 (12/18) | 53 (17/34) | 2·82 (0·51–15·72) | 62 (15/25) | 47 (14/30) | 2·50 (0·54–11·62) |
| No treatment | 5 (3/55) | 0 | 3 (9/34) | .. | 4 (1/25) | 7 (2/30) | ‐ |
| Intensity of most recent treatment, | |||||||
| Non‐intensive | 65 (36/55) | 74 (14/19) | 63 (22/35) | 1·00 | 64 (16/25) | 67 (20/30) | 1·00 |
| Intensive | 29 (16/55) | 26 (5/19) | 29 (10/35) | 0·79 (0·22–2·79), | 32 (8/25) | 27 (8/30) | 1·25 (0·38–4·07), |
| No treatment | 5 (3/55) | 0 | 9 (3/35) | 4 (1/25) | 7 (2/30) | ||
BMI, body mass index; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; IHD, ischaemic heart disease; CKD, chronic kidney disease; autoSCT, autologous stem cell transplant; alloSCT, allogeneic stem cell transplant; chemo, chemotherapy.
Fisher's exact test used to calculate differences between patient groups.
denotes a significant P value (<0·05).
COVID‐19 diagnosis and symptoms.
|
All patients
|
Died
|
Recovered
| OR (95% CI), |
Severe Disease
|
No severe disease
| OR (95% CI), | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Days from symptoms to presentation | 4 (0–28) | 3 (0–14) | 4 (0–28) | .. | 4 (0–20) | 4 (0–28) | .. |
| COVID presentation, % (n/total) | |||||||
| Outpatient | 15 (8/55) | 5 (1/19) | 20 (7/35) | .. | 8 (2/25) | .. | .. |
| Inpatient | 86 (47/55) | 95 (18/19) | 80 (28/35) | .. | 92 (23/25) | .. | .. |
| Swab positive, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No | 13 (7/55) | 16 (3/19) | 11 (4/35) | .. | 12 (3/25) | .. | .. |
| Yes | 87 (48/55) | 84 (16/19) | 89 (31/35) | .. | 88 (22/25) | .. | .. |
| Method of diagnosis, % (n/total) | |||||||
| Nose and throat swab | 80 (44/55) | 79 (15/19) | 80 (28/35) | .. | 80 (20/25) | .. | .. |
| Radiological | 16 (9/55) | 21 (4/19) | 14 (5/35) | .. | 20 (5/25) | .. | .. |
| Clinical | 4 (2/55) | 0 | 6 (2/35) | .. | 0 | .. | .. |
| Highest fever recorded | 38·5 (37–40·5) | 38·5 (37–40·5) | 38·5 (37–40·2) | .. | 38·8 (37–40·5) | 38·4 (37–40) | .. |
| Fever ≥ 38, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No fever | 19 (9/47) | 22 (4/18) | 18 (5/28) | 1·00 | 17 (4/24) | 22 (5/23) | 1·00 |
| Fever | 81 (38/47) | 78 (14/18) | 82 (23/28) | 0·76 (0·17–3·32), | 83 (20/24) | 78 (18/23) | 1·39 (0·32–5·99), |
| Cough, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No cough | 30 (16/53) | 17 (3/18) | 38 (13/34) | 1·00 | 17 (4/24) | 41 (12/29) | 1·00 |
| Cough | 70 (37/53) | 83 (15/18) | 62 (21/34) | 3·10 (0·75–12·80), | 83 (20/24) | 59 (17/29) | 3·53 (0·96−12·99), |
| Sputum, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No sputum | 83 (44/53) | 78 (14/18) | 88 (30/34) | 1·00 | 75 (18/24) | 90 (26/29) | 1·00 |
| Sputum | 17 (9/53) | 22 (4/18) | 12 (4/34) | 2·14 (0·47, 9·84), | 25 (6/24) | 10 (3/29) | 2·89 (0·64−13·08), |
| Myalgia, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No myalgia | 89 (47/53) | 100 (18/18) | 82 (28/34) |
| 92 (22/24) | 86 (25/29) | 1·00 |
| Myalgia | 11 (6/53) | 0 | 18 (6/34) | 8 (2/24) | 14 (4/29) | 0·57 (0·09–3·41), | |
| Fatigue, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No fatigue | 53 (28/53) | 44 (8/18) | 59 (20/34) | 1·00 | 33 (8/24) | 69 (20/29) | 1·00 |
| Fatigue | 47 (25/53) | 56 (10/18) | 41 (14/34) | 1·79 (0·56–5·66), | 68 (16/24) | 31 (9/29) | 4·44 (1·40−14·14), |
| Dyspnoea, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No dyspnoea | 39 (20/51) | 24 (4/17) | 48 (16/33) | 1·00 | 22 (5/23) | 54 (15/28) | 1·00 |
| Dyspnoea | 61 (31/51) | 77 (13/17) | 51 (17/33) | 3·06 (0·82–11·36), | 78 (18/23) | 46 (13/28) | 4·15 (1·20−14·33), |
| Diarrhoea, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No | 81 (43/53) | 83 (15/18) | 82 (15/18) | 1·00 | 79 (19/23) | 83 (24/29) | 1·00 |
| Yes | 19 (10/53) | 17 (3/18) | 18 (3/18) | 0·93 (0·20–4·27), | 21 (5/23) | 17 (5/29) | 1·26 (0·32–5·01), |
| Other infection present | |||||||
| No | 37 (20/55) | 37 (7/19) | 37 (13/35) | 1·00 | 32 (8/25) | 40 (12/30) | 1·00 |
| Possible bacterial | 33 (18/55) | 32 (6/19) | 31 (11/35) | 1·01 (0·32–3·22), | 40 (10/25) | 27 (8/30) | 1·42 (0·47–4·31), |
| Confirmed bacterial | 31 (17/55) | 32 (6/19) | 31 (11/35) | 28 (7/25) | 33 (10/30) | ||
| Chest X‐ray performed, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No CXR | 4 (2/50) | 6 (1/18) | 3 (1/31) | .. | 4 (1/24) | 4 (1/26) | .. |
| CXR | 96 (48/50) | 94 (17/18) | 97 (30/31) | .. | 96 (23/24) | 96 (25/26) | .. |
| Chest X‐ray findings, % (n/total) | |||||||
| Clear | 17 (8/47) | 12 (2/16) | 21 (6/29) | 1·00 ( | 13 (3/23) | 21 (5/24) | 1·00 ( |
| Bilateral interstitial infiltrates | 53 (25/47) | 65 (11/16) | 45 (13/29) | 3·38 (0·59–19·38) | 70 (16/23) | 38 (9/24) | 3·38 (0·59–19·38) |
| Other infective findings | 26 (12/47) | 24 (4/16) | 28 (8/29) | 2·00 (0·28–14·20) | 17 (4/23) | 33 (8/24) | 2·00 (0·28–14·20) |
| Other, non‐infective findings | 4 (2/47) | 0 | 7 (2/29) | 0 | 8 (2/24) | ||
| CT Scan, % (n/total) | |||||||
| No CT scan | 71 (34/48) | 71 (12/17) | 73 (22/30) | .. | 65 (15/23) | 76 (19/25) | .. |
| CT scan performed | 29 (14/48) | 29 (5/17) | 27 (8/30) | .. | 35 (8/23) | 24 (6/25) | .. |
| CT scan findings, % (n/total) | |||||||
| Ground glass | 71 (10/14) | 80 (4/5) | 75 (6/8) | .. | 75 (6/8) | 67 (4/6) | .. |
| Nodular changes | 7 (1/14) | 0 | 0 | .. | 12 (1/8) | 0 | .. |
| Others | 21 (3/14) | 20 (1/5) | 25 (2/8) | .. | 12 (1/8) | 33 (2/6) | .. |
Other, non‐infective findings on chest X‐ray (CXR) group with clear X‐ray for regression analysis.
Fisher's exact test used to calculate differences between patient groups.
denotes a significant result (P < 0·05).
Possible infection and confirmed infection grouped for regression analysis.
Fig 1Consort diagram.
COVID‐19 therapies and clinical outcomes.
| COVID‐19 therapies and clinical outcomes |
|
|---|---|
| Thrombotic event/anticoagulation | % ( |
| Admission anticoagulation | |
| Prophylactic low molecular weight heparin | 58% (26/45) |
| Therapeutic dose low molecular weight heparin | 13% (6/45) |
| Direct oral anticoagulants | 7% (3/45) |
| Thrombotic events | |
| Deep vein thrombosis | 5% (3/55) |
| Pulmonary embolism | 5% (3/55) |
| PICC‐associated superficial thrombophlebitis | 2% (1/55) |
| ICU/HDU level therapy | % ( |
| CPAP | 35% (19/55) |
| Endotracheal intubation | 11% (6/55) |
| Renal replacement therapy | 2% (1/53) |
| Vasopressors | 10% (5/55) |
| Treatment escalation plans: | % ( |
| Full escalation | 58·1% (32/55) |
| Escalation to NIV only | 29·1% (16/55) |
| Ward based therapies only | 12·7% (7/55) |
| DNACPR in place | 41·8% (23/55) |
| Outcomes | Days (range) |
| Median length of stay: | |
| In hospital | 13 (0–135) |
| In ICU | 7 (1–32) |
| Median duration of: | |
| CPAP | 4 (1–15) |
| % ( | |
| Died in hospital | 35% (19/55) |
| Discharged from hospital | 64% (35/55) |
| Restarted haematological cancer‐directed therapy | 52% (14/27) |
FiO2, fraction of inspired oxygen; ICU, intensive care unit; HDU, high dependency unit; CPAP, continuous Positive Airway Pressure; DNACPR, do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation; NIV, non‐invasive ventilation; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.
Data regarding baseline anticoagulation missing in 6/51 hospitalised patients.
Fig 2Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis of C‐reactive protein. (A) Death; for a cut‐off of 100, sensitivity 71·5% and specificity 65·4%. (B) Severe disease; for a cut‐off of 100, sensitivity 65·0% and specificity 71·4%.
Fig 3Cumulative incidence of event (severe disease) for (A) whole cohort, (B) by treatment group (intensive/non‐intensive) and (C) by treatment time. Patients who had recovered without severe disease were recorded as not having an event and last follow‐up time was censored at day 35 (the day after last reported COVID severe event in the cohort). (D) Kaplan–Meier survival curve of the whole cohort, (E) treatment intensity and (F) treatment time. Patients who had recovered were censored at day 35 (the day after the last reported COVID death). [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]