| Literature DB >> 32526986 |
Anne Nobels1, Christophe Vandeviver2,3, Marie Beaulieu4, Adina Cismaru Inescu5, Laurent Nisen5, Nele Van Den Noortgate6, Tom Vander Beken2, Gilbert Lemmens7, Ines Keygnaert1.
Abstract
Sexual violence (SV) is an important public health issue with a major impact on victims and their peers, offspring and community. However, SV in older adults is under-researched. This paper aims to establish the prevalence and nature of SV in older adults in Europe, link this with existing policies and health care workers' response to sexual health needs in older age, and critically revise the currently used frameworks in public health research. To fill this gap in the literature, we applied a Critical Interpretative Synthesis (CIS) approach. The CIS approach uses techniques from grounded theory and processes from systematic review. It allows to critically interpret key findings from both academic as well as grey literature, engendering theory refining. In the first phase of purposive sampling, we conducted a systematic review of academic sources and included 14 references. The cut-off age used to define old age varied between 60 and 70 years old among the included studies. Subsequently we added another 14 references in the second phase of theoretical sampling. We ultimately included 16 peer-reviewed articles and 12 documents from the grey literature. The CIS results demonstrate that knowledge of SV in older adults is still limited. The current research suggests that SV in older adults rarely occurs, however, prevalence rates are likely to be underestimated because of methodological shortcomings. The complexity of SV in older adults is not acknowledged in ongoing research due to the conflation of SV with other types of violence. Information on specific risk factors and about assailants committing SV in old age is absent. Policy documents dealing with sexual and reproductive health, rights and ageing make no mention of SV in older adults. In clinical practice, the sexual health needs of older adults often remain unmet. In conclusion, our findings suggest that older adults are forgotten in prevention and response to SV. Greater awareness about this topic could contribute to a revision of current policies and health care practices, leading to more tailored care for older victims of SV.Entities:
Keywords: ageing; elder abuse and neglect; elder mistreatment; sexual abuse; sexual assault
Year: 2020 PMID: 32526986 PMCID: PMC7312038 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17114117
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Figure 1Flow diagram of reference selection process.
Description of included studies in phase 1.
| Researchers + Year | Source | Country | Sample | Cut-off Age | Proportion of Females in Study Population | Survey Method | Participation Rate | Prevalence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vandenberk et al. (1998) [ | Study report | Belgium | 523 community—dwelling older adults | 65 | 57% women | Face-to-face interview | Flanders: 43.9% Wallonia 49.4% Brussels: 30.2% | SV since the age of 60 years: 1%Lifetime SV: 6.3% |
| Casman et al. (1998) [ | Study report | Belgium | 300 female nursing homes residents | ? | 100% women | Face-to-face interview | ? | 22% of residents felt uncomfortable when intimate parts were touched during care15.8% of residents experienced a naked person entering their room |
| O’Keefe et al. (2007) [ | Study report | UK | 2111 community—dwelling older adults | 66 | ? | CAPI and CASI | 67% | SV in past 12 months: 0.2% |
| Lowenstein et al. (2009) [ | Peer reviewed article | Israel | 1045 community—dwelling older adults | 65 | 62.5% | Face-to-face interview | 75% | SV in past 3 months: 2% |
| Soares et al. (2010) [ | Study report | Italy, Greece, Spain, Lithuania, Germany, Portugal, Sweden | 4476 older adults between 60-84 | 60 | 57.3% women | Self-response and face-to-face interview | 45.2% | SV in past 12 months: 0.7% |
| Naughton et al. (2010) [ | Study report | Ireland | 2021 community—dwelling older adults | 65 | 55% women | Face-to-face interview | 82% | SV in past 12 months: 0.05% |
| Luoma et al. (2011) [ | Study report | Austria, Belgium, Finland, Lithuania, Portugal | 2880 older women living in private houses | 60 | 100% women | Postal survey, telephone survey, face-to-face interviews | Ranging from 26.1% in Belgium to 49.1% in Austria | SV in past 12 months: 3.1% |
| Nisen et al. (2011) [ | Study report | Belgium | 766 older adults living in the community and 111 older adults with specific needs in Wallonia and Brussels | 70 | 54.7% women | Face-to-face interview | 43,7% | SV since the age of 70 years: 1.2% |
| Kissal et al. (2011) [ | Peer reviewed article | Turkey | 331 community—dwelling older adults living in the area covered by a primary health care centre in Izmir | 65 | 56.8% women | Face-to-face interview | ? | SV in past 12 months: 0.9% |
| Gil et al. (2015) [ | Peer reviewed article | Portugal | 1123 community—dwelling older adults | 60 | 56.4% | Telephone interview | 74% | SV in past 12 months: 0.2% |
| Kulakci et al. (2019) [ | Peer reviewed article | Turkey | 691 community—dwelling older adults visiting a primary health care centre | 60 | ? | Face-to-face interviews | ? | SV in past 12 months: 0% |
| Aslan et al. (2019) [ | Peer reviewed article | Turkey | 455 community—dwelling older adults registered at a primary health care centre | 65 | 34.7% | Face-to-face interview | 93% | Prevalence SV: 12.6% (timeframe unclear) |
| Badenes-Ribera et al. (2019) [ | Peer reviewed article | Italy | 393 older adults living in the community and in nursing homes | 60 | 60.7% | Self-administered questionnaire | ? | SV in past 12 months: 0.8% |
| Kolodziejczak et al. (2019) [ | Peer reviewed article | Poland | 137 older adults active in rural day centres | ? | ? | Face-to-face interview | ? | SV in past 6 months: 0.7% |
SV: Sexual Violence, CAPI: Computer assisted personal interviewing, CASI: Computer assisted self-interviewing, ?: not known.