Akhil M Abraham1, Sunil P Lonkar2, Vishnu V Pillai2, Saeed M Alhassan2. 1. Department of Chemistry, University of Calgary, 2500 University Dr. NW, Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4, Canada. 2. Department of Chemical Engineering, Khalifa University, P.O. Box 127788, Abu Dhabi, UAE.
Abstract
An economical and binder-free electrode was fabricated by impregnation of sub-5 nm MoS2 nanodots (MoS2 NDs) onto a three-dimensional (3D) nickel substrate using the facile dip-coating method. The MoS2 NDs were successfully synthesized by controlled bath sonication of highly crystalline MoS2 nanosheets. The as-fabricated high-surface area electrode demonstrated promising electrochemical properties. It was observed that the as-synthesized NDs outperformed the layered MoS2 peers as the electrode for supercapacitors. MoS2 NDs exhibited an excellent specific capacitance (C sp) of 395 F/g at a current load of 1.5 A/g in a three-electrode configuration. In addition, the fabricated symmetric supercapacitor demonstrated a C sp value of 122 F/g at 1 A/g and a cyclic performance of 86% over 1000 cycles with a gravimetric power and energy density of 10,000 W/kg and 22 W h/kg, respectively. Owing to its simple and efficient fabrication and high surface area, such 3D electrodes show high promise for various energy storage devices.
An economical and binder-free electrode was fabricated by impregnation of sub-5 nm MoS2 nanodots (MoS2 NDs) onto a three-dimensional (3D) nickel substrate using the facile dip-coating method. The MoS2 NDs were successfully synthesized by controlled bath sonication of highly crystalline MoS2 nanosheets. The as-fabricated high-surface area electrode demonstrated promising electrochemical properties. It was observed that the as-synthesized NDs outperformed the layered MoS2 peers as the electrode for supercapacitors. MoS2 NDs exhibited an excellent specific capacitance (C sp) of 395 F/g at a current load of 1.5 A/g in a three-electrode configuration. In addition, the fabricated symmetric supercapacitor demonstrated a C sp value of 122 F/g at 1 A/g and a cyclic performance of 86% over 1000 cycles with a gravimetric power and energy density of 10,000 W/kg and 22 W h/kg, respectively. Owing to its simple and efficient fabrication and high surface area, such 3D electrodes show high promise for various energy storage devices.
Recently, with ever-growing energy concerns,
the quest for high-performance multifunctional materials that display
high performance toward energy storage and conversion with effective
usage is on high demand. On this front, supercapacitors, owing to
its ability to outburst power instantaneously, high specific energy,
fast charge/discharge rates, and source of green energy have attracted
a great deal of interests.[1,2] Supercapacitors, otherwise
electric double layer capacitor (EDLC), possess excellent energy and
power density that opens portal for myriad applications in industries
such as consumer electronics, hybrid automobiles, military devices,
industrial power, and memory backup systems.[3,4] Therefore,
development of high-performance supercapacitors always remains a thrust
area of research in the scientific community. In general, supercapacitors
can be categorized into pseudo and double-layer capacitor, respectively,
based on their charge storage mechanism. In a pseudocapacitor, energy
storage occurs primarily via redox mechanism on the periphery of electrode
materials such as transition metal oxides and hydroxides, conducting
polymers such as PANI, poly-oxometalates, EDOT, and so forth are typical
electrode materials in pseudo-capacitors.[5−7] However, in EDLC charge separation occurs
at the interface of electrode and electrolyte; usually carbon materials
like graphene, CNTs, carbon nanospheres, and activated carbon are
utilized as the electrode material.[8−10] In addition to metal oxides and conducting polymer-based
pseudocapacitors, metal organic frameworks, conductive metal sulfides
such as WS2, MoS2, CoS, NiS, SnS, and ZnS and
their hybrids have also emerged as distinctive[1] materials for supercapacitor applications.[11−18] Amongst, molybdenum disulfide
(MoS2) possess a unique S–Mo–S trilayer atomic
structure that is restrained by weak van der Waals forces, analogous
to that of graphene.[19,20] Also, due to its high electrical
conductivity, and unique layered morphology, MoS2-based
materials offer better prospects as an electrode material for high-performance
supercapacitor compared to metal oxides and graphitic materials. Similarly,
nanostructured MoS2 can be synthesized via simple and economical
processes such as hydrothermal, sono-chemical, and chemical vapor
deposition techniques.[21−23] Nowadays,
MoS2 has also attracted plenty of recognition in electrochemical
energy storage devices attributed to its innate ionic conductivity
and higher theoretical capacity than graphite, owing to its graphene
analogous structure.[24,25] The aforementioned characteristics
of MoS2 make them excellent electrode material compared
to metal oxides and graphite. However, adorned with such fascinating
properties, the studies that explore supercapacitive nature of MoS2 electrodes are still limited and mostly focus nanostructured
MoS2 and its composites. Soon and Loh reported MoS2 micro-supercapacitor with an areal capacitive value of 8
mF/cm2.[26] Similarly, Sun et
al. fabricated a tubular C/MoS2 electrode material with
a Csp value of 210 F/g at 1 A/g.[27] Huang et al. reported high-performance supercapacitor
with polyaniline/graphene equivalent MoS2 as electrode
material.[28] Kim et al. reported MoS2 nanostructures obtained via hydrothermal reaction and utilized
as negative electrode material in 1 M Na2SO4 electrolyte and maximum capacitive performance of 92 F/g was observed
at a current load of 0.5 mA/cm2.[11] A flower-like MoS2 structure was communicated by Ma et
al. with a Csp value of 122 F/g at 1 A/g.[29] Wang et al. also reported flower like morphology
with an improved Csp value of 168 F/g
at 1 A/g.[30] Karade et al., illustrated
MoS2 nanoflakes prepared via chemical bath deposition with
a high Csp value of ∼210 F/g at
1.5 A/g.[2] Apart from this, MoS2/carbon composites such as MoS2/graphene, MoS2/graphene oxide, and MoS2/MWCNT electrode materials are
also reported.[31,32] In further advancement, the recent
reports show the synthesis of zero-dimensional nanodots (NDs) of MoS2 which are expected to possess different electronics and physico-chemical
properties than their 2D nano and bulk counterparts, owing to modulated
size confinements and edge effects.[33] Currently,
the MoS2 NDs are being investigated for applications such
as electrocatalysts.[34] However, no literary
reports investigating the MoS2 NDs supercapacitive performance
has been noted so far.Hence, in the present report we have
attempted to investigate the electrochemical and supercapacitor performance
of MoS2 NDs impregnated on the 3D nickel foam. The uniformly
sized MoS2 NDs were synthesized from controlled bath sonication
of crystalline MoS2 nanosheet in isopropanol at ambient
temperature. The resulting NDs were successfully surface impregnated
on Ni foam using a simple and facile dip-coating method. Subsequently,
the electrochemical performance of MoS2 NDs@ Ni foam was
evaluated using galvanostatic charge/discharge, chrono-potentiometry
(CD),
electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), and cyclic voltammetry
(CV) in a basic electrolyte (6 M KOH). Moreover, the supercapacitor
performance of electrode material was also evaluated in a symmetric
two-electrode configuration using MoS2 ND-doped electrode
material as cathode and anode, respectively. The resulting electrochemical
properties suggest that the 3D MoS2 NDs/Ni foam exhibit
superior supercapacitive performance and cyclic efficiency compared
to the bulk and nanostructured MoS2 and its hybrid materials.
Results
and Discussion
Experimental Section
Chemical
and Materials
Ammonium tetrathiomolybdate (ATTM) (99.97%
pure), potassium hydroxide (ACS Reagent, >85%), and isopropanol
was procured from Sigma-Aldrich and was utilized as-received. High
grade nickel foam (99.8% purity) was purchased from XIAMEN Tob New
Energy Technology, China.
Fabrication
of 3D MoS2 NDs/Ni Foam Electrodes (3D MoS2 NDs/NF)
First, uniformly distributed MoS2 NDs were synthesized
by top-down approach and by ultrasonication of a nanocrystalline MoS2 in isopropanol. The MoS2 was freshly prepared
by thermal annealing of ATTM at 600 °C for 2 h inside the tube
furnace and under a continuous flow of argon. After sonication, a
color change of the dispersion to yellowish-green was observed. Further,
the resulting dispersion was subjected to centrifugation at 4000 rpm
for 1 h, which enabled the separation of highly dispersed MoS2 NDs and large-sized MoS2 particles. Thus the resulting
MoS2 NDs dispersion was recovered and used for further
structural and electrochemical characterizations. In the second step,
3D Ni foam was coated with MoS2 NDs by simple repetitive
dip-coating into the as obtained MoS2 ND dispersion with
known concentration. Pale yellow NDs impregnated Ni Foam was dried
at 80 °C under vacuum and used for further studies. The active
material loading (0.02 mg) was calculated using the weight difference
of nickel foam before and after coating by high precision weighing
balance which is accurate up to 0.0001 mg. A detailed synthesis mechanism
is shown schematic illustration presented in Figure . The areal volumetric loading of MoS2 QD on 3D nickel foam of dimension 0.8 cm × 0.5 cm ×
0.1 cm was 0.5 mg/cm3.
Figure 1
TEM image of MoS2 nanolayers (a), and MoS2 NDs (inset SAED pattern)
(b), SEM image of NDs impregnated 3D nickel foam, inset showing higher
magnification of ND doped nickel foam strut (c), HRTEM image of MoS2 NDs (d).
TEM image of MoS2 nanolayers (a), and MoS2 NDs (inset SAED pattern)
(b), SEM image of NDs impregnated 3D nickel foam, inset showing higher
magnification of ND doped nickel foam strut (c), HRTEM image of MoS2 NDs (d).
Material Characterization
The scanning electron microscopy
(SEM) images were taken with a Quanta- FEG-250 scanning electron microscope.
X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were obtained on X’Pert PRO
Powder Diffractometer with Cu Kα radiation. A Raman spectrum
of MoS2 NDs was collected using a Jobin Yvon HORIBA LabRAM
spectrometer with back-scattered confocal configuration using a HeNe
laser (633 nm). Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were
obtained using FEI Tecnai G20 with 0.11 nm point resolution operated
at 200 kV using Gatan digital camera.
Electrochemical Measurements
Electrochemical behavior of
3D MoS2 NDs/NF was studied via CV, charge–discharge
(CD), and impedance (EIS) using a potentiostat–galvanostat
(VMP-300, BioLogic) instrument. In a three-electrode configuration,
a 3D MoS2 NDs/Ni electrode was utilized as a working electrode,
and platinum wire (pt) and saturated calomel electrode (SCE) were
employed as counter and reference electrode, respectively. The electrochemical
analysis was carried out in 6 M KOH electrolyte for scan rates 10–100
mV/s, current densities 1–20 A/g, and frequency ranging from
100 kHz to 1 Hz, respectively. The specific capacitance of 3D MoS2 NDs/NF was evaluated from discharge curve (CD) by using eq where Csp is the specific capacitance in F/g, I is the current
in mA, Δt is the discharge time in seconds,
m is the amount of active material in mg, and ΔV (V) is the operational window. Also, the supercapacitor performance
of the electrode material was evaluated by fabricating a symmetric
supercapacitor device using 3D MoS2 NDs/NF as a positive
and negative electrode. Whatman filter paper, cat no.: 1441 110, soaked
in 6 M KOH was used as a separator. Specific capacitance, power density
(W/kg) and energy density (W h/kg) of fabricated supercapacitor was
estimated using the following equations eqs –4.[35] EIS was performed from 1 Hz to 100 kHz for a
sinusoidal voltage of 10 mV.The synthesis protocol was schematically demonstrated
in Scheme . The highly
crystalline as-obtained MoS2 nanosheets were subjected
to the controlled bath sonication in iso-propanol suspension for 1
h. After the stipulated time, a stable yellowish-green dispersion
of the sub-5 nm monodisperse MoS2 NDs were obtained. The
forces exerted by fluid while bath sonication could lead the breakdown
of MoS2 nanosheets, resulting in the formation of such
well-dispersed NDs. Subsequently, the impregnation of these NDs on
to 3D nickel foam substrate was achieved by facile dip coating method.
The morphological evolution of MoS2 phases was ascertained
by high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) images provided in Figures , and S1 respectively. Figure a shows the TEM image of highly crystalline MoS2 nanosheets obtained after thermal annealing of ATTM precursor
at 600 °C for 2 h, which clearly shows a characteristic layered
structure of MoS2. Upon sonication treatment, the layered
MoS2 was disintegrated into well-dispersed sub—5
nm NDs was observed (Figure b) Previously, Gopalakrishnan et al. reported the growth of
MoS2 nanoparticles distributed within the in MoS2 nanosheets via bath and probe sonication of bulk MoS2 for hydrogen evolution kinetics study.[36] However, the average sizes of MoS2 nanoparticles were
not informed. Herein, we report much smaller dimensions and uniform
distribution of MoS2 NDs. This could be attributed to the
controlled bath sonication subjected to highly crystalline MoS2 nanosheets. Henceforth, the controlled bath sonication facilitated
very precise scission of MoS2 nanosheets than latter. A
detailed study on earlier reported MoS2 NDs is shown in Table S1.
Scheme 1
Schematic Representation of Synthesis Procedure to
Obtain MoS2 NDs and Their Impregnation on to 3D Nickel
Foam
Furthermore, the resulting 3D
MoS2 NDs/NF was subjected to various structural characterizations.
The SEM image of dip-coated nickel foam in MoS2 ND dispersion
is shown in Figure c (inset provided, displays the cell strut of dip coated nickel foam).
The high-resolution TEM image obtained for the latter is shown in Figure d.The formation
of sub-5 nm MoS2 NDs was clearly evident. Moreover, the
absence of any clear and distinct lattice fringes indicated the amorphous
nature of the resulting MoS2 NDs. Similarly, the SAED pattern
(inset of Figure c)
did not show any visible diffraction spots or rings which further
support the amorphous nature of these NDs. Also, these results confirm
the simple dip-coating facilitated good adherence between NDs and
nickel foam. This can be due to weak van der Waals force between NDs
and the nickel substrate. Additionally, the nickel substrate will
provide good conductive pathway and bulk level interaction for electron/ion
transportation during oxidation/reduction reaction due to its high
conductivity and foam structure, respectively. The Raman study reveals
the formation of nanoscopic MoS2. The characteristic Raman
peaks (Figure a) near
378 and 407 cm–1 associated with E2g1 and A1g active modes,
respectively, ascertains the presence of MoS2 nanostructure.[37−39] The additional Raman peak near
450 cm–1 is associated with oxidation of MoS2 to MoO3 in the presence of laser light. Generation
of hetero-dimensional MoS2 NDs can be attributed to the
sonication assisted scission of MoS2 nanosheets. Here,
sonication parameters were controlled to obtain MoS2 NDs.
The standing waves induced during ultrasonic vibration vibrate the
planar MoS2 nanosheets and prolonged sonication resulted
in the formation of NDs, as observed in TEM images (Figure b,d). Hence, a simple bath
sonication over a prolonged time led to the formation of MoS2 NDs. The XRD pattern of 3D MoS2 NDs/NF foam was shown
in Figure b,c. It
can be seen that the no characteristic peaks associated with MoS2 diffraction was observed and only peaks associated with Ni
foam are present. This indicates that the existence of noncrystalline
nanodots of MoS2 successfully impregnated on the Ni foam
substrate. Moreover, the absence of any MoS2 specific peaks
in short-range XRD (Figure c) indicates the existence of amorphous MoS2 NDs.
For comparison, the XRD data of crystalline MoS2 and pristine
MoS2 NDs are presented in Figure S2, indicating highly crystalline MoS2 nanosheets and amorphous
MoS2 NDs. Similarly, the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
and SEM–energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometry characterization
indicates that the precursor MoS2 crystalline starting
material is free from contamination (Figures S3 and S4). Furthermore, an amorphous material possesses low lattice
energy and therefore enhances the utility ratio of active material.
This allows easy de-intercalation process, which is beneficial in
electrochemical performance of the electrode material.
Figure 2
Raman spectra recorded using 633 nm laser (a)
and XRD pattern for pristine and 3D MoS2 NDs/NF (b,c).
Raman spectra recorded using 633 nm laser (a)
and XRD pattern for pristine and 3D MoS2 NDs/NF (b,c).
Electrochemical
Studies
Under three
electrode configuration, the CV curves were obtained for scan rates
varying from 10 to 100 mV/s. As observed in Figure a, presence of redox shoulder in CV plots
indicates the redox reaction occurring between strong basic electrolyte,
(KOH), and MoS2 NDs. During the faradaic charge transfer
process, the ions such as H+ and K+ distribute
into the stacked layer of MoS2 structure resulting in a
reaction mechanism as shown in eq .[2]
Figure 3
Electrochemical
characterization of MoS2 NDs in three electrode configuration.
(a) CV profile of MoS2 NDs for varying scan rate. (b) Peak
current density as a function of scan rate. (c) CD profile for varying
current load. (d) Specific capacitance as a function of current load.
Electrochemical
characterization of MoS2 NDs in three electrode configuration.
(a) CV profile of MoS2 NDs for varying scan rate. (b) Peak
current density as a function of scan rate. (c) CD profile for varying
current load. (d) Specific capacitance as a function of current load.However nonfaradaic nature is exhibited along
the electrode/electrolyte interface, as shown in eq .[2]In addition, the CV curve area increases proportionally for
scan rates 10–100 mV/s, implying the capacitive nature of the
electrode. Besides, the shape of the CV plot more or less remains
the same even at higher scan rates indicating good rate and capacitive
performance of MoS2 NDs. Figure S5 provides a qualitative comparison between CV plots obtained for
pristine nickel and MoS2 ND impregnated nickel foam. It
can be concluded that the charge storage mechanism primarily happens
in MoS2 ND-doped nickel foam and electrochemical inertness
of utilized nickel foam. Figure d shows the change in specific capacitance for different
current densities. The decrease in capacitance was observed with increase
in current densities, which can be associated with an internal resistance
of electrode material. MoS2 NDs demonstrated excellent Csp value of 395 F/g at 1.5 A/g. Several researchers
have reported capacitive behavior of MoS2 nanostructures.
Recent studies that include MoS2 nanoflakes reported by
Karade et al.[2] reported a specific capacitance
of 576 F/g at 5 mV/s. Ilanchezhiyan et al.[12] reported a capacitance value of 122 F/g at 5 mV/s in the 1 M Na2SO4 electrolyte. Ramadoss et al.[13] reported spherical aggregates of MoS2 nanostructures
with a specific capacitance of 403 F/g at 1 mV/s. Linear relation
obtained for cathodic and anodic peak current for the corresponding
square root of scan rate (Figure b) indicates the diffusion-controlled behavior on the
MoS2 ND electrode surface.[40] The latter behavior is observed very often in the presence of strong
basic electrolytes (6 M KOH). The CD curves were obtained at varying
current load (1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 5, and 10 A/g) and showed triangular
and symmetrical behavior indicating good capacitive behavior of electrode
material. The specific capacitance of the MoS2 ND electrode
was obtained using eq , from CD curve shown in Figure c. Specific capacitance (Cs) of MoS2 NDs obtained are 395, 147, 106, 86, 62, and
47 F/g for current loads 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 5, and 10 A/g, respectively
(Figure d). Observed
specific capacitance of MoS2 NDs (1.5 A/g) is significantly
large than that of pure MoS2 (1 A/g) reported earlier 40,
98, 122, and 168 F/g, respectively.[27−30] This indicates that
the MoS2 NDs exhibited superior performance compared to
the aforementioned MoS2 peers. The observed high capacitance
for MoS2 NDs was primarily attributed due to pseudo behavior
in the presence of a strong basic electrolyte (6 M KOH), facilitated
by MoS2 NDs uniformly impregnated on the surface of the
nickel substrate via simple dip coating. In addition, nickel substrate
provides a better conductive pathway for intercalation/de-intercalation
of ions during redox reaction. Previously reported capacitive behavior
of MoS2 electrode materials along with present work are
tabulated in Table S1.The EIS studies
were performed to understand the charge transfer process occurring
between the MoS2 ND electrode and electrolyte interface
and resistance developed within the system (Figure a). The semicircle in the higher frequency
region accommodates the electrode/electrolyte charge transfer resistance
and electrolyte resistance.
Figure 4
(a) Nyquist
plot of electrode material inset showing the equivalent circuit (b)
assembly of symmetric supercapacitor and charge storage mechanism,
schematics.
(a) Nyquist
plot of electrode material inset showing the equivalent circuit (b)
assembly of symmetric supercapacitor and charge storage mechanism,
schematics.The linear line accounts for the
diffusive resistance, known as Warburg impedance. The obtained slope
is greater than 45°, suggesting good capacitive nature of the
electrode material. The Nyquist plot obtained was fitted with an equivalent
circuit (Figure a,
inset) containing R and C components. An equivalent series resistance
(Rs) ∼1.19 Ω was obtained
from the intercept on real axis. Semi arc in the high-frequency region
can be associated with double-layer capacitance Cdl and charge-transfer resistance, Rct ≈ 3.75 Ω at the electrode/electrolyte interface.[41] The presence of the Cf component implies the faradaic charge-transfer process occurring
in the alkali medium. Similarly, the performance of the resulting
3D MoS2 NDs/NF was compared with the previously reported
MoS2-based electrode materials for supercapacitor application
and tabulated in the Table .
Table 1
Comparison of 3D
MoS2 ND Performance with
Preciously Reported MoS2 Electrode Materials
sample description
synthesis method
specific capacitance
electrolyte
references
MoS2 NDs
bath sonication/probe sonication
395 F/g @ 1 A/g
6 M KOH
present work
MoS2/graphene
hydrothermal, in cysteine
solvent
243 F/g @ 1 A/g
1 M Na2SO4
(42)
MoS2/chemically modified graphene
hydrothermal reduction reaction
268 F/g @ 0.5 A/g
1 M Na2SO4
(43)
edge oriented MoS2 nanoporous film
oxidation of Mo foil by sulfur vapors
15 mF/cm2 @ 1 mA/cm2
1 M LiOH
(44)
flower like MoS2 nanostructure
hydrothermal
168 F/g @ 1 A/g
1 M KCl
(45)
MoS2 thin film electrode
physical deposition
330 F/cm3 @ 17 mA/cm2
0.5 M H2SO4
(46)
Symmetric Supercapacitor
To further investigate electrochemical
properties of MoS2 ND as an electrode material, a symmetrical
supercapacitor was fabricated
as shown in Figure b. The charge storage mechanism is also illustrated in the schematics
provided in Figure b. A 6 M KOH soaked filter paper was used as electrolyte and separator,
respectively. The operational voltage of symmetrical supercapacitor
was determined by investigating the CV plots of negative and positive
MoS2 ND electrode material in a three electrode configuration
(Figure a). As observed
in Figure a, MoS2 ND electrodes exhibited nearly rectangular shape except toward
the extreme potential, where instability of electrode material was
pronounced. This can be attributed to hydrogen and oxygen evolution
reaction, thereby narrowing the operating voltage.[47−49] Hence, the determined operating potential
of 0.6 V was used for carrying out electrochemical analysis in a symmetric
supercapacitor. The CV plot obtained for symmetric supercapacitor
at 30 mV/s with the determined operational voltage is shown in Figure b. As observed, nearly
a rectangular curve was obtained in a two-electrode configuration,
confirming the capacitive nature of MoS2 ND supercapacitor.
Figure 5
(a) Operational voltage of cathode and anode
at 30 mV/s.
(b) Working potential of symmetric supercapacitor (30 mV/s).
(a) Operational voltage of cathode and anode
at 30 mV/s.
(b) Working potential of symmetric supercapacitor (30 mV/s).Figure a shows
the CV curves of MoS2 NDs symmetric supercapacitor for
scan rates 20–100 mV/s, with an operational window of 0.6 V.
As seen in Figure a, all of the curves are identical and exhibited an approaching rectangular
shape indicating good rate capability of the two-electrode supercapacitor. Figure b shows the capacitance
(Csp) obtained for MoS2 ND
supercapacitor for different scan rates. Specific capacitance from
CV plots was calculated using eq .where I(V)dV is the area enclosed
in CV curves, v is the scan rate in V/s, and other
units were as stated elsewhere in the text.
Figure 6
(a) CV
plot for a symmetric supercapacitor (20–100 mV/s). (b) Specific
capacitance obtained for varying scan rates. (c) Constant current
charge–discharge performance of a symmetric supercapacitor.
(d) Specific capacitance obtained for current load applied.
(a) CV
plot for a symmetric supercapacitor (20–100 mV/s). (b) Specific
capacitance obtained for varying scan rates. (c) Constant current
charge–discharge performance of a symmetric supercapacitor.
(d) Specific capacitance obtained for current load applied.Specific capacitances
obtained are 105, 100, 104, 102, and 100 F/g for scan rates 20–100
mV/s. The electrode material demonstrated excellent rate capability
as there was a capacitance retention of 95% for varying scan rates
(Figure b). Galvanostatic
charge–discharge plots were obtained for MoS2 ND
symmetric supercapacitor as shown in Figure c. A voltage drop of ∼0.25 Ω
can be observed. The specific capacitances obtained using eq is 122, 98, 82, 80, and
48 F/g for current loads 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5, and 10 A/g, respectively
(Figure d). MoS2 ND symmetric supercapacitor exhibited 65% of capacitance
retention for current loads varying from 1 to 2.5 A/g.Figure , illustrates the
cyclic stability and Coulombic efficiency of MoS2 ND supercapacitor
for an input load of 2.5 A/g. As seen in Figure a, as-assembled symmetric supercapacitor
demonstrated a capacitance retention of ∼100% in the first
300 cycles and then begins to flatten. The electrode material demonstrated
a capacitance retention of ∼86% over 1000 cycles. CD curve
obtained in first and last few cycles are shown in Figure a, inset. Similarly, the MoS2 NDs displayed an excellent Coulombic efficiency of 100% at
the end of 1000 CD cycles, which further highlights the advantage
of the MoS2 ND electrode. Hence, we can conclude that the
MoS2 ND symmetric supercapacitor exhibits good reversibility
of energy storage. The Ragone plot obtained for the MoS2 ND supercapacitor is shown in Figure b. As observed, the fabricated supercapacitor exhibited
high energy density without comprising much power density. A high
energy density and power density of 22 W h/kg and 1300 W/kg were obtained
for a current load of 1 A/g. The fabricated supercapacitor exhibited
gravimetric energy and power density of 2.4 W h/kg and ∼10,000
W/kg, respectively, though the input current load was 10 A/g. The
energy and power characteristics obtained in the present work were
compared to previously reported work as shown in Figure b.[2,11,50−53] As illustrated in Figure b, present work demonstrated
better energy density compared to Krishamoorthy et al.,[11] Javed et al.,[50] and
Patil et al.[52] EIS was also performed on
supercapacitor for a frequency range of 100 kHz to 1 Hz. Nyquist plot
obtained before and after 1000 cycles is shown in Figure c. As observed, the Nyquist
plot obtained exhibited a similar trend even after 1000 cycles. The
slope of the linear curve in lower frequency that accounts for diffusive
resistance (Warburg impedance) is greater than 45°, indicating
the capacitive behavior.[2,11,30,41,54,55] An equivalent circuit for the same is provided
in Figure c (inset).
An equivalent series resistance (Rs) of ∼4.01 Ω was observed for supercapacitor before
and after 1000 cycles, demonstrating the stability of fabricated supercapacitor.
Figure 7
Electrochemical
properties of symmetric MoS2 ND supercapacitor (a) capacitance
retention of supercapacitor for current load of 2.5 A/g and inset
illustrating first few and last few cycles (b) Ragone plot for MoS2 ND supercapacitor. (c) Nyquist plot (d) Bode plot.
Electrochemical
properties of symmetric MoS2 ND supercapacitor (a) capacitance
retention of supercapacitor for current load of 2.5 A/g and inset
illustrating first few and last few cycles (b) Ragone plot for MoS2 ND supercapacitor. (c) Nyquist plot (d) Bode plot.Bode plot shown in Figure d indicates, at lower frequencies phase angle (Φ) is
closer to 90°, exhibiting the behavior of an ideal capacitor
(Cdl). However, a deviation from the ideal
capacitive behavior is associated with faradaic charge transfer process
occurring as shown in eq .[2,54] The presence of Cf component
in the equivalent circuit shown in Figure c; inset ascertains the redox nature of the
symmetric supercapacitor.
Conclusions
In
this preliminary study, we have demonstrated
the fabrication of 3D MoS2 ND-impregnated Ni foam as binder-free
electrode for supercapacitor applications. The sub-5 nm MoS2 NDs were successfully synthesized by controlled bath sonication
of 2D nanocrystalline MoS2 sheets that were obtained via
thermal annealing of the ATTM precursor. The fabrication of the electrode
was achieved by simple and economical dip-coating procedure. The morphological
and structural characterizations confirmed the formation NDs as well
as successful deposition of MoS2 NDs on the 3D nickel substrate.
The resulting electrode material exhibited a superior capacitance
value (Csp) 395 F/g for an input load
of 1.5 A/g compared to bulk and nano MoS2 based electrodes
in a three-electrode configuration. In addition, a symmetric supercapacitor
was also fabricated and successfully evaluated the supercapacitive
performance of the electrode material. The latter demonstrated promising
values (Csp = 122 F/g at 1 A/g) and a
cyclic performance of 86% over 1000 runs. Furthermore, a high energy
and power density of 22 W h/kg and 10,000 W/kg were achieved, respectively.
Overall, the presented approach can be extended to the large-scale
production of economical binder-free electrode based on MoS2 NDs for various energy storage applications.
Authors: Urmimala Maitra; Uttam Gupta; Mrinmoy De; Ranjan Datta; A Govindaraj; C N R Rao Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2013-11-11 Impact factor: 15.336