| Literature DB >> 32427321 |
S Ariane Christie1, Drusia Dickson1, Susana N Mbeboh2, Frida N Embolo2, William Chendjou2, Emerson Wepngong2, Ahmed N Fonje2, Eunice Oben2, Kareen Azemfac2, Alain Chichom Mefire2, Theophile Nana3, M Agbor Mbianyor2, Patrick Stern1, Rochelle Dicker4, Catherine Juillard4.
Abstract
Importance: Despite the highest injury rates worldwide, formal medical care is not often sought after injuries in Sub-Saharan Africa. Unaffordable costs associated with trauma care might inhibit injured patients from seeking care.Entities:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32427321 PMCID: PMC7237963 DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.5171
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JAMA Netw Open ISSN: 2574-3805
Figure 1. Use of Formal Medical Care After Injury in the Southwest Region of Cameroon
Percentages are adjusted for the clustered sampling method. SE indicates standard error.
aP = .86 for the proportion of formal care seeking among participants with fatal vs nonfatal injuries.
Participant and Household Demographics of Participants Who Sought Formal Care vs Those Who Delayed or Did Not Seek Formal Care
| Characteristic | Care group | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Formal care first (n = 272) | Delayed or no formal care (n = 217) | ||
| Age, median (IQR), y | 28 (19-40) | 23 (13-39) | .002 |
| Male, % (SE) | 61.8 (4.8) | 52.0 (5.0) | .14 |
| School completed, median (IQR), y | 8 (7-12) | 8 (5-13) | .41 |
| Weekly wage, median (IQR), US $ | 2.97 (0-17.18) | 0 (0-17.18) | .04 |
| Urban household, % (SE) | 52.5 (14.5) | 57.9 (14.6) | .25 |
| Wood cooking fuel used, % (SE) | 93.0 (2.4) | 91.2 (3.1) | .47 |
| Family owns a cell phone, % (SE) | 95.1 (1.7) | 95.4 (1.9) | .87 |
| Owns agricultural land, % (SE) | 68.2 (5.9) | 67.9 (7.0) | .96 |
| Transport time to care, mean (SD), min | 21.6 (4.5) | 22.8 (6.8) | .71 |
Abbreviations: IQR, interquartile range; SE, standard error.
Percentages reported are population estimates that have been adjusted for the clustered sampling method. The SEs present the level of variance.
Calculated using the χ2, adjusted Wald, or Kruskal-Wallis test as appropriate to compare categorical and continuous variables.
Analysis included individuals who do not earn wages, such as children.
Qualitative Summary of Barriers and Facilitators of Use of Formal Care After Injury
| Theme | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Cost structure as a barrier | Formal clinicians require cash payment in full before treatment is rendered, whereas traditional healers typically allow installation payment and payment in goods. | “When you go to a hospital, they ask you to pay an advance before they start treating you. But with the herbalist…he starts your treatment until a certain duration…But in the hospital, if you don’t have that money, they don’t help.” |
| “The nurse is insisting that they will not be attended to if they don’t pay their deposit for bed fee first. This can cause a patient to die easily since they have not been administered any treatment.” | ||
| Severity assessment as a barrier or facilitator | Care decisions are heavily influenced by responder evaluations of severity. | “It depends the gravity of the injury. Because let’s say if the, if the oil…instead of falling on his leg, it fell on the whole of his body, we would have taken him to the hospital immediately. Immediately!” |
| “You cannot stitch a wound in the house, or a traditional doctor cannot stitch a wound, yes. Or things like, you fell and broke your leg. That is, you feel like the bones are scattered inside. You will just rush to the hospital.” | ||
| Source of health care belief as a facilitator | Public health campaigns and advice were cited as influencing the decision-making process. Respondents focused more on advice content rather than expertise of the advice provider. | “And education, [the hospital] gives you education. They educate us, they tell us, ‘this one [illness] isn’t fine’…they take their time to tell us how diseases spread so that we can control them. They help us.” |
| “Medical personnel train us. They tell us, ‘If there is an accident and you can’t get a motortaxi quickly, this is what you should give them before you take the person to the hospital.… [Give them] pepper before you take them to the hospital’.… They are trained for both [traditional and formal medicine]. I heard him say he knows both. These Ghanaians, they know plenty about medical herbs.” | ||
| Use of multiple forms of care as a barrier or facilitator | Paradigms of care include an acceptance of multiple (sequential or concurrent) use of formal and informal care. Formal care will frequently be used for diagnosis, and then care will be transitioned to traditional medicine for treatment. | “Both [treatments] are fine.… Yes. If there is time for the hospital, we will try the hospital, if it works for you, you are lucky. If there is time for the hospital and it doesn’t work for you, go for the native medicine. If it isn’t the right case for the native doctor, he won’t try, you’ll go to the hospital. Yeah, you jambox [ie, meld or mesh] the two side. Yes.” |
| “Well, I just take it maximally, for the hospital is the hospital and…the man in the hospital is doctor, this is to say, is a specialist. And native doctor too is a specialist of different domains.… Yeah, because the doctor can use small machines on you, but with the herbalist, he has his own way of doing his own thing, his own uh, treatment.” |
Figure 2. Cost of Injury Treatment in the Southwest Region of Cameroon
Includes 471 participants with 503 injuries. Error bars indicate 95% CIs. RTI indicates road traffic injury.
Figure 3. Economic Consequences of Injury by Use of Formal Medical Care in Cameroon
Includes 471 participants with 503 injuries. The graph displays reports of economic consequences for the proportion of participants who used vs did not use formal care. P < .01 for all comparisons.