Successful pregnancy and delivery achieved following intracytoplasmic sperm injection using teratozoospermic sperm exhibiting marked dysplasia of the fibrous sheath: a case report.

A husband and his wife, both 34 years old, consulted our clinic because of primary infertility. Sperm analysis revealed that the sperm concentration, motility, and progressive motility were (42.8±22.8)×106/mL, 23.3%±12.2%, and 12.9%±6.1%, respectively. Based on Krugar strict morphology criteria, 100% of the sperm were teratozoospermic, with 7.9% DNA fragmentation index. Observation of the sperm under a transmission electron microscope revealed that most parts of the fibrous sheath (FS) surrounding the tails of the sperm were missing from midway through the principal piece to the end piece, although the sperm's heads, necks and midpieces were morphologically normal. To collect oocytes, the gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist protocol was carried out, and 7 oocytes were retrieved. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was performed for all the teratozoospermic sperm. Of the 7 oocytes, 3 were fertilized, and one 8-cell embryo and 2 expanded blastocysts were vitrified. Although repeated transfers of expanded blastocysts resulted in no implantation, one 8-cell embryo transfer in a hormone replacement therapy cycle led to pregnancy. The pregnancy using an 8-cell vitrified embryo resulted in the delivery of a healthy female baby at 38 weeks of gestation. No congenital malformations were found until 28 days after birth. Our results demonstrated that healthy birth could be achieved following the transfer of an embryo derived from ICSI using teratozoospermic sperm exhibiting the dysplasia of the fibrous sheath (DFS). Furthermore, while the previous reports on DFS have not investigated male infertility, we evaluated sperms from various aspects such as Kruger sperm function test, chromatin dispersion test, electron microscopy findings, time-lapse images of the obtained embryos, and concluded that ICSI could be desirable as a treatment policy for DFS. 2020 Translational Andrology and Urology. All rights reserved.

Introduction

Teratozoospermia is the morphological abnormality involving deformities of the head and tail of the sperm. Progress has been made in research investigating the association of teratozoospermia with sperm chromosomal abnormalities (1), however, there are only few reports on tail deformities contributing to teratozoospermia. Tail deformities can cause abnormal movement of the flagella, which may result in asthenozoospermia, leading to male infertility (2). Defects in the tail’s fibrous sheath (FS)—the primary structure of the tail that encloses the axial filament of the sperm tail—contributes to sperm tail deformity (3). FS is required for sperm plasticity and is known to contribute to the generation of kinetic energy in sperm. As a result, defects in FS structure can cause abnormal sperm motility (2).

Patients with dysplasia of the fibrous sheath (DFS) exhibit reduced sperm motility, making fertilization difficult with conventional in vitro fertilization (IVF). When DFS is diagnosed, it may be best to consider properly formed sperm for use in intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) (4). In the presence of many poorly formed sperm, ICSI is generally performed with sperm of good morphology, but cases with 100% tail abnormalities are generally not anticipated. There are very few reports of successful deliveries using morphologically abnormal sperm in ICSI, and the reports are old, containing little information about the sperm. Here, we report a case exhibits primary infertility, in which 100% of the sperm exhibited DFS with marked tail thinning that started around their central region. Nevertheless, a successful pregnancy and delivery were achieved using these sperm following ICSI. We present the following case in accordance with the CARE Guideline (5).

Case presentation

A Japanese husband and his wife, both 34 years old, came to our clinic for conception. They had primary infertility for 1 year and 2 months by the time they were examined at our clinic. There was nothing notable in their family histories, and the husband’s older brother and his female partner had a live birth from a natural pregnancy. The couple was performed timing intercourse once and Intra-Uterine Insemination twice but were unsuccessful. When the husband’s sperm were examined under a microscope during a semen analysis, all of the sperm exhibited thinning that started around the middle of the sperm tail (). Sperm motility and progressive motility were 23.3%±12.2% and 12.9%±6.1% (mean ± standard deviation), respectively. Both the values were below the standard thresholds defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) and indicated asthenozoospermia (). Semen volume and sperm concentration were within the reference range. Volumes of both the left and right testes were examined to be same (24 mL) with no abnormal findings in a scrotal ultrasonography. Presence of a varicocele was not detected. A blood test revealed that the levels of luteinizing hormone (4.2 mIU/mL), follicle-stimulating hormone (5.7 mIU/mL), and total testosterone (6.24 ng/mL) were within the reference ranges. As pregnancy had not occurred with non-assisted reproductive technology (ART) treatments and the patient exhibited asthenozoospermia with morphological abnormalities of the sperm tails, we decided to perform ART. Furthermore, due to the sperm tail abnormalities and reduced motility rate, we considered fertilization with conventional IVF to be difficult and decided to use ICSI following previous studies (6,7). We explained the treatment policy to the couple, mentioning the possibility that the abnormalities of the tail might be transmitted to the next generation, and informed consent was obtained.

Figure 1

The patient’s sperm and a sperm with normal morphology viewed with differential interference (×600). (A) The patient’s sperm starts to thin drastically starting around the middle of the tail, which continues to the end; (B) no areas of thinning can be seen in the sperm with normal morphology. Scale bars: 5 µm.

Table 1

Test results of the 7 semen samples

Semen tests	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	Mean ± SD
Semen volume (mL)	2.0	2.4	2.0	1.2	3.6	2.2	4.5	2.6±1.0
Sperm concentration (×106/mL)	26.9	54.5	83.0	16.4	62.5	20.6	35.5	42.8±22.8
Sperm motility (%)	16.4	33.0	48.2	14.6	23.2	9.7	18.3	23.3±12.2
Sperm progressive motility (%)	13.4	17.4	24.1	9.8	12.8	2.9	9.9	12.9±6.2

Methods

Semen analyses

After 2–3 days of abstinence, the patient masturbated to collect 7 semen samples. After confirming liquefaction, semen volume, sperm concentration, motility rate, and progressive motility rate were measured based on the WHO’s standards for semen analyses (8). To determine the proportion of deformed sperm, the man’s sperm were smeared on a glass slide, and the dried specimens were stained using Diff-Quik® (Sysmex Corporation, Kobe, Japan). Two hundred of the stained sperm were counted following the WHO’s Krugar strict criteria.

Sperm chromatin dispersion test

Three samples of semen—the patient’s sperm and two control samples of sperm without any sperm deformities—were examined by sperm chromatin dispersion test as described method with little modifications (9) (Supplementary 1).

Transmission electron microscopy

The patient’s sperm and a control sample of the sperm with no clear deformities in a semen test were analyzed under a transmission electron microscope as described method with little modifications (10) (Supplementary 2).

ICSI and culture methods

ICSI was performed according to previously described methods (11). Sperm selection and sperm immobilization were performed in 7% PVP. Sperm immobilization was performed based on a previous report (12). After immobilization with the 2 Piezo pulses, the sperm with normal tail morphology generally appear bent but are not severed. However, in the present case, because of the presence of the thin regions in the sperm tails, the tails were more fragile than those with normal morphology and were easily severed by the Piezo pulses (). When Piezo pulses were applied to the regions on the sperm tails that appeared to have normal thickness, the tails were not severed. Therefore, to avoid using sperm with severed tails in ICSI, Piezo pulses were only applied to the sperm with tails that appeared to have normal thickness, immobilizing them without severing their tails. Oocytes that underwent ICSI were cultured individually using a µDrop GPS® (LifeGlobal, China) culture dish, 50 µL of SAGE 1-Step (ORIGIO) culture medium, and a CCM-iBIS (Astec Co., Japan) incubator at 37 °C, in an environment of 5% CO2, 5% O2, and 90% N2. Time lapse photographs were taken every 15 minutes after ICSI. Considering the day of the oocyte collection as day 0, survival and fertilization were assessed on day 1 and then the oocytes cultured until day 5 and cryopreserved. Cryopreservation of embryos were performed according to previously described methods. A single vitrified-warmed embryo transfer was performed during a hormone replacement treatment cycle.

Figure 2

Sperm with a severed deformed tail. The arrow shows the sperm tail severed by a Piezo pulse. Scale bars: 5 µm.

Analysis of fertilized embryos and division speed

Time lapse images of the 3 embryos that were fertilized with ICSI were analyzed retrospectively. With ICSI as the starting point, the time (hours) taken for a 2-cell, 4-cell, 5-cell, morula, and a blastocyst formation were defined as T2, T4, T5, TM, and TB, respectively.

Results

shows the results of the 7 semen sample analyses. The motility rate was over 40% only in the case of the third semen sample, with the other 6 samples showing motility rates and progressive motility rates much lower than the WHO standards (8).

Based on the Krugar strict criteria for categorizing the sperm, in the current case, all the sperm had abnormal tails, with a normal morphology rate of 0%.

Analysis of sperm chromatin dispersion test results

The DNA fragmentation rate of the patient’s semen and that of the two control samples were 7.6%, 5.5%, and 6.9%, respectively (). No clear differences were found between the DNA fragmentation rates of the patient’s semen and that of the control samples’, suggesting that the tail deformities are not necessarily accompanied by abnormalities in sperm DNA.

Figure 3

Sperm chromatin dispersion test. (A) Sperm chromatin dispersion test of the patient’s sperm; (B) sperm chromatin dispersion test of the sperm with normal morphology. Scale bars: 20 µm.

Analysis of transmission electron microscopy findings

Observation of the patient’s sperm under a transmission electron microscope showed that most parts of the FS surrounding the tails of the sperm were missing from midway through the principal piece to the end piece (). A light microscope observation also showed thinning of the tails starting from the FS defects. Nothing abnormal was observed from the sperm head to the central fragment. The axial filaments of the sperm tails maintained their 9+2 structure. Apart from the FS defects, no other structural abnormalities were observed ().

Figure 4

Electron microscope images of fibrous sheath defects in a sperm tail. (A) The fibrous sheath is truncated and partially missing in the patient’s sperm; (B) the fibrous sheath is contiguous with no defects in the sperm with normal morphology. Scale bars: 500 nm.

Figure 5

Short-axis electron microscope images of the patient’s sperm and sperm with normal morphology. (A) The 9+2 structure of the axial filament is maintained in the patient’s sperm; (B) a short-axis slice of sperm with normal morphology. Scale bars: 500 nm.

Analysis of the fertilized embryos and division speed

shows the time points for the normally fertilized embryos. Compared to the previous reports, no clear differences in the timings of embryonic development during pregnancy were observed for T2 (21.4–34.8 h), T3 (27.8–47.8 h), T4 (33.1–57.2 h), T5 (37.5–67.0 h), TM (57.6–102.8 h), or TB (94.6–117.8 h) (13).

Table 2

Time points (h) from intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) using vitrified-warmed embryos

Embryo	T2	T3	T4	T5	TM	TB
Grade 1 8-cell	30.1	40.1	40.4	50.6	–	–
Grade 4BB	22.9	31.9	32.4	43.1	79.9	86.6
Grade 4BC	25.7	35.7	36.9	48.7	86.2	96.7

Case course

Ovarian stimulation was performed using the antagonist method for collecting oocytes. Nine oocytes were collected based on the transvaginal ultrasound. After preincubation, ICSI was performed on the 7 mature oocytes following 6 hours of collection. Considering the day of the oocyte collection as day 0, fertilization was confirmed after 24–25 hours (day 1), and 3 fertilized oocytes that exhibited 2 pronucleus (PN) were cultured until day 5. An 8-cell embryo (Veeck classification Grade 1) was vitrified for storage on day 3, and two blastocysts were vitrified on day 4 (Gardner classification 4BB) and day 5 (Gardner 4BC). Vitrified-warmed embryo transfer was performed during a hormone replacement treatment cycle. On day 5 after starting luteal support, both the blastocysts were transferred, but pregnancy could not be achieved. On day 3 after starting luteal support, an 8-cell embryo was transferred, and on day 12 after the transfer, a positive pregnancy response (serum human chorionic gonadotropin 242.6 mIU/mL) was obtained, and two weeks later, 1 fetal heartbeat was confirmed in the uterus. The pregnancy was normal, and the patient gave birth to a healthy 3,400 g female baby at 38 weeks’ gestation. Till 1 month, the neonate exhibited no clear abnormalities (14).

Discussion

DFS in the present case did not affect the fragmentation rate of the sperm DNA. Furthermore, despite 100% of the sperm being deformed and exhibiting a reduced motility rate, no abnormality in the testicular volume or hormone levels could be found, and successful pregnancy was achieved through ICSI. This case demonstrates that ICSI can be an effective method of fertilization in cases of sperm with DFS.

The FS of sperm tails in mammals is a cytoskeletal component that surrounds the axial filament with a 9+2 arrangement of microtubules and 9 outer dense fibers and is known to play a variety of roles (15). The number of functions of the FS that have so far been discovered (2) are as follows: (I) the FS protects the axial filament and controls the sperm’s flagellar movement, (II) it transmits calcium signals via proteins such as A-kinase-anchoring protein (AKAP) 4 and AKAP3, (III) a glycolysis enzyme that exists in the FS—glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH)—takes part in hyperactivation of the sperm. Owing to the above functions, FS defects are expected to cause a variety of symptoms. In a study of AKAP4 knockout mice, the outer dense fibers of the sperm were preserved in the absence of FS, which resulted in abnormal flagellar movements causing infertility (16).

DFS in human sperm was first reported by Chemes et al. in 1987 as a hereditary factor (3). Mutations of genes involved in the FS formation can cause thinning or hyperplasia of the sperm principal piece, causing the tail to shorten or thicken (4). The present case did not exhibit any clear familial factors and was considered as an isolated occurrence. Moreover, conventional IVF has been reported to be unsuccessful in producing fertilized oocytes using sperm with DFS, indicating that this may not be an effective technique in such cases (4,6,7,17). Based on these reports, we chose ICSI, which resulted in lower 2PN rate while having no effects on the normal development of the fertilized oocytes. In addition, transfer of an early embryo resulting in a successful pregnancy and delivery of a healthy baby indicates that ICSI can be an effective technique in patients with DFS.

Progress has been made in research involving the sperm deformity and its association with the rates of DNA fragmentation. The DNA fragmentation rate in the present case was 7.6%, which is not much different than that of the control specimens measured at the same time (5.5% and 6.9%) and is much lower than the level above which natural pregnancy is thought to be difficult (30%) (18). This suggests that, DFS may not affect DNA fragmentation. Furthermore, no obvious abnormalities in the testicular volume or hormone levels were observed in this case, and a fertilized embryo developed through pregnancy, leading to delivery with no abnormalities. Apart from the reduced motility rate accompanying the tail deformity, there were no other notable findings. While the previous reports on DFS did not investigate male infertility, our case may serve as a helpful reference going forward.

To date, there are 4 reports on patients with DFS whose sperm were used in successful deliveries (6,7,17,19). These results show that a wide variety of morphologies of sperm with DFS are observed. Usually, the sperm with nearly normal morphology can be selected and used in ICSI. In this case and in other births from sperm with DFS, all the babies are reported to be healthy with no chromosomal abnormalities or deformities. This indicates that the sperm with DFS are still fertile and can result in healthy deliveries, without causing major deformities in the child. In addition, it cannot be said that this 100% of the sperm exhibited DFS could not be fertilized with conventional IVF, but ICSI is considered desirable as a treatment policy.

In the present case, 2 blastocysts could not be implanted, but an 8-cell embryo was transferred. Generally, sperm-derived activation occurs in the latter half of embryonic development (20). We retrospectively examined the time points in embryonic development to determine whether the use of the deformed sperm had any negative effects on growth. The 2 blastocysts that could not be implanted and the one 8-cell embryo that was implanted were from T2 to TB and did not exhibit any clear differences in the timings of their development compared to what are considered as healthy embryos. We were concerned that the use of deformed sperm in the present case might lead to abnormalities in the latter stages of embryonic development, but the blastocysts developed without any difficulties.

In the present case, other than reduced motility rates due to tail deformities, no other abnormal findings were observed in the sperm with DFS, and ICSI resulted in the birth of a healthy female baby. Based on the findings of our study, we postulate that while developing a treatment plan with cases of infertility related to DFS, waste of time on attempting a natural pregnancy or insemination may be avoided by selecting ICSI as the first option.

The article’s supplementary files as