Kevin L Schwartz1, Bradley J Langford2, Nick Daneman2, Branson Chen2, Kevin A Brown2, Warren McIsaac2, Karen Tu2, Elisa Candido2, Jennie Johnstone2, Valerie Leung2, Jeremiah Hwee2, Michael Silverman2, Julie H C Wu2, Gary Garber2. 1. Public Health Ontario (Schwartz, Langford, Brown, Johnstone, Leung, Wu, Garber); ICES Central (Schwartz, Daneman, Chen, Brown, Candido); Unity Health Network (Langford), St. Joseph Health Centre; Sunnybrook Research Institute (Daneman); Ray D. Wolfe Department of Family Medicine (McIsaac), Sinai Health System; Departments of Family & Community Medicine (McIsaac, Tu) and Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology (Johnstone), University of Toronto; North York General Hospital (Tu); Toronto Western Hospital Family Health Team (Tu), University Health Network; Toronto East Health Network (Leung), Michael Garron Hospital; Dalla Lana School of Public Health (Hwee), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; Institute for Better Health (Hwee), Trillium Health Partners, Mississauga, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Silverman), London, Ont.; Ottawa Hospital Research Institute (Garber); Department of Medicine (Garber), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont. Kevin.schwartz@oahpp.ca. 2. Public Health Ontario (Schwartz, Langford, Brown, Johnstone, Leung, Wu, Garber); ICES Central (Schwartz, Daneman, Chen, Brown, Candido); Unity Health Network (Langford), St. Joseph Health Centre; Sunnybrook Research Institute (Daneman); Ray D. Wolfe Department of Family Medicine (McIsaac), Sinai Health System; Departments of Family & Community Medicine (McIsaac, Tu) and Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology (Johnstone), University of Toronto; North York General Hospital (Tu); Toronto Western Hospital Family Health Team (Tu), University Health Network; Toronto East Health Network (Leung), Michael Garron Hospital; Dalla Lana School of Public Health (Hwee), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.; Institute for Better Health (Hwee), Trillium Health Partners, Mississauga, Ont.; London Health Sciences Centre (Silverman), London, Ont.; Ottawa Hospital Research Institute (Garber); Department of Medicine (Garber), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ont.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Unnecessary antibiotic use in the community in Canada is not well defined. Our objective was to quantify unnecessary antibiotic prescribing in a Canadian primary care setting. METHODS: We performed a descriptive analysis in Ontario from April 2011 to March 2016 using the Electronic Medical Records Primary Care database linked to other health administrative data sets at ICES. We determined antibiotic prescribing rates (per 100 patient-physician encounters) for 23 common conditions and estimated rates of unnecessary prescribing using predefined expected prescribing rates, both stratified by condition and patient age group. RESULTS: The study included 341 physicians, 204 313 patients and 499 570 encounters. The rate of unnecessary antibiotic prescribing for included conditions was 15.4% overall and was 17.6% for those less than 2 years of age, 18.6% for those aged 2-18, 14.5% for those aged 19-64 and 13.0% for those aged 65 or more. The highest unnecessary prescribing rates were observed for acute bronchitis (52.6%), acute sinusitis (48.4%) and acute otitis media (39.3%). The common cold, acute bronchitis, acute sinusitis and miscellaneous nonbacterial infections were responsible for 80% of the unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions. Of all antibiotics prescribed, 12.0% were for conditions for which they are never indicated, and 12.3% for conditions for which they are rarely indicated. In children, 25% of antibiotics were for conditions for which they are never indicated (e.g., common cold). INTERPRETATION: Antibiotics were prescribed unnecessarily for 15.4% of included encounters in a Canadian primary care setting. Almost one-quarter of antibiotics were prescribed for conditions for which they are rarely or never indicated. These findings should guide safe reductions in the use of antibiotics for the common cold, bronchitis and sinusitis. Copyright 2020, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
BACKGROUND: Unnecessary antibiotic use in the community in Canada is not well defined. Our objective was to quantify unnecessary antibiotic prescribing in a Canadian primary care setting. METHODS: We performed a descriptive analysis in Ontario from April 2011 to March 2016 using the Electronic Medical Records Primary Care database linked to other health administrative data sets at ICES. We determined antibiotic prescribing rates (per 100 patient-physician encounters) for 23 common conditions and estimated rates of unnecessary prescribing using predefined expected prescribing rates, both stratified by condition and patient age group. RESULTS: The study included 341 physicians, 204 313 patients and 499 570 encounters. The rate of unnecessary antibiotic prescribing for included conditions was 15.4% overall and was 17.6% for those less than 2 years of age, 18.6% for those aged 2-18, 14.5% for those aged 19-64 and 13.0% for those aged 65 or more. The highest unnecessary prescribing rates were observed for acute bronchitis (52.6%), acute sinusitis (48.4%) and acute otitis media (39.3%). The common cold, acute bronchitis, acute sinusitis and miscellaneous nonbacterial infections were responsible for 80% of the unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions. Of all antibiotics prescribed, 12.0% were for conditions for which they are never indicated, and 12.3% for conditions for which they are rarely indicated. In children, 25% of antibiotics were for conditions for which they are never indicated (e.g., common cold). INTERPRETATION: Antibiotics were prescribed unnecessarily for 15.4% of included encounters in a Canadian primary care setting. Almost one-quarter of antibiotics were prescribed for conditions for which they are rarely or never indicated. These findings should guide safe reductions in the use of antibiotics for the common cold, bronchitis and sinusitis. Copyright 2020, Joule Inc. or its licensors.
Authors: Nadine Shehab; Maribeth C Lovegrove; Andrew I Geller; Kathleen O Rose; Nina J Weidle; Daniel S Budnitz Journal: JAMA Date: 2016-11-22 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Barbara Ellen Jones; Brian Sauer; Makoto M Jones; Jose Campo; Kavitha Damal; Tao He; Jian Ying; Tom Greene; Matthew Bidwell Goetz; Melinda M Neuhauser; Lauri A Hicks; Matthew H Samore Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2015-07-21 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Katherine E Fleming-Dutra; Adam L Hersh; Daniel J Shapiro; Monina Bartoces; Eva A Enns; Thomas M File; Jonathan A Finkelstein; Jeffrey S Gerber; David Y Hyun; Jeffrey A Linder; Ruth Lynfield; David J Margolis; Larissa S May; Daniel Merenstein; Joshua P Metlay; Jason G Newland; Jay F Piccirillo; Rebecca M Roberts; Guillermo V Sanchez; Katie J Suda; Ann Thomas; Teri Moser Woo; Rachel M Zetts; Lauri A Hicks Journal: JAMA Date: 2016-05-03 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Brian G Bell; Francois Schellevis; Ellen Stobberingh; Herman Goossens; Mike Pringle Journal: BMC Infect Dis Date: 2014-01-09 Impact factor: 3.090
Authors: Paul Little; Michael Moore; Jo Kelly; Ian Williamson; Geraldine Leydon; Lisa McDermott; Mark Mullee; Beth Stuart Journal: BMJ Date: 2014-03-06
Authors: Martin C Gulliford; A Toby Prevost; Judith Charlton; Dorota Juszczyk; Jamie Soames; Lisa McDermott; Kirin Sultana; Mark Wright; Robin Fox; Alastair D Hay; Paul Little; Michael V Moore; Lucy Yardley; Mark Ashworth Journal: BMJ Date: 2019-02-12
Authors: Karen Tu; Jessica Widdifield; Jacqueline Young; William Oud; Noah M Ivers; Debra A Butt; Chad A Leaver; Liisa Jaakkimainen Journal: BMC Med Inform Decis Mak Date: 2015-08-13 Impact factor: 2.796
Authors: Julie Hui-Chih Wu; Fatima Khalid; Bradley J Langford; Nathan P Beahm; Mark McIntyre; Kevin L Schwartz; Gary Garber; Valerie Leung Journal: Can Pharm J (Ott) Date: 2021-04-08
Authors: Ariana Saatchi; Andrew M Morris; David M Patrick; James Mccormack; Romina C Reyes; Phillip Morehouse; Jennifer Reid; Salimah Shariff; Marcus Povitz; Michael Silverman; Fawziah Marra Journal: JAC Antimicrob Resist Date: 2021-08-12
Authors: Braden D Knight; Jayson Shurgold; Glenys Smith; Derek R MacFadden; Kevin L Schwartz; Nick Daneman; Denise Gravel Tropper; James Brooks Journal: Clin Microbiol Infect Date: 2021-10-30 Impact factor: 8.067
Authors: Ariana Saatchi; Jennifer N Reid; Marcus Povitz; Salimah Z Shariff; Michael Silverman; Andrew M Morris; Romina C Reyes; David M Patrick; Fawziah Marra Journal: Antibiotics (Basel) Date: 2021-12-03