| Literature DB >> 32377231 |
Ayun Cassell1,2, Bashir Yunusa2, Burgess Manobah2, Desire Wambo1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Penile cancer is a rare malignancy with prevalence higher in areas of high Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) such as Africa, Asia and South America. In middle- and low-income countries where circumcision is not routinely practiced, the rate of penile cancer could be ten times higher. MAIN BODY OF THE ABSTRACT: A literature review was conducted from 1992 to 2019 using PubMed, Google Scholar, African Journal Online and Google with inclusion of 27 publications with emphasis on the Sub-Saharan literature. Findings revealed that most men with penile cancer in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) present with locally advanced to advanced disease with devastating consequences. The option of penile sparing procedure is reduced with most treatment option directed to mutilating surgeries. The lack of appropriate chemotherapy and radiotherapy worsens the prognosis in the region. SHORTEntities:
Keywords: Human papilloma virus; Penectomy; Penile Cancer; Sub-Saharan Africa
Year: 2020 PMID: 32377231 PMCID: PMC7195778 DOI: 10.1186/s13027-020-00293-9
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Infect Agent Cancer ISSN: 1750-9378 Impact factor: 2.965
Demographics, study period, age parameters, occupation and co-morbididty
| Study | Study Period | Number of Patients | Mean Age (years) | Age Range (years) | Occupation | Co-morbidities |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ngendaho et al. Rwanda [ | 2015–2016 | 30 | 60 yrs | 33 yrs–83 yrs | Petty farmers: 86.7% | HIV Infection: 20% HPV: Not tested |
| Diallo et al. Guinea [ | 1996–2013 | 06 | 51 yrs | 32 yrs–80 yrs | N/A | HIV infection:16.7% HPV: Not tested |
| Magoha et al. Kenya [ | 1970–1999 | 55 | 47.9 yrs | 20 yrs–80 yrs | N/A | HIV infection: not tested HPV: Not tested |
| Wentzel et al. South Africa (Blacks) [ | 2000–2008 | 65 | 50.9 yrs | 37 yr –69 yrs | N/A | HIV Infection: 56.2% HPV: 41.5% |
| Gueye et al. Senegal [ | 10 years | 11 | 55 yrs | 40 yrs–75 yrs | N/A | HIV: 9.1% HPV: Not tested |
| Ajekigbe et al. Nigeria [ | 1990–2009 | 07 | 52.2 yrs | 42 yrs–79 yrs | N/A | HIV infection: not tested HPV: Not tested |
| Sow et al. Cameroon [ | 1994–2005 | 08 | N/A | 43 yrs–75 yrs | Rural inhabitants: 100% | HIV infection: 12.5% HPV: Not tested |
| Abdulkadir et al. Nigeria [ | 1998–2015 | 06 | 59.7 yrs | 50 yrs–75 yrs | ||
| Chalya et al. Tanzania [ | 2004–2013 | 236 | 47 yrs | 21 yrs–78 yrs | Unemployed | HIV infection: 6.7% HPV: 5.1% |
| Sow et al. Senegal [ | 2000–2011 | 08 | 51.5 yrs | 27 yrs–77 yrs | Low socioeconomic status |
HIV Human Immunodeficiency Virus, HPV Human Papilloma Virus, N/A Not Available
Risk factors, clinical presentation, histology and staging
| Study | Risk Factors | Clinical Presentation | Histology | Stage (TMN/Jackson) | ILN status + Metastasis | Grade + Metastasis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ngendaho et al. [ | Phimosis: 50% Poor Hygiene:80% Smoking: 56.7% Lichen Sclerosis:13.3% | Subpreputial symptoms: 63.3% Penile Ulceration:26.7% Meatal lesion: 10% | SCC: 100% | T1:3.3% T2: 36.7%T3: 56.7%T4:3.3% | N0:43.3% N1:20% N2:23.3% N3:13.3% M1: 16.7% | G1:43.3% G2: 50% G3: 6.7% |
| Diallo et al. [ | Late Circumcision: 66.7% | Fungating Ulcerated | SCC: 100% | T1:16.7 T2:33.3% T3:50% | N2:66.7% M1:16.7% | G1:33.3% G2:16.7% G3:50% |
| Magoha et al. [ | Uncircumcision: 72.7% Late Circmcision: 21.8% | N/A | SCC:100% | Stage 1: 18.2% Stage 2: 12.7% Stage 3: 50.9% Stage 4: 18.2% | N/A | N/A |
| Wentzel et al. [ | N/A | N/A | SCC: 80% VC: 15.4% | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Gueye et al. [ | Uncircumcision: 18.2% Late Circmcision: 27.3% Phimosis: 18.2% | N/A | SCC: 90.9% | Stage 1: 36.4% Stage 2: 45.5% Stage 3: 18.2% | N: 27.3% M1: 0% | N/A |
| Ajekigbe et al. [ | N/A | Ulcerated Warty | SCC: 100% | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Sow et al. [ | Childhood circumcision: 100% | Ulceration Fungating Fungating + Ulcerated | SCC: 87.5% NHL: 12.5% | Stage 3&4: 100% | N2&N3: 100% | N/A |
| Abdulkadir et al. [ | N/A | N/A | SCC: 100% | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Chayla et al. [ | Uncircumcision: 89.8% Smoking: 77.1% Phimosis: 62.3% Repeated STDs: 22.9% | SCC: 99.2% | Stage 1: 10.2% Stage 2: 11.2% Stage 3: 55.9% Stage 4: 12.7% | N: 65.3% M: 4.2% | ||
| Sow et al. [ | Poor hygiene | Fungating + Ulcerated | SCC: 100% | T1: 12.5% T2: 50% T3: 37.5% T4: 00% | N0: 62.5% N1: 00% N2: 12.5% N3: 37.5% M1: 00% | G1: 25% G2: 62.5% G3: 12.5% |
G Grade, M Metastasis, N Node, NHL Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma, N/A Not Available, SCC Squamous Cell Carcinoma, T Tumor
Management, Complication and Follow-up
| Ngendaho et al. [ | Glans: 46.7% | Partial Penectomy: 80% Total Penectomy:13.3% Penectomy + ILND:33.3% | N/A | SSI:10%; Lymphocele:10%, Skin necrosis, Death, Meatal stenosis | 0% recurrence at 6 months |
| Diallo et al. [ | Glans: 33.3% Glans + Penile Shaft: 66.7% | PP: 16.7% TP + ILND: 16.7% Emasculation:16.7% Decline Treatment:33.3% | N/A | N/A | 50% Loss to follow-up 1-year mortality 33.3% |
| Magoha et al. [ | Glans: 43.6% Glans + Penile Shaft: 21.8% Prepuce: 12.7% | Circumcision: 3.6% Local Excision + Rad: 7.2% PP + Rad: 20.1% PP + Chemo: 5.5% PP + Chemo + rad: 10.9% TP + Rad: 14.5% | Rad alone: 9.1% Chemo + Rad: 10.9% | N/A | N/A |
| Gueye et al. [ | Glans: 36.4% Glans + Shaft: 45.5% | Partial Penectomy: 18.2% Total Penectomy: 9.1% Decline Treatment: 72.7% | N/A | N/A | 100% Loss to Follow-up |
| Ajekigbe et al [ | Penile Shaft: 42.9% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Sow et al. [ | Glans: 62.5%% Shaft: 12.5% Prepuce: 25% | TP: 37.5% Emasculation + ILND:12.5% | N/A | N/A | Loss to follow-up: 50% |
| Abdulkadir et al. [ | Glans: 50% Glans + Prepuce:33.3% Shaft: 16.7% | ||||
| Chayla et al. [ | Glans: 60.1% Glans + Shaft: 13.6% Prepuce: 7.6% | Partial penectomy: 63.1% Total Penectomy:10.8% ILND: 16.8% Penile sparing: 9.3% | Chemo: 5.9% Rad: 5.1% | SSI: 44.8%; DVT: 15.5% Chronic Pain: 13.8% Scrotal edema: 10.3% | 76.1% loss to follow-up at 5 years Mortality:10% Recurrence: 5.3% |
| Sow et al. [ | Glans: 12.5% Glans + Shaft: 62.5% Shaft: 25% | Partial Penectomy: 62.5% TP + ILND: 12.5% Decline Treatment: 25% | 25% loss to follow-up Recurrence: 12.5% Death: 12.5% |
DVT: Chemo: Chemotherapy; Deep Venous Thrombosis, ILND: Inguinal Lymph Node Dissection; N/A: Not Available; PP: Partial Penectomy; Rad: Radiotherapy; SSI: Surgical Site Infection; TP: Total Penectomy
Fig. 1a-b Shows an advanced ulcerated and fungated penile mass that has eroded the glans, the corpora bodies and urethra