New MOF/COF Hybrid as a Robust Adsorbent for Simultaneous Removal of Auramine O and Rhodamine B Dyes.

In this study, by hybridization of zinc-based metal-organic framework-5 (MOF-5) and melamine-terephthaldehyde-based intergrade two-dimensional π-conjugated covalent organic framework (COF), a novel MOF-5/COF (M5C) hybrid material was prepared and characterized by Fourier transform infrared, field emission scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, and thermogravimetric analysis. MOF-5 has a well-defined cubic structure, and the proposed COF has an orderly and spherical nanosize shape. The prepared MOF-5/COF was applied as an effective adsorbent for rapid and high-efficient simultaneous removal of auramine O (AO) and rhodamine B (RB) cationic dyes via electrostatic, H-bonding, Lewis acid-base interactions, and π-π stacking from aqueous solution. The effect of experimental parameters such as pH, M5C mass, contact time, and AO and RB dyes concentration was investigated for removal efficiency and optimized. The M5C adsorbent showed an adsorption capacity of 17.95 and 16.18 mg/g for AO and RB dyes, respectively, at pH 9.5. The adsorption study of AO and RB dyes by M5C comprises both isotherm and kinetic studies. The equilibrium adsorption data followed by Langmuir isotherm and the adsorption kinetic process were found to be a pseudo-second-order model. The robustness adsorption efficiency of MOF/COF hybrids can be attributed to the formation of amide bonds between COF and MOFs, which improve the stability of the adsorbent.

Introduction

Recently, because of the rapid development of various industries, large amounts of dyeing wastewater are released into the environment directly without appropriate treatments.[1−4] The n class="Disease">toxicity of industrial dyes imposes a serious menace to the water perimeter and human health.[5] Synthetic dyes from printing and dyeing industries hamper sunlight penetration into water and causes the death of plants and animals, as well as is harmful to humans.[6,7] Accordingly, efficient treatment technologies such as photocatalytic oxidation or reduction, membrane filtration, biological treatment, and adsorption have been developed for the removal of organic dyes from wastewater.[7−10] Amongst the removal techniques, adsorption is an eco-friendly technology for the removal of dyes from wastewater owing to its simple operation, great efficiency, and economic facility and produces no byproducts.[11,12] For the adsorption process, finding a new effective surface adsorbent containing aromatic rings, functional groups, and reactive sites for π–π stacking, H-bonding, and electrostatic interactions with other aromatic-containing compounds with OH, NH, =O, and SH groups as well as surface charges for efficient capture is very important.[13,14] A hybrid of two of these compounds is discussed in this study.

New compounds with diverse structures and unique properties are considered for various applications in chemical and material science in recent years. Therefore, n class="Chemical">metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) and covalent organic frameworks (COFs) have received increasing attention in recent years in various technological and scientific fields owing to the capability to control their pore size, shape, and chemical functionalities.[15,16] MOFs consisting of organic linkers for π–π stacking interaction and metal ions for electrostatic interaction are an attractive class of porous crystalline materials because of their outstanding properties such as excellent surface area, adjustable pore sizes, and various functionalities.[17,18] MOFs are utilized in various applications while the direct use of MOFs for the adsorption of dyes has limitations such as skimp chemical stability to aqueous and organic and strongly acidic or alkaline media.[19−21] We consider that grafting of MOFs with COFs can prevail these limitations impressively which could possess structural features of each component and demonstrate new traits.[22,23] COFs are beneficial because of their lower densities and improved chemical and thermal stability and generate hydrogen bonding, electrostatic bonding, and π–π stacking interactions for adsorption of organic dyes.[24] They overcame the limitations of chemical instability compared with MOFs because of their excellent porosity, surface area, and adsorption capacities; excellent chemical stability; high thermal stability; low density; ability to transport charge; and highly ordered structures and have drawn remarkable research interest in the adsorption process.[25,26] They are produced by the exact assembly of organic molecular building moieties via covalent bonds and commonly comprise nanometer-sized uniform pores.[24] Lately, the great advance in COF materials has led to the development of COF materials with potential performance and prolonged their applicability. There are only a few reports available on the hybridization of COFs and MOFs for different applications.

Zhang et al. have successfully produced a type of MOF and n class="Chemical">COF hybrid, NH2-MIL-68@TPA-COF, with pore structure and crystallinity, and used it as an efficient photocatalyst.[23] Lan et al. have constructed a type of MOF/COF hybrid material through covalently anchoring NH2-UiO-66 on the TpPa-1-COF surface. The obtained hierarchical porous hybrid materials display effective photocatalytic H2 evolution.[27] Zhao et al. have reported the production of mixed matrix membranes comprising MOF@COF hybrid fillers for effective CO2/CH4 separation.[28] Ben et al. have prepared COF–MOF-based membranes and demonstrated that the obtained membranes give desirable separation selectivity of H2/CO2 mixtures than the exclusive COF and MOF membranes.[29] Xia et al. have reported electrocatalysts based on MOF/COF for water splitting.[30] Therefore, in this work, a type of MOF/COF hybrid with the potential of high π–π stacking, H-bonding, and electrostatic interactions was hydrothermally synthesized and applied for the simultaneous removal of auramine O (AO) and rhodamine B (RB) cationic dyes from aqueous media under sonication conditions. While detection of color and other organic and drug materials in effluents is difficult, many scientists and researchers have focused on designing and fabrication of electroanalytical kits and sensors with good selectivity and high sensitivity for different types of these compounds.[2,31−33] The effects of various utilizable parameters, such as pH, M5C mass, initial AO and RB concentration, and process time on removal percentage, were checked and optimized. The adsorption isotherms, kinetics, and mechanism were also studied.

Experimental Section

Materials and Apparatus

All reagents including ethanol, n class="Chemical">1,4-benzendicarboxylic acid (BDC, terephthalic acid), zinc acetate dihydrate (Zn(CH3CO2)2·2H2O), ethylenediamine, N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), melamine, terephthaldehyde, dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), AO, and RB were purchased from Merck Company (Darmstadt, Germany). Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectra were recorded with a Jasco-680 spectrometer (Japan) in the range of 4000–400 cm–1 by making their pellets in KBr as a medium. The diffraction patterns of related materials were recorded in the reflection mode using a Bruker, D8 ADVANCE diffractometer. Nickel-filtered Cu Kα radiation (radiation wavelength, λ = 0.154 nm) was produced at an operating voltage of 45 kV and a current of 100 mA. The surface morphology of the resulting materials was investigated using field emission-scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM; EM10C-ZEISS, 80 kV, Zeiss Co., Germany). Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was recorded using a thermogravimetric analyzer TGA-PL-1500 from 30 to 800 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C min–1 under a N2 atmosphere.

Synthesis of MOF-5

Terephthalic acid (0.5 g) was dissolved in 60 mL of n class="Chemical">DMF, and subsequently, 2.19 g of Zn(CH3CO2)2·2H2O was added and stirred for 10 min. Then, the mixture was transferred to an autoclave and heated at 100 °C for 12 h. Finally, the resulting solid was collected and washed with ethanol and dried at room temperature.

Preparation of MOF-5-NH2

A mixture of 0.20 g of MOF-5, 25 mL of ethanol, and 5 mL of ethylenediamine was refluxed for 12 h, and subsequently, the resulting mixture was filtered to yield a white precipitate which was washed with ethanol and dried at 80 °C.

Preparation of MOF-5/COF (M5C)

MOF-5-NH2 (0.20 g), 0.5 g (3.96 mmol) of melamine, 0.5 g (3.73 mmol) of terephthaldehyde, 25 mL of DMSO, and 5 mL of distilled water were mixed and subsequently, transferred to an autoclave and heated at 180 °C for 12 h. Finally, the resulting solid was collected, washed with ethanol, and dried at room temperature. A schematic illustration of all steps for the synthesis of the MOF/COF hybrid material is shown in Figure , and the proposed mechanism for the chemical synthesis of M5C is presented in Scheme .

Figure 1

Graphical illustration of the synthesis of an M5C hybrid material.

Scheme 1

Proposed Mechanism for the Synthesis of M5C

AO and RB Adsorption Method

The adsorption experiment of AO and n class="Chemical">RB dyes with the help of ultrasound waves by M5C using a batch method was conducted as follows: 0.02 g of M5C was added to 25 mL of AO and RB dyes solution (5 mg/L) at pH 9.5, and then the suspension was dispersed for 1 min at room temperature. Finally, the M5C adsorbent was collected, and the final AO and RB contents were quantified by a UV–vis spectrophotometer. The adsorption capacity (qe, mg/g) and the removal percentage (R %) were calculated according to our previous reports.[34,35] The adsorption behaviors in binary solution were investigated by UV–vis spectrophotometry at different M5C masses (Figure ), which shows that M5C merely adsorbs AO and RB. These results further indicate that M5C can serve as a promising superadsorbent material for AO and RB absorption from polluted water. In addition, there was no overlap observed in the UV–vis spectrum of AO and RB, revealing that UV–vis spectrophotometry is a low-cost and an easily available technique for the detection of these compounds.

Figure 2

UV–vis spectra of the mixture dyes of AO and RB at different M5C masses.

Results and Discussion

Characterization of the Synthesized Materials

Figure A shows the FT-IR spectra of MOF-5, n class="Chemical">MOF-5-NH2, and M5C; the absorption band around 3416 cm–1 in MOF-5 corresponds to O–H stretching vibration of H2O in the MOF. The peaks at 1662 and 1392 cm–1 correspond to the stretching encryptions of the O=C–O bonded to Zn. The absorption band at 532 cm–1 is attributed to the stretching vibration of Zn–O. In the functionalized MOF-5 spectrum, the new absorption peaks at 3324 and 3270 cm–1 are attributed to the stretching vibrations of NH2 groups, and the absorption bands appeared at 2958, 2904, and 2873 cm–1 correspond to the vibration of C–H bonds of ethylenediamine. From the spectral data, it can be deduced that ethylenediamine has been grafted on the MOF-5 surface. The FTIR spectrum of the M5C hybrid displays a series of new characteristic stretching vibrations at 1547, 1465, and 1338 arising from the C=N, C=C, and C–N bonds, respectively, showing condensation reaction and tautomerization.

Figure 3

FT-IR spectra (A) of MOF-5 (a), MOF-5-NH2 (b) and M5C (c) and XRD patterns of as simulated, as prepared MOF-5 and MOF-5-COF (B).

Figure B shows the X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of simulated and as-prepared MOF-5 and M5C that exhibit a crystal structure of as-prepared MOF-5, which matches its simulated pattern published previously. The XRD pattern of M5C shows two broad peaks at 2θ of 8 and 20, which is probably related to the overlap of XRD peaks of MOF-5 and M5C, and the corresponding COF and MOF peaks were well-observed with short tentacles and wide spikes.

Figure a shows FE-SEM images of MOF-5 with well-defined n class="Chemical">cubic crystals of 2.5 μm in width. The FE-SEM investigation of M5C confirms that the smooth pure MOF-5 structure significantly changes due to the loading of the orderly and spherical shape of the COF on the MOF-5 surface (Figure b). The FE-SEM images of the resulting M5C hybrid show that the COF is well-dispersed on the MOF-5 surface. The M5C hybrid surface tends to be rougher after the insertion of the COF on MOF-5 and had a fatal effect on the MOF-5 support structure.

Figure 4

SEM images of MOF-5 (a,b) and M5C (c,d).

Figure a presents the weight loss of M5C with the inn class="Chemical">crease in temperature, and the observations are explained as follows: weight loss was observed between 50 and 150 °C, which could be ascribed to the loss in moisture and solvent molecules. No obvious mass loss from 150 to 420 °C demonstrates the superior thermodynamic stability of M5C up to 400 °C. Further, the increase in temperature to 520 °C leads to weight loss due to the destruction of MOF and COF structures.

Figure 5

STA thermogram (a) and N2 adsorption/desorption isotherm (b) of M5C.

The N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms of the as-obtained n class="Chemical">M5C (Figure b) revealed a slight capillary condensation step at high relative pressure, which belongs to type IV isotherm according to IUPAC classification, and the specific surface area BET was found to be 7.025 m2/g.

Effect of the Operational Parameter on AO and RB Removal

The solution pH as a significant factor can affect the adsorption capacity owing to its effect on the surface properties as well as ionization or dissociation of the adsorbents. To evaluate the pH effect on the simultaneous adsorption of n class="Chemical">AO and RB, pH values were varied between 2.0 and 9.5 (Figure a). The pHzpc of M5C hybrid was found to be 6.0, which shows that below the pHzpc value, the M5C surface has a positive charge and above the pHzpc value, the M5C surface possesses a negatively charged surface. Hence, the M5C hybrid possesses high adsorption capacity at pH 9.5 due to the electrostatic interaction between M5C negative surface charge and cationic AO and RB dyes. When pH > 7, the M5C adsorption capacity tends to be constant due to the π–π stacking and electrostatic interaction of aromatic rings of AO and RB and electrostatic charges of M5C, which are stable in weak alkali media. In addition, at low pH, low electrostatic attraction exists between the adsorbent M5C surface and AO and RB because of the presence of positively charged sites on both the AO and RB and M5C surfaces and the lack of free unpaired electrons on the adsorbent surface that hinders increased adsorption; hence acidic pH values do not favor the proposed adsorption system. As the pH of the system increases, free unpaired electrons become available on the adsorbent surface, which in turn will increase the electrostatic attraction forces between AO and RB and the adsorbent sites resulting in high adsorption capacity of AO and RB at high pH values.

Figure 6

Effect of pH (a), adsorbent mass (b), contact time (c), and initial dye concentration (d) on the adsorption of AO and RB on M5C.

The adsorption of AO and n class="Chemical">RB on M5C was investigated at various adsorbent doses in the range of 0.004–0.020 g at a dye concentration (5 mg/L) and pH (9.5) at a contact time of 10 min (Figure b). The removal efficiency was enhanced as the adsorbent dose increased from 0.004 to 0.016 g due to increase in active surface adsorption sites.

The effect of contact time on the removal of AO and n class="Chemical">RB dyes was studied to evaluate the adsorption rate. The AO and RB removal percentage at pH 9.5 has a synergic and positive relation with contact time (Figure c). As shown in Figure c, more than 90% of AO and RB removal occurs in the first 8 min. Subsequently, the adsorption rate has a slight changed trend that is ascribed to diffusion rate diminution and concentration gradient. The rate of dye adsorption by M5C was observed to be very rapid for 8 min, which indicates the efficiency and high ability of M5C in the removal of AO and RB dyes. Afterward, the dye adsorption processes proceeded at a slower rate. The slow rate of dye adsorption for a long time may result from the saturation and coverage of M5C with the dyes.

The effect of the initial AO and n class="Chemical">RB concentrations and their removal efficiency were assessed by varying the AO and RB concentrations from 5 to 25 mg/L (Figure d). The obtained results show that the adsorption capacity of AO and RB by the M5C hybrid is a function of the initial AO and RB concentrations and the adsorption percent decreases with the increase in the initial AO and RB dyes concentration. At lower AO and RB concentrations, the ratio of the number of active sites of M5C to the available reactive sites of AO and RB was detracted. In fact, at lower AO and RB concentrations, M5C has more chance to react with the reactive sites of AO and RB and thus, the adsorption capacity is augmented.

For selectivity investigation, some anionic dyes such as fast green FCF, eosin yellow, and n class="Species">quinine yellow were tested, and M5C was able to eliminate 20, 23.5, and 31.2% of the dyes, respectively. Therefore, it can be said that the proposed adsorbent effectively eliminates cationic dyes and repels anionic dyes. In addition, methylene blue and malachite green as cationic dyes were tested in which M5C was able to eliminate a large percentage of the dyes, while due to the spectral overlap of these dyes with colors of AO and RB, they were excluded from simultaneous removal.

Adsorption Isotherms

The correlation between the adsorbent amount and the retained material in bulk at a constant temperature is significant in n class="Chemical">MOF- and COF-based adsorption systems. To optimize the conditions of the adsorption of AO and RB, it is important to prescribe the most suitable correlations of the equilibrium data. The most extensively utilized surface adsorption models are the Langmuir, Temkin, Freundlich, and Dubinin–Radushkevich (D–R) isotherms, which are the best-fitting isotherms found by linear regressions as well as the applicability of isotherms are compared by recognizing the correlation coefficients and error analysis. The resulting correlation coefficients provided strong evidence that AO and RB adsorption onto M5C follows the Langmuir isotherm (Table ). The applicability of the Langmuir model was corroborated by the high correlation coefficients R2 > 0.984. The Qm values obtained from the Langmuir isotherms were 17.95 and 16.18 mg/g for AO and RB, respectively. The R2 values for other models are not fit of equilibrium data as compared with the Langmuir isotherm model.

Table 1

Adsorption Isotherm Parameters for the Adsorption of AO and RB

		value
isotherm models	parameters	AO	RB
Langmuir: Ce/qe = 1/KaQm + Ce/Qm	Qm (mg g–1)	17.95	16.18
	Ka (L mg–1)	2.34	3.33
	R2	0.9848	0.9882
Freundlich: ln qe = ln Kf + (1/n)ln Ce	1/n	0.8689	0.1396
	Kf (L mg–1)	3.092	1.909
	R2	0.8938	0.3748
Temkin: qe = Bl ln KT + Bl ln Ce	BT	4.9542	0.5843
	KT (L mg–1)	2.49	307.07
	R2	0.9477	0.8278
Dubinin–Radushkevich: ln qe = ln Qs – Kε2	Qs (mg g–1)	12.69	5.92
	K	6 × 10–8	4 × 10–8
	R2	0.9477	0.8278

Kinetics Models

To examine the adsorption kinetics, pseudo-first-order, pseudo-second-order, Elovich, and intraparticle diffusion models were studied, and the experimental and calculated qe values have good correlation and agreement at different initial n class="Chemical">AO and RB concentrations and adsorbent mass for the pseudo-second-order model (Table ).

Table 2

Adsorption Kinetics Parameters for the Adsorption of AO and RB

		value
kinetic model	parameters	AO	RB
first-order: log(qe – qt) = log(qe) – (K1/2.303)t	K1	0.2975	0.3030
	qe (cal.)	0.044	2.225
	R2	0.5352	0.9196
second-order: t/qt = 1/k2qe2 + (1/qe)t	K2	1.160	1.242
	qe (cal.)	3.13	3.15
	R2	0.9900	0.9997
intraparticle diffusion: qt = Kidt1/2 + C	Kid	0.1046	0.1680
	C	2.75	2.58
	R2	0.9319	0.8572
Elovich: qt = 1/β ln(αβ) + 1/β ln(t)	β	8.76	5.29
	α	1.40	2.26
	R2	0.9458	0.9258
experimental adsorption capacity	qe(exp)	0.134	2.125

Adsorption Mechanism

The plausible interaction of M5C with n class="Chemical">AO and RB (Figure ) is controlled by various factors like the AO and RB molecules structure and functional behavior and the M5C surface characteristics. The AO and RB molecules are planar and can be conveniently adsorbed on the M5C via physical interactions in addition to M5C cavities. The cavities of M5C could encapsulate all the AO and RB organic dyes. AO and RB can bind to M5C via electrostatic and van der Waals forces and hydrogen bonding and host–guest interactions with the M5C cavities.

Figure 7

Interactions of the dyes with the adsorbent and proposed mechanism.

Regeneration and Reusability of M5C

To examine the reusability of M5C, the adsorption experiments were carried out, and subsequently, n class="Chemical">M5C was collected by a centrifuge, and the adsorbed AO and RB were washed with methanol for 6 cycles in which the removal percentage only slightly reduced (Figure ). This supports the adsorption process and offers the possibility to reuse chemically stable M5C for multiple cycles, which indicates that M5C is a promising and robust adsorbent for the removal of AO and RB dye pollutants.

Figure 8

Recycle, regeneration, and reuse cycle of the M5C.

Comparison with the Previously Reported Adsorbents

A comparison study of adsorption capacity, contact time, pH, and adsorbent mass for different methods was performed, and the results are reported in Table . Considering the literature, we have reached satisfactory results in partin class="Chemical">cular in the simultaneous adsorption of AO and RB.

Table 3

Comparison of the Removal of AO and RB Dyes by Different Adsorbents

adsorbent	dye	pH	adsorbent mass (mg)	contact time (min)	qm (mg/g)	refs
humic acid-modifying Fe3O4 NPs	RB	2.53	100	30	161.8	(36)
Sistan sand	RB	6.0	1000	30	0.11	(37)
3A zeolite	RB	9.0	1000	40	0.74	(38)
carboxylated cellulose derivative	AO	6.0	70 g//L	24 h	5.443	(39)
MOF-5-Ag2O-NPs	AO	6.0	25	50 s	260.70	(40)
ZnS:Cu-NP-AC	AO	7.0	40	2.2	94.2	(41)
Fe3O4/C–COP	AO	6.5	12	4	107.11	(42)
Fe3O4/C–COP	RB	6.5	12	4	131.23	(42)
M5C	AO	9.5	16	8	17.95	this work
M5C	RB	9.5	16	8	16.18	this work

Conclusions

As a novel shell structure adsorbent, n class="Chemical">M5C has electrostatic, hydrogen bonding, Lewis acid–base, and π–π stacking interactions for AO and RB molecule adsorption, which enables rapid and efficient removal of AO and RB; therefore, M5C has a good potential in dyeing wastewater treatment. The optimum conditions for AO and RB dye adsorption were found to be the initial AO and RB concentration of 5 ppm, 0.016 g of M5C, and pH = 9.5. The linear forms of Langmuir and pseudo-second-order models were the best isotherm and kinetic model, respectively. Finally, water treatment agents with MOF and COF hybrids are envisaged to become a new orientation in the development of wastewater treatment engineering.