Anuradhi Liyanapathiranage1, Maria J Peña2, Suraj Sharma1, Sergiy Minko1. 1. Nanostructured Materials Lab, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602, United States. 2. Complex Carbohydrate Research Center, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602, United States.
Abstract
This research aims at minimizing environmental pollution by effluents discharged from current textile dyeing processes. The reduction of pollution is approached with a nanofibrillated cellulose (NFC) dyeing method. In the commonly used exhaust reactive dye bath cotton dyeing process, water effluents are contaminated with unreacted dyes and dyeing formulation auxiliaries amid the consumption of 20 weight units of water per weight unit of colored textile products. It was recently demonstrated that using reactive dye-colored NFC hydrogels-an aqueous dispersion of the NFC pigment-a sustainable dye carrier-results in 6-fold reduction in consumption of water and auxiliaries. Here, we report further developments of this technology. Cotton fabrics and NFC hydrogels inherit a fraction of soluble polysugars that react and conjugate with the reactive dyes. These soluble dye-conjugated polysugars are released into the wastewater, thus resulting in water pollution and also in reduced efficiency of the dyeing process. We demonstrate here that post-treatment of NFC-colored cotton textiles with polycarboxylic acid secures permanent chemical grafting of the soluble dye-labeled polysugars and forms chemical cross-links with the NFC fibers on the cotton fabric via the esterification reaction. This combination leads to the improvement of dye fixation by 30% and reduces the dye discharge in the washing stage by 60%. This enhancement is approached without compromising the stiffness and breathability of the fabrics. The advanced textile method is tested for a series of reactive dyes covering the entire visual spectrum range.
This research aims at minimizing environmental pollution by effluents discharged from current textile dyeing processes. The reduction of pollution is approached with a nanofibrillated cellulose (NFC) dyeing method. In the commonly used exhaust reactive dye bath cotton dyeing process, water effluents are contaminated with unreacted dyes and dyeing formulation auxiliaries amid the consumption of 20 weight units of water per weight unit of colored textile products. It was recently demonstrated that using reactive dye-colored NFC hydrogels-an aqueous dispersion of the NFC pigment-a sustainable dye carrier-results in 6-fold reduction in consumption of water and auxiliaries. Here, we report further developments of this technology. Cotton fabrics and NFC hydrogels inherit a fraction of soluble polysugars that react and conjugate with the reactive dyes. These soluble dye-conjugated polysugars are released into the wastewater, thus resulting in water pollution and also in reduced efficiency of the dyeing process. We demonstrate here that post-treatment of NFC-colored cotton textiles with polycarboxylic acid secures permanent chemical grafting of the soluble dye-labeled polysugars and forms chemical cross-links with the NFC fibers on the cotton fabric via the esterification reaction. This combination leads to the improvement of dye fixation by 30% and reduces the dye discharge in the washing stage by 60%. This enhancement is approached without compromising the stiffness and breathability of the fabrics. The advanced textile method is tested for a series of reactive dyes covering the entire visual spectrum range.
The
exponential growth of the human population has created an increasing
demand for the consumption of clothing, thereby amplifying the needs
for textile production and textile dyeing. The current textile dyeing
industry consumes water massively and releases a copious amount of
untreatable hazardous effluents such as salts, hydroxides, and unreacted
dyes to the environment. Unreacted azo dyes contained in the textile
wastewater may metabolize into mutagenic products.[1,2] Generating
a significant level of pollutants, the current textile dyeing industry
is responsible for 1/5 of the global industrial water pollution.[3,4]Cellulosic fabrics are dyed using reactive dyes—water-soluble
synthetic chromophores with chlorotriazine and ethylsulfonyl functional
groups in their chemical structures for covalent attachments to the
cellulose surface. These dyes react with hydroxyl groups of cellulose,
forming covalent bonds in alkaline medium at a high concentration
of salt to maintain high ionic strength and pH 10. In conventional
dyeing of cotton, only 80–85% of the initially loaded dyes
are covalently bound to the cotton fabric. Hence, unreacted dyes and
salts are discharged into the wastewater and should be removed before
released to the environment as a safe practice. The government environmental
regulations are concerned with textile dyeing, and the industry is
responsible for the removal of residual dyes and other pollutants
from industrial effluents. Environmental pollution associated with
the textile industry is becoming a critical global issue, and novel
technologies need to be established for the mitigation of the problem.Recently, we introduced a new environmentally sound textile dyeing
technology that explores a successful application of nanocellulose
hydrogels of nanofibrillated cellulose (NFC) as an efficient carrier
for textile dyes.[5,6] NFC is a nontoxic nanomaterial
engineered from abundantly found cellulose sources. The manufacturing
process of the NFC hydrogel involves mechanical homogenization when
cellulose powder from a cut wood pulp passes through a homogenizer
at high shear forces to facilitate the defibrillation of the cellulose
fibers into nanofibrils and make a stable colloidal dispersion (hydrogels).[7−10] NFC is a thixotropic colloidal dispersion, which consists of entangled
nanofibrils, several micrometers long and 10–50 nm in diameter
with a specific surface area of 400–800 m2/g.According to this novel method, NFC nanofibers are being dyed instead
of cotton fabrics using reactive dyes and under dyeing conditions
(pH, salt concentration, and temperature) typical for the traditional
exhaust reactive dye bath cotton dyeing process. By conjugating NFC
with reactive dyes, the nanocellulose fibrils are transformed into
a colored NFC-dye pigment. The colored NFC hydrogel is then deposited
on the surface of textiles using conventional deposition methods and
annealed at an elevated temperature. Colored NFC hydrogels can be
optimized to use for the existing batch and continuous dye deposition
methods as well as for waterless dye-depositing methods such as spray
dyeing. In comparison to the conventional dyeing of cotton and other
fibers in a dye bath, the dyeing of NFC requires about six folds less
water, salt, and alkali because of the high surface-to-volume ratio
of NFC hydrogels. As compared with the conventional exhaust dyeing,
the NFC dyeing technology is a proven green production strategy based
on the life cycle analysis and the measures of water and dye auxiliary
consumption.[5,6]Water-soluble hemicelluloses
which are present in NFC hydrogels
and cotton fibers are typically extracted during dyeing at elevated
temperatures in alkali solutions. However, hemicelluloses react with
reactive dyes via the same chemical reactions as NFC and tend to be
readily removed with wastewater. The disposal of the hemicelluloses
conjugated with reactive dyes limits further improvement of the dye
fixation of NFC dyeing. The release of the soluble hemicellulose–dye
conjugates mainly associates with environmental pollution. We address
this issue by grafting the hemicellulose–dye conjugates to
the surface of NFC nanofibers and cotton fabric fibers using polycarboxylic
acids (PCA). The combination of NFC dyeing and PCA post-treatment
leads to a substantial improvement of dye fixation and reduction of
dye contaminants in wastewater. Notable attempts have been reported
using PCA for wrinkle-resistant post-treatment on cotton and had discussed
the formation of chemical crosslinks/grafts with the submicron-scale
cellulose fabric fibers using maleic, itaconic, and citric acids.[11−15] Naturally existing PCAs such as malonic acid,[16] cutin,[17] and suberin[18] can be used as potential green crosslinking
agents for future research perspectives. As of polyesterification
catalysts, niobium oxide[19,20] and zeolite[20] can be experimented for alternative catalyst
systems. Therefore, the proposed chemical crosslinking post-treatment
from PCA can be used as a solution for the substantial reduction of
environmental pollution of wastewater with unreacted dyes generated
by the current textile dyeing industry.
Results
and Discussion
Textile Dyeing with NFC-Dye
Hydrogels
The cotton textiles were dyed following the recently
published NFC-based
dyeing method.[5] The NFC dyeing method (Supporting Information, Figure S1) involves the
dyeing of NFC hydrogels via reactions of cellulose hydroxyl groups
residing on the surface of NFC nanofibers with chlorotriazine and
ethylsulfonyl functional groups of the reactive dyes. A variety of
colors can be achieved through combinations of blue, yellow, red,
and black commercial reactive dyes (Supporting Information, Figure S2).In the presence of sodium sulfate
and sodium carbonate, the reaction of the dye with the NFC hydrogel
takes place at elevated temperatures. The prepared NFC-dye hydrogel
is then deposited on the cotton fabric surfaces following the conventional
knife dye deposition method, and the colored fabrics samples are dried.
Then, the NFC-dyed fabrics were washed, conditioned, and used to evaluate
the efficiency of coloration. To demonstrate the color retention of
the NFC-dyed fabric subjected to the wear and care conditions of the
textile products, we selected a series of standard tests to evaluate
the dye fixation and colorfastness. The dye fixation was assessed
as the pivotal criterion to analyze the fraction of the reactive dye
covalently bound to cellulose fabric fibers. The result of the tests,
along with the visual appearance of the colored fabrics, is shown
in Table and Figure , respectively. All
the dyes show more than 90% retention after 10 laundry cycles, but
black and blue dye underperformed in terms of dye fixation in comparison
to red and yellow reactive dyes.
Table 1
Overall Dye Performance of Fabrics
Dyed from NFC-Reactive Dye Systems (100% Cotton Woven)
reactive dye
blue
black
red
yellow
dye concentration, g cm–3
0.32
0.33
0.31
0.34
dye fixation, %
65 ± 4
77 ± 5
82 ± 3
84 ± 2
colorfastness to accelerated
laundry, grade
4.5
4/5
5
5
colorfastness to crocking (dry/wet), grade
4.5/3.5
4.5/4
4.5/4
5/4
color retention after 10
laundering cycles, %
92 ± 4
95 ± 4
96 ± 5
93 ± 7
Figure 1
Photographs of fiber samples (100% cotton
woven fabric) before
and after five accelerated laundry cycle washing colored with NFC
dyes (a) blue, (b) black, (c) red, and (d) yellow.
Photographs of fiber samples (100% cotton
woven fabric) before
and after five accelerated laundry cycle washing colored with NFC
dyes (a) blue, (b) black, (c) red, and (d) yellow.The bonding mechanism of reactive dyes to the cellulose matrix
includes two steps; dye adsorption on cellulose surfaces and chemical
reaction with the hydroxyl functional groups of cellulose. Both of
these steps depend on the reactive dye chemical structure. The reactive
dyes are anionic compounds that bear two to four sodium sulfonate
functional groups (to provide solubility in water), chromogens, and
reactive groups. NFC nanofibers are negatively charged because of
(i) the slight acidity of hydroxyl groups, (ii) a small fraction of
carboxylic functional groups formed by the oxidation of cellulose
in the stages of NFC fabrication at high shear forces and elevated
temperatures, and (iii) adsorption of salts.[21] Therefore, NFC nanofibers electrostatically repel similarly charged
anionic dyes. The electrostatic repulsions are partially screened
at high salt concentrations. However, dye adsorption is indeed limited
by these repulsive electrostatic interactions. This effect depends
on the number of ionizable groups and their special arrangements in
the dye molecules.The efficiency of the covalent binding of
the dyes via the nucleophilic
addition–elimination reaction between the cellulose hydroxyl
groups and reactive groups of the dyes depends on the type and the
number of reactive groups per dye molecule. The reaction of cellulose
hydroxyls with reactive groups of the dyes competes with the hydrolysis
of these groups in aqueous solutions at high pH.NFC hydrogels
and cotton fibers contain a fraction of water-soluble
hemicelluloses (mainly xylans). These soluble polysaccharides react
with the reactive dyes following the same mechanism as cellulose nanofibers.
The interplay of all these factors results in different dye fixation
efficiencies among the dyes (Table ). The typical range for the dye fixation efficiency
of reactive dyes with one functional reactive group is 50–75%
and dye fixation for two functional reactive groups is 75–90%.[22] Hence, 10–25% of the dye remains in the
bath as hydrolyzed (nonreactive form) or bound to the soluble polysaccharides
form. Contributing to the decrease of the dye fixation, nonreactive
and soluble sugar bound forms of the reactive dyes remain dissolved
in the medium. This leads to water pollution if the dye contaminated
water is released to the environment without further purification
(Supporting Information, Figure S3).
Analysis of Soluble Sugars in NFC Hydrogels
The plant cell wall contains up to 30% of soluble polysaccharides.
Most of them are extracted at different stages of biomass treatments.
However, the mechanical shearing applied to kraft pulp in the homogenization
process of NFC production may result in the extraction of an additional
fraction of the soluble sugars embodied at the cellular level.[14] Carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) is a water-soluble
derivative of cellulose, bearing residual hydroxyl functional groups
that contribute to the total soluble polysugars content in the NFC
hydrogel. CMC is used as a plasticizer in the NFC hydrogel formulation
to facilitate the defibrillation of bundles such as cellulose fibrils.[8,23,24] We used hydrogel samples with
no CMC added for the analysis of soluble sugars to avoid the possible
contribution of the CMC additive.The soluble sugars and products
of their reactions with reactive-dye molecules (the soluble sugar–dye
covalently bound complex) are most likely to dissolve and exist in
the aqueous phase of the NFC hydrogel. This soluble sugars fraction
can be transferred into the supernatant during the centrifugation
process. The presence of simple and complex carbohydrates in the supernatant
of the NFC hydrogel was confirmed from the phenol–sulfuric
acid method[25,26] by observing an orange-yellow
color with a maximum absorbance at 490 nm (Supporting Information, Figure S4). The quantified total soluble sugar
content is 1.2% of the cellulose weight and was estimated from the
gravimetric analysis of the NFC supernatant. The MALDI mass spectroscopic
analysis (Figure S5) of the supernatant
extracted from the NFC hydrogel revealed two series of hexose and
pentose containing oligosaccharides (Tables and 3).
Table 2
Oligosaccharides of Pentose Sugars
oligosaccharide
P7
P8
P9
P10
P11
P12
P13
P14
theoretical, m/z
966
1098
1230
1362
1494
1626
1758
1890
observed, m/z
968
1099
1231
1363
1495
1628
1760
1892
Table 3
Oligosaccharides
of Hexose Sugars
oligosaccharide
H6
H7
H8
H9
H10
H11
H12
theoretical, m/z
1013
1175
1337
1499
1661
1823
1985
observed, m/z
1015
1178
1340
1505
1664
1825
1988
Oligosaccharide
series of pentose sugars consist of 7–14
monomeric units (Table ), and oligosaccharides of hexose sugars series include 6–12
monomeric units (Table ). Considering the composition of the wood plant cells, we can speculate
that the hexoseoligosaccharides are glucose based, and the pentoseoligosaccharides are xylose-based complex carbohydrates. Covalent
bonding of the reactive dyes to the polysugars will lead to the loss
of a fraction of reactive dyes during the washing process. This was
further verified from the following experiments.
Effect of Soluble Hemicelluloses on Cellulose
Dyeing
We hypothesized that the 65–85% dye fixation
rate is affected by a combination of several side chemical processes:
hydrolysis of the reactive groups in the basic aqueous solution, conjugation
of the reactive dyes to the soluble polysaccharides present in the
NFC hydrogel, and dye release from the cotton fabric under dyeing
conditions (elevated temperature and alkaline dyeing liquor). Poor
dye fixation is an effect of these side processes that could be minimized
by covalent grafting of the water-soluble polysaccharide–dye
conjugate to the cellulosic surfaces, either to NFC nanofibers or
to the cotton fabric or both the materials.We proved this hypothesis
in several control experiments. In Experiment 1 (Figure ), we collected a solution
of soluble polysugars from the supernatant after the centrifugation
of the NFC hydrogel. This solution was mixed with the reactive-blue
dye to synthesize soluble polysugar-dye conjugates under reaction
conditions typically used for NFC dyeing. This conjugate solution
was then used to dye cotton samples using two different methods: (i)
the fabric was immersed into the conjugate solution with sodium sulfate
and sodium carbonate at the same concentrations and temperature regimes
as for NFC hydrogel dyeing, and (ii) after the exhaust dyeing as per
step (i) we applied a post-treatment with maleic acid and sodium hypophosphite
(SHP) catalysts followed by drying of the fabric samples at 120 °C.
In the latter case, maleic acid reacts with hydroxyl functional groups
of cellulose and soluble hemicelluloses, forming covalent bonds with
the polysaccharides. Hence, the dye–hemicellulose conjugates
could be grafted to the surface of the cotton fabrics. These experiments
were compared with two control experiments when the exhaust dyeing
of the fabrics was performed in a conventional dye bath, with and
without maleic acid post-treatment. The results of these experiments
are shown in Figure .
Figure 2
Control experiment 1: soluble sugars extraction, dyeing of soluble
sugars, and the application of PCA.
Figure 3
Effect
of grafting of soluble hemicellulose–dye conjugates
on dye fixation: (a,b) control experiment of exhaust dyeing with reactive
blue and, (c,d) dyeing with the supernatant of the NFC-dye hydrogel
containing dissolved hemicellulose–dye conjugates; (a,c)—no
post-treatment and (b,d)—post-treatment with maleic acid.
Control experiment 1: soluble sugars extraction, dyeing of soluble
sugars, and the application of PCA.Effect
of grafting of soluble hemicellulose–dye conjugates
on dye fixation: (a,b) control experiment of exhaust dyeing with reactive
blue and, (c,d) dyeing with the supernatant of the NFC-dye hydrogel
containing dissolved hemicellulose–dye conjugates; (a,c)—no
post-treatment and (b,d)—post-treatment with maleic acid.Results in Figure show that maleic acid has no effect on exhaust dyeing
with the reactive-blue
dye (control). The dyed fabrics with the soluble sugar dye-conjugated
hemicelluloses (no post-treatment with maleic acid) show about 55%
of dye fixation. Consequently, some fraction of reactive groups of
reactive-blue conjugates remained intact after bonding to the hemicellulose.
These residual reactive groups facilitate grafting of the conjugates
to the cotton surfaces. The post-treatment provided a further improvement
of dye fixation (up to 70%) due to the grafting of the soluble sugar-conjugates
via the maleic acid crosslinker.The above conclusions about
the surface grafting of the soluble
hemicellulose–dye conjugates to cotton using PCA post-treatment
were further supported by the following control Experiment 2 (Figure ). The NFC-blue dye
hydrogel was used as the control for the dyeing of cotton fabric samples.
A sample of the same NFC-blue dye hydrogel was centrifuged and separated
into two fractions: soluble hemicellulose–dye conjugates in
the supernatant and the NFC-bound dye in the precipitate. These two
fractions were separately used to dye cotton fabrics providing the
same conditions. Both samples were post-treated with maleic acid.
The dye fixation of each sample was examined after drying and washing.
The results are shown in Figure .
Figure 4
Control experiment 2: NFC-blue hydrogels (not-centrifuged),
extraction
of soluble sugar–dye conjugates, and NFC-bound precipitates
and application of PCA.
Figure 5
Effect of the post-treatment
with maleic acid on dye fixation for
the NFC dye (Reactive Blue) in the cotton dyeing process with (a,b)
the NFC-dye hydrogel (control), (c,d) the supernatant of the NFC-dye
hydrogel, and (e,f) the precipitate of the NFC-dye hydrogel; (a,c,e)—no
post-treatment and (b,d,f)—post-treatment with maleic acid.
Control experiment 2: NFC-blue hydrogels (not-centrifuged),
extraction
of soluble sugar–dye conjugates, and NFC-bound precipitates
and application of PCA.Effect of the post-treatment
with maleic acid on dye fixation for
the NFC dye (Reactive Blue) in the cotton dyeing process with (a,b)
the NFC-dye hydrogel (control), (c,d) the supernatant of the NFC-dye
hydrogel, and (e,f) the precipitate of the NFC-dye hydrogel; (a,c,e)—no
post-treatment and (b,d,f)—post-treatment with maleic acid.The dye concentration analysis in the washing effluents
(rinsing
water) of the dyed fabric samples (dyed from NFC-blue hydrogel) without
and with post-treatment are shown in Figure . These experiments demonstrate a substantial
improvement of the dye fixation in all three cases and a reduction
of unbound dye concentration in the washing effluents when the PCA
post-treatment was applied (Figure ). The surface grafting of maleic acid to the polysaccharides
(Figure S6) was confirmed with FTIR-spectroscopy
analysis (Figure S7).
Figure 6
Concentration of the
unbound reactive-blue dye in washing effluents
for dyeing with (a,b) NFC-dye hydrogel, (c,d) its supernatant, and
(e,f) its precipitate; (a,c,e)—no post-treatment and (b,d,f)—post-treatment
with maleic acid.
Figure 7
Refers to 100% cotton
fabrics dyed from noncentrifuged NFC-blue
dye with 0.83% percentage dye deposition on the weight of the fabrics.
Discharged water from the washing process of NFC-blue-dyed fabrics
without PCA (a1) and with PCA (b1). NFC-blue-dyed fabrics; (a2—before wash, a3—after wash). NFC-blue-dyed
fabrics underwent PCA post-treatment; (b2—before
wash, b3—after wash).
Concentration of the
unbound reactive-blue dye in washing effluents
for dyeing with (a,b) NFC-dye hydrogel, (c,d) its supernatant, and
(e,f) its precipitate; (a,c,e)—no post-treatment and (b,d,f)—post-treatment
with maleic acid.Refers to 100% cotton
fabrics dyed from noncentrifuged NFC-blue
dye with 0.83% percentage dye deposition on the weight of the fabrics.
Discharged water from the washing process of NFC-blue-dyed fabrics
without PCA (a1) and with PCA (b1). NFC-blue-dyed fabrics; (a2—before wash, a3—after wash). NFC-blue-dyed
fabrics underwent PCA post-treatment; (b2—before
wash, b3—after wash).The difference between the experiments shown in Figures and 5, is that in the first case, soluble sugars were first extracted
from the NFC hydrogel and then were conjugated with reactive dyes.
Then, these soluble sugar–dye conjugates were used to dye the
cotton fabrics. In the second case, the NFC hydrogel (containing both
NFC nanofibers and soluble sugars) was dyed as the first step. Then,
NFC-dye nanofibers and soluble sugar–dye conjugates were separated
from the centrifuging process and used to dye the cotton fabrics.
In both cases, the amount of dye conjugated to soluble sugars are
the same. By comparing the results labeled as c and d in Figures and 5, we may conclude that dyeing efficiency in both cases is
comparable. However, the dye fixation in the first case is more significant
(Figure ). This difference
is explained by the competition of soluble sugars and NFC nanofibers
in the reaction with reactive dyes. The results confirm that a significant
fraction of the dye is bound to NFC nanofibers than that to soluble
sugars as the concentration of soluble sugars is much lower.The obtained results explain the improvement of dye fixation in
the presence of maleic acid. Maleic acid covalently binds both the
NFC-dye and hemicellulose–dye conjugates to the surface of
cotton fabrics. The crosslinking of NFC additionally improves the
stability of the coating. With the PCA post-treatment, NFC-based textile
dyeing secures a significant reduction of the unbound dye concentration
in wastewater, as shown in Figure .
Textile Dyeing with NFC-Dye
Hydrogels and
PCA Post-treatment
The developed cotton dyeing method was
tested for different types of PCA: citric, maleic, and itaconic acids.
In these experiments, we varied PCA post-treatment formulations using
equal concentrations of different PCAs. PCAs are commonly used to
improve wrinkle resistance[11,12] of the cotton fabrics
via crosslinking of cellulose molecules to minimize their swelling
in water. In this research, we used the commonly studied PCAs for
industrial applications to form crosslinks such as maleic, itaconic,
and citric acids.[27−29] The crosslinking efficiency of the PCA esterification
reaction elevates with the SHP[28,30,31] catalyst to reduce the esterification reaction temperature.For all studied PCAs, the combination with SHP provided a higher
blue-dye fixation as compared to 65 ± 4% dye fixation for the
reference NFC-dyed fabric with no post-treatment (Figure ). Critic acid was found to
deliver a slightly higher level of dye fixation followed by maleic
and itaconic acids when the crosslinking reaction is favored with
SHP. In the crosslinking reaction carried out in the absence of SHP,
maleic acid shows the highest dye fixation. Crock-fastness and wash-fastness
tests resulted in improvements of NFC-dyed fabrics with the PCA post-treatment.
Figure 8
Dye performance
upon post-treatment with different PCAs: (a,b)—citric
acid, (c,d)—maleic acid, and (e,f)—itaconic acid; (a,c,e)—no
SHP catalyst and (b,d,f)—with SHP catalyst.
Dye performance
upon post-treatment with different PCAs: (a,b)—citric
acid, (c,d)—maleic acid, and (e,f)—itaconic acid; (a,c,e)—no
SHP catalyst and (b,d,f)—with SHP catalyst.The crosslinking post-treatment improves dyeing for the all
tested
reactive dyes (Figure ). NFC-blue and NFC-black dyes indicate more significant improvement
than the NFC-red and NFC-yellow dye. For all dyes, the dye fixation
can be enhanced to the level above 85% with the PCA post-treatment.
Figure 9
Different
dye system response to the post-treatment using citric
acid and SHP; reactive dyes; (a,b)—blue, (c,d)—black,
(e,f)—yellow, and (g,h)—red; (a,c,e,g)—no post-treatment
and (b,d,f,h)—with post-treatment.
Different
dye system response to the post-treatment using citric
acid and SHP; reactive dyes; (a,b)—blue, (c,d)—black,
(e,f)—yellow, and (g,h)—red; (a,c,e,g)—no post-treatment
and (b,d,f,h)—with post-treatment.The PCA crosslinking post-treatment improves pivotal characteristics
of NFC-dyed fabrics and makes less or no impact on fabric comfort
properties (Table ). For example, stiffness of textiles is characterized by the mean
bending length (higher the bending length, stiffer the fabric), and
the air permeability of fabrics is closely related to the heat management
and fabric comfort. Both these characteristics were not changed upon
crosslinking. Having a minor impact with PCA crosslinking post-treatment
on the textile characteristics can be explained by depositing a relatively
thin (micrometer range) skin of NFC-dye coating on the surface of
cotton fabrics (Figure ).
Table 4
Comparison of Dye Performance for
the NFC-Blue Dye with and with No Crosslinking
NFC-blue dye
NFC-blue dye with crosslinks
dye concentration, wt %
1.19
1.19
dye fixation, %
65 ± 4
89.1 ± 3
colorfastness to accelerated
laundry
4.5
5
colorfastness to crocking (dry/wet), grade
4.5/3.5
5/4.5
color
retention (after 10 cycles), %
92 ± 4
95 ± 4
air permeability, cfm
14.8 ± 2.7
13.7 ± 1.1
mean bending length, mm
28 ± 2
26 ± 1.2
tensile modulus (Figure S8)
113.6
130.1
Figure 10
SEM images of a cotton woven fabric at 1500 magnification:
(a)
control, 100% cotton, (b) ultra-thin NFC-dye coating prior to washing,
(c) NFC-blue dye coating fabric after 5 laundry cycles, (d) NFC-blue
dye coating with PCA post-treatment—after 5 laundry cycles
and the coating retention with crosslinks.
SEM images of a cotton woven fabric at 1500 magnification:
(a)
control, 100% cotton, (b) ultra-thin NFC-dye coating prior to washing,
(c) NFC-blue dye coating fabric after 5 laundry cycles, (d) NFC-blue
dye coating with PCA post-treatment—after 5 laundry cycles
and the coating retention with crosslinks.The NFC-dye coating is made up of thin porous patches
on the cotton
surfaces formed at the microscopic level; hence, these colored structures
appear as a uniform shade that delivers visual level of the color.
The stiffness and the breathability are less affected with PCA crosslink
formation because of the porous structure of the ultra-thin NFC-dye
coating.
Conclusions
This
study demonstrates that the PCA post-treatment promotes grafting
and permanent crosslinking of NFC-dye and soluble polysaccharide-dye
conjugates to the cotton fabric surface. The PCA post-treatment delivers
up to 30% improvement in reactive dye fixation and up to 60% reduction
in dye discharge. The proposed chemical crosslinking method, as a
post-treatment, can be explored as a solution for a substantial reduction
of wastewater pollution with dyes generated from the current textile
dyeing technology. The PCA post-treatment improves the overall stability
and permanent retention of the NFC-dye coating with no impact on other
important textile characteristics such as stiffness and breathability
as the deposited NFC-dye coating is formed by thin microscopic porous
patches.The efficiency of the PCA post-treatment is mainly
governed by
several factors: temperature, the presence of SHP, NFC concentration,
the type of PCA, and the chemical structure of the reactive dye. Maleic
acid demonstrated the highest dye fixation (up to 86%) with no SHP
in the formulation. Citric acid is the highest performing PCA (up
to 90% dye fixation) followed by maleic and itaconic acids with the
presence of SHP at 120 °C.
Experimental
Section
Materials and Reagents
Cellulose
powder (Weyerhaeuser); carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC, MM = 90,000 g/mol,
Sigma-Aldrich); sodium carbonate (Fisher-Scientific); sodium sulfate
(Fluka); phenol (Fisher-Scientific); sulfuric acid (98%, Fisher-Scientific);
SHP (Sigma-Aldrich); PCAs: maleic, itaconic, and citric acids (Sigma-Aldrich);
reactive dyes: Everzol Red 3BS, Everzol Yellow 3RS, Everzol BRF, Everzol
BHC, and 100% grey cotton knitted and woven fabrics (provided by Cotton
Inc., North Carolina); and kraft pulp (Weyerhaeuser, Dacula, GA, USA)
were used as received.
Preparation of NFC
The kraft pulp
sheets were knife-milled and sieved three times using a sieve with
a mesh size of 500 μm. The pulp powder was then stored at 60
°C to prevent moisture absorbance. In the procedure of making
2 wt % NFC hydrogel, 10 g of the pulp powder were mixed with 500 mL
of deionized (DI)water into a slurry and processed through the homogenizer
(APV 1000) at a high shear rate (650–700 bar pressure).
Preparation of the NFC-Dye Hydrogel
The NFC-dye hydrogel
was prepared as reported previously[5] and
is shown in a diagram (Figure , Supporting Information: Figures S1 and S2, Tables S1 and S2); the NFC
hydrogel was mixed with the reactive dye and sodium sulfate. After
heating to 60 °C, sodium carbonate was added, and the mixture
was stirred for 75 min.
Figure 11
Dyeing steps for the NFC-dye hydrogel: the
dyeing formulation with
NFC, reactive dye, and sodium sulfate was heated to 60 °C for
25 min. After adding sodium carbonate, the mixture was stirred for
75 min before cooling.
Dyeing steps for the NFC-dye hydrogel: the
dyeing formulation with
NFC, reactive dye, and sodium sulfate was heated to 60 °C for
25 min. After adding sodium carbonate, the mixture was stirred for
75 min before cooling.
Dyeing
of the Cotton Fabric
The NFC-dye
hydrogel was deposited using a conventional knife or padding method,
which gave a homogeneous level of the color. Then, dyed fabrics were
subjected to 100–120 °C drying temperature to remove moisture
and to promote thermofixation of the NFC-dye fibrous pigment with
the cotton fabric. Dyed fabrics were then washed, following five laundry
cycle combined process of hot (at 60 °C) and cold (at 20 °C)
washing (Figure S1). Washed fabrics were
dried at 60 °C to prevent the boarding of cotton fibers. Then,
the NFC-dyed fabrics were conditioned for 24 h before using for standardized
testing.
PCA Post-treatment
PCAs (Figure S2) and SHP were dissolved in DI-water
at 40 °C at a ratio of 8:3 at 5 wt% PCA in the solution.[30] The NFC-dye colored samples of fabrics were
soaked into the solution and dried at 120 °C (Figure S9).
Extraction and Analysis
of Soluble Hemicelluloses
from the NFC Hydrogel
The NFC hydrogel 2 wt %) was centrifuged
at 13,000 rpm for 45 min. Then, the supernatant was separated and
filtered using a 0.2 μm (Fisher) filter. From the clear supernatant,
2 mL of the sample was mixed with 0.5 mL of 80 wt % phenol solution.
Then, 5 mL of 98 wt % concentrated sulfuric acid was added. The occurrence
of the orange-pink color was observed. The absorbance wavelength of
the obtained color was evaluated using a UV spectrophotometer. The
extracted supernatant was freeze-dried (LABCONKO freeze drying system,
FREEZONE 4.5) to quantify the hemicellulose content in the NFC hydrogel
after subtraction of the CMC weight. The samples were analyzed for
oligosaccharides using a MALDI- TOF Bruker Microflex LT mass spectrometer.
FTIR spectra for NFC-dyed fabric surfaces were measured using a Nicolet
6700-FTIR spectrometer using absorbance in 64 scanning cycles. The
reactive dye concentration in water collected from the washing process
was measured by UV–visible spectroscopy (UV-2401PC) at wavelengths:
yellow 410 nm, red 520 nm, blue 630 nm, and black 580 nm.
Testing of Dyed Fabrics
Dye Fixation
Dye fixation is determined
by the ratio of the color strength of the colored fabrics before and
after wash off. Color strength (as a ratio of adsorption to scattering
characteristics K/S) as defined by the Kubelka–Monk theory[32] was estimated from reflectance spectra of fabric
samples acquired with a Macbeth Color-Eye 7000A spectrophotometer.
Colorfastness
Laundering and crocking
(dry and wet) tests that show the retention of the color after washing
and rubbing (for dry and wet samples) were conducted according to
the AATCC 61-2013, 2A and AATCC 8-2016 test methods, respectively.
Note, the colorfastness is reported in arbitrary grades with the highest
grade of 5 and lowest of 1.
Air
Permeability and Bending Length
The air permeability and
bending length of the fabric were measured
according to the ASTM D737-96 and ASTM D1388 tests, respectively.
Scanned Electron Microscope Imaging
Washed
and dried fabric samples were gold coated and examined using
the FEI Teneo FE-SEM instrument.