Anxiolytic and Anxiogenic? How the Transcription Factor MEF2 Might Explain the Manifold Behavioral Effects of Oxytocin.

The neuromodulator oxytocin, since its first synthesis by du Vigneaud in 1953, has mainly been associated with beneficial physiological effects, as well as positive social and emotional behaviors. This overall positive picture of oxytocin as the "love-, cuddle-, or bonding-hormone" has repeatedly been challenged since then. Oxytocin-induced effects that would be perceived as negative by the individual, such as increased anxiety or potentiation of stress-induced ACTH release, as well as the regulation of negative approach-related emotions, such as envy and schadenfreude (gloating) have been described. The general consent is that oxytocin, instead of acting unidirectional, induces changes in the salience network to shift the emphasis of emotional contexts, and therefore can, e.g., produce both anxiolytic as well as anxiogenic behavioral outcomes. However, the underlying mechanisms leading to alterations in the salience network are still unclear. With the aim to understand the manifold effects of oxytocin on a cellular/molecular level, a set of oxytocin receptor-coupled signaling cascades and downstream effectors regulating transcription and translation has been identified. Those oxytocin-driven effectors, such as MEF2 and CREB, are known modulators of the neuronal and glial cytoarchitecture. We hypothesize that, by determining cellular morphology and connectivity, MEF2 is one of the key factors that might contribute to the diverse behavioral effects of oxytocin.

Introduction

The neuropeptide oxytocin is mainly produced in the hypothalamic paraventricular (PVN) and supraoptic nuclei (SON), it is released from magnocellular cells by axonal and somatodendritic release, and into the periphery via axonal projections (1). Peripheral axonal release into the blood stream and central dendritic release can occur in an orchestrated or independent manner (2–4) and produces a variety of behavioral effects, ranging from anxiety, fear conditioning and fear extinction, social exploration and recognition to aggressive behavior (5). After taking differences in dosing, timing, species, or central vs. peripheral release into account, we are still left with some puzzling inconsistencies regarding the behavioral effects of oxytocin [for review see (1)]. The concept to explain and interpret the behavioral effects of oxytocin is centered around a change in salience of emotional contexts (6–8), rather than unidirectional influences on certain types of behavior (e.g., anxiety). Our aim is to establish a coherent mechanistic understanding of the intracellular processes that underlie this change in emotional salience and therefore the effects on opposing behavioral outcomes.

Alleviating Behavioral Effects of Oxytocin

In rodents, the level of anxiety can be assessed by testing the exploratory drive vs. the fear of open and brightly lit spaces, as it is done in the elevated plus maze (EPM) or Light Dark Box (LDB). In previous publications, we have established that an infusion of synthetic oxytocin directly into the PVN of male and female rats reduces anxiety-like behavior for at least 4 h, i.e., increases the time spent in the open arms or lit compartment of the EPM and LDB, respectively (9–12). The endogenous release of oxytocin within the PVN can be triggered in male and female rats by various stimuli (13, 14). For instance, mating leads to a similar anxiolysis as observed with synthetic oxytocin infusions, indicating the behavioral valence of synthetic oxytocin (15, 16). In female prairie voles, intra-PVN infusions of oxytocin reduce anxiety-like behavior by activating local GABAergic neurons, which dampen the stress-induced activity of CRF-positive neurons and subsequent corticosterone release (17). As oxytocin receptors are also expressed on CRF-positive neurons (18), it not only acts via GABAergic inhibition, but also relies on direct oxytocin receptor-coupled modulation of stress-induced CRF transcription in the PVN of male rats as well (19). The interplay between oxytocin and the CRF system is not restricted to the PVN, as oxytocin receptor interneurons in the medial prefrontal cortex are responsible for anxiolysis in male mice, whereas in female mice they act pro-social by GABAergic inhibition of CRF receptor 1 expressing neurons (20, 21).

In a similar manner, infusions into the central amygdala reduce anxiety as well (22), and evoked release of endogenous oxytocin attenuates freezing in fear-conditioned mice (23) by acting on a local GABAergic inhibitory output circuit (24, 25). The type of fear response displayed, i.e., either startle response or active escape, is orchestrated by glutamatergic projections from the basolateral amygdala to oxytocin receptor positive cells in the central amygdala of mice and humans (26). Oxytocin also attenuates social fear expression in male, virgin and lactating female mice (27, 28), and cued fear extinction in male mice (29).

Those positive “dampening” or “alleviating” effects of oxytocin have been well-established in literature, so much, that a comprehensive list of all studies would be beyond the scope of this review [for extended discussion see (1)]. However, not all findings are in line with such a “positive” image of oxytocin. Depending on the context, oxytocin can produce opposing, more adverse or negative effects on behavior.

Adverse Behavioral Effects of Oxytocin

However, well-described the alleviating effects of oxytocin might be, potentiating effects of oxytocin on the stress response and increased anxiety have to be reflected to generate a comprehensive understanding. For instance, when peripheral oxytocin levels are increased chronically by subcutaneous infusion in male rats over the course of 14 days, ACTH and corticosterone levels, and adrenal weights are increased, indicating a potentiating effect of oxytocin on the HPA axis, and therefore the stress response (30). In addition, single subcutaneous injections transiently increase plasma ACTH and corticosterone levels in male rats (31), but decrease corticosterone levels 6 h after the injection without affecting ACTH levels. In an ex vivo setting, i.e., isolated hemipituitaries from male rats, oxytocin potentiated the CRF-induced ACTH release (32). In an in vivo setting, peripheral oxytocin secretion is modestly influenced by the activated HPA axis, i.e., plasma corticosterone levels; however, corticosterone levels amplified stress-induced oxytocin release within the PVN (33). Those data delineate oxytocin as a modulator of activated systems like the HPA axis instead of acting as a solitary driving force. However, a recent study conducted in wild chimpanzees failed to associate oxytocinergic system activity with increased stress and aggression during out-group conflict (34), which is seemingly in contrast to predictions made by the social salience hypothesis of oxytocin. However, whether urinary oxytocin and cortisol levels reflect central or plasma concentrations has yet to be determined, as a random discrepancy between those body-fluids might be the cause for the failed association.

In addition, timing and dosage seem to be key aspects that orchestrate the functional outcome. For instance, in a mouse model of chronic oxytocin infusion via osmotic minipumps, a low dose of chronic oxytocin (1 ng/0.2 μl/h) alleviated the effects of chronic stress, such as thymus atrophy, adrenal hypertrophy and decreased in vitro adrenal ACTH sensitivity; whereas a high dose (10 ng/0.2 μl/h) increased anxiety-like behavior in male mice (35). The increased anxiety was concomitant with a decreased expression of oxytocin receptors in the septum, likely as part of a negative feedback regulation, indicating this region as one important regulatory region for oxytocin-driven anxiety. However, the expression of fear in socially defeated male mice is positively associated with the expression level of oxytocin receptors and its coupling to the MAP kinase pathway in the lateral septum (36). When knocked down, the level of fear displayed by socially defeated mice toward their defeater was diminished, compared to mice where oxytocin receptors were overexpressed. The authors conclude that oxytocin does not have a unidirectional influence on anxiety, but rather changes the salience or valence of an emotional context (36). Another study revealed a full rescue of socially transmitted fear in unfamiliar male mice together with an enhanced cellular activity within the anterior cingulate cortex after acute intranasal oxytocin administration (37). To the contrary, the same study also investigated the effects of chronic oxytocin administration, which led to long-term facilitation of observational fear. Interestingly, none of these manipulations affected fear acquired as a result of direct experience with the stressor, but only socially transmitted fear. Hence, these results emphasize the role of oxytocin in context-dependent empathy.

Effects on empathy and context-dependent social cues have also been studied in human probands that received intranasal oxytocin. Those studies found increased aggression toward game partners in the “social orientation paradigm” (38), increased envy and schadenfreude or gloating in a game of chance (39), and even increased anxiety, indicated by an enhanced startle response after unpredictable threats (40).

Most of the above-mentioned studies interpret their data according to the salience hypothesis stating that oxytocin increases the perception of social stimuli dependent on the context, instead of acting unidirectional on any behavior. Thus, if oxytocin is not a pure anxiolytic, analgesic, or anti-stress hormone, but rather shifts the salience of an emotional context, changes in the activity of the salience network must be detectable (see Figure 1).

Figure 1

Graphical Abstract of the proposed signaling scheme. Oxytocin binds its receptor, which transactivates different types of calcium channels, leading to calcium influx from the extracellular space. Calcium activates protein kinase C, and subsequent MAPK pathway activation, i.e., MEK1/2-ERK1/2, which translocates to the nucleus and activates the transcription factor CREB. Calcium also activates the calcium-dependent phosphatase calcineurin, which dephosphorylates and therefore activates MEF2. Active MEF2 increases gene transcription of negative regulators of synaptic structures, causing decreased neurite outgrowth, synapse number, and hypoconnectivity between neighboring neurons. As oxytocin receptor positive neurons are located within brain regions of the salience network, MEF2 activity regulates the connectivity within those regions, dampening or increasing the activity in the whole network. Depending on the emotional context of external stimuli, those changes in the salience network can cause alleviating or adverse behavioral responses. The schematic art pieces used in this figure were provided by Servier Medical art (http://servier.com/Powerpoint-image-bank). Servier Medical Art by Servier is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

Oxytocin and the Salience Network

In order to understand the multitude of behavioral effects of oxytocin, a theoretical framework has been proposed that includes a prominent role for oxytocin-dopamine-interactions in regulating the salience of social cues (41). For instance, a recent study conducted in titi monkeys found increased anxiety and a trend toward increased glucose uptake in regions of the salience network. Specifically, glucose uptake tended to increase in the SON and caudate nucleus, in male animals treated chronically with intranasal oxytocin from 12 to 18 months of age (42). In addition to the SON and caudate nucleus, the salience network consists of other brain regions that have already been associated with oxytocinergic effects and that express the oxytocin receptor, like the anterior cingulate cortex, lateral septum, striatum, medial prefrontal cortex, hippocampus, amygdala, nucleus accumbens, and PVN (42). The significance of the salience network for psychiatric disorders has been shown by a very comprehensive meta-analysis that included more than 7,000 individuals with psychiatric diagnoses ranging from depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, or obsessive-compulsive disorder, to anxiety disorders (43). In each of those disorders, changes in myelin protein expression (44, 45), decreased gray and white matter volume (46), and loss of connectivity have been detected in core regions of the salience network, like the anterior cingulate cortex or medial prefrontal cortex, leading to impairments of cognitive control, which has been proposed as a diagnostic feature across the above-mentioned psychiatric disorders (47).

Besides alterations in oligodendrocyte-based myelin formation or damage, reduced gray matter volume and connectivity can be caused either by morphological changes of neurons (i.e., increased or decreased synapse formation) or by reduced neuronal survival rates. Consequentially, factors that influence those two aspects, and are triggered by oxytocin could be the sought after molecular substrates of the behavioral effects of oxytocin. In search for those factors, we investigated the signaling cascades coupled to the oxytocin receptor.

Oxytocin and MEF2

A first clue can be drawn from the apparent universal involvement of the MAP kinase pathway in the above-described contexts, e.g., the fear enhancing effects in the lateral septum (36), or the anxiolytic and anti-stress effects in the PVN (9, 10, 19). Potential targets of the MEK1/2-ERK1/2 pathway are on the one hand the transcription factor CREB, which is involved in oxytocin-induced spatial memory formation (48) and CRF gene transcription (19). On the other hand, the transcription factor myocyte enhancer factor 2 (MEF2), which has been shown to be directly activated following oxytocin receptor activation (49, 50) via the calcium-dependent phosphatase calcineurin (51). MEF2 is a main regulator of neuronal morphology, survival, connectivity, plasticity, and metaplasticity (52–54). CREB and MEF2 can act independently, but have also been shown to bind in concert to the synaptic response element (SARE), an enhancer sequence found upstream of many neuronal plasticity-related genes (55, 56). While we have identified a MEF2 binding sequence in the oxytocin receptor promoter with in silico prediction tools, there is no recent evidence available, whether activated MEF2 alters the transcription of the Oxtr gene. Decreased MEF2 levels and increased phosphorylation levels, i.e., decreased gene transcription, have been found in mice that underwent fear conditioning and spatial memory tasks. In contrast, increasing MEF2 levels and dephosphorylation prevented the formation of spatial memory and associated increase in spine density. These findings suggest that MEF2-mediated transcription constrains memory formation by interfering with neuronal plasticity (57).

MEF2 and Neuronal Connectivity

Neuronal plasticity and connectivity is governed by the ability of the neurons to adapt their cellular morphology to the momentary requirements, i.e., induce neurite outgrowth and retraction. Both factors, CREB and MEF2 have been shown to actively regulate neurite outgrowth (58, 59) and thus influence the formation of synapses (60, 61). Those oxytocin-induced cellular effects can depend on MEF2 expression levels as the transcription factor is known to be a regulator of metaplasticity, i.e., it determines how neurons respond to stimuli by shifting plasticity thresholds (54). Moreover, mutated MEF2 has been associated with Rett-like syndrome (62, 63) and autism spectrum disorder (64–66). Recent publications indicate a connection between dysregulated synapse number, i.e., hyperconnectivity, and symptoms of autism spectrum disorder (67); moreover, lower plasma oxytocin levels have been reported in children with autism and social impairments (68, 69). Those impairments and low plasma oxytocin levels might be associated with an altered composition of the gut microbiome (70), a process that also impacts MEF2 phosphorylation (71), and neuronal plasticity (72). A current study revealed that in male patients with autism spectrum disorder higher levels of endogenous salivary oxytocin are associated with lower degrees of functional coupling between the amygdala and hippocampus (73). Notably, a single dose of intranasal oxytocin induced a further reduction in the degree of functional connectivity between those two regions. Those data suggest that abnormal oxytocin synthesis and/or intracerebral release could be the cause for the observed connectivity differences in autistic patients. In support of this hypothesis, we and others have recently shown that oxytocin modulates neuronal morphology and synapse formation in dependence of MEF2A, calcium signaling, and the MAPK pathway (50, 74–78).

MEF2-Driven Mechanisms Affecting Neuronal Connectivity

In order to elucidate the underlying signaling pathways explaining the manifold behavioral effects of oxytocin, we have gathered evidence for a central role of the transcription factor MEF2. The activity-dependent influence on neuronal plasticity, termed metaplasticity, is one key characteristic trait of MEF2 (54, 79), and could explain the multitude of behavioral effects of oxytocin, by altering the connectivity, and therefore activity, between neurons of brain regions that are part of the salience network (e.g., within the mPFC, hypothalamus, or amygdala). Altered activity within those oxytocin-sensitive brain regions dampens or stimulates adjacent regions (80, 81), and therefore the whole network. The molecular machinery that determines MEF2 activity, and therefore causes this plasticity, has been investigated in detail. MEF2 contains several different phosphorylation sites, acting either inhibitory, or stimulatory on gene transcription (52). Two different calcium-dependent pathways have been described: (1) Class II HDACs are bound to MEF2, acting as permanent inhibitors. Upon calcium influx, these HDACs are phosphorylated by calcium/calmodulin activated kinase (CaMK) and exported out of the nucleus, relieving MEF2 repression and allowing for the activation of MEF2-dependent transcription (58). (2) Calcium influx leads to the dephosphorylation of MEF2 proteins at serine 408, via the calcium-dependent phosphatase calcineurin (60, 82). This dephosphorylation promotes a switch from sumoylation to acetylation at lysine 403, which leads to inhibition of dendritic claw differentiation (82). The question remains how activated (acetylated and dephosphorylated) MEF2 regulates synapse number, and therefore connectivity between neurons. Several possible mechanisms have been described: first, activated MEF2 promotes the sumoylation and subsequent degradation of a synaptic scaffolding protein, the postsynaptic density protein 95 (PSD-95) (83). Second, the transcription of negative regulators of synapse development, arc and synGAP, is stimulated by activated MEF2, leading to a reduced excitatory synapse number in hippocampal neurons (60). And lastly, MEF2 closely interacts with another regulator of neuronal connectivity, the mitochondria (79). We have shown that MEF2 expression modulates the basic mitochondrial functions like maximal respiration, spare respiratory capacity, and ATP production in neurons by means of a CRISPR-Cas-generated MEF2A functional knockout cell line (51). Those mitochondrial mechanisms are known to regulate synaptic strength (79). Since mitochondria have their own genome, transcription factors like MEF2 are able to induce mitochondrial gene transcription in addition to nuclear transcription. Indeed, MEF2 promotes the expression of the mitochondrial gene ND6, which is essential for the function of the oxidative phosphorylation system (84), which regulates the production of ROS. Release of ROS activates the pro-apoptotic caspase-3, which induces the breakdown of PSD-95, thereby weakening synaptic strength (79).

Taken together, the above-described effects of MEF2 on synaptic strength can be bidirectional, as MEF2 can either stimulate or inhibit gene transcription (85). Oxytocin receptor signaling activates MEF2 in a context-dependent manner and thereby induces morphological changes, e.g., neurite retraction (50). Morphological changes in turn determine the synaptic strength and therefore connectivity between oxytocin receptor positive neurons (76). Oxytocin-sensitive neurons are located in brain regions that are part of the salience network (80), which has been shown to be responsive to oxytocin (42) and modulates anxiety-like behavior or the stress response (86, 87).

Conclusion

In conclusion, oxytocin exerts its behavioral effects not in a direct manner, but rather acts modulatory on the activated salience network, to alter the emotional context of a secondary stimulus and produce a variety of context-dependent behavioral outcomes, including anxiolysis and anxiogenesis and increased or reduced stress response. We hypothesize that MEF2 is one of the key elements enabling this behavioral variability by modulating the connectivity of oxytocin receptor-positive neurons within a brain region and as result of this, potentially affecting the salience network as a whole.

Author Contributions

BJ and MM contributed equally to the manuscript.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.