Chia-Chun Wang1, Aimee L McNamara2, Jungwook Shin2, Jan Schuemann2, Clemens Grassberger2, Alphonse G Taghian2, Rachel B Jimenez2, Shannon M MacDonald2, Harald Paganetti3. 1. Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts; National Taiwan University Cancer Center, Taipei, Taiwan. 2. Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. 3. Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. Electronic address: hpaganetti@mgh.harvard.edu.
Abstract
PURPOSE: A prospective trial of proton therapy for breast cancer revealed an increased rib fracture rate of 7%, which is higher than the expected rate based on the literature on photon therapies. We aim to evaluate the hypothesis that the increased relative biological effectiveness (RBE) at the distal edge of proton beams is the cause. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We combined the cohort from the prospective clinical trial and a retrospective cohort from a database. Monte Carlo simulations were performed to recalculate the physical dose and dose-averaged linear energy transfer (LETd). The first 10 ribs and fracture areas in patients with fractures were contoured and deformably registered. The LETd-weighted dose was used as a surrogate for biological effectiveness and compared with the conventional fixed RBE of 1.1. Dose to 0.5 cm3 of the ribs (D0.5) was selected to analyze the dose-response relationship using logistic regression. We chose an alpha/beta ratio of 3 to calculate the biological effective dose in Gy3(RBE). RESULTS: Thirteen of 203 patients in the cohorts exhibited a total of 25 fractures. The LETd in fractured areas is increased (6.1 ± 2.0 keV/μm, mean ± standard deviation), suggesting possible end-of-range radiobiological effects with increased RBE. The D0.5 of the fractured ribs is 80.3 ± 9.4 Gy3(RBE) with a generic factor of 1.1 and is relatively low compared with historical photon results. On the other hand, the D0.5 of the fractured ribs is 100.0 ± 12.5 Gy3(RBE) using the LETd-based model with a dose-response curve that is more consistent with historical photon data. CONCLUSIONS: The increased rib fracture rate seen in our trial is probably associated with the increased LETd and RBE at the distal edge of proton beams. This phenomenon warrants further investigation and possible integration of LETd into treatment planning and optimization in proton therapy.
PURPOSE:A prospective trial of proton therapy for breast cancer revealed an increased rib fracture rate of 7%, which is higher than the expected rate based on the literature on photon therapies. We aim to evaluate the hypothesis that the increased relative biological effectiveness (RBE) at the distal edge of proton beams is the cause. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We combined the cohort from the prospective clinical trial and a retrospective cohort from a database. Monte Carlo simulations were performed to recalculate the physical dose and dose-averaged linear energy transfer (LETd). The first 10 ribs and fracture areas in patients with fractures were contoured and deformably registered. The LETd-weighted dose was used as a surrogate for biological effectiveness and compared with the conventional fixed RBE of 1.1. Dose to 0.5 cm3 of the ribs (D0.5) was selected to analyze the dose-response relationship using logistic regression. We chose an alpha/beta ratio of 3 to calculate the biological effective dose in Gy3(RBE). RESULTS: Thirteen of 203 patients in the cohorts exhibited a total of 25 fractures. The LETd in fractured areas is increased (6.1 ± 2.0 keV/μm, mean ± standard deviation), suggesting possible end-of-range radiobiological effects with increased RBE. The D0.5 of the fractured ribs is 80.3 ± 9.4 Gy3(RBE) with a generic factor of 1.1 and is relatively low compared with historical photon results. On the other hand, the D0.5 of the fractured ribs is 100.0 ± 12.5 Gy3(RBE) using the LETd-based model with a dose-response curve that is more consistent with historical photon data. CONCLUSIONS: The increased rib fracture rate seen in our trial is probably associated with the increased LETd and RBE at the distal edge of proton beams. This phenomenon warrants further investigation and possible integration of LETd into treatment planning and optimization in proton therapy.
Authors: Rachel B Jimenez; Shea Hickey; Nicolas DePauw; Beow Y Yeap; Estelle Batin; Michelle A Gadd; Michelle Specht; Steven J Isakoff; Barbara L Smith; Eric C Liao; Amy S Colwell; Alice Ho; James L Januzzi; Jonathan Passeri; Tomas G Neilan; Alphonse G Taghian; Hsiao-Ming Lu; Shannon M MacDonald Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2019-08-26 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Jinhai Huo; Sharon H Giordano; Benjamin D Smith; Simona F Shaitelman; Grace L Smith Journal: Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys Date: 2015-12-17 Impact factor: 7.038
Authors: Prashant Gabani; Hetal Patel; Maria A Thomas; Beth Bottani; S Murty Goddu; William Straube; Julie A Margenthaler; Laura Ochoa; Jeff D Bradley; Imran Zoberi Journal: Clin Transl Radiat Oncol Date: 2019-10-02
Authors: Mojgan Taremi; Andrew Hope; Patricia Lindsay; Max Dahele; Sharon Fung; Thomas G Purdie; David Jaffray; Laura Dawson; Andrea Bezjak Journal: Radiat Oncol Date: 2012-09-17 Impact factor: 3.481
Authors: Helge Henjum; Tordis J Dahle; Lars Fredrik Fjæra; Eivind Rørvik; Sara Pilskog; Camilla H Stokkevåg; Andrea Mairani; Kristian S Ytre-Hauge Journal: Adv Radiat Oncol Date: 2021-08-17
Authors: Line Bjerregaard Stick; Maria Fuglsang Jensen; Søren M Bentzen; Claus Kamby; Anni Young Lundgaard; Maja Vestmø Maraldo; Birgitte Vrou Offersen; Jen Yu; Ivan Richter Vogelius Journal: Int J Part Ther Date: 2021-11-11
Authors: Robert W Mutter; J Isabelle Choi; Rachel B Jimenez; Youlia M Kirova; Marcio Fagundes; Bruce G Haffty; Richard A Amos; Julie A Bradley; Peter Y Chen; Xuanfeng Ding; Antoinette M Carr; Leslie M Taylor; Mark Pankuch; Raymond B Mailhot Vega; Alice Y Ho; Petra Witt Nyström; Lisa A McGee; James J Urbanic; Oren Cahlon; John H Maduro; Shannon M MacDonald Journal: Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys Date: 2021-05-25 Impact factor: 8.013
Authors: Harald Paganetti; Chris Beltran; Stefan Both; Lei Dong; Jacob Flanz; Keith Furutani; Clemens Grassberger; David R Grosshans; Antje-Christin Knopf; Johannes A Langendijk; Hakan Nystrom; Katia Parodi; Bas W Raaymakers; Christian Richter; Gabriel O Sawakuchi; Marco Schippers; Simona F Shaitelman; B K Kevin Teo; Jan Unkelbach; Patrick Wohlfahrt; Tony Lomax Journal: Phys Med Biol Date: 2021-02-26 Impact factor: 4.174