| Literature DB >> 32187847 |
Cheyennedra C Bieg-Bourne1, Ryosuke Okamura1, Razelle Kurzrock1.
Abstract
We examined the impact of spatial, temporal, histologic, and quantitative factors on concordance between TP53 alterations in tissue DNA vs in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). Four hundred and thirty-three patients underwent next-generation sequencing (NGS) in which both tissue and blood samples were evaluated. TP53 was detected in 258 of 433 patients (59.6%); 215 had tissue TP53 alterations (49.7%); 159, ctDNA (36.7%); and 116, both tissue and ctDNA (27.8%). Overall concordance rate between ctDNA and tissue biopsies for TP53 alterations was 67.2%; positive concordance was 45.0%. Overall concordance for TP53 did not vary among patients with ≤ 2 months vs > 6 months between test samples; however, positive concordance trended higher when time intervals between test samples were shorter, suggesting that the lack of difference in overall concordance may be due to the large number of negative/negative tests. There was a trend toward higher overall concordance based on biopsy site (metastatic vs primary) (P = 0.07) and significantly higher positive concordance if the tissue biopsy site was a metastatic lesion (P = 0.03). Positive concordance significantly decreased in noncolorectal cancer patients vs colorectal cancer patients (P = 0.02). Finally, higher %ctDNA was associated with higher concordance rates between blood and tissue (P < 0.001). Taken together, these data indicate that both blood and tissue DNA sequencing are necessary to evaluate the full scope of TP53 alterations, and that concordance rates may be related to multiple factors including, but not limited to, amount of ctDNA, histologic context, and site of tissue biopsy.Entities:
Keywords: TP53; cancer; concordance; ctDNA; genomics
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32187847 PMCID: PMC7266274 DOI: 10.1002/1878-0261.12672
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Mol Oncol ISSN: 1574-7891 Impact factor: 6.603
Patient demographics among (N = 433) patients who underwent tissue and blood‐derived ctDNA NGS .
| Characteristic | Number of patients |
|---|---|
| Gender ( | |
| Women | 237 (54.7%) |
| Men | 196 (45.3%) |
| Median age at time of ctDNA (Range) | 62 years (19–93) |
| Diagnosis ( | |
| Lung cancer | 78 (18.0%) |
| Brain cancer | 56 (12.9%) |
| GI, Colorectal | 54 (12.5%) |
| GI, Noncolorectal | 50 (11.5%) |
| Breast cancer | 50 (11.5%) |
| Hepato‐pancreato‐biliary | 40 (9.2%) |
| Head and neck cancer | 31 (7.2%) |
| Gynecologic cancer | 22 (5.1%) |
| Others/Unknown primary | 52 (12.0%) |
| Time interval between blood draw and tissue biopsy, months | |
| ≤ 2 | 165 (38.1%) |
| > 2–6 | 69 (15.9%) |
| > 6 | 199 (46.0%) |
| Disease stage at time of blood draw ( | |
| Metastatic or locally advanced | 385 (88.9%) |
| Not metastatic | 48 (11.1%) |
| Disease state at time of tissue biopsy ( | |
| Metastatic or locally advanced | 328 (75.8%) |
| Not metastatic | 105 (24.2%) |
Data derived from database described by Mardinian et al. (2019).
Fig. 1The 10 most common characterized alterations (VUS excluded) among tissue biopsy and blood‐derived ctDNA (N = 433 total patients). If there were two alterations in one gene in a patient, only one was counted.
Fig. 2Alteration detection performed by tissue and ctDNA tests. Venn diagrams represent the proportion of patients who had TP53 detected in only tissue, in both tissue and ctDNA, and only in ctDNA. Concordance was examined at the gene level. If there was more than one time point of tissue or ctDNA NGS, the time points closest together for each patient were chosen.
Overall and positive concordance of TP53. Concordance of TP53 alterations (N = 433 patients) stratified by time between tissue biopsy and blood draw (≤ 2, 2–6, and > 6 months between tissue biopsy and blood draw) as well as overall concordance; temporal and spatial effects and positive concordance among patients with (≤ 2 months, 2–6 months, and > 6 months between tissue biopsy and blood‐derived ctDNA as well as primary vs metastatic site for tissue biopsy comparison.
| All patients ( | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tissue DNA results | Overall concordance rate | Kappa (SE) | Positive concordance rate | ||
| Positive | Negative | ||||
| ctDNA results | |||||
| Positive | 116 | 43 | 67.2% | 0.34 (0.04) | 45.0% |
| Negative | 99 | 175 | |||
Overall concordance = (++) + (−−)/ Total. b
Fig. 3Consort diagram that displays the detection of TP53 alteration in both tissue and blood‐derived ctDNA NGS.