| Literature DB >> 32158518 |
Amanda Nagulendran1, Laura Jobson1.
Abstract
Background: Emotion regulation difficulties are central to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). While cultural differences exist in the ways in which individuals regulate their emotions, researchers have not examined cultural differences in emotion regulation in PTSD.Objective: This study explored emotion regulation in individuals from European and East Asian cultures with and without PTSD. Method: Emotion regulation measures were administered to Caucasian Australian (n = 31) and East Asian Australian (n = 38) trauma survivors with and without PTSD.Entities:
Keywords: Posttraumatic stress disorder; culture; emotion regulation; • Sufferers of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) have emotion regulation difficulties.• This study highlights that culture may influence the emotion regulation strategies associated with PTSD.• This may have implications for assessment and treatment of emotion in PTSD and highlights the need for further research in the area.
Year: 2020 PMID: 32158518 PMCID: PMC7048195 DOI: 10.1080/20008198.2020.1729033
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Eur J Psychotraumatol ISSN: 2000-8066
Definitions of emotion regulation strategies implicated in posttraumatic stress disorder.
| Emotion Regulation Strategy | Definition |
|---|---|
| Expressive Suppression | Inhibiting the outward expression of an emotion |
| Thought suppression | Suppressing a specific thought and the emotions associated with it |
| Rumination | Dwelling on one’s symptoms of distress and their consequences |
| Worry | Directing attention towards future-oriented negative outcomes |
| Experiential Avoidance | Avoiding contact with uncomfortable thoughts, feelings, and memories |
| Reappraisal | Reinterpreting the meaning of a stimulus to change its emotional impact |
Mean and (Standard Deviations) for group characteristics for demographic and study variables.
| Caucasian no-PTSD ( | Caucasian PTSD ( | East Asian no- PTSD ( | East Asian PTSD ( | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age (years) | 29.40 (13.87) | 30.81 (12.66) | 23.74 (6.72) | 23.53 (5.04) |
| Gender F:M ( | 13:2 | 14:2 | 16:7 | 14:1 |
| Educationa | 9:6:0 | 7:7:2 | 15:5:3 | 9:6:0 |
| Years in Australia | 26.27 (15.61) | 30.00 (11.69) | 3.63 (9.37) | 6.46 (9.51) |
| Years since trauma | 6.09 (8.62) | 6.33 (7.96) | 7.69 (9.74) | 4.24(5.22) |
| Depression | 1.54 (0.35) | 2.57 (0.67) | 1.85 (0.61) | 2.26 (0.57) |
| Reappraisal | 32.80 (5.06) | 25.19 (6.64) | 27.78 (5.90) | 29.53 (8.11) |
| Expressive Suppression | 12.60 (4.70) | 18.69 (4.40) | 14.87 (4.13) | 16.20 (5.49) |
| Experiential Avoidance | 19.40 (7.53) | 33.50 (9.19) | 23.45 (8.13) | 29.80 (9.72) |
| Worry | 42.67 (12.56) | 55.69 (14.36) | 49.43 (15.60) | 47.73 (13.48) |
| Thought Suppression | 41.07 (10.49) | 62.34 (9.39) | 48.55 (13.18) | 55.55 (7.65) |
| Rumination | 43.00 (9.16) | 58.38 (12.19) | 49.83 (13.19) | 58.87 (11.65) |
| Rumination – Trauma | 16.87 (8.43) | 34.06 (9.59) | 20.07 (10.52) | 33.07 (9.10) |
| General Emotional Dysregulation | 65.14 (16.49) | 96.04 (27.51) | 79.85 (20.37) | 88.22 (19.86) |
ahigh school:undergraduate diploma/degree:postgraduate.
Correlation coefficients between the main study variables for the overall sample and the East Asian (presented bottom half of the diagonal) and Caucasian (presented top half of the diagonal) groups separately.
| PTSD Symptoms | Depression Symptoms | Reappraisal | Expressive Suppression | Experiential Avoidance | Worry | Thought Suppression | Rumination | Rumination-Trauma | General Emotion Dysregulation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTSD Symptoms | 1.00 | .57** [.38–.71] | −.27* [−.50–.01] | .33** [.01–.53] | .54** [.32–.71] | .17 [−.03-.36] | .55** [.38–.70] | .41** [.19–.60] | .65** [.49–.79] | .46** [.23–.63] |
| Depression Symptoms | - | 1.00 | −.41** [−.56–−.22] | .50** [.33–.66] | .77** [.67-.86] | .50** [.30–.66] | .63** [.48–.75] | .69** [.51–.83] | .65** [.49–.78] | .77** [.64–.86] |
| Reappraisal | - | - | 1.00 | −.03 [−.28–.23] | −.29* [−.51–−.04] | −.30* [−.53–.05] | −.15 [−.33–.05] | −.25* [−.43–−.06] | −.13 [−.33–.11] | −.40** [−.57–−.20] |
| Expressive Suppression | - | - | - | 1.00 | .60** [.43–.75] | .41** [.20–.60] | .47** [.27–.64] | .48** [.34–.60] | .45** [.29–.61] | .50** [.30–.67] |
| Experiential Avoidance | - | - | - | - | 1.00 | .63** [.49–.75] | .70** [.56–.80] | .65** [.51–.75] | .68** [.54–.80] | .78** [.66–.86] |
| Worry | - | - | - | - | - | 1.00 | .51** [.29–.69] | .55** [.35–.71] | .38** [.16–.56] | .64** [.47-.78] |
| Thought Suppression | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1.00 | .60** [.44–.72] | .75** [.60-.86] | .64** [.49-.76] |
| Rumination | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1.00 | .67** [.51–.79] | .65** [.47–.79] |
| Rumination-Trauma | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1.00 | .52** [.31–.69] |
| General Emotion Dysregulation | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | 1.00 |
| PTSD | 1.00 | .75** [.60–.86] | −.52** [−.75–−.22] | .53** [.27–.75] | .74** [.57–.86] | .43* [.13–.70] | .74** [.62–.89] | .51** [.27–.76] | .70** [.51–.92] | .68** [.46–.82] |
| Depression Symptoms | .39* [.10–.64] | 1.00 | −.47** [−.68–−.21] | .61** [.39–.80] | .87** [.77–.94] | .67** [.49–.80] | .67** [.47–.85] | .65** [.35–.84] | .69** [.49–.84] | .80** [.59–.90] |
| Reappraisal | −.08 [−.46–.39] | −.35* [−.58- −.05] | 1.00 | −.46** [−.68–−.16] | −.47** [−.71- −.20] | −.37* [−.72-.01] | −.37* [−.64–−.11] | −.36* [−.61–.05] | −.35 [−.64–−.04] | −.46** [−.75–−.13] |
| Expressive Suppression | .12 [−.26–.49] | .38* [.09–.62] | .38* [.01–.67] | 1.00 | .66** [.44–.81] | .58** [.31–.79] | .50** [.19–.72] | .49** [.26–.69] | .48** [.20–.68] | .65** [.38–.83] |
| Experiential Avoidance | .35* [−.05–.66] | .67** [.47–.82] | −.11 [−.46–.26] | .50** [.15–.74] | 1.00 | .67** [.48–.83] | .81** [.63-.92] | .71** [.49–.86] | .81** [.66–.91] | .86** [.71–.94] |
| Worry | −.04 [−.32–.23] | .33* [.01–.64] | −.25 [−.56–.12] | .28 [−.11–.57] | .55** [.33–.74] | 1.00 | .65** [.43–.82] | .66** [.46–.80] | .59** [.35–.76] | .81** [.69–.89] |
| Thought Suppression | .36* [.01–.56] | .58** [.33–.74] | .07 [−.19–.34] | .43** [.10–.67] | .55** [.32-.73] | .34* [−.03-.67] | 1.00 | .68** [.50-.82] | .88** [.81–.94] | .75** [.60-.87] |
| Rumination | .37* [.08-.64] | .74** [.50-.89] | −.16 [−.43–.13] | .48** [.26–.67] | .60** [.43–.74] | .43** [.14-.70] | .54* [.26–.75] | 1.00 | .72** [.50–.85] | .78** [.61–.90] |
| Rumination-Trauma | .61** [.36-.79] | .61** [.32-.83] | .07 [−.25–.38] | .42** [.19-.63] | .54** [.27–.75] | .17 [−.15-.49] | .61** [.33–.83] | .64** [.39-.82] | 1.00 | .70** [.48–.84] |
| General Emotion Dysregulation | .24 [−.12-.53] | .73** [.56-.87] | −.34* [−.56- −.05] | .31 [−.03–.58] | .67** [.48–.81] | .43** [.10-.70] | .49** [.20–.72] | .52** [.17–.76] | .31 [−.06–.65] | 1.00 |
PTSD = Posttraumatic stress disorder. * p < .05, ** p < .01.