| Literature DB >> 32132906 |
Jacquelyn S Christensen1, Heather Wild2, Erin S Kenzie3, Wayne Wakeland3, Deborah Budding4, Connie Lillas5.
Abstract
The specific role of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) in emotional and behavioral regulation-particularly in relation to automatic processes-has gained increased attention in the sensory modulation literature. This mini-review article summarizes current knowledge about the role of the ANS in sensory modulation, with a focus on the integrated functions of the ANS and the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis and their measurement. Research from the past decade illustrates that sympathetic and parasympathetic interactions are more complex than previously assumed. Patterns of ANS activation vary across individuals, with distinct physiological response profiles influencing the reactivity underlying automatic behavioral responses. This review article advances a deeper understanding of stress and the complex stress patterns within the ANS and HPA axis that contribute to allostatic load (AL). We argue that using multiple physiological measurements to capture individual ANS response variation is critical for effectively treating children with sensory modulation disorder (SMD) and sensory differences. We consider the relative contributions of automatic vs. deliberately controlled processes across large-scale neural networks in the development of sensorimotor function and their associated links with arousal patterns and sensory over- and under-responsivity.Entities:
Keywords: allostatic load; automatic processes; autonomic nervous system; complex systems; large-scale network; physiological arousal; sensory modulation; stress response
Year: 2020 PMID: 32132906 PMCID: PMC7040227 DOI: 10.3389/fnint.2020.00006
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Integr Neurosci ISSN: 1662-5145
Contributions of key stress models.
| ANS-HPA emphasis | Model example | Author/Key citation | Primary measures | Core contributions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SNS HPA | Allostasis/Allostatic Load | McEwen ( | EDA; PEP (SNS) Cortisol (HPA) | Allostasis—expected stress and stress recovery cycle that allows one to return to baseline Proposed four allostatic load (AL) patterns based upon variation in SNS activation or HPA inhibition. Identified AL patterns underly many disease processes |
| PNS | Polyvagal Theory | Porges ( | RSA or HRV | Identified two PNS vagus nerve branches Offers sequential and hierarchical stages of activation from newer (ventral vagal) to older (dorsal vagal) High PNS activity through HRV measurement associated with better self-regulation and less stress over-reactivity |
| SNS and PNS | Modes of Autonomic Control | Berntson et al. ( | PEP and HRV PEP and RSA | Proposed nine modes of autonomic control from differing SNS and PNS dynamics—coupled, reciprocal, and uncoupled patterns Found four arousal profile patterns paralleling some patterns within the doctrine of autonomic control—Coactivation and co-inhibition, Reciprocal sympathetic, Reciprocal parasympathetic |
| SNS and PNS SNS, PNS, and HPA-axis | Adaptive Calibration Model | Del Giudice et al. ( | EDA and RSA PEP, RSA, Cortisol | Originally proposed four patterns of SNS/PNS activity (Sensitive; Buffered; Vigilant; Unemotional) Found six arousal profile patterns in the multi-site study; Moderate reactivity (most common); Parasympathetic-specific reactivity; Anticipatory arousal; Multisystem reactivity; HPA-specific reactivity; Under-aroused |
SNS, Sympathetic nervous system; PNS, Parasympathetic nervous system; HPA-axis, Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis; EDA, Electrodermal activity; HRV, Heart-rate variability; RSA, Respiratory sinus arrhythmia; PEP, Pre-ejection period.
Selected SMD articles by stress response model and physiological patterns.
| Study | Sample age | Diagnosis (n) | Physiological measurement | Activation patterns of physiology | Inhibition patterns of physiology |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stress Model: SNS and HPA Axis Focus | |||||
| Miller et al. ( | 4–49 | Fragile × Syndrome (15) Fragile × Mutation (25) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater EDA frequency and magnitude; Lower habituation rate | – |
| McIntosh et al. ( | 3–9 | SMD (19) TYP (19) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater EDA frequency and magnitude; Lower habituation rates | No EDA response to stimulation ( |
| Mangeot et al. ( | 5–13 | ADHD (26) TYP (30) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater EDA magnitude (early response to sensations) | – |
| Schoen et al. ( | 4–15 | SMD (31) ASD (38) TYP (33) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater response arousal of EDA (1st trial of sensory stimulation) (SMD); Greater EDA magnitude and amplitude (SMD); Habituation occurred | Lower arousal at baseline (ASD) No EDA response to stimulation found 20–35% of each subgroup |
| Su et al. ( | 4–8 | SMD (14) TYP (17) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater EDA frequency and magnitude; Slower habituation | – |
| Miller et al. ( | 6–12 | SMD (37) ADHD (28) SMD and ADHD (12) TYP (30) | EDA (for SNS) | Greater EDA magnitude (SMD vs. ADHD and TYP) | – |
| Reynolds et al. ( | 6–12 | ADHD w/ SMD (13) ADHD w/o SMD (11) TYP (24) | Salivary Cortisol (for HPA axis) | – | Blunted cortisol response (ADHD w/o SMD) |
| Lane et al. ( | 6–12 | ADHD (18); TYP (36); ADHD w SOR (21); TYP w SOR (9) | EDA (for SNS) Salivary Cortisol (for HPA axis) | Twice as many non-specific EDA spikes post a challenge, during the recovery phase (ADHD w/ SOR) Elevated cortisol post a challenge (TYP and ADHD with SOR) | – |
| Stress Models: PNS Focus | |||||
| Schaaf et al. ( | 4–8 | SMD (9) TYP (6) | HRV (for PNS) | – | Significantly lower cardiac vagal tone Lower heart period |
| Schaaf et al. ( | 5–12 | TYP (40); Severe SMD (15); Moderate SMD (13) Borderline SMD (11) | HRV (for PNS) | – | Severe SMD—lower mean vagal tone during baseline, tones, and prolonged auditory stimulation |
| Stress Models: SNS and PNS Focus | |||||
| No studies specific to SMD done at this time with both biomarkers | |||||
Note: All studies included used Sensory Challenge Protocol (SCP). SMD, Sensory modulation disorder; TYP, Typical; ADHD, Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; EDA, Electrodermal activity; HRV, Heart-rate Variability; SNS, Sympathetic nervous system; PNS, Parasympathetic nervous system; HPA-axis, Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis.