Dear EditorWe read with interest the article by Dr Gorlier et al. in which they aimed to
evaluate the soluble form of triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells-1
(sTREM-1) activation in Familial Mediterranean Fever (FMF).[1] They reached the conclusion that sTREM-1 plasma levels can be more specific
to FMFpatients with amyloidosis. We have certain points to make in order to
understand the conclusions that can be drawn related to the molecule.First, there is research in the literature on diseases of the adaptive immune system,
especially on systemic lupus erythematosus and systemic sclerosis where sTREM-1
was found to be correlated with disease activity.[2-4] You also shared the study
on septic conditions.[5] We are curious about the opinion of the authors on the status of this
potential marker among a variety of conditions. Perhaps a new study comparing
these different conditions would enhance our understanding.Second, there appear to be two potential biases related to this study. When comparing
the FMF groups with and without amyloidosis, the significant difference in age
should be highlighted. In the FMF with amyloidosis group, the mean age was
60.2 ± 16.3 yr, whereas in the FMF without amyloidosis group, the mean age was
40.9 ± 11.2 (P < 10–4). Another bias is related to kidney function.
There are studies where sTREM-1 is increased in kidney injury.[6] The probability of sTREM-1 signalling kidney damage rather than amyloid
deposition should not be overlooked, as this lowers the specificity of the
molecule. For example, a potential study comparing FMF-related amyloidosispatients with high and normal creatinine levels could show us the actual
specificity of sTREM-1 to amyloidosis.It would be of interest to hear the opinion of the authors on these points and to
have studies on this matter with higher statistical power and with control
groups.
Authors: Iman H Bassyouni; Samar Fawzi; Tamer A Gheita; Rasha H Bassyouni; Aml S Nasr; Samah A El Bakry; Naglaa Afifi Journal: Immunol Invest Date: 2016-09-20 Impact factor: 3.657