An evaluation of temporal and spatial trends of pyrethroid concentrations in California surface waters.

Pyrethroid insecticides are frequently detected in urban surface waters at levels that are deleterious to sensitive aquatic species. The California Department of Pesticide Regulation (CDPR) Surface Water Protection Program collected 717 water and 191 sediment samples from 2009 to 2018 throughout California, providing a large dataset to conduct spatial and temporal trend analysis of pyrethroid concentrations. The pyrethroid bifenthrin accounted for 72% of average sample concentrations, and a strong relationship between whole water bifenthrin concentrations and the observed toxicity to the test species Hyallela azteca was established. To help mitigate runoff concentrations, CDPR adopted regulations in 2012 intended to limit the mass of pyrethroids applied to structures by professional pest control operators. A statistical analysis of CDPR statewide monitoring data collected at storm drain outfall and receiving water sites was conducted to determine if any significant trends in pyrethroid concentrations exist. Nonparametric statistical analysis of monitoring data revealed significant regional differences. In Northern California, decreasing trends in bifenthrin and cypermethrin concentrations may be counterbalanced by a potential switch to deltamethrin-containing products. Conversely, the few observed trends in concentrations at Southern California monitoring stations could be a result of regional hydrological and pest pressure differences. To evaluate the effects of structural applications on pyrethroid concentrations in urban runoff, CDPR conducted field trials using a tracer pyrethroid that was applied in accordance with the regulations. Detectable levels in runoff were observed, with an estimated 0.004-0.005% mass transport offsite per storm. Using field-derived sediment, the observed half-lives (514 days+) highlight the potential for contaminant laden sediment to serve as a long-term source of pyrethroids within waterways. Both chemistry and observed toxicity data identify storm water runoff as a primary transport mechanism. However, the presence of pyrethroids in dry-weather runoff suggests that significant loading can occur under various hydrologic conditions.