Prevalence of allergen sensitization among 1,091 patients with urticaria.

The etiology of urticaria is heterogeneous and allergic responses may be involved in it. The aim of the present study was to investigate the prevalence and distribution of sensitivity to inhaled and food allergens among patients with urticaria in Henan province (China). The levels of specific immunoglobulin E (sIgE) were detected using the AllergyScreen test and a total of 524/1,091 cases (48.0%) tested positive for sIgE to at least one of the 19 allergens. The most common inhaled allergens the urticaria patients were sensitive to were D. pteronyssinus (34.5%), cockroach (12.5%) and tree pollen mix (11.1%), while the food allergens with the highest rate of allergic reactions were cashew nut (8.1%), shrimp (6.8%) and crab (6.4%). The positive rates for D. pteronyssinus, dog hair, cockroach, mold mix, tree pollen mix and shrimp in the chronic urticaria group were higher than those in the acute urticaria group (P<0.05). Furthermore, positive rates for the majority of allergens were higher in males than in females and were significantly different between age groups (P<0.05). The results of the present study provided information on the characteristics of allergen sensitization of patients with urticaria and may facilitate the prevention, diagnosis and management of urticaria in Henan province. Copyright: © Ping et al.

Introduction

Urticaria is a common skin disease characterized by wheals, itch and/or angioedema. The life-time prevalence for any subtype of urticaria is ~20% (1). Based on frequency and duration, it is classified into acute urticaria (AU) and chronic urticaria (lasting >6 weeks; CU). Recurrence of disease causes a serious decline in quality of life.

Urticaria is a heterogeneous disease in which allergy may be involved. Consequently, the determination of major allergens triggering these pathological processes is crucial for the prevention, diagnosis and management of patients with urticaria (2). Specific immunoglobulin E (sIgE) is a collective term for antibodies produced by the immune system with specificity for an individual allergen (3). Apart from the skin prick test, the serum-sIgE test may be an attractive alternative method to identify specific allergens, which is rapid and easy to perform in clinical practice (4). In the present study, the prevalence and distribution characteristics of sensitization to various allergens among patients with urticaria were investigated.

Patients and methods

Patients

Chinese Han patients (n=1,091) with urticaria who were treated at the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University (Zhengzhou, China) between October 2013 and February 2018 were enrolled in the present study. All patients resided in Henan Province (China). The cohort included 474 males (43.4%) and 617 females (56.6%) and the mean age was 29.59±15.93 years (range, 0–95 years). Patients with symptoms lasting ≤6 weeks were diagnosed with AU and if the duration was >6 weeks, patients were assigned to the CU group. All of these patients were clinically evaluated by their attending physicians and only patients with single disease (urticaria) were included. Patients were excluded if they were diagnosed with any other allergic diseases or malignancy, or were pregnant or lactating. Furthermore, patients who ever took immunosuppressants or other drugs within two weeks previously were also excluded. Each patient with urticaria was carefully checked according to the above criteria by JP and JY, who are laboratory physicians at our department. The present study was a retrospective study. Written informed consent was obtained from the patients or their legal guardians and the present study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University (Zhengzhou, China).

AllergyScreen test

Serum allergen-sIgE of patients was detected by using an AllergyScreen test (cat. no. A182; Mediwiss Analytic GmbH). An immunoblot assay was used to semi-quantitatively detect circulating sIgE according to the manufacturer's protocol.

The results were semi-quantified and categorized into seven levels according to the manufacturer's protocol and a previous study by our group (5): Class 0 (<0.35 IU/ml, undetectable), class 1 (0.35–0.70 IU/ml, low), class 2 (0.70–3.50 IU/ml, intermediate), class 3 (3.5–17.5 IU/ml, high), class 4 (17.5–50 IU/ml, very high), class 5 (50–100 IU/ml, quite high) and class 6 (>100 IU/ml, extremely high). The cut-off value was set as 0.35 IU/ml and sIgE ≥0.35 IU/ml was considered positive.

A total of 10 inhaled allergens and 9 food allergens were tested in all of the 1,091 patients. Inhaled allergens included D. pteronyssinus, house dust, mulberry, dog hair, cat dander, cockroach, amaranth, mold mix, grass mix and tree pollen mix. Food allergens included egg, cow's milk, shrimp, beef, cowry, crab, mango, cashew nut and pineapple.

Statistical analysis

Data were classified and analyzed by using SPSS version 19.0 (IBM Corp.). Demographic features (age, sex) and urticaria status were considered as categorical variables. Differences among variables were evaluated by the χ2 test or Fisher's exact probability method. Odds ratios were determined to analyze the difference in positive rates between different disease types and genders. P<0.05 was considered to indicate statistical significance.

Results

Overall sensitization to inhaled and food allergens

Of all of the 1,091 patients, 524 (48.0%) tested positive for sIgE to at least one of 19 allergens. D. pteronyssinus (n=376, 34.5%), cockroach (n=136, 12.5%) and tree pollen mix (n=122, 11.1%) were the top three inhaled allergens, while cashew nut (n=88, 8.1%), shrimp (n=74, 6.8%) and crab (n=70, 6.4%) were the food allergens for which the patients most frequently tested positive (Table I). Furthermore, the patients' sIgE-positive rate for a single allergen was 22.1%, while it was 25.9% regarding positivity for multiple allergens (Table SI).

Table I.

Overall allergen sensitization to inhaled and food allergens.

A, Inhaled allergens
Allergens	Patients (N)	Positive rate (%)
D. pteronyssinus	376	34.5
House dust	74	6.8
Mulberry	92	8.4
Cat dander	15	1.4
Dog hair	29	2.7
Cockroach	136	12.5
Amaranth	85	7.8
Mold mix	70	6.4
Grass mix	103	9.5
Tree pollen mix	122	11.1
B, Food allergens
Allergens	Patients (N)	Positive rate (%)
Egg	4	0.3
Cow's milk	22	2.0
Shrimp	74	6.8
Beef	11	1.0
Cowry	0	0
Crab	70	6.4
Mango	59	5.4
Cashew nut	88	8.1
Pineapple	26	2.4

Comparison of allergen sensitization in different urticaria groups

The total cohort of 1,091 cases comprised 818 patients with CU (75.0%; mean age, 32.41±15.98 years; age range, 3–95 years) and 273 with AU (25.0%; mean age, 24.10±15.16; age range, 0–83 years). Among the inhaled allergens, positivity for sIgE to D. pteronyssinus, dog hair, cockroach, mold mix and tree pollen mix was more common in patients with CU than in those with AU (37.4 vs. 25.7%, P<0.001; 3.6 vs. 0.0%, P<0.001; 15.3 vs. 4.1%, P<0.001; 7.7 vs. 2.7%, P=0.002; 12.6 vs. 6.8%, P=0.005, respectively). Similarly, regarding the food allergens, positivity for sIgE to shrimp was more frequent among patients with CU than in those with AU (7.7 vs. 4.1%, P=0.037; Table II).

Table II.

Comparison of allergen sensitization in different urticaria groups.

Allergen	CU (N=818)	AU (N=273)	P-value	OR (95%CI)
D. pteronyssinus	306 (37.4)	70 (25.7)	<0.001	1.733 (1.276–2.355)
House dust	55 (6.8)	18 (6.8)	1.000	1.021 (0.589–1.771)
Mulberry	74 (9.0)	18 (6.8)	0.257	1.409 (0.826–2.404)
Cat dander	7 (0.9)	7 (2.7)	0.055	0.328 (0.114–0.944)
Dog hair	29 (3.6)	0 (0)	<0.001	–
Cockroach	125 (15.3)	11 (4.1)	<0.001	4.296 (2.282–8.087)
Amaranth	70 (8.6)	15 (5.4)	0.118	1.610 (0.905–2.861)
Mold mix	63 (7.7)	7 (2.7)	0.002	3.171 (1.434–7.010)
Grass mix	74 (9.0)	30 (10.8)	0.343	0.806 (0.515–1.261)
Tree pollen mix	103 (12.6)	18 (6.8)	0.005	2.041 (1.212–3.435)
Egg	4 (0.5)	0 (0)	0.577	–
Cow's milk	15 (1.8)	7 (2.7)	0.459	0.710 (0.286–1.760)
Shrimp	63 (7.7)	11 (4.1)	0.037	1.987 (1.032–3.829)
Beef	7 (0.9)	4 (1.4)	0.482	0.580 (0.169–1.998)
Cowry	0 (0)	0 (0.0)	–	–
Crab	59 (7.2)	11 (4.1)	0.065	1.851 (0.958–3.578)
Mango	48 (5.9)	11 (4.1)	0.282	1.485 (0.760–2.902)
Cashew nut	66 (8.1)	22 (8.1)	1.000	1.001 (0.605–1.656)
Pineapple	22 (2.7)	4 (1.4)	0.359	1.859 (0.635–5.442)

Values are expressed as n (%). AU, acute urticaria; CU, chronic urticaria; OR, odds ratio.

Comparison of allergen sensitization among different gender groups

Significant differences in allergen sensitization were observed between the male and female groups of the present cohort (χ2=9.597, P<0.01). The overall sIgE-positive rate was higher in males than in females (53.4 vs. 43.9%, P<0.01; Table SII). The prevalence of sensitization to 10 allergens (D. pteronyssinus, mulberry, dog hair, cockroach, amaranth, tree pollen mix, cow's milk, cowry, crab and cashew nut) exhibited significant gender-specific differences and the positive rates were higher in males than in females (Fig. 1).

Figure 1.

Allergen sensitization in different gender groups. *P<0.05; **P<0.01.

Comparison of allergen sensitization in different age groups

In the present study, individuals were divided into seven age groups: 0–3 years, 4–12 years, 13–18 years, 19–25 years, 26–40 years, 41–60 years and >60 years. There were no obvious age-specific differences in the sIgE-positive rates for the allergens of house dust, mulberry, tree mix, shrimp, beef, cowry and pineapple, but the positive rates for the other 12 allergens were significantly different (Table SIII). The positive rates of sIgE for D. pteronyssinus, cockroach and grass mix peaked in the 19–25 year-old group (41.0, 18.5 and 12.7%, respectively), as well as the rate for mulberry peaked in the 26–40 year-old group. The positive rate of sIgE for amaranth increased with age and plateaued from 19–25 to 41–60 year-old group. sIgE-positive rates remained at a relatively high level with further increases in age. The sIgE-positive rates for cat dander and dog hair exhibited a steady decline with age and were higher in the 0–3 year-old group than in all of the other age groups (14.8 and 18.5%, respectively), while the rate for mold mix exhibited a constant increase and reached 20.0% in the >60 year-old group (Fig. 2).

Figure 2.

Sensitization to inhaled allergens in individuals of different age groups. Total number of cases in each age group: 0–3 years (n=54), 4–12 years (n=150), 13–18 years (n=103), 19–25 years (n=173), 26–40 years (n=338), 41–60 years (n=233) and >60 years (n=40).

With regard to food allergens, the sIgE-positive rates to egg and cow's milk were highest in the 0–3 year-old group (7.4 and 31.5%, respectively). The rates of allergy to crab and cashew nut increased with age, but the difference was that the rate for crab peaked in the 19–25 year-old group (9.8%), while the rate for cashew nut reached a high level at 19–25 years and subsequently remained there (Table SIII).

Comparison of degree of sIgE positivity for various allergens

According to the grading, positivity for the 19 allergens was classified into 7 levels according to extent of positivity. The results indicated that the degree of sIgE positivity for most allergens was mainly at an ‘Intermediate’ or ‘High’ level, while that for certain food allergens (cow's milk and beef) was at a ‘Low’ level. As for cowry, there was an equivalent amount of ‘High’- and ‘Low’-level cases, but the overall positive rate was relatively low (Fig. 3).

Figure 3.

Comparison of the degree of allergic reactions to inhaled and food allergens in patients with urticaria: Class 0 (<0.35 IU/ml, undetectable), class 1 (0.35–0.70 IU/ml, low), class 2 (0.70–3.50 IU/ml, intermediate), class 3 (3.5–17.5 IU/ml, high), class 4 (17.5–50 IU/ml, very high), class 5 (50–100 IU/ml, quite high), class 6 (>100 IU/ml, extremely high).

Discussion

Urticaria, a common skin disorder, is a member of the group of severe allergic diseases, which may not only cause a decline in the quality of life of affected individuals, but also in their performance at work and school (1). Symptomatic treatment, including anti-histamines, is currently the most frequently used form of management, but after discontinuation of medications a rapid relapse of symptoms commonly occurs (1). Therefore, identification of the responsible allergens prevalent in a particular region may facilitate early diagnosis and the development of strategies to prevent this disease. In the present study, the prevalence of allergen sensitization in recent years in Henan province, where no allergen profile of patients with urticaria has been reported to date, to the best of our knowledge, was investigated.

The present results indicated that 48.0% (524) of the subjects were sIgE-positive to at least one of the 19 allergens tested, which was comparable with the rates in central China (42.9%) (6), Italy (41%) (7) and northern China (52.4%) (8). These results indicated that only half of the patients with urticaria had contact sensitization. However, at present, there isn't any one biomarker with sufficient ability to reflect urticaria. As urticaria is a heterogeneous disease, other reliable indicators, including histamine and cytokines, are helpful to indicate the patients' condition in association with allergens and may be added to support a diagnosis of urticaria in the future. Compared with food allergens, inhaled allergens were the major components in patients with urticaria (the positive rate ranged from 1.4 to 34.5% vs. 0 to 8.1%). In China, the majority of patients with urticaria choose to, or rather they are instructed by their physicians, to eliminate certain foods from their diet without undergoing any further diagnostic procedures. The present results suggested that the contribution of food allergens to urticaria was limited. This was similar to the results of a study by Hsu and Li (9), which indicated that food avoidance is common among patients with CU in China but was revealed to be mostly ineffective, and part of the reason is that allergic disorders in adults generally involve environmental factors through the respiratory tract rather than through food. Furthermore, according to the present data, sensitivity to multiple allergens was more common than that to a single allergen, indicating that sensitization to multiple allergens is common in urticaria. As is known, excessive accumulation of seasonal and perennial allergens above the clinical relevance threshold may give rise to symptoms of allergy (10). It is necessary to develop comprehensive plans to avoid allergens and help patients remain below the clinical relevance threshold. Of note, although sIgE-positivity for certain allergens is likely to be a reaction from other allergic diseases, including rhinitis and asthma, patients were excluded if they were diagnosed with any other allergic diseases in the present study. Patients with known sIgE positivity avoiding those specific allergens may reduce the incidence of urticaria, as previously reported by Chen et al (11).

The present results indicated that of the 19 allergens tested, patients reacted most frequently to the inhaled allergen D. pteronyssinus, cockroach and tree pollen mix, which is similar to the results of a previous study on urticaria (8) or studies on other allergic diseases (12–14). However, cashew nut, shrimp and crab were identified to be the most common food allergens in Henan province, which was inconsistent with a previous study (8), whose results suggested that egg and cow's milk were the most frequent food allergens with positivity in northern China, but the prevalence of them was similar to commonly reported allergens worldwide (15). It is known that the climate determines the types of flora and fauna in a particular geographical area, which may affect airborne and food allergens (16). Henan is a province in the center of China characterized by a high population density and dry weather conditions, providing a relatively suitable environment for dust mite and cockroach. Moreover, the imbalanced economic development and sanitation in Henan may also have played a part. Zhengzhou, the capital of Henan Province, is commonly referred to as a ‘green city’ due to its environment with plenty of vegetation. This may explain the common sensitivity to tree pollen mix allergen. Furthermore, with the development of economy and transportation in this region in recent years, access to seafood, including shrimp and crab, has increased, which explains for the inconsistent results between the present study and traditional food allergens in northern China. However, as the tested allergen sources were not identical to those of/among previous studies, it was not possible to directly compare them. Of note, the present study indicated that positive reactions to several allergens, including D. pteronyssinus, dog hair, cockroach, mold mix, tree pollen mix and shrimp were more frequent in the CU group than in the AU group, suggesting that sensitization to allergens, particularly inhaled ones, had a crucial role in the relapse and duration of urticaria.

Among the 1,091 patients with urticaria, a difference in the sensitization to certain allergens was observed between males and females. The positive rates to 10 allergens (D. pteronyssinus, mulberry, dog hair, cockroach, amaranth, tree pollen mix, cow's milk, cowry, crab and cashew nut) were higher in males than in females. This phenomenon has been reported in several previous studies (6,17,18), but the reacting allergen types between genders were inconsistent. This may be due to different rates of contact to allergens and the difference in immune sensitivity between males and females.

In addition, certain allergens were reported to be associated with age (19,20). The rates of sIgE positivity for six allergens (D. pteronyssinus, mulberry, cockroach, amaranth, grass mix and crab) were low in the younger groups. Subsequently, they increased with age and peaked or plateaued in the 19–25-year-old group followed by a modest decline (the rate for mulberry peaked in the 26–40 year-old group), but they still remained at a relatively high level in the highest age group. For cat dander, dog hair, egg and cow's milk, the positive rates were the highest in the 0–3-year-old group and declined with age. These results were similar to those of previous studies (21–23). Regarding the high sensitization to cat dander and dog hair, one explanation may be that children are more likely to be in close contact with pets whilst playing with them or tend to crawl on the ground where pet hair/dander may accumulate (24). Furthermore, cow's milk and eggs have been reported to be the primary food allergens in children worldwide, including China. It has been indicated that avoidance of pets and breastfeeding in infants and young children were effective to prevent urticaria (25). As for whether any genetic predisposition or hormone secretion has a role in these pathological processes, further research is required in the future.

Furthermore, the present study indicated that the degree of positivity for most allergens was mainly at an ‘Intermediate’ or ‘High’ level in positive cases, indicating that the intensity of sensitization to these allergens was obvious but not extremely high in patients with urticaria. As, hypersensitivity occupied an important position in the pathological process of urticaria (7,26), it is necessary for patients in this area to identify and avoid major allergens in order to remain below the clinical relevance threshold.

The prevalence and distribution of allergens among patients with urticaria revealed by the present study provided information that may be utilized for the prevention, diagnosis and management of urticaria in Henan province. For instance, although the scoring system dividing the intensity of the positivity of sIgE into seven levels has been widely used in clinical research for allergic diseases (5,12), based on the allergen distribution data of the present study, a novel scoring system may be proposed to assist the diagnosis of urticaria, integrating the clinical symptoms of patients with urticaria, as well as histamine, cytokines and other reliable indicators with the consultation of dermatologists. However, further comprehensive, in-depth and multi-center research is still required.

Of note, the present study had certain limitations. First, the tests included a variety of allergens in the environment but the reactivity to only 19 allergens was assessed in the present study. Furthermore, the difference in tested allergen sources limits the comparability with other studies (27). In addition, due to the heterogeneity of urticaria, only part of the cases featured IgE production and type I hypersensitivity (26,28). Further studies are required to explore the pathogenic mechanism of urticaria. Furthermore, healthy controls are not included and there may be bias associated with patient selection due to the retrospective nature of the present study and the severity of this disease cannot be assessed with allergen distribution patterns in detail. Furthermore, patients with urticaria are no longer tested for allergen sensitization after treatment in clinical practice at our hospital, and whether the dynamic changes of the allergen distribution patterns reflect the treatment response still requires to be investigated in further studies.

In conclusion, the prevalence and distribution of several allergens among patients with urticaria in Henan province exhibited differences in terms of gender, age and type of urticaria (CU or AU). The characteristics of allergen sensitization revealed in the present study may facilitate the prevention, diagnosis and management of urticaria in this area, particularly in terms of allergen avoidance management for this disease.