Trisha Petitte1, Allison Nichols2, Georgia Narsavage1. 1. School of Nursing, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA. 2. Extension Service, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: West Virginia (WV) residents have often rejected participation in community-based cancer research studies. Nationally, 49% of eligible patients participate in clinical trials but less than 10% of patients in WV participate. OBJECTIVE: To understand issues related to recruitment and retention of patients for cancer research in Appalachian WV. METHODS: Data were obtained from 3 focus groups including: (1) 9 patients who participated in clinical cancer trials, (2) 8 cancer research nurse coordinators, and (3) 10 physicians involved in cancer research. Groups were audio-taped and transcriptions were analyzed using MAXQDA and results were verified by two co-investigators. RESULTS: Most enablers and barriers identified were cultural as indicated by 72% of patients; 68% nurse coordinators; and 55% physicians. Patients identified personal emotional strength as an enabler, and negative health behaviors and fears as barriers. Enablers that nurses identified were positive patient characteristics and barriers included fear of trials, randomization, and death. Physicians identified enablers as a patient's understanding of the clinical trial and motivation to help others and the inverse of these two enablers as barriers. CONCLUSION: A foundation for improving recruitment and retention of participants in cancer research in Appalachia was identified. The next step will involve cancer community organizations and patients in developing a plan to enhance enablers and overcome barriers to patient recruitment in cancer studies. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Cultural influences must be considered when recruiting for clinical trials. Community organizations educating the public about cancer research may be the key to enhancing patient enrollment.
BACKGROUND: West Virginia (WV) residents have often rejected participation in community-based cancer research studies. Nationally, 49% of eligible patients participate in clinical trials but less than 10% of patients in WV participate. OBJECTIVE: To understand issues related to recruitment and retention of patients for cancer research in Appalachian WV. METHODS: Data were obtained from 3 focus groups including: (1) 9 patients who participated in clinical cancer trials, (2) 8 cancer research nurse coordinators, and (3) 10 physicians involved in cancer research. Groups were audio-taped and transcriptions were analyzed using MAXQDA and results were verified by two co-investigators. RESULTS: Most enablers and barriers identified were cultural as indicated by 72% of patients; 68% nurse coordinators; and 55% physicians. Patients identified personal emotional strength as an enabler, and negative health behaviors and fears as barriers. Enablers that nurses identified were positive patient characteristics and barriers included fear of trials, randomization, and death. Physicians identified enablers as a patient's understanding of the clinical trial and motivation to help others and the inverse of these two enablers as barriers. CONCLUSION: A foundation for improving recruitment and retention of participants in cancer research in Appalachia was identified. The next step will involve cancer community organizations and patients in developing a plan to enhance enablers and overcome barriers to patient recruitment in cancer studies. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Cultural influences must be considered when recruiting for clinical trials. Community organizations educating the public about cancer research may be the key to enhancing patient enrollment.
Authors: Electra D Paskett; James L Fisher; Eugene J Lengerich; Nancy E Schoenberg; Stephenie K Kennedy; Mary Ellen Conn; Karen A Roberto; Sharon K Dwyer; Darla Fickle; Mark Dignan Journal: Oncologist Date: 2011
Authors: C J Peddle-McIntyre; M K Baker; Y C G Lee; D A Galvão; P Cormie; V Graham; R U Newton Journal: Eur J Cancer Care (Engl) Date: 2017-06-09 Impact factor: 2.520
Authors: Eugene J Lengerich; Stephen W Wyatt; Angel Rubio; Joyce E Beaulieu; Cathy A Coyne; Linda Fleisher; Ann J Ward; Pamela K Brown Journal: J Rural Health Date: 2004 Impact factor: 4.333
Authors: Trisha M Petitte; Georgia L Narsavage; Yea-Jyh Chen; Charles Coole; Tara Forth; Kevin D Frick Journal: Oncol Nurs Forum Date: 2014-03-01 Impact factor: 2.172
Authors: Neal J Meropol; Kevin P Weinfurt; Caroline B Burnett; Andrew Balshem; Al B Benson; Liana Castel; Sandra Corbett; Michael Diefenbach; Darrell Gaskin; Yun Li; Sharon Manne; John Marshall; Julia H Rowland; Elyse Slater; Daniel P Sulmasy; David Van Echo; Shakira Washington; Kevin A Schulman Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2003-07-01 Impact factor: 44.544