Simultaneous engineering of electron and phonon transport through nanoscale molecular junctions is fundamental to the development of high-performance thermoelectric materials for the conversion of waste heat into electricity and cooling. Here, we demonstrate a systematic improvement of the room-temperature thermoelectric figure of merit (ZT) of molecular junctions. This is achieved by phonon interference (PI)-suppressed thermal conductance and quantum interference-enhanced electrical conductance and Seebeck coefficient. This strategy leads to a significant enhancement of ZT from low values ca. 10-6 in oligo(phenylene-ethynylene) (OPE2) to the record values of 2.4 in dinitro-functionalized OPE2 (DOPE2). The dinitro functionalization also considerably enhances ZT of biphenyl-dithiol (BDT) and bipyridyl molecular junctions. Remarkably, the energy levels of electron-withdrawing nitro groups are hardly changed from one molecule to the other. Because of this generic feature, a resonance transport in the vicinity of Fermi energy of electrodes is formed leading to a significant improvement of Seebeck coefficient and ZT of all derivatives. For example, the Seebeck coefficient enhances from 10.8 μV/K in BDT to -470 μV/K in dinitro-BDT (DBDT). In addition, destructive PI due to the nitro groups suppresses phonon thermal conductance, for example, from 20 pW/K in BDT to 11 pW/K in DBDT at room temperature. We also demonstrate that quantum and PI-enhanced single-molecule thermoelectric efficiency is conserved when parallel molecules are placed between gold electrodes. These results promise to remove the key roadblocks and open new avenues to exploit functionalized organic molecules for thermoelectric energy harvesting and cooling.
Simultaneous engineering of electron and phonon transport through nanoscale molecular junctions is fundamental to the development of high-performance thermoelectric materials for the conversion of waste heat into electricity and cooling. Here, we demonstrate a systematic improvement of the room-temperature thermoelectric figure of merit (ZT) of molecular junctions. This is achieved by phonon interference (PI)-suppressed thermal conductance and quantum interference-enhanced electrical conductance and Seebeck coefficient. This strategy leads to a significant enhancement of ZT from low values ca. 10-6 in oligo(phenylene-ethynylene) (OPE2) to the record values of 2.4 in dinitro-functionalized OPE2 (DOPE2). The dinitro functionalization also considerably enhances ZT of biphenyl-dithiol (BDT) and bipyridyl molecular junctions. Remarkably, the energy levels of electron-withdrawing nitro groups are hardly changed from one molecule to the other. Because of this generic feature, a resonance transport in the vicinity of Fermi energy of electrodes is formed leading to a significant improvement of Seebeck coefficient and ZT of all derivatives. For example, the Seebeck coefficient enhances from 10.8 μV/K in BDT to -470 μV/K in dinitro-BDT (DBDT). In addition, destructive PI due to the nitro groups suppresses phonon thermal conductance, for example, from 20 pW/K in BDT to 11 pW/K in DBDT at room temperature. We also demonstrate that quantum and PI-enhanced single-molecule thermoelectric efficiency is conserved when parallel molecules are placed between gold electrodes. These results promise to remove the key roadblocks and open new avenues to exploit functionalized organic molecules for thermoelectric energy harvesting and cooling.
Currently nearly 10%
of the world’s electricity is used
by computers and the internet. This is expected to double over the
next decade. Most of this energy is converted to heat. This waste
heat could be used to generate electricity economically, provided
materials with a high thermoelectric efficiency could be identified.[1] Conversely, efficient Peltier cooling using such
materials would have applications to on-chip cooling of CMOS-based
devices.[1] The demand for new thermoelectric
materials has led to a worldwide race to develop materials with a
high thermoelectric efficiency.[2] The efficiency
of a thermoelectric device for power generation is characterized by
the dimensionless figure of merit[3]ZT = GS2T/κ,
where G is the electrical conductance, S is the Seebeck coefficient (thermopower), T is
temperature, and κ = κel + κph is the thermal conductance[4] due to electrons
κel and phonons κph. Therefore,
low-κ, high-G, and high-S materials
are needed for efficient conversion of heat into electricity. However,
the interdependency of transport coefficients constrains the options
for materials design and makes optimization a difficult task.Despite several decades of development, the world record for ZT is only slightly above 2 at 900 K[5] and close to unity at room temperature,[6] which is not sufficient to create a viable technology platform.
At the level of fundamental science, it was demonstrated recently
that molecular wires can mediate long-range phase-coherent tunneling
with remarkably low attenuation over sub-nanometer distances even
at room temperature.[7] This creates the
possibility of using quantum interference (QI) in single- or few-molecular
junctions[8−11] to engineer enhancement of thermoelectricity in molecular materials[12,13] and design new high-performance organic materials.[14−16] The aim of this paper is to demonstrate that room-temperature QI
(RTQI) of electrons can be employed to obtain high-G, high-S materials, and simultaneously room-temperature
phonon interference (RTPI) can be used to suppress phonon thermal
transport.In this paper, we systematically characterize thermoelectric
properties
of biphenyl-dithiol (BDT), oligo(2-phenylene ethynylene) (OPE2) and
bipyridine (BP)-based single molecule junctions. BDT, OPE2, and BP
derivatives are placed between two hot and cold gold electrodes (Figure a; see Figure S1
of the Supporting Information for the optimized
geometry of these molecules). BDT, OPE2, and BP molecules are ideal
choices because they can be functionalized.[2,17−19] In addition, the electrical conductance and Seebeck
coefficient measurement of parent BDT[20−22] and BP[23,24] molecules can be used for benchmarking. In what follows, our aim
is to demonstrate for the first time that the thermoelectric efficiency
of parent BDT, OPE2, and BP molecules is enhanced significantly by
a systematic functionalization of their molecular structure.
Figure 1
Thermoelectric
molecular junction. (a) Molecular junction consists
of bipyridine molecule between hot top and cold bottom electrodes.
Molecular structure of (b) biphenyl-4,4′-dithiol BDT (c) 2,2′-dinitro-biphenyl-4,4′-dithiol
DBDT (d) oligo(2-phenylene-4,4′-ethynylene)-dithiol OPE2, (e)
2,2′-dinitro-oligo(2-phenylene-4,4′-ethynylene)-dithiol
DOPE2, (f) 4,4′-bipyridyl BP, (g) 3,3′,5,5′-tetrachloride-BP
TBP and (h) 3,3′-dinitro-BP DBP. These molecules are viable
synthetic target.
Thermoelectric
molecular junction. (a) Molecular junction consists
of bipyridine molecule between hot top and cold bottom electrodes.
Molecular structure of (b) biphenyl-4,4′-dithiol BDT (c) 2,2′-dinitro-biphenyl-4,4′-dithiol
DBDT (d) oligo(2-phenylene-4,4′-ethynylene)-dithiol OPE2, (e)
2,2′-dinitro-oligo(2-phenylene-4,4′-ethynylene)-dithiol
DOPE2, (f) 4,4′-bipyridylBP, (g) 3,3′,5,5′-tetrachloride-BP
TBP and (h) 3,3′-dinitro-BP DBP. These molecules are viable
synthetic target.We show that by introducing
nitro (NO2) side groups
to BDT to form 2,2′-dinitro-BDT (DBDT), both Seebeck coefficient,
and conductance enhance significantly. This is because electron-withdrawing
nitro side groups form a resonance transport in the vicinity of Fermi
energy of the electrode and in the gap of parent BDT. In addition,
the thermal conductance due to phonons decreases considerably in the
presence of nitro groups. Simultaneous RTQI enhancement of G and S and RTPI suppression of κph lead to a high ZT. We also demonstrate
that formation of resonance transport close to Fermi energy is a generic
feature of molecules functionalized with nitro groups as evident in
three different backbones, BDT, OPE2, and BP. Remarkably, the energy
levels of nitro groups are hardly changed from one molecule to the
other. This generic effect leads to a larger enhancement of thermoelectric
efficiency in the vicinity of Fermi energy for molecules in which
the electron transport is mainly through the highest occupied molecular
orbital (HOMO). Nitro side groups enhance room temperature ZT of OPE2-dithiol molecular junctions from 4 × 10–6 to record values of 1.55 and 2.4. Chlorine side groups
strongly suppress phonon transport through BP and enhance ZT. Furthermore, we show that RTQI and RTPI enhanced thermoelectricity
is conserved when multiple parallel molecules are placed between electrodes.
These results are significant because they open new avenues to exploit
functionalized organic molecules for thermoelectric energy harvesting
and cooling.
Results and Discussion
From optimized
geometry of the junctions, we obtain material-specific
mean-field Hamiltonians using density functional theory (DFT). We
then combine the obtained Hamiltonians with our transport code Gollum,[3,25] to calculate transmission coefficient Tel(E) for electrons traversing from the hot electrode
to the cold one (Figure a) through the molecules (see the Computational
Methods section). Tel(E) is combined with Laundauer formula to obtain the electrical conductance.
In the low temperatures, the conductance G = G0Tel(EF) where G0 is quantum conductance
and EF is the Fermi energy of electrodes.
At room temperature, the conductance is obtained by thermal averaging
of transmission coefficient weighted by the Fermi function (see the Computational Methods section).Figure a shows
the transmission coefficient of BDT derivatives. Transport through
the biphenyl-4,4′-dithiol (BDT) molecule is mainly through
the HOMO in agreement with the previous reports.[20−22] The measured
conductance of parent BDT[22,26] is in the range of
3 to 7.5 × 10–3G0 in agreement with our calculation shown in Figure a for a wide range of energy around DFT Fermi
energy (EF = 0). The electronic thermal
conductance κel and Seebeck coefficient S can also be calculated from Tel(E) (see the Computational Methods section). Figure b,c shows κel and S for a range
of energies around the DFT Fermi energy at room temperature. At EF = 0, we obtain S = 10.8 μV/K
and κel = 2.3 pW/K for BDT. Our calculated S is in agreement with measured values of 8.35 ± 0.23
μV/K.[22]
Figure 2
Electronic properties
of the BDT-based molecular junctions. (a)
Electron transmission coefficient vs energy, (b) room temperature
electronic thermal conductance and (c) Seebeck coefficient vs Fermi
energy of BDT and DBDT. Inset of (a) shows the local density of states
on the DBDT for the energy range marked by gray color in (a) which
includes the resonance.
Electronic properties
of the BDT-based molecular junctions. (a)
Electron transmission coefficient vs energy, (b) room temperature
electronic thermal conductance and (c) Seebeck coefficient vs Fermi
energy of BDT and DBDT. Inset of (a) shows the local density of states
on the DBDT for the energy range marked by gray color in (a) which
includes the resonance.While experimental methods for measuring S of
a single molecule using scanning-probe techniques are now rather well
established, no such method exists for determining ZT of a single molecule because of difficulties in measuring the thermal
conductance.[27,28] However, using material-specific
ab initio calculation, we can calculate the phonon transmission coefficient Tph(h̵ω) of phonons
with energy h̵ω traversing from one electrode
to the other. Using Laundauer-like formula, the thermal conductance
due to phonons (κph) is obtained from Tph(h̵ω) (see the Computational Methods section). Figure a,b show the phonon transmission
coefficient Tph(h̵ω) and corresponding κph for BDT molecule.
We predict κph = 19.6 pW/K for BDT molecular junction
which is 5 times higher than room temperature κel. This means that the thermal conductance is dominated by phonons
in this junction. A low S and high κ in BDT,
leads to a low-room temperature ZT = 5 × 10–4 (Figure c) at the Fermi energy. In what follows, we demonstrate that
high values of ZT can be obtained in nitro-functionalized
BDT (DBDT) which is driven by RTQI and RTPI effects.
Figure 3
Phononic properties of
the BDT-based molecular junctions and thermoelectric
figure of merit. (a) Phonon transmission coefficient vs energy and
LUMO states of BDT and DBDT, (b) phononic thermal conductance vs temperature
and (c) room temperature ZT vs Fermi energy of BDT,
and DBDT.
Phononic properties of
the BDT-based molecular junctions and thermoelectric
figure of merit. (a) Phonon transmission coefficient vs energy and
LUMO states of BDT and DBDT, (b) phononic thermal conductance vs temperature
and (c) room temperature ZT vs Fermi energy of BDT,
and DBDT.The molecular structure of DBDT
is shown in Figure c where two hydrogen atoms in BDT are replaced
by two NO2 groups. The electronic transmission coefficient
is shown in Figure a. The amplitude of Tel(E) decreases except around the Fermi energy where a resonance is formed.
Local density of state calculations (inset of Figure a) for energy range around the resonance
(marked by the gray region in Figures a and S2a of the Supporting Information) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of gas phase BDT
and DBDT (Figure S2a and Table S2 of the Supporting Information) confirms that this resonance is due to the localized
states on NO2 groups. Because of the interference[3] between transmitted wave through the backbone
and reflected wave by nitro groups, a Fano resonance is formed. On
one hand, because of the steric hindrance of nitro side groups, the
two benzene rings are rotated and form an angle of 77.8°. This
reduces the overlap between p orbitals[29] and decreases the conductance for a wide range of energies in DBDT
compared to parent BDT (Figure a). On the other hand, because of the resonance close to the
Fermi energy, the conductance increases in DBDT compared to parent
BDT around EF. In addition, S is improved significantly to ca. −470 μV/K in DBDT
compared to that of parent BDT (S = 10.8 μV/K).
This is due to a high slope of transmission coefficient close to this
resonance (Figure c). S is proportional to the slope of natural logarithm
of the transmission coefficient Tel(E) evaluated at the Fermi energy (S ∝
∂ln T(E)/∂E at E = EF).[3]Furthermore, by introducing
NO2 side groups to BDT, Tph(h̵ω) suppresses
in DBDT (Figure a)
and κph decreases strongly (Figure b). Just like a guitar string where waves
with certain frequencies are suppressed by pressing the string, introducing
a heavy side group suppresses phonons with given frequencies. The
side groups with higher mass supress lower frequency modes. Our calculation
shows that the room-temperature thermal conductance of DBDT (κph = 11.7 pW/K) is about two times lower than that of parent
DBT. QI-mediated high-G and high-S is combined with the PI-mediated suppression of κ to yield
a significant improvement of ZT from ca. 10–4 in parent DBT to ca. 0.55 in DBDT in the vicinity of the Fermi energy
(Figure c).To demonstrate that enhancement of ZT due to the
nitro side groups is independent of the molecular backbone, we study
thermoelectric properties of OPE2 derivatives (Figures d,e and 5a–d). Figure a shows the electron
transmission coefficient through OPE2 and its nitro-functionalized
derivative DOPE2. The electrical conductance of OPE2 single-molecule
junction is about 0.6 × 10–3 (Figure a) at the DFT Fermi energy
in agreement with the reported experimental values.[30] OPE2 is a fully conjugated molecule and its ground-state
structure is planar. Unlike DBDT, where the two benzene rings were
rotated because of the steric hindrance of two close NO2 groups, DOPE2 remains planar because the rings are separated by
ethynylene groups and are far from each other. Therefore, the conductance
reduction in DBDT is not present in DOPE2 (see Figure S14 of the Supporting Information).
Figure 5
OPE2 derivatives. OPE2 with different side groups (a) NO2 in meta position, (b) CN, (c) CF3, (d) NH2. (e) Electron transmission coefficient for OPE2 derivatives between
two gold electrodes.
Figure 4
Thermoelectric properties
of the OPE2-based molecular junctions.
(a) Electron transmission coefficient vs energy, room temperature,
(b) frontier orbitals of OPE2 and DOPE2. Seebeck coefficient S (c) and total thermoelectric figure of merit ZT (d) vs Fermi energy of OPE2 and DOPE2.
Thermoelectric properties
of the OPE2-based molecular junctions.
(a) Electron transmission coefficient vs energy, room temperature,
(b) frontier orbitals of OPE2 and DOPE2. Seebeck coefficient S (c) and total thermoelectric figure of merit ZT (d) vs Fermi energy of OPE2 and DOPE2.By nitro functionalization, two new states are formed in
the HOMO–LUMO
gap of the parent OPE2 (Figure b) which are mainly localized on the nitro groups. Consequently,
two new resonances in Tel(E) of DOPE2 are formed in the HOMO–LUMO gap of the parent OPE2
(Figure a). The local
density of state calculation in the vicinity of these resonances (Figure
S3 of the Supporting Information) also
confirms that these resonances are due to nitro groups. The new LUMO
resonance close to the DFT Fermi energy leads to a simultaneous enhancement
of G and S. Electrical conductance
increases from ca. 0.6 × 10–3 in OPE2 to ca.
10–2 in DOPE2 (Figure a). S also increases from
ca. 6 μV/K in OPE2 to ca. −180 μV/K in DOPE2 (Figure b). Phonon transmission
through DOPE2 is suppressed for lower frequencies because of nitro
groups (Figure S5a of the Supporting Information) but it increases for higher energy phonons. Therefore, κph of OPE2 (9.9 pW/K) and DOPE2 (9.7 pW/K) remains almost the
same (Figure S5 of the Supporting Information). High-G and high-S in DOPE2 lead
to a significant enhancement of the full ZT from
5 × 10–6 in OPE2 to a record value of 1.55
in DOPE2 at room temperature (Figure c). This is even increased further to 2.4 by a few
meV shift of EF.To understand the
effect of nitro group on electron transport,
we note that the transmission coefficient through a one-level system
with energy ε0 in the presence of a pendent group
with energy εp between two 1D leads (Figure S9 of
the Supporting Information) is obtained
from Breit–Wigner formula:[3]Tel(E) = 4ΓLΓR/((E – εn)2 + (ΓL + ΓR)2) where εn = ε0 – σ
+ a2/(E – εp), ΓL,R are tunnel rates and λ is the
eigen energy of the molecular orbital shifted slightly by an amount
σ because of the coupling of the orbital to the electrodes.
If an electron resonates with the molecular orbital (E = εn), electron transmission is a maximum, whereas
electron transmission is destroyed at E = εp. This antiresonance at E = εp followed by a resonance at E = εn called Fano resonance. The width of Fano resonance is proportional
to the coupling between the orbital and the pendent group. The energy
of nitro groups are close to the DFT Fermi energy, therefore, Fano
resonance happens to be around EF. Two
Fano resonances are expected because of two nitro groups with the
same energy. The splitting between these two degenerate states depends
on the indirect coupling between them through the backbone of DBDT
and DOPE2. Because two rings are coupled to each other stronger in
DOPE2 compare to that of DBDT, two resonances (LUMO and LUMO + 1 in Figure a) are formed in
transmission coefficient of DOPE2. By moving the intro groups in DOPE2
from ortho to meta positions to form DOPE2-m (Figure a), the electronic coupling between NO2 groups
through the backbone decreases dramatically. This is because the effective
electronic coupling between two sites in a molecule is proportional
to Green’s function matrix element between the two sites as
demonstrated in the Supporting Information. In the vicinity of the middle of the HOMO–LUMO gap, Green’s
function matrix element between the meta sites is smaller than that
of the ortho sites because of a destructive QI of standing waves.
Consequently, the splitting of the resonances due to the nitro groups
is smaller in DOPE2-m compared to that of DOPE2 (Figures e and 6a). This is also demonstrated with a simple tight-binding model in
the Supporting Information (see Figure
S10).
Figure 6
Energy level diagram of gas phase BP, BDT, and OPE2 derivatives
and thermoelectric properties of the BP-based molecular junctions.
(a) Energy levels of gas phase molecules calculated using B3LYP functional
(see the Computational Methods section). Two
degenerate energy levels around −4 eV are mainly due to the
nitro group as evident by their associated wave functions in Tables S1–S3. (b) Phonon thermal conductance
and (c) room temperature ZT vs Fermi energy of BP,
TBP, and DBP junctions.
OPE2 derivatives. OPE2 with different side groups (a) NO2 in meta position, (b) CN, (c) CF3, (d) NH2. (e) Electron transmission coefficient for OPE2 derivatives between
two gold electrodes.Energy level diagram of gas phase BP, BDT, and OPE2 derivatives
and thermoelectric properties of the BP-based molecular junctions.
(a) Energy levels of gas phase molecules calculated using B3LYP functional
(see the Computational Methods section). Two
degenerate energy levels around −4 eV are mainly due to the
nitro group as evident by their associated wave functions in Tables S1–S3. (b) Phonon thermal conductance
and (c) room temperature ZT vs Fermi energy of BP,
TBP, and DBP junctions.Because nitro is a strong electron-withdrawing group, we
have studied
the effect of another electron-withdrawing group, cyano (CN) on transport
properties of OPE2 as shown in Figure b. As a result of cyano functionalization of OPE2 (to
form CNOPE2), the LUMO resonance moves toward the Fermi energy (Figure e and Tables S3 and
S4 of the Supporting Information). The
wave function calculations of gas phase CNOPE2 reveals that the state
due to the CN group hybridizes with the LUMO of OPE2 backbone and
forms a new LUMO state closer to the Fermi energy (Table S4 of the Supporting Information). We did not find a sizable
effect on the transport properties of OPE2 using other functionalization
such as CF3 and NH2 (Figure c–e and Table S4 of the Supporting Information).To examine the
effect of side groups on the thermoelectric properties
of BP derivatives, we study electron and phonon transport through
4,4′-bipyridyl (BP), 3,3′,5,5′-tetrachloride-BP
(TBP) and 3,3′-dinitro-BP (DBP) molecules shown in Figure d–f. Figure S6a shows the transmission coefficient
of BP derivatives. Transport through the BP molecule is mainly through
LUMO in agreement with the previous reports.[23,31] The measured conductance of the BP molecule[23,32] is in the range of 0.9 to 4.4 × 10–4G0 in agreement with our calculation (Figure S6a) for a wide range of energies around E = 0 eV.Our calculation shows that the electron
transport is also mainly
through LUMO in TBP and DBP functionalized molecular junctions. Their
conductances are smaller than BP parent at EF (Figure S6a). This is because
of the rotation of two pyridine rings relative to each other in TBP
and DBP (see Figure S1 of the Supporting Information). The conductance is expected to reduce by cos(θ) where θ
is the angle between pyridine rings.[29] θ
is 66° and 79° in TBP and DBP, respectively. Our transport
calculations (Figure S6a) show that the
conductance of the DBP junction is smaller than that of TBP. Just
like DOPE2 and DBDT molecular junctions where a resonance due to NO2 side groups is formed between HOMO and LUMO of parent OPE2
and BDT, the resonance in Tel(E) of DBP is formed between HOMO and LUMO of BP (Figure S6a). Figure a shows the energy levels of gas-phase BP,
BDT, and OPE2 derivatives. Remarkably, two degenerate energy levels
(indicated by black arrows in Figure a) are located about E = −4
eV for all nitro functionalized molecules. As illustrated with the
wave function calculations of Tables S1–S3 of the Supporting Information, these states are localized
on NO2 groups.Figure S6c of the Supporting Information shows S of BP, TBP,
and DBP at room temperature.
A negative Seebeck coefficient in the range of −7.9 to −9.5
μV/K is obtained for parent BP around EF in agreement with previous measurements.[23,24]S of the functionalized DBP molecule is higher
compared to that of BP and TBP around EF. A few meV away from EF, S of DBP increases to ca. −380 μV/K (Figure S6c). This tiny shift of EF can be achieved by doping using charge-transfer complexes or electrostatic
gating using a third electrode. By introducing side groups to BP,
for example, Cl or NO2, Tph(h̵ω), and κph of TBP
and DBP is suppressed (Figure S7b of the Supporting Information). Room temperature κph of BP,
TBP, and DBP are 34.8, 14.8 and 23.6 pW/K, respectively (Figure b). Although NO2 side groups are heavier than Cl, κph is
supressed largely in TBP. This is because the number of side groups
(4 chlorine atoms) in TBP is more than that of DBP with only two NO2 side groups. Note that unlike the monotonic angle dependence
of electronic transmission, dependence of phonon transmission to θ
is nonmonotonic (Figure b). By increasing θ, κph decreases from BP
to TBP, whereas it increases from TBP to DBP. In fact, phonon transmission
is mainly influenced by the side groups not θ. Figure c shows the total ZT of BP derivatives. Clearly, ZT enhances from parent
BP to nitro functionalized DBP. A larger improvement of room temperature ZT = 0.9 in DBP is possible at a few meV away from the Fermi
energy. It is worth mentioning that the nitro-functionalization reduces
phonon thermal conductance of all junctions. The main contribution
to the total thermal conductance of all nitro-functionalized junctions
is due to phonons except in DOPE2 where the improvement of electron
transmission coefficient and consequently electron thermal conductance
is larger than phonon contribution to the total thermal conductance.To understand how the thermoelectric performance of molecular devices
changes by up-scaling to many molecule junctions, we calculate the
electronic and phononic properties of junctions formed with two BP
molecules sandwiched between gold electrodes as shown in Figure S11
of the Supporting Information. The electron
transmission coefficient increases by almost a factor of 2 for a wide
range of energy between HOMO and LUMO (Figure S8a of the Supporting Information). S is
nearly unchanged because the slope of electronic transmission coefficient
does not change by the number of molecules (Figure S8c). Phonon transmission and κph is almost
scaled linearly with the number of molecules (Figure S8d,e of the Supporting Information). Consequently, ZT is hardly affected. Unlike junctions formed from graphene
electrodes, where indirect coupling between molecules through the
graphene electrodes lead to a QI and nonlinear variations of thermoelectric
properties,[33] in the junctions formed by
gold electrodes, interference effects due to indirect coupling is
less significant provided there is not a direct coupling between molecules
e.g. through cross-linking.
Conclusions
We have studied systematically
the thermoelectric properties of
BDT, oligo(2-phenylene ethynylene), and bipyridine derivatives. We
calculated the electron and phonon transport from the first principle.
Guided by quantum and phonon interference effects; we engineered the
molecular structures and enhanced the thermoelectric efficiency. We
showed that record values of ZT = 1.55 and 2.4 are
accessible in the nitro-functionalized OPE2-ditihol molecules. Nitro
groups also enhance ZT of BDT and BP derivatives.
Energy level diagram of gas phase molecules shows that energy levels
of nitro groups are moved hardly from one molecule to the other. This
suggests that enhancement of ZT using nitro functionalization
is a generic feature and is independent of the choice of a parent
molecule. The enhancement of ZT by NO2 groups is more significant in HOMO dominated DBDT and DOPE2-dithiol
molecules. Furthermore, we showed that phonon transport can be suppressed
strongly in tetrachloride-BP compared to its parent BP leading to
enhancement of ZT. Unlike a monotonic dependence
of electronic transmission of BP derivatives to angle between two
pyridines, angle dependence of phonon transmission is nonmonotonic.
We also demonstrated that in the junctions formed by gold electrodes,
interference effects due to indirect couplings through the leads are
less significant. Consequently, RTQI and RTPI enhanced ZT is conserved when parallel molecules are placed between gold electrodes.
Computational
Methods
Geometry Optimization
The geometry of each structure
was relaxed to the force tolerance of 10 meV/Å using the SIESTA[34] implementation of DFT, with a double-ζ-polarized
basis set and the generalized gradient approximation functional with
Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof parameterization. A real-space
grid was defined with an equivalent energy cutoff of 250 Ry. For energy
level diagram (Figure a) and wave function calculations (Tables S1–S4 of the Supporting Information) of gas phase molecules,
we employed experimentally parameterized B3LYP functional using Gaussian
g09v2[35] with 6-311++g basis set and tight
convergence criteria.
Phonon Transport
Following the method
described in
refs,[3,28] a set of xyz coordinates were generated by displacing
each atom from the relaxed xyz geometry in the positive
and negative x, y, and z directions with δq′ = 0.01 Å.
The forces F = (F, F, F) in three directions q = (x, y, z) on each atom were then calculated
and used to construct the dynamical matrix D = K/M where
the mass matrix and K = [F(δq′) – F(−δq′)]/2δq′ for i ≠ j obtained from
finite differences. To satisfy momentum
conservation, the K for i = j (diagonal terms) is calculated from K = −∑K. The phonon transmission Tph(ω)
then can be calculated from the relation Tph(ω) = Trace(ΓLph(ω)GphR(ω)ΓRph(ω)GphR†(ω)) where ΓL,Rph(ω) = i(∑L,Rph(ω) –
∑L,Rph†(ω)) describes the level broadening due to the coupling to
the left L and right R electrodes, ∑L,Rph(ω) are the retarded self-frequencies
associated with this coupling and GphR = (ω2I – D – ∑Lph – ∑Rph)−1 is the retarded Green’s function, where D and I are the dynamical and the unit matrices,
respectively. The phonon thermal conductance κph at
temperature T is then calculated from κph(T) = (2π)−1∫0∞ℏωTph(ω)(∂fBE(ω,T)/∂T)dω
where fBE(ω,T)
= (e – 1)−1 is Bose–Einstein
distribution function and ℏ is reduced Planck’s
constant and kB = 8.6 × 10–5 eV/K is Boltzmann’s constant.
Electron Transport
To calculate electronic properties
of the device, from the converged DFT calculation, the underlying
mean-field Hamiltonian H was combined with our quantum
transport code, Gollum.[3,25] This yields the transmission
coefficient Tel(E) for
electrons of energy E (passing from the source to
the drain) via the relation Tel(E) = Tr(ΓLel(E)GelR(E)ΓRel(E)GelR†(E)) where ΓL,Rel(E) = i(∑L,Rel(E) – ∑L,Rel†(E)) describes the level broadening due to the coupling between
left L and right R electrodes and the central scattering region, ∑L,Rel(E) are the retarded self-energies associated with this coupling and GelR = (ES – H – ∑Lel – ∑Rel)−1 is the retarded Green’s function, where H is the Hamiltonian and S is the overlap matrix
obtained from SIESTA implementation of DFT. DFT + ∑ approach
has been employed for spectral adjustment.[3]
Thermoelectric Properties
Using the approach explained
in ref (3), the electrical
conductance Gel(T) = G0L0, the electronic
contribution of the thermal conductance κel(T) = (L0L2 – L12)/hTL0 and the thermopower S(T) = −L1/eTL0 are calculated from the electron transmission coefficient Tel(E) where the moments L(T) = ∫–∞+∞dE(E – EF)Tel(E) (−∂fFD(E,T)/∂E) and fFD(E,T) is the Fermi-Dirac probability distribution function fFD(E,T) =
(e( + 1)−1, T is the temperature, EF is the Fermi energy, G0 = 2e2/h is the
conductance quantum, e is electron charge and h is the Planck’s constant. The full thermoelectric
figure of merit ZT is then calculated as ZT(EF,T) = G(EF,T)S(EF,T)2T/κ(EF,T) where G(EF,T) is the electrical conductance, S(EF,T) is Seebeck coefficient,
κ(EF,T) = κel(EF,T) + κph(T) is the thermal conductance due to the
electrons and phonons, EF is Fermi energy
and T is temperature.
Authors: Latha Venkataraman; Jennifer E Klare; Colin Nuckolls; Mark S Hybertsen; Michael L Steigerwald Journal: Nature Date: 2006-08-24 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Gita Sedghi; Víctor M García-Suárez; Louisa J Esdaile; Harry L Anderson; Colin J Lambert; Santiago Martín; Donald Bethell; Simon J Higgins; Martin Elliott; Neil Bennett; J Emyr Macdonald; Richard J Nichols Journal: Nat Nanotechnol Date: 2011-07-31 Impact factor: 39.213
Authors: Veerabhadrarao Kaliginedi; Pavel Moreno-García; Hennie Valkenier; Wenjing Hong; Víctor M García-Suárez; Petra Buiter; Jelmer L H Otten; Jan C Hummelen; Colin J Lambert; Thomas Wandlowski Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2012-03-06 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Su Ying Quek; Maria Kamenetska; Michael L Steigerwald; Hyoung Joon Choi; Steven G Louie; Mark S Hybertsen; J B Neaton; Latha Venkataraman Journal: Nat Nanotechnol Date: 2009-03-01 Impact factor: 39.213