Facing off with the phalangeal phenomenon and editorial policies: A commentary on Swift-Gallant, Johnson, Di Rita and Breedlove (2020).

Swift-Gallant et al. (2020) provide a thought-provoking perspective on the topic of digit ratio research, research that has had some prominence in the journal Hormones and Behavior, and is research that has garnered much controversy. In this commentary on their paper, we add to the discussion of why there is skepticism of the use of digit ratios as a measure of individual differences in prenatal androgens, we comment on the mis-use of the facial width-to-height ratio as a measure of individual differences in testosterone, the grey areas in the interpretation of evidence, and we address the concern raised in their article regarding editorial policies at Hormones and Behavior (spoiler alert: there are no secret policies).