| Literature DB >> 32055072 |
Ajit Bhide1, Kaustav Chakraborty2.
Abstract
Entities:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32055072 PMCID: PMC7001347 DOI: 10.4103/psychiatry.IndianJPsychiatry_811_19
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Indian J Psychiatry ISSN: 0019-5545 Impact factor: 1.759
Possible therapeutic interventions
| Family therapy - seeing the whole family |
| Individual work with children (for example, play therapy) |
| Individual work with adolescents |
| Individual work with parents |
| Couple/marital work with parents |
| Group-work with children and adolescents |
| Group-work with parents |
| Drop-in groups (for example, at a family resource or after-school service) |
| Consulting/liaising with other professionals (for example, teachers) |
| All of the above can be offered either in the home or in a clinical setting such as child mental health setting, or indeed in a community setting such as a school or after-school service |
Creative therapeutic activities
| Construction materials |
| Artwork and drawing |
| Reading and story books |
| Worksheets and workbooks |
| Puppets and figures |
Challenges in establishing rapport
| Challenges | Underlying issues | How to go about it |
|---|---|---|
| The “silent” child | Anxiety | Slow to warm up children may gradually open up as the session progresses or in subsequent sessions. While assessing the temperament of the child, clinician will get a cue of this |
| Parents who have brought the child on some other pretext (e.g., consultation for parents, concerns about academics even though the real reason may be disruptive behavior), OR Coerced the child into coming for the consultation | Silence may be a manifestation of parenting skill deficits or helplessness arising out of aggressive behavior of the child | |
| Children with developmental delays or specific deficits in speech and social skills | Assessment of infants and toddlers should be done at a time when they are awake, alert, and cooperative | |
| Selective mutism | The child should be encouraged to express through nonverbal means, e.g., drawing, writing, and gestures | |
| Psychotic and obsessivecompulsive disorders | The child may withhold sharing the information with the clinician because of its “threatening/fearful” content. | |
| The “difficult” child | Older children and adolescents with disruptive behavior and substance abuse | Adolescents may feel embarrassed seeing his/her parents discussing his/her problem behavior with others or may be apprehensive of being reprimanded |
| The “sexually abused” child | High degree of sensitivity is required on part of the clinician to deal with a child who has been sexually abused |
Points to consider in clinical assessment from psychotherapeutic point of view
| Referral | “Who has referred the child?” |
| Birth and postnatal history | Obstructed labor, forceps delivery, birth asphyxia, delayed crying |
| Developmental trajectories and attainments | Psychomotor |
| Family environment | Joint/nuclear/single parent family |
| Schooling | Adaptation at school History of school refusal, absenteeism |
| Temperamental traits of the child | Activity level, rhythmicity, distractibility, approach/withdrawal, adaptability, attention span and persistence, intensity of reaction, responsiveness threshold, mood |
| Child’s interests, skills, and talents | “What makes the child happy?” |
| Questions to elucidate ongoing concerns | Ongoing concerns |
Factors to be considered in evaluation for psychotherapy
| Age | Supportive psychotherapy - all age group |
| Duration of illness | Specify the target problem in relation to duration - e.g., a newly emerging disruptive behavior in a case of autism |
| Severity of symptoms | Personal distress/family distress/social distress |
| Intelligence | Presence of normal intelligence is a prerequisite for a more elaborative kind of psychotherapy (re-educative or psychoanalytic) |
| Verbal felicity | Excellent/good/average/poor |
| Motivation | Why does he/she want to get better? What are his/her plans for the immediate future (after treatment)? |
| Insight | Introspective ability about illness and emotional matters |
| Secondary gain | Personal level |
| Temperamental traits | Activity level, rhythmicity, distractibility, approach/withdrawal, adaptability, attention span and persistence, intensity of reaction, responsiveness threshold, mood |
| Ego strength | Hereditary factors: Nil/minimal/significant |
| Method of handling stress | Denial/repression |
| Symptoms | Ego dystonic |
| Precipitating factors | School change, change of residence, break in romantic relationship, academic failures, verbal/physical abuse by parents, etc. |
| Current environmental situation | Time |
| Past therapeutic contact | Psychiatric: No/yes |
| Proposed length of treatment contract | Brief psychotherapy, long-term psychotherapy |
CBT – Cognitive behavioral therapy
Do’s and Don’ts of psychotherapy
| Do’s |
| Be open |
| Be flexible |
| Be trustworthy |
| Be approachable |
| Be understanding |
| Be patient |
| Show respect |
| Use of good nonharmful humor |
| Don’ts |
| No interrogation mode |
| No imposing of your values |
| No blaming attitude |
| Inadequate time |
| Advice or look too hastily for a solution |
| Technical jargons |
| Influencing client’s values, attitudes, beliefs, interests, decisions, etc. |
Goals, indications, and contraindications of family therapy
| Goals |
| To explore family dynamics and their relation to psychopathology |
| To mobilize the family’s inner strength and functional resources |
| To remodel the maladaptive interaction within a family |
| To buttress the problem-solving behavior of the family |
| Indications |
| Overt and disturbing conflicts amongst family members, with or besides symptomatic behaviors in one or more members |
| Covert conflicts inside the family giving rise to maladaptive behavior in one or more household members, or when other household members covertly stand by and maintain the disorder |
| Recognizing covert household interactional problems along with overt dysfunctions in one or more household participants is the expertise of the field of family therapy, e.g., externalizing adolescent problems and substance abuse |
| Contraindications |
| Long dormant, charged, or explosive family problems before the family commits significantly to treatment |
| Discussing disturbing situations with the members of the household when one or more participants are severely destabilized and require hospitalization |
| Inadequate information in family therapy |
| Lack of information on child development and psychopathology |
Models of family therapy
| Intergenerational family therapy models | Structural and strategic family therapies | Behavior family therapy | Psychodynamic and experiential family therapies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Families whose members have chronic disorders and have not separated enough from preceding generations | Families facing a crisis in which it has separated from preceding generations and has a good precrisis adjustment in the nuclear family | Problems related to marriage and children with longstanding conduct problems | Family members having narcissistic traits and a wide range of personality and neurotic problems who maintain an adequate level of functioning however do not lead a joyful life |
Risk factors, warning signs and management strategies for violent and aggressive behavior in child or adolescent
| Risk factors | Previous aggressive or violent behavior |
| Being the victim of physical abuse and/or sexual abuse | |
| Exposure to violence in the home and/or community | |
| Genetic (family heredity) factors | |
| Exposure to violence in media (television, movies, etc.) | |
| Use of drugs and/or alcohol | |
| Presence of firearms in home | |
| Combination of stressful family socioeconomic factors (poverty, severe deprivation, marital breakup, single parenting, unemployment, loss of support from extended family) | |
| Brain damage from head injury | |
| Warning signs | Intense anger |
| Frequent loss of temper or blow-ups | |
| Extreme irritability | |
| Extreme impulsiveness | |
| Becoming easily frustrated | |
| Unreasonable demanding behavior | |
| Management strategies | Whenever a child or adolescent show violent or aggressive behavior, he/she should be immediately assessed by a qualified mental health professional |
| Early treatment by a professional can often help | |
| It is important to be nonjudgmental while dealing with such cases | |
| Rapport may take a longer time to establish | |
| Discuss the aggressive behavior only after the rapport has been established | |
| Avoid taking sides with parents, especially in early sessions | |
| Consistency in parenting is another important aspect that is needed to be addressed | |
| Avoid involving children in family politics | |
| The goals of treatment typically focus on helping the child to: learn how to control his/her anger; express anger and frustrations in appropriate ways; be responsible for his/her actions; and accept consequences. Apply certain behavioral principles, e.g., time-out, contingency management | |
| In addition, family conflicts, school problems, and community issues must be addressed |
Summary of researches on psychotherapeutic approaches for childhood and adolescent psychiatric disorders/conditions
| Authors | Type of Study | Study sample | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zhou | Systematic review and network meta-analysis | Children and adolescents with depressive disorder. 52 studies. | At posttreatment, IPT and CBT were significantly more effective than most control conditions, play therapy and problem-solving therapy. Psychodynamic therapy and play therapy were not significantly superior to waitlist. IPT and problem-solving therapy had significantly fewer all-cause discontinuations compared to cognitive therapy and CBT |
| Gillies | Cochrane review | Children and adolescents exposed to trauma. 51 trials, | Receiving a psychological therapy decreased the likelihood of being diagnosed with PTSD in children compared to those who received no treatment, treatment as usual or were on a waiting list for up to a month following treatment. However, CBT was found to be equally effective as EMDR and supportive therapy in reducing diagnosis of PTSD in the short term |
| Hawton | Cochrane review | Children and adolescents with SH. 11 trials. | Results of three trials, which were of very low-quality as per the GRADE criteria, found little support for the effectiveness of group-based psychotherapy for adolescents with multiple episodes of SH. Therapeutic assessment, mentalization, and dialectical behavior therapy as treatment for SH need further evaluation. |
| James | Cochrane review | Children and adolescents with anxiety disorders. 41 studies. | CBT was effective for childhood and adolescent anxiety disorder; however, CBT being more effective than active controls or TAU or medication at follow-up was inconclusive |
| Macdonald | Cochrane review | Children who have been sexually abused. 10 trials. | CBT may positively influence on the sequelae of child sexual abuse, but most results were not statistically significant. CBT was “moderately” effective in reducing PTSD and anxiety symptoms |
| O’Kearney | Cochrane review | Children and adolescents with OCD. 8 trials. | BT/CBT lowered posttreatment OCD severity and reduced risk of continuing with OCD compared to pill placebo or wait-list comparisons |
| Catalá-López | Meta-analysis | Children and adolescents with ADHD. 190 randomized trials, | BT alone, BT in combination with stimulants, stimulants alone, and nonstimulants alone were all more efficacious than placebo in reducing ADHD symptoms |
| Maw and Haga, 2018[ | Systematic review and meta-analysis | Preschool children with autism spectrum disorders. 14 RCTs. | Effectiveness of cognitive, developmental, and behavioral interventions was assessed. RIT, SP, and music therapy showed the largest effects for improving the communication and social interactions of affected children |
OCD – Obsessive–compulsive disorder, RIT – Reciprocal Imitation Training, SP – Symbolic Play; SH – Self-harm, CBT – Cognitive behavioral therapy, BT – Behavioral therapy, ADHD – Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, PTSD - Post traumatic stress disorder, EMDR - Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing, IPT - Interpersonal therapy
| Fighting | Disagreeing about relatives | ||
| Feeling distant | Disagreeing about friends | ||
| Loss of fun | Alcohol or drug use | ||
| Lack of honesty | Trauma | ||
| Medical concerns | Infidelity (couple) | ||
| Education problems | Divorce/separation | ||
| Financial problems | Issues regarding remarriage | ||
| Death of a family member | Birth of a child | ||
| Inadequate health insurance | Job change or job dissatisfaction | ||
| Inadequate housing/feeling unsafe | Other |
| Name | Relationship (parent, sibling, etc.) | Age | Sex | Type (bio, step, etc.) | Living with you? Y/N |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fighting | Disagreeing about relatives | ||
| Feeling distant | Disagreeing about friends | ||
| Loss of fun | Alcohol or Drug use | ||
| Lack of honesty | Trauma | ||
| Medical Concerns | Infidelity (couple) | ||
| Education problems | Divorce/separation | ||
| Financial problems | Issues regarding remarriage | ||
| Death of a family member | Birth of a child | ||
| Inadequate health insurance | Job change or job dissatisfaction | ||
| Inadequate housing/feeling unsafe | Other |