| Literature DB >> 32055068 |
Vivek Agarwal1, Anil Nischal1, Samir Kumar Praharaj2, Vikas Menon3, Sujita Kumar Kar1.
Abstract
Entities:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32055068 PMCID: PMC7001354 DOI: 10.4103/psychiatry.IndianJPsychiatry_775_19
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Indian J Psychiatry ISSN: 0019-5545 Impact factor: 1.759
Somatoform disorders
| Category | Description | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Somatization disorder | Multiple, recurrent, variable physical symptoms involving several body systems, of 2 years duration (includes Briquet syndrome) |
| 2 | Undifferentiated somatoform disorder | Multiple, persistent, variable symptoms of severity and/or duration less than that of somatization disorder |
| 3 | Hypochondriacal disorder | Persistent preoccupation with the possibility of having a major disease or presumed bodily disfigurement/deformity (includes body dysmorphic disorder) |
| 4 | Somatoform autonomic dysfunction | Multiple unexplained symptoms related to systems under autonomic control (includes psychogenic cardiac, gastrointestinal, respiratory, and genitourinary disorders) |
| 5 | Persistent somatoform pain disorder | Unexplained persistent and distressing pain symptoms of possible psychogenic origin |
| 6 | Other somatoform disorders | Unexplained symptoms limited to specific body parts/system not mediated by autonomic pathways (includes globus hystericus, psychogenic torticollis, psychogenic pruritus, psychogenic dysmenorrhoea, teeth grinding) |
| 7 | Somatoform disorder, unspecified | Unspecified medically unexplained symptoms |
Pretherapy assessment in somatoform disorder
| Component | Comments | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The presence of somatic symptoms | Symptoms without obvious medical cause or in clear excess to medical condition |
| 2 | Subjective description of symptoms | Description in local language (e.g., gas-like sensation, churning in bowels) |
| 3 | Number of symptoms | Higher number possibly indicates severe illness (monosymptomatic vs. polysymptomatic) |
| 4 | Symptom types related to body systems | Symptoms across body systems indicate severe illness (e.g., somatization disorder) |
| 5 | Frequency and duration of symptoms | Symptoms may fluctuate (continuous vs. intermittent), chronicity indicates severe illness |
| 6 | Severity of symptoms | The intensity of symptoms may vary (e.g., degree of pain as assessed by visual analog scale) |
| 7 | Pattern of symptoms | Symptoms are dynamic (symptoms change over time) |
| 8 | Beliefs about symptoms | Each patient will have specific beliefs related to the symptoms |
| 9 | Attribution | Persistent attribution to medical illness despite medical reassurance |
| 10 | Distress related to symptoms | Subjective distress demarcates presence of syndromal disorder |
| 11 | Interference with functioning | How the symptoms interfere with the functioning |
| 12 | Aggravating and relieving factors | Factors that worsen or improve the symptoms |
| 13 | Mood and anxiety symptoms | These symptoms may be present at syndromal or subsyndromal level |
| 14 | Medical illness | Comorbid medical illness present (may or may not account for all the somatic symptoms) |
| 15 | Psychosocial factors | Factors related to somatic symptoms (though not acknowledged by the patient) |
Assessment of biopsychosocial factors
| Factors | Comments | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Genetic | Family history of somatization |
| 2 | Early life events | Childhood adversities such as separation from mother, abuse or maltreatment, neglect, insecure attachment |
| 3 | Recent life events | Major life events in the past year |
| 4 | Chronic daily life stress | This includes feeling pressured at work, feeling “tensed,” frequent arguments with family members |
| 5 | Coping | Not able to handle everyday demands of life |
| 6 | Unhealthy lifestyle | Lack of exercise, substance use, irregular sleep pattern |
| 7 | Personality factors | Presence of alexithymia, Type A behavior, coping styles |
| 8 | Support system | Lack of social support (emotional or instrumental), Employment status, Financial condition |
| 9 | Comorbid medical or psychiatric disorders | Long-standing medical illnesses, substance use, other psychiatric comorbidities |
| 10 | Cultural factors | Higher somatizing tendencies |
Rating instruments for somatoform disorder
| Scale | Comments | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | PHQ-15 | A 15-item questionnaire exploring 15 somatic symptoms. Each symptom is rated from 0 (refers to – not bothered at all) to 2 (refers to – bothered a lot). The cut-off points for low, medium and high symptom severity are 5, 10 and 15 respectively[ |
| 2 | SSS-8 | An 8-item self-report scale. The symptoms are rated from 0 (not at all) to 4 (very much). The score ranges from 0 to 32. The severity of the symptoms is rated as “no to minimal:” 0–3; “low:” 4–7; “medium:” 8–11; “high:” 12–15; and “very high:” 16–32[ |
| 3 | SASS | This scale consists of four subscales: 1. Pain-related symptoms; 2. Sensory somatic symptoms; 3. Non-specific somatic symptoms; 4. Biological function related symptoms. The symptom severity is rated on a four-point scale ranging from 0 to 3, where “0” refers to absent; “1” refers to mild; “2” refers to moderate and “3” refers to severe. The scale measures symptoms during the past 2 weeks[ |
| 4 | SSI | A scale listing 11 symptoms used for screening. The presence of 5 or more symptoms suggest somatoform disorder[ |
| 5 | BSI | This is a multi-ethnic inventory of somatic symptoms present with depressive and anxiety symptoms. It contains 46 items[ |
| 6 | WI | It has 14 items used to characterize three dimensions, a) disease conviction, b) somatic preoccupation, and c) disease phobia[ |
PHQ-15 – Patient health questionnaire 15; SSS-8 – Somatic Symptom Scale 8; SASS – Scale for the Assessment of Somatic Symptoms; SSI – Swartz Somatization Index; BSI – Bradford Somatic Inventory; WI – Whitley Index
Physician and patient centered strategies
| 1. Establishing a therapeutic alliance | This is the cornerstone of all the successful nonpharmacological approach and forms the base upon which the therapist makes further recommendations including delivery of the diagnosis |
| 2. Validating the nature of and distress caused by symptoms | A thorough clinical assessment, including history and examination is necessary. The findings of the examinations are conveyed to the patient while validating their symptoms |
| 3. Manage general medical conditions | All comorbid general medical conditions are treated appropriately |
| 4. Restrict diagnostic testing and specialist referrals | Limiting diagnostic testing and unnecessary referrals is essential so as to avoid the “next best investigation trap” which is frequently suggested by the patients |
| 5. Communicate with the patient | Includes an open discussion about the formulation of the symptom(s) in biopsychosocial terms (e.g., back pain caused by stress-induced muscle tension and perpetuated by bad sleep habits), the diagnostic tests proposed and outcomes anticipated, the treatment options available, reassurance and setting goals of treatment (whether symptom reduction or cure). The psychogenic basis of the illness and relevance of learning certain therapeutic skills to deal with the psychological distress also need to be communicated to the patient |
| 6. Avoid “dualistic thinking” trap | Patients may try to steer the conversation towards whether the symptoms are purely mental, based on the fact that they have been referred for psychiatric evaluation. Gently move the discussion from “either mental or physical” to “mental as well as physical.” Evidence suggests that patients are often ready to receive both biological as well as psychosocial explanations for their problem |
| 7. Carefully target reassurance | Desist from excessive reassurance and acknowledge uncertainty about the cause of symptoms. Explain that symptoms do not equate with disease and educate about coping with physical symptoms |
| 8. Treat any concurrent anxiety or depression | Early identification and management of these treatable co-morbidities should be focussed upon |
| 9. Shift focus away from symptoms to functioning | Though the patient may focus on the symptom at every visit, the therapist should focus on other areas of life such as work output, activity, and sleep |
| 10. Maintain consistency | This implies that the therapist sticks to the case formulation and management plan in successive consultations and does not get pressurized into changing course in the face of evolving anger or frustration on the part of either the patient or physician |
| 11. Liaise with other specialists involved in care of the patient | Very often, bodily symptoms may require multidisciplinary care for optimum benefits. It also sends across a message to nonpsychiatrists about the necessity and possibility of a collaborative care approach to the management of these cases |
| 12. Be aware of prescription drug dependence (commonly benzodiazepine dependence) | This can affect engagement with and effectiveness of therapy. To avoid this undesirable complication, emphasis should always be given to nonpharmacological strategies as the first line of treatment |
| 13. Look for hints that suggest a psychosocial contributor to the problem | An example of this is symptoms getting exacerbated following an argument with the spouse. The psychosocial factor may/may not have a temporal correlation with the onset of somatoform disorder. These variables need to be explained to the client (as an explanatory model for the illness) during psychoeducation and can be targeted in the therapy too |
| 1. Explicit resetting of treatment goals | The goals of the treatment are restated with a shift in focus from symptoms to functional improvement |
| 2. Lifestyle changes | Encourage the patient to adopt a healthy lifestyle such as; regular aerobic exercises, balanced diet, sleep hygiene practices, and pursuing hobbies. This will simultaneously activate reward mechanisms in the brain as well as boost the body’s own endogenous opioid systems resulting in attenuation of pain symptoms if any |
| 3. Addressing illness beliefs, dysfunctional behaviors (such as avoidance), explanatory models, health-related anxiety and disease conviction | There is a fair amount of evidence showing that these variables are linked to disease outcomes and prognosis in somatoform disorders and therefore, are important for clinicians to address |
| 4. Manage “secondary gain” | Explain caregiver the concept of secondary gains and gradually reduce these gains |
Simple therapeutic techniques for somatoform disorder
| Technique | Comments | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Positive suggestion: Somatic symptoms improve with “positive” suggestion about the definite diagnosis, as compared to “negative” suggestion of uncertainty of diagnosis and outcome | This can be incorporated as part of psychiatric consultation |
| 2 | Symptoms clinic intervention: Initially provide biomedical explanations for symptoms and initiate psychosocial talk when cued by the patient | Shorter and less psychologically oriented |
| 3 | Reattribution therapy: The three parts of this brief intervention includes a) feeling understood – to elicit physical symptoms, psychosocial problems, mood state, beliefs about the problem, relevant examination and tests, b) changing or broadening the agenda – to summarize physical and psychosocial findings and negotiate, and c) making the link – explanation relating the physical symptom to psychosocial problem based on timing or physiology | Has been studied well, but in absence of clear psychosocial problem it is difficult to use |
| 4 | Problem-solving approach: Simple steps of problem-solving can be taught to patients in situations when symptoms are related to conflict because of indecision regarding a different course of action | Advantage and disadvantage matrix can be constructed |
| 5 | Guided imagery: Construct an image representing a symptom in their mind and then they change it to become “how it should be” | Has been used in gastrointestinal disorders |
| 6 | Combined consultation: Simultaneous presence of a physician and a psychiatrist during the process of investigation, announcement of diagnosis and treatment plan | A pragmatic approach. An alternative is a sequential consultation |
Evidence-based psychotherapies in individual somatoform disorders
| Disorder | Therapy | Active components |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Somatization disorder/Undifferentiated Somatoform Disorder | First line | |
| Psychoeducation | Emphasize the mechanism of symptoms than cause/encourage coping. Evidence exists for both individual and group format. Can be combined with consultation letter to physician | |
| Brief intervention – comprising of psychoeducation, relaxation therapy, and reattribution training | Empathically provide information to patient, progressive muscular relaxation and encourage a biopsychosocial approach to the symptom | |
| CBT | Targeting catastrophic misinterpretation of symptoms and encourage behavioral activation/functioning. Evidence says that individual CBT may be superior to group CBT | |
| Supportive psychotherapy | Listen, validate, empathize and targeted reassurance of the patient | |
| Relaxation therapy | Training on progressive muscular relaxation and diaphragmatic breathing | |
| Second line | ||
| Short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy | Aim for insight into various unconscious phenomena, while others seek to address alexithymia, or difficulty identifying and experiencing emotions | |
| Family therapy | Examine the family’s contribution to symptoms and their reactions. Joint discussions with family allow them to be more supportive toward the patient | |
| Stress management | Combines elements of relaxation, problem-solving, assertiveness training, and time management | |
| 2. Hypochondriasis | First line | |
| CBT | Cognitive restructuring, Exposure and response prevention to tackle maladaptive behaviors | |
| Second line | ||
| MBCT | Combines mindfulness meditation with elements of CBT | |
| Acceptance and commitment therapy | Mindfulness training, acceptance of feared thoughts and feelings, clarification of values, and commitment to change behavior | |
| Third line | ||
| Problem-solving therapy | Six step approach to defining, listing and weighing up solutions and implementing them | |
| Relaxation therapy | Progressive muscle relaxation, release only muscle relaxation, and diaphragmatic breathing | |
| Behavior stress management | Combines elements of relaxation, problem-solving, assertiveness training, and time management | |
| 3. Persistent somatoform pain disorder | First line | |
| CBT | Patient education, behavioral skill training, and cognitive-restructuring. Can be given in individual or group format | |
| Biofeedback | Psychophysiological demonstration of how mental faculties can influence physiological or biological functions | |
| Second line | ||
| Family therapy | Focus on communication patterns and appropriate responses | |
| Relaxation therapy | Targets muscular tension to relieve pain. Induced self-hypnosis also described. Often combined with CBT approaches |
MBCT – Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy; CBT – Cognitive behaviour therapy
Evidence for psychotherapies in somatoform disorder
| Title of the study | Study design/sample | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy in somatoform disorders and medically unexplained physical symptoms: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (2019)[ | Meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials | CBT is effective for the somatic symptoms, anxiety and depressive symptoms in somatoform disorder |
| 2.The effect of positive psychology interventions on well-being and distress in clinical samples with psychiatric or somatic disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysis (2018)[ | Systematic review and meta-analysis | Positive psychology interventions have a beneficial role in somatic disorders by reducing stress and promoting well being |
| 3.CBT for Health Anxiety: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (2017)[ | Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials | Psychological interventions are superior to usual care, medication, and other psychological treatments |
| 4. CBT for medically unexplained symptoms: A systematic review and meta-analysis of published controlled trials (2017)[ | Meta-analysis of controlled trials | CBT is more effective than treatment as usual or enhanced usual care |
| 5.Cognitive-behavioral therapy for body dysmorphic disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (2016)[ | Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials | CBT is superior to waitlisted controls and psychological placebo in body dysmorphic disorder |
| 6. Nonpharmacological interventions for somatoform disorders and medically unexplained physical symptoms (MUPS) in adults (2014)[ | Cochrane database systematic review | Psychological interventions are superior to usual care |
| 7. Effectiveness of psychotherapy for severe somatoform disorder: meta-analysis (2014)[ | Meta-analysis of controlled trials | Psychotherapies are more effective than treatment as usual |
| 8.Mindfulness-Based Therapies in the Treatment of Somatization Disorders: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (2013)[ | Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis | Mindfulness-based therapies are superior to waitlisted controls in reducing pain, depression, anxiety, symptom severity and improving quality of life |
| 9. Efficacy of short-term psychotherapy for multiple medically unexplained physical symptoms: a meta-analysis (2011)[ | Meta-analysis of controlled trials 27 controlled trials; pooled | Short-term Psychotherapy is superior to treatment as usual |
| 10.Short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy for somatic disorders. Systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical trials (2009)[ | Systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical trials 14 trials; pooled | Short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy has a beneficial role for physical as well as psychological symptoms and sociooccupational functioning |
CBT – Cognitive behaviour therapy
Figure 1Factors related to suitability of therapy
Situations where in-patient care for somatization disorder can be considered
| Persistent somatization (Lipowski’s criteria)[ |
| Patients with severe and long-standing physical disabilities (such as wheelchair bound or dependent on walking aids) who require both physical and psychological rehabilitation |
| When there is a need of multidisciplinary evaluation and psychological testing and when this may be better achieved by admitting the patient |
| When therapy needs to be planned on a more intensive basis either for the primary disorder or associated co-morbidities (such as depression) |
| When the family environment carries severe stressors and a brief change of environment is deemed helpful in symptom removal |
| When the patient resides far-away and may not be able to meet the structure and frequency of outpatient visits at least during the initial phase of treatment |
| When there is severe caregiver distress; to provide caregivers respite from the burden of care |
Situations where dependence on the therapist may be suspected
| The client insists on frequent sessions |
| Lack of progress after the initial few sessions |
| Bringing up too many other issues (which are not part of initially agreed-upon agenda) |
| The spacing of the sessions resulting in worsening of symptoms |
| Resisting the change of therapist |
| Unreasonable demands from the client |
| Concurrent Personality disorder (especially anxious/dependent personality disorder) |
Figure 2Hierarchical stepped care model for the management of functional somatic syndromes