Renzo Bianchi1. 1. Institute of Work and Organizational Psychology, University of Neuchâtel, Neuchâtel, NE, Switzerland. Electronic address: renzo.bianchi@unine.ch.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The issue of burnout-depression overlap remains contentious. In this study, the question of whether burnout symptoms form a syndrome that is distinct from depression was reexamined. METHODS: The study involved 332 employed individuals (65% female; mean age: 34). Burnout symptoms were assessed with the Shirom-Melamed Burnout Measure (SMBM). The SMBM operationalizes burnout based on three interconnected components, namely, physical fatigue, cognitive weariness, and emotional exhaustion. Depressive symptoms were assessed with the PHQ-9, a scale that covers the main manifestations of major depression. Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and exploratory structural equation modeling (ESEM) bifactor analysis were conducted. RESULTS: On average, the factors underlying burnout's components correlated more strongly with the Depressive Symptom factor than with each other. Remarkably, such results were obtained even when fatigue-related items were excluded from the depression scale. Second-order CFA revealed that the factors underlying burnout's components and the Depressive Symptom factor were reflective of the same higher-order factor. ESEM bifactor analysis indicated that the general factor accounted for about 2/3 of the common variance extracted. CONCLUSION: Consistent with a growing corpus of research, this study suggests that the burnout-depression distinction is untenable. Because the burnout-depression distinction tends to convey the idea that burnout is not as serious a problem as depression, many people struggling with depression might underestimate the gravity of their condition and not seek help when self-identifying as "burned out." Maintaining a line of demarcation between burnout and depression may thus be problematic from both a scientific and a health management standpoint.
OBJECTIVE: The issue of burnout-depression overlap remains contentious. In this study, the question of whether burnout symptoms form a syndrome that is distinct from depression was reexamined. METHODS: The study involved 332 employed individuals (65% female; mean age: 34). Burnout symptoms were assessed with the Shirom-Melamed Burnout Measure (SMBM). The SMBM operationalizes burnout based on three interconnected components, namely, physical fatigue, cognitive weariness, and emotional exhaustion. Depressive symptoms were assessed with the PHQ-9, a scale that covers the main manifestations of major depression. Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and exploratory structural equation modeling (ESEM) bifactor analysis were conducted. RESULTS: On average, the factors underlying burnout's components correlated more strongly with the Depressive Symptom factor than with each other. Remarkably, such results were obtained even when fatigue-related items were excluded from the depression scale. Second-order CFA revealed that the factors underlying burnout's components and the Depressive Symptom factor were reflective of the same higher-order factor. ESEM bifactor analysis indicated that the general factor accounted for about 2/3 of the common variance extracted. CONCLUSION: Consistent with a growing corpus of research, this study suggests that the burnout-depression distinction is untenable. Because the burnout-depression distinction tends to convey the idea that burnout is not as serious a problem as depression, many people struggling with depression might underestimate the gravity of their condition and not seek help when self-identifying as "burned out." Maintaining a line of demarcation between burnout and depression may thus be problematic from both a scientific and a health management standpoint.
Authors: Cristina Queirós; Fernando Passos; Ana Bártolo; António José Marques; Carlos Fernandes da Silva; Anabela Pereira Journal: Front Psychol Date: 2020-05-07
Authors: Nikitha K Menon; Tait D Shanafelt; Christine A Sinsky; Mark Linzer; Lindsey Carlasare; Keri J S Brady; Martin J Stillman; Mickey T Trockel Journal: JAMA Netw Open Date: 2020-12-01
Authors: Caterina Fiorilli; Daniela Barni; Claudia Russo; Vanessa Marchetti; Giacomo Angelini; Luciano Romano Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-09-09 Impact factor: 4.614