Joanna E Steinglass1, Deborah R Glasofer1, Maya Dalack1, Evelyn Attia1,2. 1. Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University Irving Medical Center & New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, New York. 2. Weill Cornell Medical Center, Presbyterian Hospital, White Plains, New York.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Psychiatric illnesses, like medical illnesses, can sometimes be considered as progressing through stages. Understanding these stages can lead to a better understanding of pathophysiology, and clarification of prognosis and treatment needs. Opinions from experts in the field of anorexia nervosa (AN) were sought to create a model of stages of illness. METHOD: The Delphi approach was used to achieve consensus from a panel of 31 individuals from a range of disciplines with expertise in AN. Over three iterative rounds, participants rated agreement with statements about an overall staging framework and definitions of specific stages. RESULTS: Agreement was reached about a longitudinal progression including Subsyndromal, Full Syndrome, Persistent Illness, and Partial and Full Remission. The panel achieved consensus in defining Subsyndromal AN as characterized by body image disturbance and mild to moderate restrictive eating. Overall, there was consensus that restrictive eating is central to the behavioral features of all stages of AN, and agreement that its absence is essential to any stage of health. There was little consensus about biological markers, other than body mass index, and no consensus about quality of life indices associated with different stages. DISCUSSION: This panel discussion yielded an expert-informed staging model for AN. This model now needs to be tested for its validity. The lack of consensus in several areas highlighted other research questions to address in order to develop an empirically valid and scientifically useful model of the progression of AN.
OBJECTIVE: Psychiatric illnesses, like medical illnesses, can sometimes be considered as progressing through stages. Understanding these stages can lead to a better understanding of pathophysiology, and clarification of prognosis and treatment needs. Opinions from experts in the field of anorexia nervosa (AN) were sought to create a model of stages of illness. METHOD: The Delphi approach was used to achieve consensus from a panel of 31 individuals from a range of disciplines with expertise in AN. Over three iterative rounds, participants rated agreement with statements about an overall staging framework and definitions of specific stages. RESULTS: Agreement was reached about a longitudinal progression including Subsyndromal, Full Syndrome, Persistent Illness, and Partial and Full Remission. The panel achieved consensus in defining Subsyndromal AN as characterized by body image disturbance and mild to moderate restrictive eating. Overall, there was consensus that restrictive eating is central to the behavioral features of all stages of AN, and agreement that its absence is essential to any stage of health. There was little consensus about biological markers, other than body mass index, and no consensus about quality of life indices associated with different stages. DISCUSSION: This panel discussion yielded an expert-informed staging model for AN. This model now needs to be tested for its validity. The lack of consensus in several areas highlighted other research questions to address in order to develop an empirically valid and scientifically useful model of the progression of AN.
Authors: Bryony Bamford; Christina Barras; Richard Sly; Colleen Stiles-Shields; Stephen Touyz; Daniel Le Grange; Phillipa Hay; Ross Crosby; Hubert Lacey Journal: Int J Eat Disord Date: 2014-07-22 Impact factor: 4.861
Authors: M Berk; F Kapczinski; A C Andreazza; O M Dean; F Giorlando; M Maes; M Yücel; C S Gama; S Dodd; B Dean; P V S Magalhães; P Amminger; P McGorry; G S Malhi Journal: Neurosci Biobehav Rev Date: 2010-10-08 Impact factor: 8.989
Authors: Sarah Maguire; Stephen Touyz; Lois Surgenor; Ross D Crosby; Scott G Engel; Hubert Lacey; Suzanne Heywood-Everett; Daniel Le Grange Journal: Int J Eat Disord Date: 2011-08-30 Impact factor: 4.861
Authors: Mathieu Favier; Helena Janickova; Damian Justo; Ornela Kljakic; Léonie Runtz; Joman Y Natsheh; Tharick A Pascoal; Jurgen Germann; Daniel Gallino; Jun-Ii Kang; Xiang Qi Meng; Christina Antinora; Sanda Raulic; Jacob Pr Jacobsen; Luc Moquin; Erika Vigneault; Alain Gratton; Marc G Caron; Philibert Duriez; Mark P Brandon; Pedro Rosa Neto; M Mallar Chakravarty; Mohammad M Herzallah; Philip Gorwood; Marco Am Prado; Vania F Prado; Salah El Mestikawy Journal: J Clin Invest Date: 2020-12-01 Impact factor: 14.808