| Literature DB >> 32030197 |
Richard S Nicholas1, Martin L Heaven, Rodden M Middleton2, Manoj Chevli3, Ruth Pulikottil-Jacob3, Kerina H Jones2, David V Ford2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To investigate through survey and data linkage, healthcare resource use and costs (except drugs), including who bears the cost, of multiple sclerosis in the United Kingdom by disease severity and type.Entities:
Keywords: Resource use; UKMS register; disability; medical and non-medical costing; multiple sclerosis
Year: 2020 PMID: 32030197 PMCID: PMC6977221 DOI: 10.1177/2055217320901727
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Mult Scler J Exp Transl Clin ISSN: 2055-2173
Figure 1.Sankey diagram illustrating the funding flow for 3 months medical and 12 months non-medical costs (Other: combined costs from stair-lifts, raising electrical sockets/lower light switches, wheelchairs, purchase of items to help with daily activities, laying new paths, widening doorways for wheelchair access, installing lighting to outside steps/path, fitting handrails and moving beds downstairs).
Demographics and disease characteristics of the cost of the MS responder population (n=537), the contacted population (n=3035) and the total UKMSR population (n=13244). P values calculated using t-test or χ-square goodness of fit. Current DMT use was only available in the responder population as they were the only group who had reviewed the DMT use question as part of completing the cost of MS questionnaire.
| Variable | Cost of MS population
| Contacted population
| Total UKMSR population
| |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age at diagnosis: (mean±SD) | 40.2±10.5 | 37.7±9.6 | 39.1±10.4** | |||
| Age at questionnaire: (mean±SD) | 51.1±10.5 | 48.4±9.8 | 53.5±12.0** | |||
| MS type: | ||||||
|
| 52 (10) / 322 (60) / 127 (24) / 36 (7) | 225 (7) / 1859 (71) / 422 (14) / 529 (17)** | 1401 (11) / 5731 (43) / 2742 (21) / 3370 (25)** | |||
| Gender: | 392 (73) | 2213 (73) NS | 9688 (73) NS | |||
| Employment: | ||||||
|
| 287 (53) / 222 (41) / 28 (5) | 1625 (54) / 962 (32) / 448 (14)** | 5546 (42)/ 6164 (42) / 1534 (12)** | |||
| Education: | ||||||
|
| 189 (35) / 182 (34) / 105 (20) / 61 (11) | 989 (33) / 775 (26) / 616 (20) / 655 (21)** | 4212 (32)/ 3821 (29) / 2860 (22)/ 2351 (18)** | |||
| Household: | ||||||
|
| 237 (44) / 101 (19) / 78 (15) 92(17) / 29 (5) | 1366 (45) / 285 (9) / 384 (13) / 517 (17) / 473 (16)** | 5007 (38) / 2547 (19) / 1454 (11) / 2530 (19) /1706 (13)** | |||
| DMT: | 86 (16) | - | - | |||
| prEDSS: , | ||||||
|
| 78 (15) / 64 (12) / 66 (12) / 33 (6) / 55 (10) / 104 (19) / 43 (8) / 12 (2) / 82 (15) | 353 (12) / 259 (9) / 257 (8) / 118 (4) / 135 (4) / 333 (11) / 165 (5)27 (1) / 1388 (46)** | 935 (7) / 656 (5) / 705 (5) / 363 (3) / 542 (4) / 1306 (10) / 868 (7) / 192 (1) / 7677 (58)** | |||
| Normalised MSIS: | Phys: | Psych: | Phys:** | Psych:** | Phys:** | Psych:** |
|
| 164 (31) / 154 (29) / 150 (28) / 53 (10) / 16 (3) | 178 (33) / 186 (35) / 122 (23) / 35 (7) / 16 (3) | 714 (24) / 586 (19) / 590 (19) / 444 (15) / 701 (23) | 588 (19) / 678 (22) / 710 (23) / 404 (15) / 655 (22) | 2218 (17) / 2281 (17) / 2622 (20) / 2667 (20) / 3456 (26) | 2259 (17) / 3021 (23) / 3238 (24) / 1871 (14) / 2885 (22) |
DMT: disease-modifying therapy; MS: multiple sclerosis; MSIS: MS Impact Score; NS: not significant; PPMS: Primary Progressive Multiple Sclerosis; prEDSS: patient-reported Expanded Disability Status Score; RRMS : Relapsing Remitting Multiple Sclerosis; SPMS: Secondary Progressive Multiple Sclerosis; UKMSR: United Kingdom MS Register.
*p<0.002,**p<0.0001.
Medical and non-medical costs included in the study.
Medical | Non-medical | |
|---|---|---|
|
|
| |
| Unplanned admissions | MSN / MSN telephone | Build downstairs extension for WC/washroom |
| Planned admissions | Physiotherapy | Build downstairs extension for bedroom |
| Outpatients | Neurology | Build downstairs extension for bedroom and en-suite facilities |
| Rehabilitation | Community district nurse | Stairlift (straight) |
| Nursing homes etc | Occupational therapy | Stairlift (more complex) |
| General practitioner | Raise electrical sockets | |
| Urology | Wheelchair (non-powered) | |
|
| Chiropody | Purchase of items to help with daily activities |
| Blood tests | Ophthalmology | Level access to shower |
| MRI scan | Clinical psychology | Convert room or downstairs WC/washroom |
| Ultrasound | Psychiatry | Lay new path |
| Lumbar puncture | Gastroenterologist | Widen doorway for wheelchair access |
| ECG | Social services | Install lighting to outside steps/path |
| CT scan | Rheumatology | Move bed to downstairs room |
| X-rays | Nephrology | Fit handrail – external |
| Gynaecology | Fit handrail – internal | |
| Speech therapy | Fit handrail to bath | |
| Medical oncology | Fit over bath shower | |
| Dietician | Create step to front/back door | |
| Continence | Create ramp to front/back door | |
| Endocrinology | Wheelchair (powered) | |
| Dermatology | Car adaptations | |
| Emergency department | ||
CT: computed tomography; ECG: electrocardiogram; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; MSN: multiple sclerosis nurse.
Figure 2.(a) The total medical and non-medical costs pp reported by people with multiple sclerosis (pwMS) (n=455) with a patient reported Expanded Disability Status Score (prEDSS) score. (b) Total medical and non-medical costs by Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS) physical (n=521) and psychological component (n=521).
Figure 3.Comparison of medical cost per patient per annum (pppa) for those with non-medical and medical costs. Excludes people who only reported a single non-medical cost for the purchase of items to help with daily activities. This has been done to eliminate small number effects.
Demographics and disease characteristics of the medical and non-medical population at baseline.
| Variable | Medical ( | Non-medical ( | ꭓ2 ( |
|---|---|---|---|
| MS type: | |||
| PP | 30 (8) | 22 (16) | 64.6 (<.00001) |
| RR | 275 (69) | 47 (34) | |
| SP | 65 (16) | 62 (45) | |
| Benign or unknown | 29 (7) | 7 (5) | |
| Employment: active / inactive / unknown, | 236 (59) / 143 (36) / 20 (8) | 51 (37) / 79 (57) / 5 (5) | 21.4 (<.00002) |
| DMT: yes, | 75 (19) | 11 (8) | 8.9 (<.003) |
| prEDSS: | |||
| 0–5 | 219 (55) | 22 (16) | 85.1 (<.0001) |
| 6 | 35 (9) | 20 (14) | |
| 6.5 | 54 (14) | 50 (36) | |
| 7 | 19 (5) | 24 (17) | |
| 8–9 | 7 (2) | 5 (4) | |
| unknown | 65 (16) | 17 (12) | |
| Normalised MSIS Phys/psych, | |||
| 0–20 | 157 (39) / 147 (37) | 7 (5) / 31 (22) | 122.0 (<.00001) /X2=36.8 (<.00001) |
| 21–40 | 129 (32) / 149 (37) | 25 (18) / 37 (27) | |
| 41–60 | 79 (20) / 70 (18) | 71 (51) / 52 (38) | |
| 61–80 | 20 (5) / 19 (5) | 33 (24) / 16 (12) | |
| unknown | 14 (4) / 14 (4) | 2 (1)/ 2 (1) | |
DMT: disease-modifying therapy; MS: multiple sclerosis; MSIS: MS Impact Score; prEDSS: patient-reported Expanded Disability Status Score.