| Literature DB >> 32016321 |
Kelly Del Tredici1, Albert C Ludolph2, Simone Feldengut1, Christian Jacob1,3, Heinz Reichmann4, Jürgen R Bohl5, Heiko Braak1.
Abstract
Although Gaucher disease can be accompanied by Lewy pathology (LP) and extrapyramidal symptoms, it is unknown if LP exists in Fabry disease (FD), another progressive multisystem lysosomal storage disorder. We aimed to elucidate the distribution patterns of FD-related inclusions and LP in the brain of a 58-year-old cognitively unimpaired male FD patient suffering from predominant hypokinesia. Immunohistochemistry (CD77, α-synuclein, collagen IV) and neuropathological staging were performed on 100-µm sections. Tissue from the enteric or peripheral nervous system was unavailable. As controls, a second cognitively unimpaired 50-year-old male FD patient without LP or motor symptoms and 3 age-matched individuals were examined. Inclusion body pathology was semiquantitatively evaluated. Although Lewy neurites/bodies were not present in the 50-year-old individual or in controls, severe neuronal loss in the substantia nigra pars compacta and LP corresponding to neuropathological stage 4 of Parkinson disease was seen in the 58-year-old FD patient. Major cerebrovascular lesions and/or additional pathologies were absent in this individual. We conclude that Lewy body disease with parkinsonism can occur within the context of FD. Further studies determining the frequencies of both inclusion pathologies in large autopsy-controlled FD cohorts could help clarify the implications of both lesions for disease pathogenesis, potential spreading mechanisms, and therapeutic interventions.Entities:
Keywords: CD77; Fabry disease; Lewy bodies/neurites; Lysosomal storage diseases; Parkinson disease; α-Galactosidase A; α-Synuclein
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32016321 PMCID: PMC7092358 DOI: 10.1093/jnen/nlz139
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Neuropathol Exp Neurol ISSN: 0022-3069 Impact factor: 3.685
Demographic and Neuropathological Data From the Cases Studied
| F/M | Age | Brain Wt | NFT | Aβ | α-Syn | APOE | Cause of Death | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FD | ||||||||
| 1 | M | 58 | 1320 | 0 | 0 | 4 | ε3/4 | Congestive heart failure |
| 2 | M | 50 | 1450 | I | 0 | 0 | NA | Ruptured basilar artery aneurysm |
| Controls | ||||||||
| 3 | M | 50 | 1315 | I | 0 | 0 | ε3/3 | Malignant neoplasm |
| 4 | M | 55 | 1425 | I | 0 | 0 | ε3/3 | Malignant neoplasm |
| 5 | M | 58 | 1300 | I | 0 | 0 | ε2/3 | Malignant neoplasm |
FD, Fabry disease; F/M, female/male; Age, age in years; Brain Wt, fresh brain weight in grams; NFT, Alzheimer disease-related neurofibrillary stages 0–VI (Gallyas silver-iodide staining) [82, 83]; Aβ, amyloid-β deposition phase 0–5 (Campbell-Switzer pyridine staining, 4G8 immunohistochemistry [83]); α-Syn, Parkinson disease-related neuropathological stages 0–6 (syn-1 immunohistochemistry [84, 85]); APOE, APOE allele status [86]; NA, not available.
Regional Distribution and Severity of Lewy Pathology in a Case With Fabry Disease
| Case | 1 | 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| aon/ob | Anterior olfactory nucleus and olfactory tract/olfactory bulb | +++/++ | − |
| dm | Dorsal motor nucleus of the vagal nerve (X) | ++ | − |
| ap | Area postrema | + | − |
| irz | Intermediate reticular zone | ++ | − |
| ro | Obscure raphe nucleus | + | − |
| rm | Great raphe nucleus | ++ | NA |
| gig | Gigantocellular nucleus of the reticular formation | ++ | NA |
| ph | Prepositus hypoglossal nucleus | ++ | NA |
| fa | Motor nucleus of the facial nerve (VII) | + | NA |
| tr | Spinal tract nucleus of the trigeminal nerve | + | NA |
| lc | Locus coeruleus | +++ | − |
| pc | Central reticular nucleus of the pons | + | − |
| dr | Dorsal raphe nucleus | +++ | − |
| cr | Central raphe nucleus | + | − |
| sn | Substantia nigra, pars compacta | +++ | − |
| pa | Paranigral nucleus | + | NA |
| pg | Pigmented parabrachial nucleus | ++ | NA |
| ppt | Pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus | +++ | − |
| oc | Oculomotor nucleus (III) | + | NA |
| ce | Central nucleus of the amygdala | + | − |
| ba | Basal nucleus of the amygdala | + | − |
| la | Lateral nucleus of the amygdala | + | − |
| ct | Cortical nucleus of the amygdala | + | NA |
| ac | Accessory cortical nucleus of the amygdala | ++ | − |
| me | Medial nucleus of the amygdala | + | − |
| db | Interstitial nucleus of the diagonal band | ++ | − |
| bn | Basal nucleus of Meynert | ++ | NA |
| so | Hypothalamic supraoptic nucleus | + | − |
| pv | Hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus | + | NA |
| tm | Hypothalamic tuberomamillary nucleus | ++ | NA |
| tl | Hypothalamic lateral tuberal nucleus | + | NA |
| in | Thalamic intralaminar nuclei | + | NA |
| rt | Reticular nucleus of the thalamus | + | NA |
| pu | Putamen | +++ | − |
| nc | Caudate nucleus | ++ | NA |
| CA2 | Ammon’s horn, second sector | + | − |
| tre | Transentorhinal cortex | + | − |
| ent | Entorhinal cortex | + | − |
| pi | Prepiriform cortex (Brodmann Area 51) | + | NA |
| ai | Agranular insular cortex, layer Vb | + | NA |
| ci | Anterior cingulate gyrus, layer Vb | + | NA |
| af | Anterolateral funiculus of the spinal cord | + | NA |
| lam 1 | Layer 1 of the spinal cord | + | NA |
| IML | Intermediolateral nucleus (layer 7) of the spinal cord | + | NA |
The pathology was assessed semiquantitatively: − absent or not detectable; + slight; ++ moderate; +++ severe. Only regions that displayed Lewy pathology are shown. For accompanying heat maps, see Supplementary Data Tables.
NA, not available.
Regional Distribution and Severity of Fabry Disease Intraneuronal CD77-Positive Gb3 Inclusions in 2 Cases
| Case | 1 | 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| olf | Olfactory bulb/tract | − | − |
| dm | Dorsal motor nucleus of the glossopharyngeal and vagal nerves (IX/X) | +++ | ++ |
| am | Ambiguus nucleus | + | + |
| irz | Intermediate reticular zone | ++ | + |
| io | Inferior olivary complex | + | ++ |
| hn | Motor nucleus of the hypoglossal nerve (XII) | + | + |
| rm | Great raphe nucleus | + | NA |
| gig | Gigantocellular nucleus of the reticular formation | + | NA |
| ph | Prepositus hypoglossal nucleus | +++ | NA |
| su | Subventricular nucleus | + | NA |
| fa | Motor nucleus of the facial nerve (VII) | +++ | NA |
| pc | Central reticular nucleus of the pons | ++ | NA |
| tri | Motor nucleus of the trigeminal nerve (V) | +++ | NA |
| dr | Dorsal raphe (supratrochlear) nucleus | +++ | − |
| sn | Substantia nigra, pars compacta & pars reticulata | + | − |
| pa | Paranigral nucleus | + | NA |
| pg | Pigmented parabrachial nucleus | ++ | NA |
| ppt | Pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus | + | NA |
| tro | Trochlear nucleus (IV) | + | NA |
| ce | Central nucleus of the amygdala | +++ | NA |
| ba | Basal nucleus of the amygdala | +++ | ++ |
| la | Lateral nucleus of the amygdala | + | − |
| ct | Cortical nucleus of the amygdala | ++ | NA |
| ac | Accessory cortical nucleus of the amygdala | +++ | +++ |
| db | Interstitial nucleus of the diagonal band | + | + |
| bn | Basal nucleus of Meynert | + | NA |
| ts | Bed nucleus of the terminal stria | ++ | NA |
| so | Hypothalamic supraoptic nucleus | +++ | +++ |
| pv | Hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus | +++ | NA |
| CA4 | Ammon’s horn, fourth sector | (+) | − |
| pro | Prosubiculum | +++ | +++ |
| tre | Transentorhinal region layer pri-β | +++ | NA |
| ent | Entorhinal region layer pri-β | +++ | + |
| pi | Prepiriform cortex (Brodmann Area 51) | +++ | NA |
| mol | Cajal-Retzius cells in the molecular layer between the dentate fascia and Ammon’s horn on both sides of the hippocampal fissure | +++ | NA |
| fu | Fusiform gyrus, layers I and Vb | +++ | NA |
| it | Inferior temporal gyrus, layer Vb | +++ | NA |
| mt | Medial temporal gyrus, layer Vb | + | NA |
| st | Superior temporal gyrus, layer Vb | + | + |
| in | Insula | +++ | NA |
| ai | Agranular insular cortex, layer I Cajal-Retzius cells | ++ | NA |
| ci | Anterior cingulate gyrus, layer I Cajal-Retzius cells | ++ | NA |
| pm | Primary motor area Betz cells (Brodmann Area 4) | (+) | NA |
| vis | Primary visual cortex, layer I Cajal-Retzius cells (Brodmann Area 17) | + | NA |
| vh | Spinal cord ventral horn α-motoneurons (layer 9) | + | NA |
| IML | Intermediolateral nucleus (layer 7) | ++ | NA |
The pathology was assessed semiquantitatively: −, absent or not detectable; +, slight; ++, moderate; +++, severe. Only regions with CD77-positivity are shown. For accompanying heat map, see Supplementary Data Table.
NA, not available.
Regional Distribution and Severity of Fabry Disease Astrocytic CD77-Positive Gb3 Inclusions in 2 Cases
| Case | 1 | 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| olf | Olfactory bulb/tract | +++ | + |
| dm | Dorsal motor nucleus of the glossopharyngeal and vagal nerves (IX/X) | ++ | + |
| ap | Area postrema | ++ | ++ |
| ge | Gelatinosus nucleus | ++ | NA |
| io | Inferior olivary complex | + | + |
| fL | Subependyma close to the foramen of Luschka (fourth ventricle) | +++ | NA |
| ts | Subependyma along anterior horn of lateral ventricle, medially from bed nucleus of the terminal stria | +++ | NA |
|
| Fornix | ++ | NA |
| CA1 | Alveus of CA1 | +++ | ++ |
| ep | Subependyma along posterior horn of lateral ventricle | +++ | − |
| pur | Bergman glia in the molecular and Purkinje cell layers of the cerebellum | + | − |
| vh | Spinal cord ventral horn α-motoneurons (layer 9) | + | NA |
| dh | Spinal cord dorsal horn (layers 1 and 2) | + | NA |
The pathology was assessed semiquantitatively: −, absent or not detectable; +, slight; ++, moderate; +++, severe. Only regions with CD77-positivity are shown. For accompanying heat map, see Supplementary Data Table.
NA, not available.
FIGURE 1.CD77-immunopositive intraneuronal inclusions in a 58-year-old male with Fabry disease. (A) Gb3 accumulations (DAB, brown chromogen) occurred chiefly in nerve cells of the superficial cellular layers (II and IIIa) and deep layer (V) of the prepiriform cortex (Brodmann Area 51). The afferents to this area originate in the olfactory bulb, retrobulbar region, olfactory tubercle, septal region, amygdala, orbitofrontal cortex, and contralateral piriform cortex. The connectivity of the piriform cortex indicates its role as a link between the olfactory and limbic system. Also detectable in this micrograph, upon closer inspection, in the upper and lower cellular layers is syn-1-immunopositive Lewy pathology (SK-4700, dark blue chromogen). (B) Gb3 inclusions in nerve cells of the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagal nerve and in astrocytes of the area postrema (ap) of the glossopharygeus-vagus nuclear complex. In addition, Lewy pathology (LP) was present in the somata and cellular processes of nerve cells in the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagal nerve (SK-4700). (C) The prepositus hypoglossal nucleus also displayed Gb3 inclusions (DAB) and LP (SK-4700). A few nerve cells in the subventricular nucleus (su) were also CD77-positive. (D) Gb3 accumulation in motoneurons (DAB) of the motor nucleus of the facial nucleus accompanied by Lewy neurites (dark blue chromogen) and extraneuronal remnants of Gb3 (arrow) marking cell loss (E) there. (F) CD77 immunoreactivity (DAB) in nerve cells of the cortical accessory nucleus of the amgydala. (G) Gb3 inclusions (DAB) in nerve cells of the cholinergic nucleus of the diagonal band (similar pathology was also present in the basal nucleus of Meynert and bed nucleus of the terminal stria of the same case). (H) Severe intraneuronal Gb3 pathology in the prosubiculum. Immunonegative portions below the wave-shaped prosubiculum belong to pyramidal layers of the subiculum. Immunoreactions: CD77 (DAB, brown chromogen) or CD77 (DAB) plus syn-1 (SK-4700, dark blue chromogen) in 100 µm sections. Scale bar in (A) applies to (B), (C), (F), and (G).
FIGURE 2.CD77-immunopositive intraneuronal inclusions (continued), CD77-immunopositive astrocytic and vascular inclusions in a 58-year-old male with Fabry disease. (A) Cajal-Retzius cells in layer I of the anterior cingulate gyrus contained Gb3 accumulations (DAB, brown chromogen). Framed area is shown at higher magnification in panel (B). (C) Detail of SMI-311-immunopositive Cajal-Retzius cell in the molecular layer located between the dentate fascia and sector CA1 close to the obliterated hippocampal fissure. (D) Overview showing CD77-positive (DAB) pyramidal cells in layers I and Vb of the fusiform gyrus. (E) Intensely CD77-immunoreactive astrocytes in the hypothalamus and, to a considerably lesser extent, in the fornix (fo). (F) Gb3 (CD77) deposits (DAB, brown chromogen) in a vessel wall close to the lateral ventricle surrounded by intensely CD77-positive astrocytes. (G) Tortuous vessels and an infarction marked by puckering of the capillary network (collagen IV) in the subiculum (DAB, brown chromogen, plus erythrosin-phosphotungstic acid-aniline blue staining) (96). Immunoreactions: CD77 (DAB) or, in (G), collagen IV with EPA staining in 100 µm sections. Scale bar in (A) applies to (D), (E), and (G). Scale bar in (B) is also valid for (F).
FIGURE 3.α-Synuclein-immunopositive Lewy neurites and Lewy bodies in a 58-year-old male with Fabry disease. (A) In the olfactory bulb, syn-1 immunoreactive LP (SK-4700, dark blue chromogen) occurred in the olfactory tract and anterior olfactory nucleus, and numerous CD77-positive (DAB, brown chromogen) astrocytes were present. Framed area is shown at higher magnification in panel (B). (C) Micrograph of LP and cell loss in the locus coeruleus. (D) LP (SK-4700) accompanied by very severe cell loss in the pars compacta of the substantia nigra (at left); noncatecholaminergic nerve cells within the paranigral nucleus (at right) were CD77-immunopositive (DAB) and accompanied by fewer LP-containing catecholaminergic neurons than the pars compacta. (E) Lewy bodies/neurites (SK-4700) in the somatomotor system tegmental pedunculopontine nucleus. (F) LP (SK-4700) in axons of the vagal nerve in the medulla oblongata (intermediate reticular zone), a finding identical to that seen in the medulla of individuals with Parkinson’s disease. Immunoreactions: CD77 or CD77 plus syn-1 in 100 µm sections. Scale bar in (E) applies to (A), (C), and (D). Scale bar in (F) is also valid for (B).
FIGURE 4.α-Synuclein-immunopositive Lewy neurites/bodies and CD77-immunopositive intraneuronal inclusions (continued) in a 58-year-old male Fabry patient. (A) The great raphe nucleus (at right) and gigantocellular reticular nucleus (at left): Gb2 inclusions (DAB, brown chromogen) and more numerous Lewy bodies/neurites (SK-4700, dark blue chromogen) in the reticular formation. (B) LP in the accessory cortical (olfactory) nucleus of the amygdala. (C) LP in the tuberomamillary nucleus of the hypothalamus (fo, fornix). (D, E) Isolated ballooned CD77-immunopositive nerve cells were also syn-1-positive, for example, here, in the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagal nerve (arrow in D, compare the Lewy body at left) and in a motoneuron in the motor nucleus of the facial nerve (arrow in E, compare the Lewy neurite and CD77-positive cell at left). In micrograph E, syn-1-positive extraneuronal remnants faintly positive for CD77 (lower left) mark the place where cell loss has occurred. (F) Note the syn-1 (here, DAB)-immunoreactive axons of the medullary portion of the vagal nerve at the point where axons exit the lower brainstem (lower right) to the periphery. Immunoreactions: Syn-1 except for micrographs (A), (D), and (E) (CD77 plus syn-1 double immunohistochemistry) in 100 µm sections. Scale bar in (A) applies to (C). Scale bar in (F) is also valid for (B); bar in (D) applies to (E).