José Augusto Berrocal1,2, G Henrieke Heideman1, Bas F M de Waal2, Mihaela Enache3, Remco W A Havenith1,3,4, Meike Stöhr3, E W Meijer2, Ben L Feringa1,3. 1. Stratingh Institute for Chemistry , University of Groningen , Nijenborgh 4 , 9747 AG Groningen , The Netherlands. 2. Institute for Complex Molecular Systems and Laboratory of Macromolecular and Organic Chemistry , Eindhoven University of Technology , 5600 MB Eindhoven , The Netherlands. 3. Zernike Institute for Advanced Materials , University of Groningen , Nijenborgh 4 , 9747 AG Groningen , The Netherlands. 4. Department of Inorganic and Physical Chemistry , Ghent University , Krijgslaan 281 (S3) , B-9000 Gent , Belgium.
Abstract
Achieving long-range order with surface-supported supramolecular assemblies is one of the pressing challenges in the prospering field of non-covalent surface functionalization. Having access to defect-free on-surface molecular assemblies will pave the way for various nanotechnology applications. Here we report the synthesis of two libraries of naphthalenediimides (NDIs) symmetrically functionalized with long aliphatic chains (C28 and C33) and their self-assembly at the 1-phenyloctane/highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (1-PO/HOPG) interface. The two NDI libraries differ by the presence/absence of an internal double bond in each aliphatic chain (unsaturated and saturated compounds, respectively). All molecules assemble into lamellar arrangements, with the NDI cores lying flat and forming 1D rows on the surface, while the carbon chains separate the 1D rows from each other. Importantly, the presence of the unsaturation plays a dominant role in the arrangement of the aliphatic chains, as it exclusively favors interdigitation. The fully saturated tails, instead, self-assemble into a combination of either interdigitated or non-interdigitated diagonal arrangements. This difference in packing is spectacularly amplified at the whole surface level and results in almost defect-free self-assembled monolayers for the unsaturated compounds. In contrast, the monolayers of the saturated counterparts are globally disordered, even though they locally preserve the lamellar arrangements. The experimental observations are supported by computational studies and are rationalized in terms of stronger van der Waals interactions in the case of the unsaturated compounds. Our investigation reveals the paramount role played by internal double bonds on the self-assembly of discrete large molecules at the liquid/solid interface.
Achieving long-range order with surface-supported supramolecular assemblies is one of the pressing challenges in the prospering field of non-covalent surface functionalization. Having access to defect-free on-surface molecular assemblies will pave the way for various nanotechnology applications. Here we report the synthesis of two libraries of naphthalenediimides (NDIs) symmetrically functionalized with long aliphatic chains (C28 and C33) and their self-assembly at the 1-phenyloctane/highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (1-PO/HOPG) interface. The two NDI libraries differ by the presence/absence of an internal double bond in each aliphatic chain (unsaturated and saturated compounds, respectively). All molecules assemble into lamellar arrangements, with the NDI cores lying flat and forming 1D rows on the surface, while the carbon chains separate the 1D rows from each other. Importantly, the presence of the unsaturation plays a dominant role in the arrangement of the aliphatic chains, as it exclusively favors interdigitation. The fully saturated tails, instead, self-assemble into a combination of either interdigitated or non-interdigitated diagonal arrangements. This difference in packing is spectacularly amplified at the whole surface level and results in almost defect-free self-assembled monolayers for the unsaturated compounds. In contrast, the monolayers of the saturated counterparts are globally disordered, even though they locally preserve the lamellar arrangements. The experimental observations are supported by computational studies and are rationalized in terms of stronger van der Waals interactions in the case of the unsaturated compounds. Our investigation reveals the paramount role played by internal double bonds on the self-assembly of discrete large molecules at the liquid/solid interface.
The non-covalent functionalization
of surfaces has become one of
the pillars of nanotechnology in the past 20 years.[1−4] Achieving exact control over the
formation of monolayers allows scientists to modulate the properties
of surfaces in a predictable manner,[5] which
holds promise for relevant technological breakthroughs.[6−8] For instance, controlling the density of nitrogen-based n-dopants
onn class="Chemical">graphene via monolayer formation has proved to play a pivotal role
in tuning the charge carrier concentration of the modified 2D material.[9]
Surface-supported supramolecular
assemblies rely on stabilizing
interactions between the adsorbed molecules and the surface, as well
as favorable intermolecular interactions between the adsorbed compounds.[10,11] Given the significant epitaxial stabilization of 64 meV (1.5 kcal/mol) per methylene unit that highly oriented pyrolytic graphite
(HOPG) exerts at the liquid/HOPG interface, the molecular designs
typically adopted in the field feature long alkyl chains—usually
up to 18 carbon atoms—to favor adsorption to the substrate.[12,13] Previous work on long-chain alkanes[14−17] highlighted the tendency of long
aliphatic tails to form thermodynamically stable self-assembled monolayers.
Moreover, a number of studies have highlighted the role played by
the alkyl chains in the 2D structure.[18−23] While a favorable interaction between the molecules and the substrate
is certainly necessary, the structure and extent of order of the assemblies
generated are mostly the manifestation of the intermolecular interactions
between the adsorbed molecules.[10,13] On-surface supramolecular
assemblies are typically created by resorting to non-covalent forces,
such as van der Waals (vdW) interactions,[24] hydrogen bonding (HB),[25−32] coordination chemistries,[33−36] and halogen bonding.[37,38] So far, various
approaches focused on limiting the number of domain boundaries and/or
molecular defects to improve the organization and quality of the 2D
architectures generated.[39−41] More recently, spatially confining
the self-assembly process into nanocorrals created on HOPG afforded
impressive results in terms of order.[42] However, the defect-free engineering of surface-supported supramolecular
assemblies on unconfined HOPG remains a major challenge for the whole
field.[43]Given the high commercial
availability of alkylating reagents in
the C1–C22 range, a large body of work
has been carried out using alkyl chain-functionalized compounds. To
the best of our knowledge, however, the attention dedicated to their
unsaturated analogues featuring internal double bonds has been very
limited. Deng et al. compared the assemblies of E-oleic acid and Z-oleylamine at the 1-phenyloctane
(1-PO)/HOPG interface.[44] Monolayers obtained
from E-oleic acid at the 1-PO/HOPG interface were
characterized by a high stability, while those deriving from the amine
with Z-configuration were poorly stable.[44] This comparative study[44] was consistent in terms of chain length (oleyl = C18)
and double bond position (between carbon atoms 9 and 10), but the
two structures investigated differed in double bond configurations
(E vs Z) and end-group functionalities
(carboxylic vs amino). The hypothesis that various parameters could
play a role in the overall stability of the on-surface assemblies
could not be ruled out. More recently, Shokri et al. suggested that
the introduction of a Z-configured double bond in
the side chains of bis(urea) molecules leads to the formation of long-range
ordered polymers on graphite.[45] However,
the study was conducted with one chain length only (C18), and the influence of the internal double bond was visible only
after storage of the modified surface for 1 year.[45] Although both studies independently posed the question
of the influence of internal double bonds on on-surface self-assembly
processes, no further investigations followed in this direction.Intrigued by the chance to unravel the possible influence of internal
double bonds on surface-supported supramolecular assemblies,
we envisioned a system based on long carbon chains featuring internal
double bonds symmetrically bound at the periphery of naphthalenediimides[46] (NDIs). NDIs are electron poor[46] and have a pronounced tendency to be deposited at the liquid/HOPG
interface due to a highly favorable enthalpy of interaction.[47,48] Symmetrical NDIs functionalized with fully hydrogenated, linear
alkyl chains (C-NDI-C design) with a number of carbon atoms (n)
in the 3–18 range were previously investigated at the 1-tetradecane/HOPG
interface.[47] Particularly relevant for
the present work, alkyl chains with a number of carbon atoms equal
to or greater than 13 units consistently afforded lamellar arrangements
in which both the long carbon chains and aromatic cores lie flat on
the surface, as visualized with scanning tunneling microscopy (STM).[47] The morphology of the obtained monolayers was
explained (lamellar), but the larger long-range-ordered areas obtained
represented only a limited part of the surface (50 nm × 50 nm).
In order to exploit the potential of supramolecular assemblies
on surfaces, ordered areas larger than 100 nm × 100 nm (at least)
are highly desirable.[43] Relying on the
consistency of the C-NDI-C design with n > 13 (lamellar
arrangement),
we hypothesized that extending the carbon chain length in the C-NDI-C design
would be beneficial for expanding the order extent. Moreover, to answer
the key question about the role of the internal double bonds, we envisioned
a C-NDI-C system that features internal unsaturations in the carbon chain.
Reducing these double bonds by catalytic hydrogenation should offer
the possibility to compare compounds that belong to a very consistent
molecular platform (long-chain NDIs) but that differ by a subtle structural
modification (formally two hydrogen molecules).We present the
synthesis and on-surface investigation of uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC (unsaturated NDIs) and compare
them to their hydrogenated counterparts C-NDI-C and C-NDI-C (saturated NDIs). The fully extended chemical structures are
shown in Chart . The
studied NDIs feature either 28 or 33 carbon atoms in the linear chain
(C28 and C33, respectively) and only differ
by the presence/absence of one unsaturation in each carbon chain.
The unsaturation (when present) is highlighted by the letter u. The key synthetic intermediates in the preparation of the
final compounds were the unsaturated amines uC-NH and uC-NH, also shown in Chart . We discover that the self-assembled monolayers obtained
at the 1-PO/HOPG interface from the unsaturated compounds are characterized
by a significantly higher degree of organization compared to their
saturated counterparts, with a size difference for ordered domains
corresponding to thousands of squared nanometers. The experimental
results are supported by computational studies. Our results point
to the establishment of the internal double bond as a counterintuitive
yet key structural element for obtaining long-range order in self-assembled
monolayers at the liquid/solid interface. Finally, the highly adaptive
character of supramolecular assemblies at the liquid/solid interface[49] allows for the use of mixtures of EE, EZ, and ZZ isomers of the unsaturated
NDIs, as the system selects the most stable pattern created (almost
exclusively) by one stereoisomer.
Chart 1
Fully Extended Chemical Structures
of uC, uCC, C,
and Key Synthetic Intermediates uC and uC
Results and Discussion
Synthesis and Characterization
Compounds uC-NH and uC-NH (Chart ) were the key intermediates
in the preparation
of the target NDIs. They were synthesized from building blocks 1,[50]2, and 3 in 67% and 40% yield, respectively, applying a strategy
based on Wittig olefination (Scheme ). Details on the preparation of 2 and 3 are presented in the Supporting Information (SI). The amines were obtained as an ∼84:16 mixture
of non-separable Z and E isomers,
respectively (assigned by integration of the 13C NMR spectra,
see SI). The preference for the Z-configuration of the double bond is in line with the Wittig
olefination conditions adopted, especially with the use of non-stabilized
phosphonium ylides.[51] The position of the
unsaturation along the two carbon chains (between C6 and
C7 in uC, and C11 and C12 in uC) was exactly engineered, as will be corroborated by our STM
study (vide infra). The choice of the base-induced
Wittig reaction for the elongation step implied a careful choice of
protecting groups for the amino moieties on the phosphonium salts.
We opted for tert-butyloxycarbonyl- (Boc) and phthalimide-
(Phth) protected 2 and 3 for uC-NH and uC-NH, respectively, after an initial
screening of the reaction conditions. A related approach for obtaining
discrete oligoethylenes (C ≤ 400)
was previously reported in the effort to build model compounds to
study the crystallization of polyethylene.[52,53] Being complementary, our synthesis allows for the introduction of
functional groups in the linear moieties, expanding the applicability
of these long aliphatic chains. The cleavage of the -Boc and -Phth
protecting groups was carried out with trifluoroacetic acid (TFA)
and methylamine solution in ethanol (33 wt%), respectively (experimental
details in SI).
Scheme 1
Synthesis of uC and uC
The unsaturated amines
were subsequently coupled to commercially
available naphthalenedianhydride (NDA) via a modified microwave
assisted protocol (Scheme ).[54−56] The unsaturated NDIs uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC were obtained in 71% and 80% yield, respectively, as non-resolvable
mixtures of ZZ:ZE:EE isomers (∼70.5:27:2.5, based on the possible combinations
of the two reacting amines) after chromatographic purification. The
fully saturated analogs C-NDI-C and C-NDI-C were
prepared from their alkenyl counterparts by palladium-on-carbon (Pd/C)-catalyzed
hydrogenation in ethyl valerate at 100 °C (Scheme ) and purified by Soxhlet extraction (see SI).
Scheme 2
Synthesis of uC, uC, C, and C
Self-Assembly on HOPG
We started our investigation
by studying the self-assembly of saturated C-NDI-C and C-NDI-C at the 1-PO/HOPG interface. Solutions of the two NDIs (0.4
mg/mL in 1-PO) were drop-cast at 100 °C onto freshly cleaved
HOPG substrates and subsequently imaged. The saturated compounds spontaneously
self-assembled into ordered lamellae immediately after deposition.
In the STM images, the aromatic cores appear as bright protrusions
and the alkyl chains as dark regions (Figure a–d). The lamellar packings are consistent
with the aromatic cores lying flat and next to each other on the surface,
while the alkyl chains are straight and parallel to each other and
modulate the distance between the NDI cores (Figure a,c).[47] The arrangement
of the individual alkyl chains was determined from high-resolution
STM images. We could identify two different packing modes for the
aliphatic chains of C-NDI-C (Figure b) and C-NDI-C (Figure d): an interdigitated mode,
hereby defined as “lamellar phase A”, and a non-interdigitated
diagonal mode, denominated “lamellar phase B”. A pictorial
representation of both lamellar phases A and B is given in Figure e. The lamellae are
rotated by 60° with respect to each another. The observation
of the two different packing modes of the aliphatic chains is in line
with previous reports on C-NDI-C, with 13 ≤ n ≤
18.[47] In this respect, extending the length
of the alkyl chains did not result in significant differences compared
to previous studies.
Figure 1
Self-assembly of C and C at the
1-phenyloctane/HOPG
interface. (a) STM image of C (40 nm × 40 nm, Vtip = 1
V, Iset = 50 pA). (b) STM image of C showing the two arrangements
of alkyl chains (phase A and phase B) (10 nm × 10 nm, Vtip = 1 V, Iset =
50 pA). (c) STM image of C (40 nm × 40 nm, Vtip = −0.6
V, Iset = 50 pA). (d) STM image of C showing the two arrangements
of alkyl chains (phase A and phase B) (10 nm × 10 nm, Vtip = 0.6 V, Iset = 150 pA). (e) Schematic representation of lamellar phase A (with
interdigitation of the alkyl chain) and phase B (no interdigitation,
diagonal organization of the alkyl chains).
Self-assembly of C and C at the
1-phenyloctane/HOPG
interface. (a) STM image of C (40 nm × 40 nm, Vtip = 1
V, Iset = 50 pA). (b) STM image of C showing the two arrangements
of alkyl chains (phase A and phase B) (10 nm × 10 nm, Vtip = 1 V, Iset =
50 pA). (c) STM image of C (40 nm × 40 nm, Vtip = −0.6
V, Iset = 50 pA). (d) STM image of C showing the two arrangements
of alkyl chains (phase A and phase B) (10 nm × 10 nm, Vtip = 0.6 V, Iset = 150 pA). (e) Schematic representation of lamellar phase A (with
interdigitation of the alkyl chain) and phase B (no interdigitation,
diagonal organization of the alkyl chains).The unit cell parameters determined for C-NDI-C and C-NDI-C are listed in Table , while for a visualization of the unit cell we refer to Figure and the discussion
further on. Although the two lamellar assemblies differ in the orientation
of the aliphatic chains, the unit cell parameters do not differ for
a fixed alkyl chain length. The measured value are a = 4.45 ± 0.24 nm, b = 0.88 ± 0.08 nm,
and γ = 85.21 ± 3.39° for C-NDI-C, and a = 5.29 ± 0.49 nm, b = 0.99 ±
0.10 nm, and γ = 84.10 ± 5.28° for C-NDI-C.
Table 1
Unit Cell Parameters for the Supramolecular
Arrangements of C, uC, C, and uC at the 1-PO/HOPG Interfacea
compound
a [nm]
b [nm]
γ [deg]
lamellar
phase
domain size
average [nm2]
domain size
median [nm2]
disordered
areas [%]
C28-NDI-C28
4.45 ± 0.24
0.88 ± 0.08
85.21 ± 3.39
A and B
949
737
26 ± 5
uC28-NDI-uC28
4.53 ± 0.08
0.86 ± 0.10
87.33 ± 1.78
A
6764
2923
–
C33-NDI-C33
5.29 ± 0.49
0.99 ± 0.10
84.10 ± 5.28
A and B
1268
540
24 ± 8
uC33-NDI-uC33
5.27 ± 0.08
0.94 ± 0.06
84.93 ± 1.80
A
8026
3684
–
The lengths
of the unit cell
vectors are labeled a and b, and
the internal angle is specified by γ (see also Figure a,b).
Figure 5
(a) Optimized
geometries for phase A of (a) C and (b) uC adsorbed
on a graphene surface. The black rectangle
shows the unit cells. The orange ellipses show the positions of the
double bonds within the NDIs. Hydrogen, carbon, oxygen, and nitrogen
atoms are shown in white, gray, red, and blue, respectively. The graphene
layer is shown in cyan. The unit cell parameters a, b, and γ are marked in magenta. (c) Single
molecule in lamellar phase A geometry (top) and simulated STM image
(bottom, black and white image) at −1 V for C. (d) Single molecule in lamellar phase
A geometry (top) and simulated STM image (bottom, black and white
image) at −1 V for uC.
The lengths
of the unit cell
vectors are labeled a and b, and
the internal angle is specified by γ (see also Figure a,b).Next, we focused on unsaturated uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC at the 1-PO/HOPG interface under similar
experimental conditions.
Exemplary images are shown in Figure . Assemblies similar to the ones obtained for the saturated
NDIs were observed with uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC. The lamellar arrangements correspond to parallel NDI cores flat
on the surface (bright protrusions) and the interdigitating aliphatic
chains that tune the distance between them (dark regions) (Figure a for uC-NDI-uC, and Figure b for uC-NDI-uC). In stark contrast with the saturated
NDIs, additional bright protrusions were observed in the STM images
of uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC (orange arrows in Figure a,b). They appeared
symmetrically with respect to the aromatic cores, and their distance
to the aromatic cores changed upon extending the chain length. These
features were less evident in the case of uC-NDI-uC (Figure a), while they appeared
more separated and resolved in the case of uC-NDI-uC (Figure b). We attribute
these additional bright protrusions to the double bonds present in
the unsaturated chains. As a general remark, the imaging of the double
bonds was in general easier for uC-NDI-uC than uC-NDI-uC. Such behavior is attributed to the structural differences
between the two molecules and corroborates the more remote position
of the double bond with respect to the NDI core in uC-NDI-uC (between C11 and C12) compared to uC-NDI-uC (between C6 and C7).
Figure 2
Self-assembly
of uC and uC at the 1-phenyloctane/HOPG
interface. (a) STM image of uC (20 nm × 20 nm, Vtip = 1
V, Iset = 100 pA). (b) STM image of uC (20 nm × 20 nm, Vtip = 1 V, Iset =
90 pA). The double bonds appear as bright protrusions next to the
bright NDI cores (orange arrows). Both unsaturated molecules assemble
in an interdigitated fashion (phase A).
Self-assembly
of uC and uC at the 1-phenyloctane/HOPG
interface. (a) STM image of uC (20 nm × 20 nm, Vtip = 1
V, Iset = 100 pA). (b) STM image of uC (20 nm × 20 nm, Vtip = 1 V, Iset =
90 pA). The double bonds appear as bright protrusions next to the
bright NDI cores (orange arrows). Both unsaturated molecules assemble
in an interdigitated fashion (phase A).The determined unit cell parameters for uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC are reported in Table . The values are very similar to those obtained for
the saturated counterparts, pointing to an apparent similarity between
the assemblies of saturated and unsaturated NDIs. The close resemblance
of the unit cell parameters of the NDIs with the same chain length
(C28 or C33) strongly suggests that the self-assembled
monolayers are mostly formed by all-E-configured
molecules. The E-configured carbon chains are expected
to assume zigzag conformations on HOPG in a very similar fashion to
alkyl chains and hence cover distances comparable to their saturated
counterparts (C28 and C33). The Z-configured chains, instead, should differ in distance, as the Z-configuration forces a bending of the carbon which cannot
be compensated by a rotation around the double bond (forbidden in
this case). As an indicative example, the carbon chain of Z-oleylamine shows this bending as a consequence of
the fixed configuration of the double bond.[44] The deposition of mainly EE-isomer is remarkable,
since this isomer is calculated to be roughly 2.5% of the whole population
of unsaturated NDIs (based on the 13C NMR analysis of uCNH and uCNH and the binomial distributions of the two
amines). The remaining 97.5% of the material, which accounts for the EZ- and ZZ-isomers, remains in the overlying
liquid phase and is not imaged. We conclude that our long-chain NDIs
system at the 1-PO/HOPG interface is highly dynamic and adaptive.
Such characteristic allows for the use of EE-, EZ-, and ZZ-isomers mixtures because the
system autonomously selects the isomer that forms the most stable
pattern on the surface—the EE-isomer in this
case. A similar concept has been recently reported by Samorì,
Lehn, et al. with on-surface bisimine formation.[49] It should be noted that some Z-configured double bonds
were present in the monolayer and we speculate that these are responsible
for the tiny defects and irregularities observed in the monolayers.
Pivotal Role of the Internal Double Bonds in the 2D Crystallization
The results presented so far have apparently revealed only minor
differences in the self-assembly of both saturated and unsaturated
NDIs at the 1-PO/HOPG interface. However, a very important difference
arises in the organization of the aliphatic chains: the fully saturated
ones simultaneously arrange in either phase A or B, while the unsaturated
chains only pack in the phase A fashion. This difference does not
alter the local ordering of the self-assembled monolayer,
but has dramatic repercussions on the global ordering
of the 2D architectures. The presence of just one type of self-assembly
arrangement (phase A) for the carbon chains of uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC results in considerably increased domain
sizes and thus, in a reduction of the number of domains per area compared
to those created by their saturated counterparts. The contrast is
striking: for large-scale images, very large domains and significantly
less defects are observed in the STM images of uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC (Figure b,d, respectively) compared to those of C-NDI-C and C-NDI-C (Figure a,c, respectively).
Figure 3
Large-scale STM images (300 nm ×
300 nm) of different NDIs
at the 1-PO/HOPG interface: (a) C (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA), (b) uC (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 80 pA), (c) C (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA), and (d) uC (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA).
Large-scale STM images (300 nm ×
300 nm) of different NDIs
at the 1-PO/HOPG interface: (a) C (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA), (b) uC (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 80 pA), (c) C (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA), and (d) uC (Vtip = 1 V, Iset = 100 pA).The different position of the double bonds in uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC does not seem to play a role, considering
the very similar behavior (Figure b,d). Results obtained on a positional isomer of uC-NDI-uC with the double bond located between carbon atoms
11 and 12 also rule out a positional influence of the unsaturation
(see SI). In contrast, the overview STM
images of the saturated NDIs are characterized by relatively small
domains accompanied by disordered areas. The lack of a clear preference
for either lamellar phase A or B arrangements seems to cause the existence
of disordered regions and welter areas (Figure a,c; see SI for
the assignment of disordered areas).We conducted a statistical
analysis on the domain sizes for the
different NDIs to support the qualitative observation on the dramatic
influence of the internal double bonds. For a detailed description
on the assignment of the domain size and further experimental observations
upon scanning see the SI. The results on
the domain size distributions for C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC, and C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC, are summarized
by the two histograms shown in Figure . The saturated NDIs mainly arrange in relatively small
domains (≤1000 nm2) (Figure a and 4b, blue columns).
Moreover, on roughly 24% of the surface, the molecules do not arrange
in an ordered way resulting in disordered areas. On the other hand,
the images of the unsaturated NDIs show only a marginal amount of
disordered areas. The observed domains reach much larger extensions,
with a significant population larger than 15000 nm2 (Figure a,b, orange columns).
Figure 4
Domain
size distribution for (a) C (blue) and uC (orange), and (b) C (blue) and uC (orange). Y-axis: percentage of ordered
domains (% of domains); X-axis: domain size (103 nm2).
Domain
size distribution for (a) C (blue) and uC (orange), and (b) C (blue) and uC (orange). Y-axis: percentage of ordered
domains (% of domains); X-axis: domain size (103 nm2).The experimental results were rationalized by means of a computational
study (for computational details see SI). For consistency with our experimental observations on the self-assembled
monolayers, we studied only alkenes with E-configurations.
Our working hypothesis focused on the increasing strength of van der
Waals interchain interactions upon introducing internal double bonds
in the carbon chains. Initial studies on shorter carbon chains (C6) in the gas phase showed a promising trend in this respect
(see SI). Periodic energy decomposition
analysis (PEDA)[57] revealed that the interaction
energy between neighboring chains becomes more favorable upon introducing
the internal double bonds (Figure S41 and Table S1). Encouraged by these results, we focused on both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC in the lamellar A organization. In the
calculated molecular arrangements, the NDI cores lay flat and next
to each other while the carbon chains interdigitate, in line with
the experimental observations (Figure a for C-NDI-C, and Figure b for uC-NDI-uC). The distance between the hydrogen atoms
of the aromatic C–H and the oxygen atoms of the neighboring
imide moieties amounts to 2.5 Å for both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC, in line with the literature.[47] This allows for unconventional hydrogen bonding interactions
between adjacent NDI cores, which stabilize the molecular arrangement.
Unconventional hydrogen bonding may additionally occur between the
oxygen atoms of the imide moieties and the terminal methyl groups
of the interdigitating chains from the adjacent row of NDIs for both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC. The H–O distance varies in the
2.6–3 Å range in this case. The calculated unit cell values
are a = 44.8 Å, b = 8.5 Å,
and γ = 90° for C-NDI-C, and a = 44.5 Å, b = 8.5 Å, and γ = 90°
for uC-NDI-uC, nicely matching with the experimental values
(Table ). This further
confirmed the accuracy of the computational study. Finally, we compared
the adsorption energies for both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC in the lamellar phase A arrangement on graphene. Assemblies
of C-NDI-C adsorbed on graphene were 0.166 eV (3.83 kcal/mol)
per molecule energetically more favorable than those of uC-NDI-uC. However, the experimental observation of improved long-range
order with uC-NDI-uC compared to C-NDI-C and the stronger
van der Waals interchain interactions between unsaturated C6 carbon chains (Figure S41 and Table S1) clearly point to more favorable intermolecular interactions in
the case of uC-NDI-uC. Considering that the unconventional hydrogen
bonding occurring in the calculated lamellar phases of C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC should be very similar, if not identical,
from the energetic point of view, we can only ascribe such “more
favorable intermolecular interactions” to van der Waals forces.(a) Optimized
geometries for phase A of (a) C and (b) uC adsorbed
on a graphene surface. The black rectangle
shows the unit cells. The orange ellipses show the positions of the
double bonds within the NDIs. Hydrogen, carbon, oxygen, and nitrogen
atoms are shown in white, gray, red, and blue, respectively. The graphene
layer is shown in cyan. The unit cell parameters a, b, and γ are marked in magenta. (c) Single
molecule in lamellar phase A geometry (top) and simulated STM image
(bottom, black and white image) at −1 V for C. (d) Single molecule in lamellar phase
A geometry (top) and simulated STM image (bottom, black and white
image) at −1 V for uC.We simulated an STM image for
an individual molecule at a bias
voltage of −1 V from the calculated lamellar phases of both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC. The individual molecules, as well as
the corresponding simulated STM images at bias −1 V for C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC, are shown in Figure c,d. Both C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC showed some level of distortion from a linear geometry of
the carbon chains (Figure c,d, top part). Interestingly, the two E-configured
double bonds (encircled by an orange ellipse in Figure d) were rotated by almost 90° with respect
to the imaginary line that connects the nitrogen atoms of the NDI
core in uC-NDI-uC (Figure d, top part). As expected, the simulated STM images
of C-NDI-C and uC-NDI-uC are almost identical
with respect to the aromatic cores (Figure c,d, top parts). The main difference concerns
the long carbon chains, with the clear presence of the internal double
bonds in uC-NDI-uC (Figure d). The two internal double bonds appear as bright
spots, suggesting the presence of two localized areas of higher electronic
densities along the carbon chains (Figure d). In stark contrast, the distribution of
the electronic density along the carbon chains of C-NDI-C is more homogeneous and points to a discrete series of single bonds
(Figure c). Consistently
with the on-graphene optimized structure of uC-NDI-uC, the
internal double bonds are rotated by almost 90°, also in the
simulated STM image (Figure d). This peculiar feature may account for a different visualization
of the internal double bond by STM. Such hypothesis seems to be consistent
with the experimental STM images reported in Figure , in which one of the two double bonds appears
more visible than the other one for both uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC. This difference is more evident in the case of uC-NDI-uC and it is probably due to an increased distance for
the internal double bonds from the NDI core, which ultimately facilitates
the imaging. Hence, the gratifying agreement between the calculations
on uC-NDI-uC and the experimental STM images on both uC-NDI-uC and uC-NDI-uC allowed us to generalize
the conclusions to both unsaturated molecular systems.
Conclusions
We presented the synthesis and self-assembly at the 1-PO/HOPG interface
of C-NDI-C, C-NDI-C, uC-NDI-uC, and uC-NDI-uC. The molecular structures only differ by the presence/absence
of precisely positioned internal double bonds in their molecular skeletons.
These compounds self-assembled into lamellar arrangements characterized
by parallel aromatic cores that lay flat on the surface, and aliphatic
chains that modulate the distance between such cores. The longer the
chain, the larger the distance, implying that the entire molecular
system lays flat on the surface. The packing of the long carbon chains
results into two different arrangements: one in which the tails are
interdigitated (lamellar phase A), and a second one where the long
tails arrange diagonally, without interdigitation (lamellar phase
B). We find the presence/absence of the simple double bonds to be
the critical parameter for the selection of the chain arrangements.
The fully saturated compounds present a combination of both self-assembly
motifs, whereas the unsaturated molecules are capable of selecting
the fully interdigitated arrangement. Such difference is magnified
and reflected on the long-range order of the generated monolayers,
with the unsaturated compounds forming much larger domains (in some
cases larger than 15 000 nm2). This contrasts starkly
with the locally ordered, yet globally disordered, monolayers of the saturated compounds. The experimental
results were also corroborated by computational studies, which suggest
stronger van der Waals interactions between unsaturated carbon chains
as a possible explanation. Showing the paramount role played by internal
double bonds in the self-assembly of long carbon chain derivatives
on surfaces, our results point to the use of “simple”
internal double bonds as a critical structural parameter for obtaining
long-range order in surface-supported supramolecular processes.
We envision the application of our findings toward post-functionalization
of non-covalently functionalized surfaces and highly dynamic and smart
functional substrates.
Authors: Sebastian Stepanow; Magalí Lingenfelder; Alexandre Dmitriev; Hannes Spillmann; Erik Delvigne; Nian Lin; Xiaobin Deng; Chengzhi Cai; Johannes V Barth; Klaus Kern Journal: Nat Mater Date: 2004-03-07 Impact factor: 43.841
Authors: Dominic P Goronzy; Maryam Ebrahimi; Federico Rosei; Yuan Fang; Steven De Feyter; Steven L Tait; Chen Wang; Peter H Beton; Andrew T S Wee; Paul S Weiss; Dmitrii F Perepichka Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2018-07-16 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Artur Ciesielski; Mohamed El Garah; Sébastien Haar; Petr Kovaříček; Jean-Marie Lehn; Paolo Samorì Journal: Nat Chem Date: 2014-09-14 Impact factor: 24.427
Authors: Jing Sun; Julian Vogel; Lisa Chen; A Lennart Schleper; Tim Bergner; Alexander J C Kuehne; Max von Delius Journal: Chemistry Date: 2022-02-08 Impact factor: 5.020
Authors: Jiajing Zhou; Matthew Penna; Zhixing Lin; Yiyuan Han; René P M Lafleur; Yijiao Qu; Joseph J Richardson; Irene Yarovsky; Jesse V Jokerst; Frank Caruso Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2021-08-06 Impact factor: 16.823