Eva Tanner1, Alison Lee2, Elena Colicino1. 1. Department of Environmental Medicine and Public Health, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai. 2. Department of Pediatrics, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New York, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Biomonitoring studies have shown that children are constantly exposed to complex patterns of chemical and nonchemical exposures. Here, we briefly summarize the rationale for studying multiple exposures, also called mixture, in relation to child health and key statistical approaches that can be used. We discuss advantages over traditional methods, limitations and appropriateness of the context. RECENT FINDINGS: New approaches allow pediatric researchers to answer increasingly complex questions related to environmental mixtures. We present methods to identify the most relevant exposures among a high-multitude of variables, via shrinkage and variable selection techniques, and identify the overall mixture effect, via Weighted Quantile Sum and Bayesian Kernel Machine regressions. We then describe novel extensions that handle high-dimensional exposure data and allow identification of critical exposure windows. SUMMARY: Recent advances in statistics and machine learning enable researchers to identify important mixture components, estimate joint mixture effects and pinpoint critical windows of exposure. Despite many advantages over single chemical approaches, measurement error and biases may be amplified in mixtures research, requiring careful study planning and design. Future research requires increased collaboration between epidemiologists, statisticians and data scientists, and further integration with causal inference methods.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Biomonitoring studies have shown that children are constantly exposed to complex patterns of chemical and nonchemical exposures. Here, we briefly summarize the rationale for studying multiple exposures, also called mixture, in relation to child health and key statistical approaches that can be used. We discuss advantages over traditional methods, limitations and appropriateness of the context. RECENT FINDINGS: New approaches allow pediatric researchers to answer increasingly complex questions related to environmental mixtures. We present methods to identify the most relevant exposures among a high-multitude of variables, via shrinkage and variable selection techniques, and identify the overall mixture effect, via Weighted Quantile Sum and Bayesian Kernel Machine regressions. We then describe novel extensions that handle high-dimensional exposure data and allow identification of critical exposure windows. SUMMARY: Recent advances in statistics and machine learning enable researchers to identify important mixture components, estimate joint mixture effects and pinpoint critical windows of exposure. Despite many advantages over single chemical approaches, measurement error and biases may be amplified in mixtures research, requiring careful study planning and design. Future research requires increased collaboration between epidemiologists, statisticians and data scientists, and further integration with causal inference methods.
Authors: Yueh-Hsiu Mathilda Chiu; Hsiao-Hsien Leon Hsu; Brent A Coull; David C Bellinger; Itai Kloog; Joel Schwartz; Robert O Wright; Rosalind J Wright Journal: Environ Int Date: 2015-11-28 Impact factor: 9.621
Authors: Yu-Han Chiu; Andrea Bellavia; Tamarra James-Todd; Katharine F Correia; Linda Valeri; Carmen Messerlian; Jennifer B Ford; Lidia Mínguez-Alarcón; Antonia M Calafat; Russ Hauser; Paige L Williams Journal: Environ Int Date: 2018-02-20 Impact factor: 9.621
Authors: Shelley H Liu; Jennifer F Bobb; Kyu Ha Lee; Chris Gennings; Birgit Claus Henn; David Bellinger; Christine Austin; Lourdes Schnaas; Martha M Tellez-Rojo; Howard Hu; Robert O Wright; Manish Arora; Brent A Coull Journal: Biostatistics Date: 2018-07-01 Impact factor: 5.899
Authors: Robert Barouki; Peter D Gluckman; Philippe Grandjean; Mark Hanson; Jerrold J Heindel Journal: Environ Health Date: 2012-06-27 Impact factor: 5.984
Authors: Annemarie Stroustrup; Jennifer B Bragg; Syam S Andra; Paul C Curtin; Emily A Spear; Denise B Sison; Allan C Just; Manish Arora; Chris Gennings Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-03-05 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Joanne E Sordillo; Karen M Switkowski; Brent A Coull; Joel Schwartz; Itai Kloog; Heike Gibson; Augusto A Litonjua; Jennifer Bobb; Petros Koutrakis; Sheryl L Rifas-Shiman; Emily Oken; Diane R Gold Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2018-07-12 Impact factor: 4.379
Authors: Elena Colicino; Katerina Margetaki; Damaskini Valvi; Nicolo Foppa Pedretti; Nikos Stratakis; Marina Vafeiadi; Theano Roumeliotaki; Soterios A Kyrtopoulos; Hannu Kiviranta; Euripides G Stephanou; Manolis Kogevinas; Rob McConnell; Kiros T Berhane; Leda Chatzi; David V Conti Journal: Environ Epidemiol Date: 2022-04-22
Authors: Elena Colicino; Erik de Water; Allan C Just; Esmeralda Navarro; Nicolo Foppa Pedretti; Nia McRae; Joseph M Braun; Lourdes Schnaas; Yanelli Rodríguez-Carmona; Carmen Hernández; Marcela Tamayo-Ortiz; Martha M Téllez-Rojo; Andrea L Deierlein; Antonia M Calafat; Andrea Baccarelli; Robert O Wright; Megan K Horton Journal: Environ Res Date: 2021-05-26 Impact factor: 8.431
Authors: Martine Vrijheid; Xavier Basagaña; Juan R Gonzalez; Vincent W V Jaddoe; Genon Jensen; Hector C Keun; Rosemary R C McEachan; Joana Porcel; Valerie Siroux; Morris A Swertz; Cathrine Thomsen; Gunn Marit Aasvang; Sandra Andrušaitytė; Karine Angeli; Demetris Avraam; Ferran Ballester; Paul Burton; Mariona Bustamante; Maribel Casas; Leda Chatzi; Cécile Chevrier; Natacha Cingotti; David Conti; Amélie Crépet; Payam Dadvand; Liesbeth Duijts; Esther van Enckevort; Ana Esplugues; Serena Fossati; Ronan Garlantezec; María Dolores Gómez Roig; Regina Grazuleviciene; Kristine B Gützkow; Mònica Guxens; Sido Haakma; Ellen V S Hessel; Lesley Hoyles; Eleanor Hyde; Jana Klanova; Jacob D van Klaveren; Andreas Kortenkamp; Laurent Le Brusquet; Ivonne Leenen; Aitana Lertxundi; Nerea Lertxundi; Christos Lionis; Sabrina Llop; Maria-Jose Lopez-Espinosa; Sarah Lyon-Caen; Lea Maitre; Dan Mason; Sandrine Mathy; Edurne Mazarico; Tim Nawrot; Mark Nieuwenhuijsen; Rodney Ortiz; Marie Pedersen; Josep Perelló; Míriam Pérez-Cruz; Claire Philippat; Pavel Piler; Costanza Pizzi; Joane Quentin; Lorenzo Richiardi; Adrian Rodriguez; Theano Roumeliotaki; José Manuel Sabin Capote; Leonardo Santiago; Susana Santos; Alexandros P Siskos; Katrine Strandberg-Larsen; Nikos Stratakis; Jordi Sunyer; Arthur Tenenhaus; Marina Vafeiadi; Rebecca C Wilson; John Wright; Tiffany Yang; Remy Slama Journal: Environ Epidemiol Date: 2021-10-01
Authors: Bonnie R Joubert; Marianthi-Anna Kioumourtzoglou; Toccara Chamberlain; Hua Yun Chen; Chris Gennings; Mary E Turyk; Marie Lynn Miranda; Thomas F Webster; Katherine B Ensor; David B Dunson; Brent A Coull Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-01-26 Impact factor: 3.390