| Literature DB >> 31835554 |
Magdalena Zgliczyńska1,2, Stanisław Zgliczyński3, Michał Ciebiera1, Katarzyna Kosińska-Kaczyńska1.
Abstract
Due to the nature of their work, physicians are exposed to chronic stress. This may potentially lead to the widespread occurrence of occupational burnout syndrome (BS). The aim of this systematic review study was to summarize available published data concerning the prevalence of BS in Polish doctors. The literature search was performed using the following databases: PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) and Google Scholar. The last search was performed on September 27th, 2019. Only articles in English or Polish on graduated doctors practicing in Poland were taken into account. All types of original research were considered eligible. However, review articles, book chapters, case reports, case series, conference papers, study protocols and articles in languages other than English and Polish were excluded. There were no restrictions on age, seniority or specialty of study participants. The literature search revealed a total of 21 studies that met the inclusion criteria. The results of individual studies were very diverse, which makes it difficult to draw specific conclusions. However, the problem of burnout among Polish doctors is valid and worth special attention from society, health policy leaders, and doctors themselves. High-quality research is essential to for a better understanding of this topic.Entities:
Keywords: Poland; burnout; depersonalization; emotional exhaustion; occupational burnout; personal accomplishment; physicians
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31835554 PMCID: PMC6950131 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph16245026
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Full electronic search strategy.
| Database | Number of Results | Search Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Pubmed | 135 | (“Physicians”[Mesh] OR doctor OR physician OR specialist OR healthcare professional OR health professional) AND (“Burnout, Professional”[Mesh] OR “Burnout, Psychological”[Mesh] OR burnout OR burned out) AND (“Poland”[Mesh] OR Poland OR Polish) |
| Scopus | 92 | (TITLE-ABS-KEY (doctor* OR physician* OR specialist* OR (healthcare AND professional*) OR (health AND professional*)) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY (burnout OR (burned AND out)) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY (Poland OR Polish)) |
| CENTRAL | 2 | #1** “Physicians”[Mesh] |
| Google Scholar | First 50* | (doctor* OR physician* OR specialist* OR (healthcare AND professional*) OR (health AND professional*)) AND (burnout OR (burned AND out) AND (Poland OR Polish)) |
| Google Scholar | First 50** | (wypalenie OR (wypalenie AND zawodowe)) AND (lekarz* OR specjalist*) AND (Polska OR polsk* OR polsc*) |
*Review of 50 first results out of 63,600 arranged in default order by database algorithms; **Review of 50 first results out of 429 arranged in default order by database algorithms. **Subsequent numbers correspond to successive lines entered in the CENTRAL search engine.
Characteristics of the research articles included in the review.
| Study | Final Number of Examined Physicians and Gender Distribution | Age* | Specialty | Seniority * |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | 70 | Range | Radiology | 12 |
| [ | 51 | 40 | Psychiatry | 9 |
| [ | 41 | 38 | Various | 15 |
| [ | 84 | =<40—28% | Neurology—29% | LoD |
| [ | 55 | Range | Internal medicine, surgery, pediatrics, social welfare home | Range |
| [ | 150 | LoD | Full-time general practitioners | LoD |
| [ | 82 | 37 | Surgery, orthopedics—44% | 11 |
| [ | 66 | 48 | Anesthesiology—52% | 1–13—53% |
| [ | 71 | Range | Primary care—41%; | LoD |
| [ | 136 | 49 | Anesthesiology | 23 |
| Series: | 54 | 29 | Various | LoD |
| [ | 48 | 43 | LoD | LoD |
| Series: | 373 | 42 in the whole study group | Anesthesiology | 16 |
| [ | 50 | LoD | Various | LoD |
| [ | 25 | 37 | Emergency Medical Services | 11 |
| [ | 318 | 47 | 42 different specialties, including: 18% of psychiatry, 16% of internal medicine, 13% of pediatrics | LoD |
* Mean unless stated otherwise. Abbreviations: ♀—women; ♂—men; BS—burnout syndrome; DP—depersonalization; EE—emotional exhaustion; LoD—lack of data; MBI—Maslach Burnout Inventory; PA—personal accomplishment.
Prevalence and the severity of burnout syndrome (BS).
| Study | Main Burnout Assessment Tool | Level of Burnout Definition | Prevalence and Severity of BS in Physicians | Severity of BS Components in Physicians |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | MBI version not specified | High EE: 22% | ||
| [ | 22-item | EE: low <13, average 14–26, high >27 | High EE: 48% | |
| [ | 22-item | Scores trichotomized with ½ of SD above and below the mean as cut points | High EE: 52% | |
| [ | MBI version not specified | High EE: 33% | ||
| [ | 22-item MBI Polish adaptation by Pasikowski | For the nurses + physicians | ||
| [ | 22-item MBI Polish adaptation by Pasikowski | Mean: | ||
| [ | 22-item | High overall stress | Mean overall result Anesthesiologists: 52 | Anesthesiologists: |
| [ | 22-item | Mean overall results: | Surgical: | |
| [ | 66-item | Stens scale: | Low: 11% | High level of: |
| [ | 66-item | Moderate 4–6 stens; | Most examined doctors do not experience significant burnout (mean 138) | Stens: |
| [ | 24-item | Mean: 60 | ||
| [ | 24-item | High | Every second doctor showed high level of BS | High level of: |
| Series | 20-item | Critical level- values equal to or higher than 90th percentile | High or critical: 18% | The weakest possible rating of: |
| [ | 36-item questionnaire regarding: attitude, stress, workload, contact with patient | Low risk <100 | Mean: 131 |
Abbreviations: BS—burnout syndrome; DP—depersonalization, EE—emotional exhaustion, LC—limited interpersonal contacts; MBI—Maslach Burnout Inventory; PA—personal accomplishment; PF—physical fatigue; RE—reduced effectiveness of action; RC—reduced emotional control; SC—loss of subject’s commitment.
Risk and protective factors for BS.
| Study | Factors Contributing to the More Frequent or Increased Incidence of BS | Protective Factors |
|---|---|---|
| [ | - practicing 10–20 years | - long work experience (≥20 years) |
| [ | - work overload | |
| [ | - sense of loss resources in last 12 months: hedonistic and vital, spiritual, family, material and political, power and prestige | |
| [ | - specialty (neurology) | - high score in Generalized Self-Efficacy Scale |
| [ | - strong internal locus of control | |
| [ | - low job satisfaction | |
| [ | - high level of psychophysical demands and of requirements associated with responsibility for other people’s safety | - high level of intellectual demands, |
| [ | - shorter professional experience | |
| [ | - non-surgical specialty | - high level of empathy |
| [ | - high workload (>60 hours a week) | - satisfaction with social life |
| Series: | 2011: low level of the sense of comprehensibility in the 6th, high level of “trait” anxiety in the 4th, high level of depression in the 3rd, low need for social approval in the 3rd year of medical school | 2012: |
| [ | - negative assessment of healthcare, | - seniority |
| [ | - high level of perceived stress | - seniority |