Plasmonic sensitization of semiconductors is an attractive approach to increase light-induced photocatalytic performance; one method is to use plasmonic nanostructures in core@shell geometry. The occurrence and mechanism of synergetic effects in photocatalysis of such geometries are under intense debate and proposed to occur either through light-induced charge transfer (CT) or through thermal effects. This study focuses on the relation between the dimensions of Ag@CeO2 nanocubes, the wavelength-dependent efficiency, and the mechanism of light-induced direct CT. A 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA) linker between core and shell acts as a Raman probe for CT. For all Ag@CeO2 nanocubes, CT increases with decreasing excitation wavelength, with notable increase at and below 514 nm. This is fully explainable by CT from silver to the 4-MBA LUMO, with the increase for excitation wavelengths that exceed the Ag/4-MBA LUMO gap of 2.28 eV (543 nm). A second general trend observed is an increase in CT yield with ceria shell thickness, which is assigned to relaxation of the excited electron further into the ceria conduction band, potentially producing defects.
Plasmonic sensitization of semiconductors is an attractive approach to increase light-induced photocatalytic performance; one method is to use plasmonic nanostructures in core@shell geometry. The occurrence and mechanism of synergetic effects in photocatalysis of such geometries are under intense debate and proposed to occur either through light-induced charge transfer (CT) or through thermal effects. This study focuses on the relation between the dimensions of Ag@CeO2 nanocubes, the wavelength-dependent efficiency, and the mechanism of light-induced direct CT. A 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA) linker between core and shell acts as a Raman probe for CT. For all Ag@CeO2 nanocubes, CT increases with decreasing excitation wavelength, with notable increase at and below 514 nm. This is fully explainable by CT from silver to the 4-MBA LUMO, with the increase for excitation wavelengths that exceed the Ag/4-MBA LUMO gap of 2.28 eV (543 nm). A second general trend observed is an increase in CT yield with ceria shell thickness, which is assigned to relaxation of the excited electron further into the ceria conduction band, potentially producing defects.
Sensitized photocatalysts are gaining
increasing attention with the growing concerns about the state of
the environment and, with it, the desire to use more sustainable energy
sources. Nanostructures that support local surface plasmon resonances
(LSPR), which is the photoinduced collective oscillation of electrons,
can be used to sensitize semiconductors through decoration, incorporation,
or hierarchical construction such as core@shell particles.[1−3] Core@shell nanostructures are attractive because they offer controllable
overlap of the enhanced electric field with the semiconductor and
even the boundary of the semiconductor with the external media by
controlling the thickness of the shell.Plasmonic enhancement
of photocatalysts can be divided into four mechanisms: plasmon-induced
resonance energy transfer (PIRET),[4−6] direct charge transfer
(CT) during photoexcitation or before plasmon dephasing, indirect
CT after plasmon dephasing,[4,7−9] and as a local heat source.[10] PIRET requires
coupling of transition dipoles and is strongly dependent on the distance
and spectral overlap of the plasmonic donor and the energy acceptor
but can occur through space.[4,5] Unlike PIRET, both CT
mechanisms need electronic coupling. Direct CT can be divided into
three categories based on wavelength dependence and association with
plasmonic modes. (1) Plasmon-induced interfacial CT transition (PICTT):
a new electronic transition that requires strong coupling between
the donor and acceptor across the interface of the plasmonic particle
and semiconductor. (2) Direct interfacial CT transition (DICTT): a
CT transition not associated with a plasmonic mode, but instead with
a weaker metal–adsorbate transition possible above a threshold
photon energy.[8] (3) Chemical interface
dampening (CID): a new adsorbate-induced plasmon dephasing pathway,
with a quantum yield in agreement with the LSPR absorption.[8,11] For indirect CT there is a sensitivity to the photon energy as excited
electrons must overcome the Schottky barrier prior to relaxation through
heat generation in the lattice.[4,5,7−10]As well as acting as a sensitizer,[2,3] the
LSPR is also a sensor for the local environment: changes to the local
refractive index (n) cause spectral shifts[12] and enhance Raman intensities.[13,14] The LSPR spectral properties depend on the particle material, shape,
size, and local environment.[15,16] Silver nanocubes support
several LSPR modes; the most relevant to this study is the dominant
corner mode (red-most mode for an isolated cube). This mode projects
the furthest from the surface and is most sensitive to the local refractive
index for supported cubes.[12,15−17] The distance-dependent refractive index sensitivity (RIS(t), with t being the distance), determined
from finite-domain time-difference (FDTD) simulations, allows for
determination of the shell coverage.CeO2 is a well-known
catalyst with demonstrable potential as a photocatalyst,[18−22] which supports Ce(IV) and Ce(III) states forming reactive oxygen
vacancies[23,24] and catalyzes reactions such as reducing
CO2 into CO.[25] CeO2 has a bulk direct band gap of 3.6 eV and an indirect band gap of
∼2.4 eV;[26] in addition, trap states
may induce light absorption throughout the visible regime. Silver
nanoparticles are an attractive choice to sensitize ceria as they
have high quality plasmonic modes,[27] a
high refractive index sensitivity,[28] and,
through geometric control, light absorption throughout the visible
and near-infrared regime.[29] Additionally,
use of a core@shell geometry is of interest, as the metal core can
be isolated—either to prevent reactions, such as silver dissolving,
or to promote selectivity by only having the semiconductor as an available
active site. There have been studies on Ag/CeO2 (nano)composites,[30−34] but only few studies report on core@shell geometries,[35−39] despite their promise as photocatalysts. Silver nanocubes are attractive
because of the spatial localization of modes[17] and high |E|2 enhancement,[40] while preserving a high degree of symmetry.
Generalizable fundamental understanding of structural effects on the
photophysics is important, specifically on the occurrence, mechanism,
and wavelength dependence of photoinduced CT.The aim of this
work is to investigate photoinduced CT in Ag@CeO2 core@shell
nanocubes through surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) spectroscopy
by using the method developed by Lombardi and Birke.[41] Comparing the intensities of totally and non-totally symmetric
Raman modes allows for a quantification of the relative enhancement
from the LSPR and from CT.[41] We have investigated
the role of core and shell dimensions on CT by using a 4-mercaptobenzoic
acid (4-MBA) tag between the silver and ceria as the Raman probe.
Here, the wavelength-dependent effects of core and shell dimensions
on CT have been examined. FDTD simulations have been performed to
model the shell coverage of the Ag@CeO2 core@shell nanocubes
and determine the distance dependences of the refractive index sensitivity.
These give insights into the relationship between Ag@CeO2 core@shell nanostructure design and light-induced CT processes.
Materials and Methods
Synthesis Ag Nanocubes
Ag nanocubes of varied sizes
were synthesized by using a method adapted from the polyol synthesis;[42,43] the solvent for all solutions used in the synthesis was ethylene
glycol. A round-bottom flask, containing 40 mL of ethylene glycol
(Fluka, >99.9%) and 0.4 g of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP, Sigma-Aldrich),
was heated at 150 °C for 2 h. 0.4 mL of 3 mM Na2S
was then added, followed by the dropwise addition of 2.5 mL of 280
mM AgNO3(Alfa Aesar, 99+%). The reaction was followed with
a spectrometer (Avantis Starline AvaSpec-2048) and quenched by cooling
when the desired spectrum was observed. After quenching, the product
was cleaned through centrifugation (9000g) and redispersion
into ethanol through sonication five times. The final suspensions
were 10 mL and had an attenuance of 4 × 102 at the
spectral maximum.
Synthesis Ag@CeO2 Core–Shell Nanocubes
Silver nanocubes with edge lengths of 47 ± 7 and 71 ± 9
nm were coated with conformal ceria shells of different thicknesses
by varying the cerium nitrate and sodium hydroxide concentrations.
A mild synthesis method to deposit the ceria shell on the plasmonic
cube was chosen, as high temperatures or caustic reagents can easily
damage or destroy the particles.[44]Ceria was deposited on silver in a method adapted from bulk precipitation
methods.[45] Ce(NO3)3·6H2O(aq) (Sigma-Aldrich, 99% trace metal)
was exposed to a molar equivalent of NaOH(aq) (Sigma-Aldrich,
>98%) in the presence of 4-MBA-modified Ag nanocubes. Specifically,
1000 μL of the OD ∼ 400 particle suspension was added
to 20 mL of water, followed by 100 μL of 3 mM 4-MBA(EtOH), and the suspension was then incubated for 10 min. The amount of
ceria precursor and base to particles was varied to achieve different
ceria shell thicknesses, where 10, 100, or 5000 μmol of both
Ce(NO3)3(aq) and NaOH(aq) was used.
Samples were cleaned through centrifugation (4000g) and dispersion into Uvasol ethanol (VWR) three times.Initial
studies did not include 4-MBA, and ceria grew off the PVP on the Ag
nanocubes; however, to observe CT the 4-MBA was included. In mildly
acidic conditions 4-MBA attaches to silver by the thiol group;[46] precipitating ceria then binds to the free carboxylic
group (similarly, the ceria can grow off the oxygen in PVP[37]) and grows off the Ag nanocubes. This allows
for the 4-MBA to act as a linker and be in electronic contact with
both the silver and ceria.
FDTD Simulations
The program Lumerical FDTD Solutions
was used for simulations for theoretical support of the experimental
spectral changes caused by the shell deposition. Ag nanocubes were
modeled with rounded edges and corners (r = 2.5 nm);
ceria shells were modeled with the same structure. As thickness was
increased, the radii of edges and corners were increased, such that
the particle was spherical when the thickness is equal to the core
size. Scattering and absorption were both considered to produce a
calculated extinction relatable to experimental results. While the
Johnson and Christy[47] model for silver
was used, noncomplex indices of refraction were used to model the
shell and surrounding media. The refractive index value n for the ceria shell was set at 2.2, and a value of 1.337 for the
solvent (water) was used. Using a fixed value for the shell facilitates
generalization of the results for use with the Lorentz–Lorenz
equation.
Nanostructure Characterization
The UV–vis spectra
of Ag@CeO2 core–shell nanostructures in suspension
were collected by using a ThermoSci EVO600 spectrometer. For refractive
index sensitivity measurements, the solvents used were deionized water,
ethanol, and ethylene glycol. Characterization of the nanoparticles
used a Philips CM300ST-FEG transmission electron microscope (TEM)
with acceleration voltage of 300 kV and energy dispersive X-ray analysis
(EDX). The dimensions of uncoated Ag nanocubes and Ag@CeO2 core–shell nanocubes were determined from 20 measurements
of shells/crystallites on the particles. Scanning electron micrographs
(SEM) were recorded by using a JSM-6010LA SEM. X-ray diffraction (XRD)
analysis was performed on a Bruker D2 (Cu Kα source) diffractometer,
which revealed increased shielding of the silver core with increased
shell thickness; the diffractogram is shown in Figure S1 of the Supporting Information. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
(XPS) was performed with a Quantera SXM, with an Al Kα source
(1486.6 eV).
Raman Measurements
Raman measurements were performed
on a diluted suspension of Ag@CeO2 core–shell nanocubes
in Milli-Q water. Raman spectra at 785 nm excitation were collected
with an Avantes AvaRaman probe system, containing 1% ethanol. For
Raman measurements with 458, 488, 514, and 568 nm excitations, the
excitation source was an Ar/Kr ion laser (Coherent). A single grating
monochromator (Jobin Yvon, focal length 640 mm) with a liquid N2 cooled CCD camera (Princeton Instruments) was used for detection.
Calibration of the Raman shift for these excitation energies was performed
using cyclohexane as a reference. The Raman spectra were invariant
with respect to the excitation intensity between 2.5 and 10 mW (Figure S2).
Results and Discussion
Nanostructural and Optical Characterization
Figure shows the TEM micrographs
of the uncoated Ag nanocubes (i) and the Ag@CeO2 core@shell
nanocubes with different ceria shells (ii–iv), for cubes with
an edge length of 47 ± 7 nm (A) and 71 ± 9 nm (B). For amounts
of ceria insufficient to coat the Ag nanocubes fully, we observe an
incomplete coverage with small CeO2 crystallites (ii);
otherwise, conformal CeO2 shells with tunable thickness
are formed (iii and iv). See Table S1 for
specific values for each sample and Figure S3 for additional TEM and SEM micrographs showing no larger structures.
There is no significant difference in the size of the isolated ceria
crystallites between the 47 and 71 nm Ag nanocubes coated with ceria,
with 2.6 ± 0.3 and 2.3 ± 0.2 nm sized crystallites, respectively.
Aggregated crystallites form the thicker ceria shells, resulting in
a relatively conformal coating of the Ag nanocubes. The TEM micrographs
show that the ceria shells are porous, that is, have voids. This is
most likely due to the absence of a chelating agent which would slow
down the deposition of ceria.[38] XPS reveals
a Ce3+/Ce4+ ratio of 0.09 (see Figure S4 and Table S2). The coverage
has been determined from the simulated and experimental extinction
properties in different solvents (see below). A summary of shell thicknesses
and coverages is provided in Table S1.
Figure 1
TEM of
(A) 47 ± 7 nm silver cubes with (i) no shell, (ii) incomplete
coverage with 2.6 ± 0.3 nm CeO2 crystallites, (iii)
a 4.6 ± 1.3 nm shell, and (iv) 14.1 ± 3.9 nm shell and (B)
71 ± 9 nm cubes with (i) no shell, (ii) incomplete coverage with
2.3 ± 0.2 nm crystallites, (iii) a 3.7 ± 1.1 nm ceria shell,
and (iv) a 17.6 ± 3.5 nm conformal shell. The scale bars in all
micrographs are 30 nm. Core and shell dimensions have all been determined
from no fewer than 20 measurements. Additional micrographs are presented
in Figure S3.
TEM of
(A) 47 ± 7 nm silver cubes with (i) no shell, (ii) incomplete
coverage with 2.6 ± 0.3 nm CeO2 crystallites, (iii)
a 4.6 ± 1.3 nm shell, and (iv) 14.1 ± 3.9 nm shell and (B)
71 ± 9 nm cubes with (i) no shell, (ii) incomplete coverage with
2.3 ± 0.2 nm crystallites, (iii) a 3.7 ± 1.1 nm ceria shell,
and (iv) a 17.6 ± 3.5 nm conformal shell. The scale bars in all
micrographs are 30 nm. Core and shell dimensions have all been determined
from no fewer than 20 measurements. Additional micrographs are presented
in Figure S3.Figure presents the UV–vis spectra of the uncoated and coated
47 nm (A) and 71 nm (B) Ag nanocubes. The silver interband transition
around 300 nm red-shifts with CeO2 shell thickness; this
is likely due to interband scattering,[48] and, in particular, for the thickest shells, possibly from the CeO2 bandgap (3.6 eV, 344 nm).[49,50] The red-shift
of all the spectral features with increased CeO2 shell
thickness is due to an increase in local index of refraction, as the
plasmonic modes are highly sensitive to the local environment.[15] CeO2 has a refractive index between
2.2 and 2.8 in the visible regime,[49,50] significantly
higher than the refractive index of water. The mode centered at 348
nm observed for uncoated 47 and 71 nm Ag cubes is localized on the
face of the cube[17] and is highly sensitive
to the sharpness of the corners.[51] The
retention of this mode during coating suggests that no significant
etching of the corners occurs. The mode at 390 nm (47 nm cubes) and
405 nm (71 nm cubes) is localized on the edges, while the intense,
lowest energy mode at 460 nm (47 nm cubes) and 485 nm (71 nm cubes)
is localized at the corners of the cube.[17] The latter mode is strongly dependent on the cube edge length and
is the most sensitive to a change in local index of refraction.[16,17] The broad band around 700 nm for the 47 nm silver nanocubes with
a 2.6 nm shell, and to a low extent those around 750 nm for the 71
nm silver nanocubes with a 2.3 nm shell, is most likely due to mild
aggregation. It is worth noting that no new electronic transitions
indicative of direct CT are observed.
Figure 2
UV–vis spectra of (A) 47 nm and
(B) 71 nm silver nanocubes, PVP capped (0 nm), and 4-MBA treated and
coated with ceria (shell thickness given in legend), suspended in
ethanol. Red-shifting of modes occurs due to the increased local index
of refraction caused by the presence of CeO2.
UV–vis spectra of (A) 47 nm and
(B) 71 nm silver nanocubes, PVP capped (0 nm), and 4-MBA treated and
coated with ceria (shell thickness given in legend), suspended in
ethanol. Red-shifting of modes occurs due to the increased local index
of refraction caused by the presence of CeO2.The ceria shell coverage, while accounting for
the voids in the shell, has been determined by correlating experimental
and simulated changes in the UV–vis spectrum induced by a change
in the local refractive index by using (i) different solvents (Figure S5) and (ii) changing the ceria shell
thickness. The volume fraction of the shell (φ) depends on the shell coverage (η) and the distance-dependent
refractive index sensitivity (RIS(t), with t the distance) according to:due to the |E|2 profile around the plasmonic nanostructure.[15] The value of φ has been determined
by using the Lorentz–Lorenz equation:[52]where neff is
the effective refractive index, a function of the ith component’s refractive index n and φ the volume
fraction. There are only two components considered for this system:
the shell and solvent as the PVP/4-MBA capping agent is a constant
and needed to prevent aggregation. The effective refractive index
of the Ag cubes has been determined from RIS(t) by
dispersing uncoated Ag cubes in solvents of different refractive indexes
and determining the peak shift of the corner mode relative to n (see Figure S5).Figure A shows the effect
of ceria shell thickness on the peak shift of the corner mode, simulated
by FDTD for cubes with an edge length ranging from 50 to 100 nm: for
an edge length ≤90 nm, RIS(t) = (0.951 ±
0.009) (see fit included in Figure A and Figure S6). This model of RIS(t) has been validated by comparing all shell thicknesses as determined
by TEM with simulated values (Figure B). Applying eq yields an average shell coverage η = 0.67 ± 0.25
(specific values for all samples are shown in Table S1), allowing quantification of the shell thickness
through UV–vis spectra alone in future synthesis of Ag@CeO2 nanocubes.
Figure 3
(A) Simulated peak shift of the corner mode with respect
to n for cubes of 50–100 nm, normalized from
a pure solvent to a pure shell system, including a fit to RIS(t) = (0.951 ± 0.009),
with t the shell thickness. (B) Comparison of the
shell thickness determined by TEM and UV–vis using the results
from FDTD and the average coverage, giving statistically similar results.
(A) Simulated peak shift of the corner mode with respect
to n for cubes of 50–100 nm, normalized from
a pure solvent to a pure shell system, including a fit to RIS(t) = (0.951 ± 0.009),
with t the shell thickness. (B) Comparison of the
shell thickness determined by TEM and UV–vis using the results
from FDTD and the average coverage, giving statistically similar results.
Photoinduced Charge Transfer
The 4-MBA linker has been
used as a SERS probe for photoinduced CT and facilitates examination
of the role of photoexcitation wavelength and core@shell dimensions.
The degree of CT (ρCT) has been determined using
the theory developed by Lombardi and Birke. Equation compares the selective enhancement of the
non-totally symmetric vibrational modes, which are enhanced by CT,
relative to totally symmetric modes which are only enhanced by the
LSPR. A value of 0.5 implies equal Raman enhancement from LSPR and
CT:[41]The parameter k is an index
identifying individual molecular bands in the Raman spectrum. I(LSPR) is the intensity of
line (k) where only the LSPR contributes to the SERS
enhancement, while I0(LSPR) denotes the
intensity of a chosen totally symmetric line, also with only LSPR
contribution. I(CT)
is the intensity of a non-totally symmetric mode where both LSPR and
CT contribute. For a non-totally symmetric line I(LSPR) will normally be small or zero,
reducing eq intoThis method is only capable of observing direct
CT that involves the 4-MBA linker. It is not possible to observe any
CT directly from silver to ceria bypassing the 4-MBA. Additionally,
there is no information regarding the directionality of the process.
However, given the lack of light absorption by the ceria or 4-MBA
and the strong absorption by the silver, it can be concluded that
CT originating from light absorbed by the silver is the most likely
mechanism.Figure shows the Raman spectra at various excitation wavelengths for the
47 nm (A) and 71 nm (B) Ag nanocubes with 4-MBA linker and different
ceria shell thicknesses. The Raman spectra are invariant to the laser
intensity between 2.5 and 10 mW (see Figure S2). The mode at 1070 cm–1 used for normalization
of the Raman spectra is the C–S stretch and a symmetric ring
breathing mode (νCS and 1)[53−55] and has A1 character. The assignment of the 1140 and 1180 cm–1 modes is in debate—however, not the modes at 1370 and 1415
cm–1 which are of B2 character.[54−58] Specifically, the 1415 cm–1 mode is the asymmetric
ring mode 18b, and the 1370 cm–1 is assigned to
βO–H, νC–ph, 19a, and asymmetric νCO2 vibrations.[53−55]Table summarizes the assignments of the modes. On the basis of these assignments,
we have used the 1415 cm–1 mode as I(CT) and the 1070 cm–1 mode as I0(LSPR) to resolve ρCT. For quantification of ρCT, the spectra
have been fit with Gaussian functions (see the Supporting Information for details).
Figure 4
Raman spectra of 4-MBA
between silver and ceria for (A) 47 nm and (B) 71 nm silver nanocubes,
normalized to the intensity of the 1070 cm–1 mode.
The degree of charge transfer, ρCT, at different
excitation energies for (C) 47 nm and (D) 71 nm Ag@CeO2 nanocubes with different shell thicknesses; the dashed vertical
line is at 543 nm, the wavelength of light needed to excite an electron
from the silver Fermi level to the 4-MBA LUMO. The ρCT was calculated by using the variance of the 1415 cm–1 mode as compared to the 1070 cm–1 mode.
Table 1
Raman Mode and Symmetry Assignments
from the Literature for 4-MBA
Raman spectra of 4-MBA
between silver and ceria for (A) 47 nm and (B) 71 nm silver nanocubes,
normalized to the intensity of the 1070 cm–1 mode.
The degree of charge transfer, ρCT, at different
excitation energies for (C) 47 nm and (D) 71 nm Ag@CeO2 nanocubes with different shell thicknesses; the dashed vertical
line is at 543 nm, the wavelength of light needed to excite an electron
from the silver Fermi level to the 4-MBA LUMO. The ρCT was calculated by using the variance of the 1415 cm–1 mode as compared to the 1070 cm–1 mode.ν: symmetric stretching; νas: asymmetric stretching; β: bending; δ: deformation.An important parameter to address is the 4-MBA layer
thickness. In the ideal case a monolayer is present, with the 4-MBA
molecule likely attached to the Ag core via the thiol group and to
the ceria shell via the carboxylic acid group,[46] implying a subnanometer 4-MBA layer thickness. Multilayer
structures may be formed through hydrogen bonding between the thiol
and the carboxylic acid groups and by van der Waals interactions.
However, such a multilayer structure would show a βOH Raman
mode which would vary between an incomplete shell to the complete
shell; that is, variation of the 1180 cm–1 mode
and the 1370 cm–1 mode.[46] As such effect is absent in the Raman spectra (Figure A,B), it can be concluded that
a multilayer of 4-MBA is unlikely, which is further supported by the
TEM experiments (Figure ) unable to resolve the 4-MBA linker. Incomplete coverage of the
Ag surface can however not be excluded, although no PVP Raman signals
have been observed.Figure C shows ρCT as a function of excitation
wavelength for the 47 nm Ag nanocubes with three different ceria shell
thicknesses. The measurements at 785 nm excitation have 1% ethanol,
which gives rise to the extraneous peak at 1460 cm–1. For both nanocube edge lengths, the most pronounced effect on the
intensities of the 1370 and 1415 cm–1 modes is observed
at 488 and 458 nm excitation. At 785 nm excitation ρCT is close to zero for all three ceria shell thicknesses, as can be
expected for photon energies significantly lower than both the LSPR
and a potential Ag to 4-MBA electronic transition. The ρCT value significantly increases on decreasing the excitation
wavelength, with a notable increase at 514 nm and shorter wavelengths.
In addition, ρCT is higher for thicker ceria shells. Figure D, presenting ρCT values for the 71 nm Ag nanocubes coated with different
ceria shell thicknesses, shows similar trends. The absence of a band
at 1415 cm–1 for Ag cubes coated with 4-MBA only
(Figure S7) demonstrates that the ceria
shell is crucial for the CT process.Figure shows an energy level diagram[24,59] and the proposed CT mechanism. If the CT were to occur through PICTT,
CID, or indirect CT, then it would be expected that ρCT would follow the LSPR absorption of the silver core.[60] Given that no LSPR dependency is observed here,
CT is most likely dominated by the DICTT mechanism. The increase in
ρCT at 514 nm and shorter wavelengths can be assigned
to CT of an electron from the Ag core to the LUMO of the 4-MBA, which
is allowed for photon energies >2.28 eV (i.e., <543 nm) through
the DICTT mechanism. The increase with photon energy likely originates
from the increasing probability for CT from an electron at a greater
depth in the Fermi sea; on average, half the photon energy is left
in the hole formed on photoexcitation.[6] Indeed, at 785 nm excitation CT is insignificant for all core@shell
geometries. However, all ρCT values at 568 nm excitation
exceed those at 785 nm, indicating some CT, although inefficient.
The photon energy at 568 nm light (2.18 eV) is 0.1 eV below the energy
gap between the Ag Fermi level and the LUMO of the 4-MBA linker.[59] Within the thermal distribution of electrons
at room temperature, there is a 2% chance of the state 0.1 eV above
the silver Fermi level being populated (Figure S8), which likely accounts for the low ρCT. Additionally, CT from the 4-MBA HOMO to the silver may occur. While
this may have some contribution to ρCT, it is not
expected to demonstrate the trends seen here, as it would lead to
relatively constant ρCT values for wavelengths shorter
than 543 nm, which is not observed.
Figure 5
Energy diagram and proposed mechanisms
of light-induced CT, the black dashed line is the Fermi energy of
silver used as a reference.[59,66] Photoexcitation could
promote an electron from the Ag core to the 4-MBA linker, followed
by electron transfer from the 4-MBA to the CeO2. The latter
process may result in the formation of an oxygen vacancy (Ovac).
Energy diagram and proposed mechanisms
of light-induced CT, the black dashed line is the Fermi energy of
silver used as a reference.[59,66] Photoexcitation could
promote an electron from the Ag core to the 4-MBA linker, followed
by electron transfer from the 4-MBA to the CeO2. The latter
process may result in the formation of an oxygen vacancy (Ovac).Aside from this excitation wavelength effect on
ρCT, a second general trend observed is a higher
ρCT value with increasing ceria layer thickness.
This dependency indicates that not only the 4-MBA intermediate layer
affects the CT process but also the ceria outer shell. There are statistically
significant increases in ρCT with a thicker shell
through the 4-MBA pathway (Figure C,D), which indicate that the electron excited from
the Ag core to the 4-MBA can relax into the CeO2 conduction
band (CB). Similar observations were made for a Au/4-MBA/TiO2 system, where the metal to 4-MBA CT occurs, and then the electron
is transferred to the semiconductor.[60] The
ρCT value for, in particular, the thinnest shells
may be limited by charge buildup, which impedes further CT.[61] This effect likely decreases with increasing
shell thickness, explaining the higher ρCT observed.Interestingly, a dependency on the core size is not observed here.
In other works,[11,60] there has been a significant
increase in ρCT values for excitation wavelengths
that were in resonance. Here we observed a ρCT dependency purely determined by incident photon energy, apparently
independent of the LSPR position, indicating a difference in mechanism
(DICTT here, CID in ref (7), and PIRET in ref (8)). Additionally, no significant shift of the Raman peaks that could
be induced by a strong electric field[62,63] is observed
for the two core sizes studied here. Only a slight shift is seen in
the 1070 cm–1 mode for Ag cubes without a ceria
shell (Figure S7), indicative of a difference
in hydrogen bonding.[64] This Ag@CeO2 system merits further studies through photocatalytic activity
testing and ultrafast spectroscopy to investigate photoinduced formation
of oxygen vacancies.
Conclusions
This study focuses on the relation between
the dimensions of Ag@CeO2 nanocubes and the efficiency
and mechanism of light-induced CT. A 4-MBA linker between core and
shell has been used as a probe for light-induced direct CT by Raman
spectroscopy. The ceria shell coverage has been determined with FDTD
simulations, which describe the distance-dependent refractive index
sensitivity, and UV–vis spectroscopy.The degree of photoinduced
CT has been determined by comparing the intensities of totally symmetric
and non-totally symmetric modes. For all Ag@CeO2 nanocubes
investigated, the degree of CT increases with decreasing excitation
wavelength, with a pronounced increase around 514 nm. This trend is
fully explicable through a direct CT mechanism from the silver Fermi
level to the 4-MBA LUMO. Interestingly, there was no trend seen relating
to the core size or to the extinction of the silver nanocube core.A second general trend observed is a higher CT yield with increasing
ceria shell thickness, indicating further electron transfer from the
4-MBA to the ceria shell. It may be that electron transfer from 4-MBA
to CeO2 becomes more likely with increasing shell thickness.
As this process could lead to formation of oxygen vacancies, this
shows promise for photocatalytic application. These results provide
deeper understanding of light-induced charge transfer in plasmonic@semiconductor
nanocubes.